HSA515 Health Care Policy, Law and Ethics
Dr. Harold Griffin
January 22, 2012
Identify and explain the four elements of proof necessary for a plaintiff to prove a negligence case
The first element that a plaintiff must prove is that the defendant owed him or her legal duty of care. Generally, this duty of care is a legal notion that states that people owe anyone around them or anyone who could be around them a duty to not place them in situations of undue risk of harm. Proving this element will largely depend on the facts of the situation. After the plaintiff has proved that a legal duty of care existed, he or she must then prove that this duty was breached. Generally, courts will use the standard of a ‘reasonable person’ when it comes to this question. Specifically, this means that the judge or jury must view the facts of the situation and decide what a reasonable person would have done in a similar situation. If this reasonable person would have acted differently than the defendant, it’s likely that it will be found that the duty was breached. Causation is the most complicated element of negligence. It means that the plaintiff must prove that the defendant either directly or indirectly caused the injuries and damages suffered by the plaintiff because of the breach of the duty of care. This element has confused even the most respected legal minds over time, and its proof should not be taken lightly. Last, a plaintiff in a negligence case must prove a legally recognized harm, usually in the form of physical injury to a person or to property. It is not enough that the defendant failed to exercise reasonable care. The failure to exercise reasonable care must result in actual damages to a person to whom the defendant owed a duty of care (FindLaw 2012). These damages can be actual costs such as medical expenses and lost income or intangible costs such as pain and suffering or loss of companionship.
References: FindLaw. (2012). Elements of a Negligence Case. Retrieved on January 22, 2012 from http://injury.findlaw.com/personal-injury/personal-injury-law/negligence/negligence-case-elements.html Law Teacher. (2012). Introduction to Vicarious Liability. Retrieved on January 22, 2012 from http://www.lawteacher.net/tort-law/lecture-notes/vicarious-liability-lecture.php Showalter, J. S. (2008). The law of healthcare administration (5th ed.). Chicago: Health Administration Press.[pic]