Ericka Davis
Nishi Shah-Williams
English 100
4 December 2013
Standardized Testing: Helpful or Harmful for American Youth
I would like to discuss the benefits and disadvantages of standardized testing for primary school children. I support standardized tests that are created based on each school or districts standards. Not all students learn at the same rate or in the same manner. I do feel that testing is one of the easiest methods of tracking how teachers are doing in the classrooms but at what cost the children. Some children who are excellent students freeze up and perform poorly during testing just as students who are sometimes seen as slackers do great when under pressure. Therefore, no one is actually getting accurate data.
Supporters argue that standardized tests are a fair and impartial way to measure students' abilities as a whole compared to their peers. It also ensures teachers and schools are accountable to taxpayers, and that the most important voters - parents and students - approve of testing.
Opponents say the tests are neither fair nor objective, that their use promotes a narrow minded curriculum and drill-like "teaching to the test," and that excessive testing undermines America's ability to produce innovators and critical thinkers. Studies have also shown that standardized tests can not accurately measure academic capabilities because racial and gender stereotypes interfere with the intellectual functioning of those taking the tests.
Questions:
Is this a good topic?
What would you discuss to strengthen the topic?
Do you my topic and/or thesis statement is?
Do you understand my points and counterpoints?
Would you add or take away anything from the paper?
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Standardized testing has been a heavily debated topic for many years because it is not evident if testing is more beneficial or detrimental for children or schools. There are many pros and cons associated with the use of standardized testing. Most educators agree that there needs to be a method of accountability for schools and school districts. However, the question remains, are students tested too much? Additionally, to what extent can a standardize test assess students achievement? Some states use alternative methods of assessment. President Obama pledged to reduce the amount of standardized testing in our schools mainly because it is clear that standardized testing has not improved student achievement in the United States. Standardized…
- 272 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
These test only show the students’ performance the day of the test and not the overall growth of the student over the year. The standardized test does a disservice to both the teacher who worked hard to help their students grow and the student who worked extremely hard over the course of the year and improved tremendously, but failed to pass the test. Many people would argue that teacher and student performance should be evaluated on growth over the year instead of one single test. Many of these students are smart and understand the content, but it does not show on the test. Also many students develop test anxiety which causes stress on the students which leads to negativity directed at school and learning in general. In a picture the teacher says “For a fair selection everybody has to take the same exam: Please climb that tree”. The students he is talking to are a money penguin, elephant, fish, seal, and a dog. Based on these animals only the money will be able to pass the test. This is how the government see all the students, they believe all students are the same when they are actually…
- 1488 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Standardized tests also create unnecessary stress for students. These tests require students to study or cram for many hours and puts them in a demanding social setting where they are forced to answer difficult questions. “Minority test takers experience anxiety, believing that if they do poorly on their test they will confirm the stereotypes about inferior intellectual performance of their minority group. As a result, a self-fulfilling prophecy begins, and the child performs at a level beneath his or her inherent…
- 1271 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Standardized testing causes many dilemmas throughout schools. One big reason why we need to fix standardized testing is if there are people that aren’t able to speak fluent in english they will have a hard time. Just because they aren't able to speak english doesn’t mean that they don't know what they are testing them on. These test are not accurate. We have to fix this. There has also been studies that show these test cause ample amount of stress towards students and teachers. We shouldn’t put kids through this.…
- 543 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Do you wanna waste time on standardized tests if not change how we take tests today. Some think standardized tests are reliable and some think they are a waste of school class time. I think standardized tests are a waste of time and money because most are not reliable.…
- 418 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
During this time, even the birds got quiet, and all you could hear were the pencil tips, racing along the bubbles A, B, C, then D. Yes, this is your typical state or even countrywide standardized testing classroom, and yes, students should have to take them. Why, because they are a helpful way for teachers to see what their students need help in, they can change school grades majorly, and they can help students review what they learned from the year.…
- 433 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
From showing where students, teachers, and even schools need to improve to providing stress to the students and teachers. Standardized tests do many great things for the students by allowing them to compare themselves to others and see areas needing improvement. Teachers can realize what needs a little more focus on the next year and what they taught well. Schools can realize what they may need to improve on as well. Overall, standardized tests bring very good things to students, teachers, and schools, and should be taken by everyone for their own…
- 781 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Diagnostic tests are used to identify the needs of students that may need extra guided instruction by testing specific skills. Standardized tests are a type of diagnostic tests that are used to diagnose individual learning problems or strengths of the students. The most commonly used forms of standardized testing are when they are used to evaluate students’ progress and teachers’ and schools’ effectiveness (Slavin, 2015, p.385,386). Benchmark assessments are another way schools will assess students usually in reading and math. These assessments are used to give schools useful information on students’ progress to benefit them in the future (Slavin, 2015, p.404).…
- 276 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Standardized testing has a detrimental and counterproductive effect on kids in the traditional education setting. It objectifies kids and ranks them according to an arbitrary scale that is not customized to fit individual students and their disparities in learning styles. There is significant evidence and numerous studies that show standardized testing's negative effects on grade school level students. Other methods should be investigated and pursued instead of proctoring standardized tests to ensure that students are being educated to their full potential. Several methods can be put in place to replace standardized testing including stealth assessment, a sampling test method, or written performance descriptions,…
- 835 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Standardized testing in our education system is oftentimes frowned upon. Though some disagree with standardized testing, others see it as an advantage to education in the future. I recently reviewed two articles with opposing opinions on this controversial topic. I noticed that one article worried more about how they felt emotionally, and less focused on the academic advantages or disadvantages. This is an issue in America, I believe when it comes to education we should worry about educational outcomes and not emotional distress due to the criteria in which you are required to abide by.…
- 484 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
One might object here that standardized testing is essential because it helps to ascertain what kids know or do not know, helps parents/guardians decide, helps create a common and fair ground, and is the most effective type of performance task.…
- 1039 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Standardized testing is not the best way to measure how well a teacher teaches or how much a student has learned. Schools throughout the United States put their main focus on standardized tests; these examinations put too much stress on the teachers and students and cause traumatizing events.…
- 861 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
There are many pros and cons of standardized testing, but many do not agree with the new system today. Standardized testing has not improved student achievement after the NCLB act was…
- 1350 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Secondly, testing hasn’t been proven to show student accomplishment. The “No Child Left Behind Act” in 2002 caused the United States test rankings to drop (Standardized Test- procon, 2017). In the United States, the math program went from 18 to the 31st place. Science had a similar drop but reading seems to stay consistent. The year of 2011, on May 26 the national research council concluded that testing programs don’t help the students. Educators and policymakers are now trying to find a way in which tests create a positive effect and have great success…
- 1048 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
My pro aren’t any because I disagree with the whole idea of standardized testing because I can’t see how it is helpfully to the children because some time it can be bias depending on the test.…
- 222 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays