Preview

How Do Alice Pung's Short Stories and Paul Keating's Eulogy, Explore the Role of a Person’s Relationship with the ‘World’ Around Them in Shaping Their Sense of ‘Identity’ ?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
912 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
How Do Alice Pung's Short Stories and Paul Keating's Eulogy, Explore the Role of a Person’s Relationship with the ‘World’ Around Them in Shaping Their Sense of ‘Identity’ ?
Identity is presented through the contents of belonging, values and beliefs. A person’s identity constantly changes and develops in time, depending on aspects of ethnicity, self-image and connection to a person or place. It is this which “builds” the qualities of identity. Prime examples of expressing the intricate nature of identity is clearly seen through Alice Pung’s short stories “The Face in the Mirror” and “Sticks and Stones and such-like” alongside Paul Keating’s memorable eulogy speech “The Unknown Soldier”.

In Pung’s short story “The Face in the Mirror”, the author explores how ethnicity illustrates how a person’s relationship in the world creates a sense of identity. The idea is seen in the quote:

“For much of my childhood, my Asian-ness was pushed to a crevice in the back of my mind. My friends were white, my family was white, my world was white.”

The female protagonist conveys her cultural identity, through the use of a compound word, describing her “Asian-ness” persona as being part of a white family. Pung also uses the technique of repetition, demonstrated through the word “white” coupled with the metaphor of “my world was white” to depict the fact that her whole lifestyle, revolves around “white” customs, as she neglects her original cultural origin being “made in Korea”. Through this, the audience are made to empathize for the protagonist as she is forced into neglecting her asian background. Hence, further reinforcing Pung’s concept of how ethnicity can be an aspect of identity.

Another way Pung demonstrated her concept of identity is through the use of the technique accumulation, in conjunction with rhetorical question in the short stories ‘Face in the Mirror’. For example. Accumulation is found where Pung lists “a name, a place, a date and temperature.” She follows this technique with the rhetorical question “but, what did it all mean?”. Pung uses these techniques to utilize the fact that the protagonist strives to find out more on

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    My Own Identity Essay

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages

    One’s own identity is derived not by circumstances, but rather by his or her experiences, moral values, as well as motivation. Especially in today’s media, people love to read or watch about impossible stories of rags-to-riches, and they try to incorporate those stories’ motivational plots into their quest to become successful. I concur with Thomas Merton in that I believe “identity is much more than the name or features one is born with. True identity is something people must create for themselves.” One’s origin does not fully account for one’s identity, but it is shaped rather by actions and perception of self. Ideals from “People Inside Me”, “Cut”, and “Commencement Speech at Mount Holyoke College” all influence my point of view regarding…

    • 870 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    GUAIA ESSAY

    • 823 Words
    • 4 Pages

    ‘The writers in Growing up Asian in Australia show embracing multiple cultural identities is a challenging and also enriching personal journey.’…

    • 823 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Taylor. S. 2009 ‘Who do we think we are? Identities in everyday life’ in Taylor. S, Hinchcliffe. S, Clarke. J, Bromley. S (eds) Making Social Lives. Milton Keynes. The Open University.…

    • 1482 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    assignment 1.2

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Also, she never thought of her skin color until shortly after she arrived in the United States. She soon became aware that she was Asian and her skin color is yellow. At last she understood that there was no choice but to adapt to the new society and learn English. Learning English is not as difficult as facing poverty. Her family’s fighting against poverty was successful and they moved to new better place in search of better jobs and education. She called her family a 1.5 U.S. generation, although they are 100-percent American on paper and official documents, because they already keep their own culture and own habits.…

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Discuss one literary element in the work you have chosen that best helps you see the idea of cultural identity (1–2 sentences). After a classmate tells the girl she has a great big nose and fat legs (Piercy…

    • 521 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The pressure for second generation immigrants to assimilate in all ways to the culture of the country in which they were born is a significant factor in the formation of a person’s identity. Intercultural romantic relationships are also used as a defense mechanism to avoid fully participating in the traditions of a person’s culture as noted by Gogol and Michelle’s relationship. Intercultural romantic relationships can also awaken a person to their insecurities in their identity, as shown with Alice and Michael’s relationship. The significance of a name is also discussed as a symptom of identity crises such as with Gogol’s change of his name to something “more American”. A name is also evidence of a cross-cultural identity as with Alice, who is called Agheare by her family but Alice by the wider…

    • 1349 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Have you ever felt like you were trapped in the wrong body? Often times people struggle with this question because they find it difficult to identify with one specific group, whether it be gender, race, religion, etc. For example, an interracial individual may find it more difficult when trying to answer the often popular Ethnicity question found on various forms. When that individual tries to answer, he/she may often feel they identify more with “African American” rather than “Caucasian.” An author, by the name of Judy Ruiz, wrote an interesting essay called “Oranges and Sweet Sister Boy.” In this essay, Ruiz attempts to describe her struggle with the acceptance of her brother identifying himself as her sister. Often times it is hard to understand the full significance of changing views that have been so instilled in the mind in an attempt to connect with individuals who have those opposing views.…

    • 572 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The graphic novel American Born Chinese (2006), by Gene Luen Yang, is a very modern and influential piece of work that can be compared to the short indie film Two Lies (1990), directed and written by Pamela Tom, which had preceded the novel by 16 years. These two different forms of work, both utilizing their ability to teach the audience, are used as powerful venues for the topic of identity crisis among the Asian people in a majority European American world. In the film, we have Mei and her family who are all having some trouble adjusting to their lives in Southern California but more specifically we have Mei and her trouble to understand her mother 's cause and intent for having undergone double eye-lid surgery. In ABC, we have our protagonist, Jin, who is having trouble fitting into his new school in San Francisco since he is one of the very few Asian admitted to the school. Another time line in the novel is the story of the monkey king who does anything to get rid of the fact that he is a monkey in order to fit into society. The third is the story of Danny, a European American who has trouble and often becomes embarrassed with his hyperbolic Chinese cousin, Chin-Kee. This character is first introduced by saying "Harro Amellica!" while Jin 's father, carrying giant Chinese take out container says "I 'll put your luggage into your room, Chin-Kee" (48). All three of these time line show our characters having some sort of shame or embarrassment to the fact that their own image or background is different from those around them.…

    • 2458 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    In America, the “melting pot” process has been associated with cultural assimilation. In American History, assimilation is the system in which an individual or minority group loses its initial culture when dominated by another culture. With all different ethnic groups in our country, there is no surprise that different individuals view racial and culture identity differently. American writers, exclusively, depict their views of racial pride. While Langston Hughes and Charles W. Chesnutt seek to depict the value in pride of black culture in their literature, Amy Tan writes about the cultural struggles she faces through her mother and…

    • 1375 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Me It Was Friday Analysis

    • 892 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Identity is one aspect of a human that makes one different from everyone else. This is the essential core of all humans. Each person is born in his own country and with his own unique and personal identity. However, as each one grows, his or her identity is consistently changing. What would happen if these factors created no distinction between one another? Would there be a clear contrast between people, or would everyone just be identical? It is evident that if there was no personal identity, then everyone would be the same and there would be no contrast or distinction between people. In Leila Ahmed’s “On becoming an Arab,” Jean Twenge’s “An Army of One: Me,” and Andrew Bacevich’s “When I Woke Up Tuesday Morning, It Was Friday,” each author discusses aspects of one’s identity. To Ahmed……, Andrew Bacevich explains the problems that America is having with foreign goods and oil, and how President Carter deals with the situation. To Twenge, the influence of education teaching self-esteem has created a lower educational standards and a raise of narcissism in a person. A person’s personal identity is formed and affected by their influence with their surroundings and the…

    • 892 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    It buttresses the notion that people of different racial backgrounds really are different in some moral, unbridgeable, permanent sense. It affirms the notion that race should be a cage to which people are assigned at birth and from which people should not be allowed to wander. It belies the belief that love and understanding are boundaries and instead instruct us that our affections are and should be bounded by the color line regardless of our efforts. (Kennedy, 1994)…

    • 970 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Asian American Dreams

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages

    She clearly pointed out a situation that Asian Americans, particularly Chinese Americans, had been facing in the American setting. There had been stereotyped ideologies unaccommodating the political and social status of Chinese Americans. Some of the stereotyped concepts were unintended, nothing malicious. They perhaps were just a product of social interactions between different social, ethnic groups, each of which holding a…

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One’s perspective of the World around them is shaped by their education, childhood, and their experiences. All of these factors culminate to form some sort of final opinion for the person; that encompassing opinion is the person’s thoughts on every country, every culture, and every country’s people. This opinion is often difficult to shift, as it has been formed under many years, and is the basis for many stereotypes, racial prejudices, and bigotry. Jenny Boully, a Thai-American author, confronts these topics in her essay titled “A Short Essay on Being” in the Triquarterly magazine. “A Short Essay on Being” illuminates the credulous American perspective of Asia by depicting Americans as ethnocentrists, who view the world around them in a simply American view and impose their own…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On My Identity

    • 648 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The identity we assume can often be a large part of how we see ourselves and how others around us can get a snapshot of our personalities, our origins, and how we wish to be portrayed. Sometimes the line between distinct identities can be blurred and a person can lose sight of who they are or where they feel like they belong most. Such can often be the case for immigrants as myself, who can sometimes struggle to find the identity that addresses the new life they have molded into and most represents their culture and experiences.…

    • 648 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Notes of a Native Speaker

    • 314 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The essay by Eric Lui, “notes of a native speaker” spoke about his experiences growing up as an Asian American male in the united states. Growing up, He had to face stereotypes and tried to overcome them all as time went on, so much he later felt he lost his identity of who he really was. He says in the essay “here are some ways you can say that I am white:” and then follows with a list of things that most Caucasian people do or wear on a everyday basis that he now does regularly. Things like wearing khakis or even being married to a white woman were on his list. He mentions this list because now people consider Eric to be a “Honorary White” because of his achievements and hobbies. During his time as a kid, he would have problems hooking up with girls around him or hanging out with certain people because of his Asian background. They would just see him as my “Asian friend” or as a math wiz. He hated that he went through this and time and time again he tried fighting the stereotypes of being Asian. He did things like taking his bowl hair cut style (the average hairstyle of a Asian boy) and cut it all off into a buzz cut and he later says, he was “playing the orchestra but also joined the wrestling team, winning science prizes but also editing the school paper”. He called himself the “renaissance boy” but only was seen as a “Asian overachiever”. The struggles Lui went through in his essay takes you step by step into how hard it is to create your own identity in a would where your just a representative of your ethnic group and the risks that come with trying to rid yourself from…

    • 314 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays