Preview

Jean Jacques Rousseau Critique

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1360 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Jean Jacques Rousseau Critique
Jean-Jacques Rousseau's philosophy of education known as "negative education" (Entwistle in Bayley, 89) describes many valid concepts which are still applied in today's educational system. Although his philosophy is reasonable in terms of its ideas, his contradictions make it such that it would be difficult to apply realistically as pedagogy. Rousseau was a French philosopher of the eighteenth century, he argued that children should not be told what to learn, instead they should learn for themselves through experiences and his pedagogies of "negative education", "the discipline of natural consequences", and "the discipline of lost opportunities" (Entwistle in Bayley, 89). He believed that anything man-made was corrupt and that children should be taught by nature. Rousseau believed in order to preserve a child's original nature, the type of education received depended on the child's age.

I. Rousseau's Concept of "Negative Education"

As defined by Rousseau, "negative education" is the act of educating children using a method other than the typical educational system. Rousseau believed that we are inherently pure and good, but we become corrupted by the chains and limitations of our evil society. We are born pure, and that is our natural state because that is how God created us. He believed that humans become corrupt because of the chains and limitations that society put on humans. Rousseau argued that knowledge was provided by the growth of the person, and that what the teacher needed to do was to create opportunities for learning. Due to this, Rousseau believed that children should be kept from a typical educational system during their early stages of schooling so they can remain pure longer (Entwistle in Bayley, 90). A significant part of Rousseau's "negative education" stresses that parents and teachers should focus on the present rather than on the future, because children are entitled to enjoy their childhood years (Entwistle in Bayley, 92). In

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Unlike Thomas Hobbes, who believed humans were naturally evil, Jean Rousseau believed that humans are born, neither good nor bad, thus corruption or goodness is taught from the society. For example, when children are born, everything they…

    • 514 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rousseau depicts man in his natural state as innocent and good, blaming the invention of property as the root of societal inequalities and lamenting the sacrifice of liberty required of members of a state. Rousseau's early man is deemed non-confrontational, concerned only with 'self-preservation'…

    • 252 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    All of these authors share some similar points, but the majority spoken is disagreement. I would expect this when there are men and women speaking their views during enlightenment. Of course, the men see women as objects to look good for them while requiring no education or the ability to reason.…

    • 759 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Discourse on the Arts and Sciences is an award winning proposal by Jean-Jacques Rousseau conceived with the intent of addressing the “potentially purifying effects upon morals through the restoration of the arts and sciences.” [p. 1] Rousseau examines the concept of measuring our own self worth with the ability to perform in a manner deemed worthy of the rest of societies approbation. This is explored as Rousseau describes the consequences of “perceiving the principal advantage of an intercourse with the Muses” [p. 3] as creating a more sociable society which will strive to achieve the acceptance of those they coexist alongside. In doing so, Rousseau incorporates the idea that the arts and sciences “stifle in men the sense of original liberty, cause them to love their own slavery, and make of them what is…

    • 538 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He expresses a disappointment in youth educational institutions by criticizing the schools for the unchanged “social and educational conditions” of children that come out of the educational system (33). Hirsch declares that underprivileged children should be able to break the cycle of deprivation and illiteracy as long as the schools are willing to break from a half a century inflexible and flawed program of study (33). He mentions the instructional principles of Jean Jacques Rousseau, John Dewey, and Plato and reveals the inadequacies that still control the educational system in the Unites States (34). Hirsch recommends a change to the educational philosophies that govern our schools and proposes an alternative to ensure an effective method to the “mature literacy” of all members of society…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the article that I read Philosopher Thomas Hobbes believed that people must surrender their freedom to a ruler. In the article, french philosopher Jean-Jacques Rousseau states that people should come together in societies and the solution was to form a social contract with general will or the common good.…

    • 414 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Education has never yet been brought to bear with one-hundredth part of its potential force upon the natures of children, and, through them, upon the character of men and of the race. In all the attempts to reform mankind which have hitherto been made, whether by changing the frame of government, by aggravating or softening the severity of the penal code, or by substituting a government created for a God-created religion, - in all these attempts, the infantile and youthful mind, its amenability to influences, and the enduring and self-operating character of the influences it receives, has been almost wholly unrecognized. Here, then, is a new agency, whose powers are but just beginning to be understood, and whose mighty energies hitherto have been but feebly invoked; and yet, from our experience, limited and imperfect as it is, we do know that, far beyond any other earthy instrumentality, it is comprehensive and…

    • 1629 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Was Rousseau a Philosophe?

    • 1154 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Was Rousseau a philosophe? According to the Wikipedia definition of a philosophe, “philosophes were a new approach to learning that encouraged reason, knowledge and education as a way of overcoming superstition and ignorance.” 1 The underlying goal of a philosophe was the concept of progress. Through the mastery and explanation of the sciences, humanity could learn to harness the natural world for its own benefit in order to live peacefully with one another. Rousseau’s ‘Second Discourse’ does exactly that: It is an incredible re-creation of the concept of how man existed in a perfect state and ultimately led themselves towards voluntary enslavement. I believe it was Rousseau’s purpose to make the world understand the transformation that had occurred in an attempt to get humanity to revert back to a level of equality and co-existence that had once occurred naturally.…

    • 1154 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Children today are given everything and in return give nothing, this is bad for humanity to become a grow and remain prosperous. Children need experience and they need to be resilient to petty problems and learn how to fight actual problems. Children need to grow into healthy self-sustaining adults. Parents often time in present day America often give their children better opportunities in school and expect them to perform up to the level that the money that they spend should equate to. This way of parenting causes high amounts of stress for the student because they feel that if they aren’t getting A’s then they have failed at their job as a student (Source A).…

    • 772 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Savages are forced to teach themselves everything from a young age, which makes them much sharper than educated men. The only goal of a savage is self preservation, so his senses are thoroughly developed compared to a civilized man, who is given everything he needs to survive starting at a young age. Men in societies are always striving to be greater than other men which has a negative affect on their minds and this shown when Rousseau wrote, “excesses of every kind, immoderate transports of every passion, fatigue, mental exhaustion, the innumerable pains and anxieties inseparable from every condition of life, by which the mind of man is incessantly tormented; … and that we might have avoided them nearly all by adhering to that simple, uniform and solitary manner of life which nature prescribed” (Rousseau, paragraph 9). Through this statement, Rousseau endorses the lifestyle of a savage, by explaining that men who lead this lifestyle have no worries besides what he will be eating and how he will protect himself. This is a simple lifestyle free of comparing yourself to others and he believes that it is ideal and that man would be much happier this…

    • 632 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    J.J. Rousseau was an optimistic Enlightenment thinker. He believed that people were born naturally good but that the cruel society corrupted him. His optimistic beliefs are showed in The Social Contract, in which he expressed his belief of general will. He argued that the individual replaced the monarch as the true source of power. Rousseau also argued that the general will was not that of the majority but it was the will of a far-seeing minority…

    • 583 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Rousseau states that Hobbes and Locke mischaracterize the state of nature, since man is not motivated by greed, envy or material things in a true state of nature. From Rousseau point of view man would be motivated by love to the self and self preservation. Rousseau expresses how animals does not have a need for material things and they life in a state of nature.…

    • 65 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rousseau Analysis

    • 677 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In ancient times all men lived in a state of nature until hardships and the necessity to form a civil society between one another became eminent. Jean Jacques Rousseau’s “The Social Contract,” analyses the steps and reasoning behind this transition. In Rousseau’s work he focuses on several key terms in order to define this transition clearly, they include: state of nature, social contract, civil society, general will, and the sovereign.…

    • 677 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    All sociologists accept that education is important in society as people receive 15000 hours of compulsory education. However, they have different opinions about the role of education in society. The originator of the functionalist ideology, Emile Durkheim (1858-1917) argued that education is an agent of secondary socialisation which transmits norms, values and roles (value consensus) and acts as a bridge between family and the whole social system. He claims pupils should see themselves as part of a nation by learning of certain subjects which can establish a common political identity for social solidarity, i.e. history, so pupils can see similarities between themselves and the past society.…

    • 1155 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dialogue

    • 2361 Words
    • 10 Pages

    In the first few sentences of this article, Giroux talks about the idea of teaching teachers. This is something that has always interested me, how do you educate someone in such a way that this person then becomes a good teacher. More interestingly though is how do two people who go through the exact same University training become different types of teachers. One could be arguably good and the other one bad. This means that there must be more to it than simply the education process. Sociologically speaking, everything that happens to us shapes us as human beings, it shapes our personality and just about everything that we do. This does not mean however that having bad teachers throughout our life will turn us into a bad teacher as well, more likely it would mean that it drove you to be a good teacher, to teach in a way that you would have liked to be taught. This leads me to wonder if the educational process really has…

    • 2361 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays