Preview

Is the Criminal Justice System Bias?

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2176 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Is the Criminal Justice System Bias?
Criminal Justice Theories
Jason Shockley
Is the Criminal Justice System Bias

By: David Atkins

Abstract This paper will ask several questions and hopefully answer most of those questions. Questions like is the criminal justice system bias against the poor and is the criminal justice system bias against minorities. We then explore some of the possible solutions to the problems that could cause biases. We then look at a study done on several communities where relations between police and the public had repaired their relationship.

Body It’s easy to understand why people see the criminal justice system as biased. Our of all of our states prisoners forty percent can not even read; and sixty-seven percent did not have full-time employment when they were arrested. So there are more uneducated people in prison then there are educated people. This seems like then that our system of criminal justice is operated on an unequal system against poor or uneducated people. However, one of the problems we run into when we try to compare the wealthy lawbreakers to poor lawbreakers is the wide difference between the amount of wealthy people and poor people we have in our population. “In 1989, the wealthiest one percent of United States households owned nearly forty percent of the nation’s wealth. The wealthiest twenty percent owned more than eighty percent of the nation’s wealth. That leaves precious little for the rest” (Cole, 2000). This isn’t just true with adults, but with children and teenagers too. The number of poor/under-funded schools in America far outweighs the number of wealthy schools in America. That’s probably the main reason our system appears to be unfair against the poor. The reason that any pole or nation wide research will be bias against the poor or lower class is because there is a much larger poor/lower class population than a wealthy/high class population.
Most American’s will probably not want to believe that our criminal

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the article, “The Rich Get Richer and Poor Get Prison” Jefferey H. Reiman clearly depicts that poor citizens have a greater chance for imprisonment over middle and upper- class citizens. The author makes it predominately obvious that he believes, at least as far as criminal justice is concerned, racism is simply one powerful form of economic bias (Reiman 1). Through studies, statics in the article overall show that black Americans with low income rates or no income at all living in “disorganized inner-cities” have an increasingly higher rate to commit crimes resulting in being arrested leading conviction. The criminal justice system functions to ‘weed out’ and thus grants advantages to the middle and upper- class. First, there is economic…

    • 523 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    stop and frisk policy

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages

    1. BIAS IN POLICE STOPS? In the late 1990s, popular, legal, and political concerns were raised across the United States about police harassment of minority groups in their everyday encounters with law enforcement. These concerns focused on the extent to which police were stopping people on the highways for “driving while black” (seeWeitzer 2000; Harris 2002; Lundman and Kaufman 2003). Additional concerns were raised about racial bias in pedestrian stops of citizens by police predicated on “zero-tolerance” policies to control quality-of-life crimes and policing strategies concentrated in minority communities that targeted illegal gun possession and drug trafficking (see Fagan, Zimring, and Kim 1998; Greene 1999; Skolnick and Caplovitz 2001; Fagan and Davies 2000, 2003; Fagan 2002; Gould and Mastrofski 2004).…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Bias-Based Policing

    • 99 Words
    • 1 Page

    One of the major problems that police deal with is bias-based policing. Bias-based policing is best described as practices that police intentionally use based on ethnicity, gender, religion, age, and sexual orientation. It also includes racial profiling (p.31). In my opinion, this problem will always be around, because there will always be at least one bad police officer. In order for us to minimize this problem, police officers should interact with the people in the community more. If the police made relationships with people of all races, it would make it easier for the community to trust law…

    • 99 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Supporting social conflict theory, which was created by Carl Marx, helps to us better understand police and citizen interact. In a Study conducted by Holmes et. al, (2008) Holmes and his colleagues realized that race and class together determines how police and citizen interacts. In the same way, Lersch’s (1998) analysis of citizens' complaints showed that people in lower income societies (miniorites) were more likely to file complaints of police misconduct and to “experience more serious acts of misconduct” than those with more power and resources (Lersch, 1998, par. 38). The main function of the police is to keep the status quo of inequality and to assist the powerful (police and/or Whites) to exploit the powerless (Blacks and minorities)…

    • 175 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Self-serving bias refers to individual tendency to attribute positive outcomes to personal factors, but attribute negative outcomes to external factors. In Schall V. Martin, Justice Thurgood Marshall pointed out that even though judges strive to apply the law, it still “gives rise to a level of inequality because they use standards they deem appropriate.” The state has power and responsibility to protect children but also has the duty to protect the public and is usually guided by public opinion. The media has already swayed the public to demonize young black males as seen by the countless stories of the demonization of young black males. While the courts seemingly set out to give the appearance of positivity to the best interest of the public…

    • 149 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    One well-known researcher in particular has been highlighted for his ample research on race as a determinant of attitudes from African-Americans toward police. He was one of the first researchers to explore this topic. His theory was that African Americans’ difficult past has led them to believe that there are active unethical practices within the justice system today, and that this belief leads to their generally unfavorable attitude toward police. In many of his findings, he observed and compared the differences between the attitudes of African Americans and their Caucasian counterparts when it came to dealings with law enforcement. What he found was that many of the African American subjects were…

    • 1337 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    David Cole wrote, "Our criminal justice system affirmatively depends on inequality." Race and class have long been issues in the criminal justice system, but does the system "affirmatively depend on inequality?" Does the criminal justice system depend on the disparities of the people that it serves? I have been learning about our criminal justice systems for three years, and consistently going to different types of Courts for assignments and my own interests in order to eye witness the court systems and how the main figures in Courts perform fairly in following the U.S. Constitutions. For the most of time, Judges were diligent, patient, courteous, and fair minded, the Defense Attorneys and the Prosecutors were efficient in the preparation and trial of the case, and seemed to respect each other in dealing with the case and even the police officers seemed to be adequately trained in courtroom decorum, respecting every person in the courtroom without any biased. However, after watch the documentary film, “Murder on a Sunday Morning” directed by Jean-Xavier de Lestrade, I started to question about the reality of the American Criminal Justice System and thought American justice is possibly somewhat blind.…

    • 596 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Most evidence suggests that when law enforcement authorities use racial profiling, racial tension can easily become a problem in communities. If ethnic minorities are far more likely to be stopped by police, they tend to feel that they are being unfairly harassed as a result, and before long racial tensions build up between the police and the local community. A great example of this tension is the reaction sparked by the Ferguson trials. Historically, black riots are driven by a collective lack of faith in the justice system, and feelings that the concerns of the community remain unheard. David A. Harris professor of law at the university of Pittsburgh says, "Neither the police nor the public can make the streets safe by themselves; police work without public support will not do the whole job. The police and those they serve must have a real partnership, based on trust, dedicated to the common goal of suppressing crime and making the community a good place to live and work." How can we expect the police to form this crucial partnership with all this tension in between the police and community?…

    • 506 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thacher (2011) found that “wealthy jurisdictions had 45 percent more police per index crime than poor jurisdictions” (p. 284). Thacher indicated that the disparities in the number of police officers responding to crime saw 15 police officers per 100 index crimes, in the wealthiest communities, compared to 10.3 police officers in the poorest communities. Thacher ascribed 137 percent more police officer per violent crimes in the wealthiest communities than there were poorest communities. The impact of disparities in policing to poorer jurisdictions is that “The minority poor pay for crime in their personal victimization and in the fear it engenders; in higher prices, shorter hours, and poorer selections of goods in the stores they patronize; in the virtual absence from their neighborhoods of some kinds of establishments, such as banks; and in diminished job opportunities in retailing, office work, and manufacturing as businesses relocate to lower-crime areas” (as cited in Thacher, 2011, p.…

    • 625 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In a court of law there are many factors that would go into social injustice. Examples would be race, ethnicity, age, gender, ETC. One of the most prominent however, is socioeconomic status. The rich will always have an advantage in the justice system in comparison to people with low socioeconomic status. This is mostly due to three key factors; corrections, courts, and poor defense attorneys. The United States government needs to reform the criminal justice system in order to ensure that every case is equal to one another.…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Police Stereotypes

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages

    "Poor police-community relations adversely affect the ability of the police to prevent crime and apprehend criminals. People hostile to the police are not so likely to report violations of the law, even when they are the victims. They are even less likely to report suspicious persons or incidents, to testify as witnesses voluntarily, or to come forward and provide information ... . Yet citizen assistance is crucial to law enforcement agencies if the police are to solve an appreciable portion of the crimes that are committed." (Sullivan, Dunham, & Alpert, 1987).…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Racial Profiling Thesis

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages

    and try to determine whether or not cultural prejudice in the interior of the criminal justice system really has come into existent (particularly in contradiction of African Americans) and if ethnic noninvolvement is even thinkable . I will precisely use information that places of interest on the racial differences found within the criminal justice system, and that offer critical and sociological clarifications for those differences. My hypothesis is that I will find that racial prejudice in the criminal justice system has produced the racial differences that occur and that racial impartiality within the system is…

    • 1076 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The populations have a complete imbalance and this is a result because of the judges that are representing the United States justice system. In a study done by William & Mary Law School researchers found that “Black men are noticeably sentenced to higher levels within the statutory matrix than white men. The difference relative to white men is about 15 to 27 percent, and the odds ratios suggest that the levels are much higher for black men than for Hispanic men or white women” (Griffin, Sloan, Eldred, 2015). This gives people a chance to see the racial disparities that are going on, it should be wake up call to many people as to how the judges that determine these sanctions should be held accountable for. Marcus Watson, 22 African American said “Judges are the main reason why people are in the system. They’re racists and there’s no telling what they are capable of, it’s scary having to go up in from of a judge but imagine going up in front of judge that you knew was going to cage you up like an animal because of the color of your skin. Or having to go up to someone and pled your innocence even though you already know the outcome. It’s people like that that have black men scared for their lives and most important enslaved to this type of discrimination.” The points being made by this student is very true, many people feel unprotected by the people whose job is to protect everyone. We…

    • 1030 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In recent times, social media has been flooding with the idea that government agencies such as the police force, are after poor minority men. Although the purpose of these agencies is to keep the peace and abolish crime, these poor minority men are thrown behind bars for an arrest far greater than what they have committed. The number and type of men thrown into prison indicate that there is a racial inequality and corruption within the penal system.…

    • 662 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    “Racial bias by the police includes such things as racial profiling of motorists, racial prejudice among police officers, and discriminatory treatment of minority individuals and minority neighborhoods” (Weitzer, 2005, p. 1009+). A negative aspect in correlation to the mistreatment of minorities within American society is the domino effect that fallows the majority of individuals after he or she is taken into custody. Racial disparity and supported biases projected toward minority offenders is common within the criminal court system. Based on the race, color, or creed of the offender the level of sentencing fallows a more stringent basis than sentencing terms for an individual who is Caucasian throughout Northern America.…

    • 1259 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics