L. Pignotti
ENGL 120
30 October 2013
Joel Stein Reading Notes According to the article, this generation is pretty much screwed. Most of us are narcissistic and have horrible ambitions in life. Technology runs the world now; elementary students don’t even know how to use an encyclopedia. More young girls would rather be Jennifer Lopez’ personal assistant over the CEO of let’s say Quicken Loans. Nowadays, we act like we care, but in reality, what are we doing about it? We complain about the way our government is running the country, but none of my friends even voted even though they were old enough.
Millennials (Pgs. 1-6)
Narcissistic (ism/ist) (Pgs. 1-5, 7)
Generation (Pgs.1-3, 6-7)
Social Media (i.e. Facebook, Twitter, Snapchat, YouTube, Instagram etc.) (Pgs. 1-4, 6-7
Technology (i.e. Internet, Television, etc.) (Pgs. 1-4)
There are a few things I agree with in this article, one would be that most of this generation is way too narcissistic; I mean a lot of girls needs to look in the mirror constantly and have the latest, most expensive items. It’s disgusting. Also included in the article that I see as true would be that nobody takes action anymore. In the 1970’s during the Women’s Liberty acts women were burning their bras in the middle of the street it show that they didn’t have to be “held down.” Now if we have a problem with something, we don’t go out and protest and take action, we complain on Twitter and Facebook. Yeah, because that’ll do a whole lot of damage.
The main thing I disagree with within the article is the title and what this whole thing is about. I almost feel as if he’s bashing the entire generation. Not the entire generation is like this, I for one am not like most people my age. I would love to have new and better things, but I can’t because there are more important things in life, like, oh I don’t know, food. We’re in college, we aren’t supposed to have new, designer clothes, you’re supposed to go on “The College Kid Diet” and “The College Kid Wardrobe.” You wear last year’s shoes, thrift store clothes and eat Ramen Noodles. Not have an Armani Exchange outfit with Fendi sunglasses and eat strictly organic $20 dollar a pound apples.
“Millennials are interacting all day but almost entirely through a screen.” Pg. 3. Basically, a lot of older people seem to think that this generation isn’t getting any interaction and we don’t talk to each other, in reality, we do communicate and talk, but it’s just through texting, Skype or Facebook.
“Because of online dating, Facebook Circles and the ability to connect with people internationally, they no longer have to marry someone from their high school class or even their home country” Pg. 4. In a few years, not meeting your significant other online is going to be weird, Ilana baker from girl code made a comment about online dating being the norm and meeting someone at a coffee shop is going to be weird, she said “What? You meant them at a coffee shop? How did you know everything about them first?”
“A generation’s greatness isn’t determined by data; it’s determined by how they react to the challenges that befall on them.” Pg. 7. This is one of the truest statements in this article. You cannot generalize; you cannot judge an entire group of people on a select few of their actions. You cannot dub every Muslim person a terrorist because a select few were terrorists. People judge and generalize when it’s convenient, they don’t hate 17 year old American boys because of the Columbine Massacre, but they hate Arabic people because some of them held terrorist attacks.
Works Cited
Stein, Joel. "Millenials: The Me Me Me Generation." TIME. TIME, 09 May 2013. Web. 30 Oct. 2013.
Baumeister, Roy. Interview. TIME 09 May 2013: 2-3. Print.
Gevinson, Tavi. Interview. TIME 09 May 2013: 2. Print.
Cited: Stein, Joel. "Millenials: The Me Me Me Generation." TIME. TIME, 09 May 2013. Web. 30 Oct. 2013. Baumeister, Roy. Interview. TIME 09 May 2013: 2-3. Print. Gevinson, Tavi. Interview. TIME 09 May 2013: 2. Print.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Summary- The millennial generation has a strong right consciousness and always has high expectations and demands. Higher expectations are born primarily from superiority, and as a result they do not work accustomed to their work, but work to adapt to their lives. The millennial generation wants to get praised from parents, teachers, and their coaches.…
- 266 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Millennials have come into a negative light in the eyes of many being blamed for problems in the world today. In Joel Stein’s article entitled The New Greatest Generation he believes they will instead of causing problems bring solutions to them and I agree with him. The millennials are a generation possessing much more resources and technology than any other generation before them by a long shot. The technological advances made from the 1980s to the early 2000 have opened a world of possibilities that millennials will and are taking advantage of to get further in life.…
- 1107 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Mark Bauerlain, in his book The Dumbest Generation, claims that the current under thirty generation is the “dumbest” in modern history, citing the fact that they “don’t know anything” (Bauerlain). Yet the under thirty generation has revolutionized social and linguistic conventions at a rate unmatched by all save for the Ancient Greeks, have grown up in an intelligence-centered culture, and, older people have been complaining about the ‘shortcomings’ of the younger generations for centuries. The facts don’t support Bauerlain - his claims that young people are “dumber” are completely unfounded and radiate an aura of elderly bitterness. Millenials are in the midst of transforming society and language at a breakneck pace, “the likes of which haven’t been seen since Greek civilization” (Clive). Young people “write far more than any generation before”, and have created “new forms of expression and rules for social behavior” (Ito, Clive).…
- 639 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
From a neutral perspective, the author possesses a definitive purpose but elicits wild generalizations upon the entire millennial generation, ultimately detracting authenticity and credibility as the author’s voice leaks into the article. Tyler is clearly well-versed in the subject and openly expresses her opinions as fact throughout her work; she smartly refrains from speaking in the first person, but with the inclusion of her opinions, she might as well use “I” in every argument. She begins the article with the inclusion that millennials have underdeveloped brains, are hopelessly reliant upon technology, and possess a cloud of over-attached parents. She assumes that this particular generation will wreak negative impacts on the workforce as she braces employers for the impending intrusion. For example, she opens her argument with youths’ inferiority. “Older generations that couldn’t wait to proclaim their independence can’t comprehend this generation’s need for parental guidance and influence” . The choice of small rhetorical choices ultimately guides the reader…
- 1032 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
On account of my own experiences (Yes, I know personal experience doesn’t trump truths) within the Millennial generation. This generation sings a song that is of a different tune than the one “The Newest Greatest Generation” suggests. When reflecting on where my peers are and are headed, I see a generation that is filled with persons of high character, creativity, and open mindedness. Not to say this isn’t a generation without flaws, as we have many, but unlike Stein, I wouldn’t hesitate to label this generation as altruistic, full of fervor, and philanthropy. As a reader it was difficult for me to believe the “truths” of this article, and easy for me to accept this as another case of social ageism, the “us vs them”…
- 493 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In May of 2013, the American journalist Joel Stein wrote an article called "The New Greatest Generation" for Time magazine that is extremely successful in convincing his audience that although millennials, or individuals born in between the years of 1980 and 2000, have a small number of unfavorable qualities, they will eventually be the generation to "save us all." In his article, Stein is extremely effective in conveying to his readers that millennials are not as terrible they are perceived to be through his use of humor, data, and the way he organizes his writing. Some may argue that Stein is ineffective in convincing readers that millennials are acceptable because he presents his counterargument first, but he organizes the article this way…
- 1206 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
In Renee Wilson’s article, “The Defence of the iGeneration” (2013), she discusses her belief of the iGeneration being the smartest generation yet. Through many anecdotes, Wilson reflects on her experiences teaching the iGeneration and how they are able to ignore negative criticism and still show their full potential. This article was originally published in This Magazine, which is a Canadian magazine that explores politics and pop culture. This Magazine works towards publishing articles on topics that usually do not go mainstream and are targeted towards a middle-aged and young adult audience. Therefore, Wilson has a dual audience and thus a dual goal as well.…
- 785 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
That only credible information for millennials are quotes given by well respected academics. According to Gary Stiteler, an Army recruiter interviewed by Joel Stein, “The generation that we enlisted when I first started recruiting was sort of do, do, do. This generation is think, think about before you do it” he says. “This generation is three to four steps ahead” (qtd. in Stein 32). After reviewing the article, one can easily realize the few examples of praising for the millennials. However, there is a surplus of praise for Generation X throughout the entire front page of the article that is front loaded with statistical data. Instead, Stein uses statistics as written, “58% more college students scored higher on a narcissism scale in 2009 than in 1982” (Stein 28). To inform the reader, that statement is used by Joel Stein from the National Institutes of Health. To clarify, Joel Stein is not feeding his audience any facts that praise the millennial generation for their hard work but only uses quotes from wellrespected academics which gives his article an unbalance of factual data. Also, the millennial generation at its youngest age is only eighteen, so there is still plenty of room for…
- 1051 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Today I read two articles that have impacted my thought of the millennials era, those two articles are The Outsiders: How Can Millennials Change Washington If They Hate It? by Ron Fournier and Millennials: The Greatest Generation or the Most Narcissistic? by Jean Twenge. In the first article they really explained that this generation, the people of today are the ones that they younger people are more service oriented than anyone ever was. This is a great thing, but whats the link? Nothing actually. These young adults are going out and helping their community just because they want to help out not because they want a job in the government or politics. In fact they don't see politics or the government actually helping their community. They are…
- 421 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
When it comes to the topic of online learning, most of us will readily agree that technology can be an incredible learning tool in this new Digital Age. Where this usually ends, however, is on the question of whether or not technology is helping or hindering the learning of students and young adults. Whereas some are convinced that technology will help students by supplying them with knowledge and vast amounts of resources, others maintain that technology is corrupting our youth and making us stupid. One such person who believes the latter is Mark Bauerlein.…
- 431 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
My name is Amanda Trevino and I attend Gila Ridge High School. In English class, we were asked to read and express our opinions about the piece of writing that we had chosen. I chose your article “5 Ways America Is Creating a Generation of Wimps.” In your article you are trying to convince the readers that our new generation is a bunch of wimps that can’t do anything else but live their lives in a video game. I agree with this claim because I think that this generation is turning into people who are incapable of taking on the real world and can’t bare to lives their lives without playing video games.…
- 904 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
People even kill themselves to see a text or picture by texting and driving, if that doesn’t say “were the dumbest generation” I don’t know what does. Our youth is not growing up receiving the knowledge they should be, obviously. I wasn’t completely oblivious to it all, but then I read this article and realized it’s actually a lot worse than I really thought it was. Ray Williams is also right about the fact that “The new elite are the angry social media posters, the ones that can shout the loudest and more often, a clique of bullies and malcontents baying together like dogs cornering a fox” it’s disgusting to see the fact that someone like Kim Kardashian makes more money than someone important, such as a doctor, or a military member all because she made a sex tape. It really infuriates me to know that we have people out there giving their lives so our country can prosper, but all were doing is getting dumber and fatter, the worst part is that most citizens of the U.S.A. can’t even pass the citizenship…
- 669 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
“.. . Are Millennials ‘Generation We’ or ‘Generation Me’” (Twenge). The general public is debating whenever Millennials, today’s age group, are caring well civic-minded people or entitled narcissists. The relationship between Millennials and narcissism is something that cannot be simply ignored, which is why various authors, for example Jean M. Twenge and Robin Marantz Henig, have published articles to back up their own personal views. Jean M. Twenge, a professor of psychology at San Diego State University, has written over 90 scientific publications and a book called Generation Me. In her article called Millennials: The Greatest Generation or the Most Narcissistic, she states how she has conducted different experiments that contradict what other authors have stated. By doing this she slowly built up and shaped her credibility; she is showing how she is far more superior for she is giving us facts she has uncovered herself. She makes her position clear and argues that other authors are wrong by coming up with a rebuttal for every claim that opposes her opinion, that Millennials are narcissistic. She creates a strong opinion with facts that supports it; however, she gives no statistics or percentages on the survey she conducted. She writes that out of ten million responses, some were ‘most likely’ or ‘least likely’ .Since she is comparing this generation the older generations, she should at least give us some statistics and comparisons. Without any numbers to prove her facts so we can compare with other authors, how can we be so sure most Millennials are narcissistic? Unlike Ms. Twenge however, Ms. Henig is more experienced in Millennials since she has raised two daughters.…
- 1022 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
With technology easily accessible throughout their lives, it is easy to say the Millennial Generation had it easy, and they did. They take for granted the ease of access and the quick flow of information, a thing unlike any prior generation. Some may even say that they abuse their use of technology by using it at inappropriate or unnecessary times. Next, the generation’s expectations are far too high when looking for a job. David Bass takes this side of the argument. Although a Millennial himself, Bass describes a generation forcing themselves into massive debt, and then blaming outside factors. “... many reasons for my generation’s predicament… a direct result of our own choices.” (Bass, 31). With low employment rates, the Millennial Generation would rather go into debt than finding a job. Millennials will go to an undergraduate school for a four degree. Afterwards, unsure of what to do, they will then go to graduate school amassing an even larger debt. During this time period, the Millennial Generation will have also gained a large credit debit, setting them even further behind. These “self inflicted wounds” force Millennials to move in with the parents as they can’t afford, or can’t function, on their own. With all the schooling behind them, Millennials hold a higher expectation in their future job force than what is realistic. With this false reality, Millennials might reject jobs they see as beneath them. It is due the unrealistic employment placement that makes the Millennials seem lazy. Is it entirely their faults,…
- 1392 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Society has changed over time. That is a result of that people has changed over time. Being young today is not the same as being young in the ancient history. Being young today is a frustrating period of time. We all have been there. Mood swings, love, friends, identity crisis. We were scared, and some of us still are, but being a part of something made us feel safe. The Article from Yale Daily News written by Marina Keegan, May 27, 2012, a week before she got killed in a car accident, is a speech where she expresses how we should not be afraid of the unknown future. Scared of being alone and making the wrong decisions.…
- 821 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays