Preview

Letter to Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau to Argue Against Implementation of War Measures Act.

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1387 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Letter to Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau to Argue Against Implementation of War Measures Act.
Topic: Letter to Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau to argue against implementation of War Measures Act.

Word Count: 1385 Words

To: Prime Minister, Pierre Trudeau
From: Mitesh Patel, Cabinet Minister
Date: October 12, 1970
Subject: Implementation of War Measures Act

As informed by the party that you have asked all the cabinet ministers of your government to lay down their suggestions on whether the War Measures Act should be implemented or not and should the government send their troops to Quebec, I hereby lay my points of view as a cabinet minister of your party on the situation we are facing in Quebec by stating both the advantages and disadvantages of the war measures act. In this memo, I will be highlighting on why the government should not implement the war measures act centring more over the demerits upon the merits of the act that province might have to face by putting this act into practice.
It is challenging situation that we are currently facing in the province of Quebec as we experienced one of the unpredicted incident taking place due to kidnapping of our prominent political member Mr. James Cross (British Trade Commissioner). He is currently taken as a hostage by FLQ activists on the 5th of October 1970. FLQ are using Mr. Cross as a tool to lay out their demands mentioned in FLQ manifesto which includes freeing of the political leaders, an airplane to send them to their families, a voluntary tax from government and no surveillance actions taken by police to search the kidnappers etc. They basically kidnapped Mr. Cross because they want Quebec to be set independent as a free society. As we are still investigating the case of kidnapping, soon after the 10th of October another prominent member of our party Mr. Pierre Laporte (minister of Immigration and of manpower and labour) is kidnapped by the same group of radicals as the demands by the group were not considered serious in nature by our government. There is a need of taking a quick and



Bibliography: Borovoy, Alan. Rebuilding a free society. Toronto: New Press, 1971. Johnson, Carole de Vault and William. Quebec. Scarborough: Fleet Publishers, 1982. —. The October Crisis. Scarborough: Fleet Publishers, 1982. Smith, Denis. The Canadian Encyclopedia. n.d. 28 November 2011 <http://www.thecanadianencyclopedia.com/index.cfm?PgNm=TCE&Params=A1ARTA008439>.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    The use of the word society is repeated on numerous occasions, such as: “I am confident that those persons who unleashed this tragic sequence of events with the aim of destroying our society and dividing our country will find that the opposite will occur. The result of their acts will be a stronger society in a unified country” (Trudeau par. 37). The repetition of the particular word in this statement demonstrates the unity of the country and how the entire Canadian population should stand together against the terrorists. This, “democratic society” (Trudeau par. 4), one that cannot be destroyed, provides hope to the audience and allows them to further comprehend the extent to which agreeing and supporting the government’s actions is important. When the Prime Minister repeats the word society, he is trying to evoke a feeling of unity and is also trying to bring together a country that might disagree with him. The repetition allows him to try and convince the citizens that he is prioritizing their best intentions and that the War Measures Act is the correct solution. The word government is also repeated over 30 times, to describe to the audience what the authorities are doing as well as to show that the Canadian government is trying to help its own citizens. Pierre…

    • 1340 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In his essay the author, Amir Attaran a Californian-born Canadian expresses his belief of how the Pearsonistic Canadian government being his incentive to move to Canada had changed drastically as well as his view of the so-called “picture perfect” appearance of Canada. Amir displays this by first showing the prime ministers contradiction of his statement on how Canada deals with kidnappings from terrorists. He then proceeds to describe how there is degeneracy in the way the Governor-in-council gives the preference of exports to Canada, when the preference are intended for developing countries in order to reduce tariffs; however, it is decided only by the countries' poverty level and needs. Yet, some wealthy countries receive these preferences when there is no need for them to receive it in the first place. Amir then carries on expressing is confusion and views of the government by recounting the grave consequences that can occur in a nation when the government covers up a threatening event.…

    • 636 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Canadian Expeditionary Force and the Military Service Act were both examples of Robert Borden’s fierce support towards the Canadian Expeditionary Force in World War I despite the opposition of the French Canadians against the English Canadians. Robert Borden knew that the Canada’s victory in World War I would let Canada to be internationally recognized and seen equal to Great Britain than a dominion of…

    • 65 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Flq Crisis Research Paper

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The October Crisis or FLQ Crisis occurred in 1970 when FLQ members kidnapped James Cross, a British diplomat. Trudeau had taken a stand against Quebec nationalists and this was the result. So in order for Cross to be released, the captors demanded tat FLQ members be released from their sentences in prison and that the FLQ manifesto be read publicly. The Premier of Quebec, Robert Bourassa agreed to many of the demands but wouldn’t release the FLQ prisoners. This led to the FLQ kidnapping Pierre Laporte, the Quebec Labor minister and Trudeau taking action to end this growing issue. Urged by Mayor Jean Drapeau of Montreal and Bourassa, Trudeau brought in the War…

    • 643 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    There is not a lot of episode in our past that required the help of the army like that. After reading both text I can affirm that even though the FLQ was an amateur group they were able to make shocking moves. Hopefully nothing like that will happen in the future. Violence and terrorism are not a way to defend our point of view. Regarding what his happening in Ukraine recently, I feel happy that we can now have diversify democratic parties that can allow everyone to shared his vision and opinion without using violence. Everyone should feel concern in a multicultural Quebec society, not only one…

    • 1490 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Flq Crisis Essay Example

    • 1056 Words
    • 5 Pages

    On October 5, 1970, British trade commissioner James Cross was kidnapped in his Westmount home by members of the terrorist group Front de liberation du Quebec. The FLQ Manifesto called for non-democratic separation to be brought about by acts of terror. From 1963 to 1967, the FLQ planted 35 bombs; from 1968 to 1970 they planted over 50 bombs. By the fall of 1970 the terrorist acts of the FLQ cells had claimed 6 lives. The kidnappers' demands included the release of a number of convicted or detained FLQ members and the broadcasting of the FLQ Manifesto. The Manifesto was read on Radio-Canada. Then, on October 10th, the Quebec minister of justice guaranteed safe passage to anywhere in the world for the kidnappers in exchange for the safe release of Cross. That same day Pierre Laporte, a famed Quebec reporter, author of The True Face of Duplessis, and the minister of immigration and labour in the Quebec government, was kidnapped by a different FLQ cell on the lawn of his suburban home. Laporte's kidnapping triggered a phone call from Liberal Premier Robert Bourassa asking Prime Minister Pierre Trudeau to prepare the Canadian Armed Forces for action in Quebec and to declare War Measures. Two days later, October 12, Trudeau summoned armed troops to guard potential targets in Ottawa and Montreal such as cabinet ministers, John Diefenbaker, who was on the FLQ hit list, and federal buildings. On the following day, October 13, Peter Reilly of CJOH and I were at the west door of the Centre Block of the House of Commons. Reilly was asking Trudeau some basic questions in a laconic, unemotional style about the army and tanks being in Ottawa. Suddenly we were joined by CBC reporter Tim Ralfe who asked Trudeau a very emotional question about his decision to invoke the War Measures Act. Pierre Trudeau interview…

    • 1056 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Over the course of its history, Canada has progressed immensely regarding its autonomy. Starting out as just a colony of Great Britain, Canada was in the control of the overarching British Empire. However, Canada now has emerged as a sovereign state, in control of its own future. A major contributing factor to Canada ultimately reaching autonomy has been its participation in war and peacekeeping efforts. Contributions made in war efforts such as WWI and WWII have allowed Canada to demonstrate just how influential and powerful the country can be. Even though Canada entered WWI under the order of Great Britain, Canada’s showing at the battle of Vimy Ridge helped it emerge as a more independent country, gaining its own seat in the League of Nations. After participation in World War Two, Canada once again progressed in independence and earned the right to be a founding member in both NATO and the UN. Along with wars, Canada has made many contributions to peacekeeping. Canadian Prime Minister, Lester B. Pearson, is considered a founder of modern peacekeeping after his efforts in the Suez Canal Crisis during the Cold War Era.…

    • 2007 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    For the first few years of World War I, the CEF relied solely on volunteers. (Valiante, “The Legacy of Canada's WWI Conscription Crisis”). However, the longer the war progressed, the more casualties increased, and the less men volunteered. The Prime Minister at that time, Robert Borden, had seen the decline in volunteers, and once he had returned from a trip to the trenches he became convinced that conscription was the only way to do soldiers justice (Jones, “Conscription”). The Military Service Act of 1917 was issued on August 29, 1917 and became law (“War on the Homefront”). The majority of French-Canadians and pacifists who have implored the government to not enforce conscription were infuriated. The results of the Conscription act culminated in riots and protests that required soldiers to bring order to chaos, and many searched for ways to be exempted from conscription (Canadian War Museum, “Recruitment and Conscription.”).…

    • 290 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Any discussion regarding the defining moments in Canada’s history must include the infamous October Crisis of 1970. Occurring throughout the province of Quebec, particularly in the metropolitan areas of Montreal, the socio-political implications of this affair were so significant that its effects can still be felt four decades later. However, many tend to overlook the substantial role that the media played in shaping the series of events that would eventually culminate in the first, and only, peacetime usage of the controversial War Measures Act and forever smear the relationship between Quebec and the Canadian government. Although many only see the major players as the Front de Libération du Québec (FLQ) and Prime Minister Pierre Elliot Trudeau and his federal government, the media played such a large role in sensationalizing the events and making tangible goods out of abstract concepts – such as civil liberties and public safety – that it should be considered its own entity in its entirety.…

    • 1860 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The bloody Vietnam War of the 1950’s was fought by the brave American troops with the help of the Canadian citizens. Though, sources claim that Canada had a limited amount of contribution in the war, facts state otherwise. The Vietnam War took place during the Cold War era where a military conflict had occurred in Vietnam, Laos, and Cambodia from November 1 1955 to April 30 1975. Canada became officially involved in the Vietnam conflict in 1954, as part of the International Commission for Supervision and Control in Vietnam. However, Canada did not post troops to Vietnam until 1973, in which Canadian troops remained under the United Nations banner to enforce the Paris Peace Accords. The War had persisted for more than nineteen years, five months, four weeks and one day. During the Cold War era, Canada remained associated with the main stream western powers. Many Canadians who truly wanted to fight in the War had served along the U.S Military. Canadians serving with the United States had occurred as far back as the Civil War. In addition, Canada was part of many organizations such as “N.A.T.O” (North Atlantic Treaty Organization) which guaranteed Canada would not partake in the Vietnam War. Even though people around the world contemplate that Canada had no contribution in the Vietnam War, various facts state that Canadians did have excessive amount of involvement towards the Vietnam War that was never taken into consideration. Throughout this essay, the reader will be able to grasp a general understanding of the ways in which the Canadians had part in The Vietnam War, regardless of what bias sources claim. To start with, Canada sent more than thirty thousand troops into the Vietnam War with the Americans – these troops volunteered and died there. Canadians had also sent plenty amounts of supplies…

    • 306 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Conscription Crisis

    • 448 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The enlistment of the army was made voluntary and thus, the number of soldiers increased. The prime minister Sir Robert Borden, said that "I made it clear to the people of Canada that we did not propose any conscription". The economic adjustments brought arguments and disagreements between the West and East provinces. (Bourassa2) "Bourassa earned for himself the praise for the French-Canadians and became instantly a dominant figure in Canadian political life". Bourassa was surely benefiting the society. The conscription act forced the Canadian men into military service, by the government which mainly were English-speaking. The military refused to take the French people, and they had no loyalty and which their only loyalty was to Canada. Wilfred Laurier was also convinced that the conscription would tear the country apart (Bourassa 3). Most French-Canadians who were first against the conscription supported the liberal party. As a result, the French Canadians had no right to fight in the war, and it remained a complex act between historical and cultural discriminations, which leads to all the…

    • 448 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Kim Richard Nossal, The Politcs of Canadian Foreign Policy Third Edition, (Prentice Hall Canada Inc., Scarborough, Ontario, 1985), 71…

    • 2704 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Therefore, Canada’s response to the Great Depression was deemed ineffective as the relief efforts from the government were little help. People were reluctant to accept the “dole” from the government as it would take away from their pride, and the weakness that was displayed by the government raised questions about the…

    • 896 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    War of 1812

    • 1652 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The War of 1812 was a war between Britain and the United States fought primarily in Upper Canada. It had many causes, few which involved British North America. The results of the war include the fact that there was no clear winner or loser among them. The only real losers in the situation were the Natives in the region. They were driven out of their lands and customs. None of the borders was changed by the war, though many attempts were made. The Treaty of Ghent, which ended the war, did nothing to advance the state of the countries. It went so far as to end the war and put things back the way that they were, but the main causes of the conflict were not addressed or dealt with. In order to evaluate the significance of this war, Canadian victories and losses, as well as overall results, must be analyzed.…

    • 1652 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sociology

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages

    For the sake of national unity, Prime Minister of Canada Mackenzie King of 1935- 1948 did not want to repeat mistakes that had occurred in the past (Quinlan, 50). As World War 1 unfolded Mackenzie King was forced to change his views on conscription (Quinlan, 50). Canada’s military had let in new troops and prepared them for war, during this time they believed conscription would not be necessary (Nelson, 42). The first military conscription divided the country (The diary of William Lyon Mackenzie King). On September 3rd, 1939, Britain and France declared war on Germany following the invasion of Poland by German troops. Mackenzie King held a special seating of Parliament with a vote directly following the debate in the House of Commons; a referendum was the elite alternative to his dilemma. “Are you in favour of releasing the government from any obligations raising men for military service?” this was what Mackenzie King had come up with. After the vote, 82.3 percent of voters, voted yes in Ontario, In British Columbia 79.49 percent vote yes. In Quebec 72.4 voters said “Non” (Quinlan, 50). This was when Mackenzie King found himself in the same position as Borden during the World War 1. Mackenzie was forced to decide between French and English voters. Firstly, for the first time being, Mackenzie King did not enforce conscription, “Not necessarily conscription, but conscription if necessary.” (Quinlan, 51). Furthermore, Mackenzie King had just made his first general tough decision that did not initialize conscription just yet but had to send men to war under the NRMA draft. Lastly, there was an election and Mackenzie made promises that he could not keep. This tells us a lot about Mackenzie and his contribution to the war.…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics