Academic Ethics Across Cultures
Presenter
Opal Leeman Bartzis
Institute for Study Abroad
Butler University
In cooperation with and with resources compiled by
Anne Hayner
Kroc Institute for International Peace Studies
University of Notre Dame
AACRAO Conference, Orlando, FL, March 2008
Center for Academic Integrity
Clemson University Rutland Institute for Ethics
“Academic integrity is a fundamental value of teaching, learning and scholarship. Yet, there is growing evidence that students cheat and plagiarize.” Research from the
Center for Academic Integrity
Clemson University Rutland Institute for Ethics
• On most US college campuses, over 75% of students admit to some cheating.
• Internet plagiarism: 10% in 1999, 41% in 2001.
• Majority of students (68%): “not a serious issue.”
• Cheating: from 11% in 1963 to 49% in 1993
(self-reported -- state universities)
• US high schools: 74% - serious test cheating
• 72% - serious cheating on written assignments
• Over half - some level of plagiarism on written assignments using the Internet.
*
Common Examples of Academic Dishonesty
• Copying answers from another
• Unapproved collaboration
• Using notes or assistance of some sort during exams
• Submitting one’s own work for multiple assignments
• Claiming another’s work as one’s own Plagiarism as a Cultural Construct
Oxford English Dictionary definition of plagiarism: “to take and use another person’s ideas as one’s own.”
Question: Is plagiarism always synonymous with cheating?
Cultural Values, Plagiarism, and Fairness: When Plagiarism Gets in the Way of Learning, written by Hayes J N and Introna L, Ethics & Behavior, 2005, Vol. 15, No. 3: pages 213-231
‘Plagiarism’ & ‘Cheating’ in
Cross-Cultural Perspective
Russia &
Eastern
Europe
• Sharing notes, talking in class OK – not hidden
• Goal is to bring the whole class level up
• Bribes routinely expected for grades
Germany
• Sharing of answers common, but understood as student vs. teacher; not sharing is social taboo
Mexico
• Sharing is common, but students will deny
• Professors do not expect citations in paper
Costa Rica
• Teamwork the rule in personal and academic life, including supporting those who do not contribute to the group
‘Plagiarism’ & ‘Cheating’ in
Cross-Cultural Perspective
China
Burma
• Students openly admit cheating is a way of life
• ‘Intellectual property’ a foreign concept
• Value: saving face, maintaining group harmony
• Cheating seen as a skill everyone should develop to succeed in the world; the world is corrupt
• Student learning seen as a task shared by group
• Worst accusation in culture is selfishness: pursuing own goals at expense of others
India &
Bangladesh
• Student riots when test cheating prevented
• Exams should not be memory tests
Greece
•Focus on learning concepts, rather than words
•Connecting quotes demonstrates understanding
‘Plagiarism’ & ‘Cheating’ in
Cross-Cultural Perspective
Non-Western countries:
•
•
•
•
Focus on textbook learning
Rote learning
Using another author’s words is a form of respect
Loved poetry and revered scholarly arguments are learned by heart
• Students have difficulty stating own opinion
• Students have difficulty criticizing others’ words
Inherent Problems in U.S.
• Academic dishonesty is defined differently across campuses, disciplines and departments • Students are educated about academic dishonesty in different ways
• Academic honesty violations vary and are inconsistent • All of this is intensified for the visiting student How is the problem approached now?
• Honor codes
• Syllabus statements
• Basic message:
“Plagiarism and cheating are not allowed and consequences are serious.”
• Detection
• Penalization
Detection Programs
• Proving plagiarism can be burdensome on faculty • Results are mixed and do not indicate unintentional plagiarism
• Devices derive from Western mindset*
- emphasis on “catching” rather supporting new members of the community - Non-natives become disproportionately identified and scrutinized
* Niall Hayes and Lucas Introna, Lancaster University Management School
Language Acquisition Issues
• “Patch writing” as a transition to language independence
• Students are taught to mimic academics to improve writing skills
• Feeling that student cannot improve upon what has already been written
Group
Work
A Model for Cross-Cultural Training
1. Acknowledge that plagiarism and cheating are not universal concepts
•
•
•
share experiences provide examples of expectations academic ethics as cultural construct
A Model for Cross-Cultural Training
2.
Identify sources of difficulty
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
“common knowledge” collaborative work vs. cheating group vs. individualist focus of society teacher-centered vs. learner-centered collaboration vs. competition model reporting on others: honor or betrayal? research & citation conventions recognizing own writing style student–teacher access pressures on international students ownership of intellectual property differing classroom cultures technology dependence of US students
A Model for Cross-Cultural Training
3. Acknowledge contradictions of US academic expectations
•
•
•
Purdue Online Writing Lab (OWL) handout:
“Avoiding Plagiarism” role of syllabus, US & abroad how to seek help with clarification of expectations, or with citation
A Model for Cross-Cultural Training
4. Provide specific training on citation
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
standards of different disciplines ungraded practice papers paraphrasing instruction and practice collaborate with campus writing center? differing writing and style guides in use alert US students to possible differences in expectations abroad utilization of tutors
A Model for Cross-Cultural Training
5. Encourage students to learn expectations of host culture
•
•
•
•
Be prepared
If expectations clash with home culture norms, look for the value in them
Make decisions about any values that cannot be accepted
Know resources for resolution
U.S. Students Abroad
• Concerns are similar
• See “Tips for U.S. Study Abroad
Students: Preparing for Academic
Ethics Across Cultures” sheet
Resources on Academic Integrity
• University of Sydney, Faculty of Economics and Business: www.econ.usyd.edu.au/
• Extensive web resources
• University sites: guidelines for students, honor codes, suggestions for faculty
• Interactive on-line quizzes
• TESL-EJ articles http://tesl-ej.org/about.html
• NAFSA: US Classroom Culture booklet
• Institute for Study Abroad, Butler University: Academic
Differences section www.ifsa-butler.org
• Center for Academic Integrity, Clemson
University Rutland Institute for Ethics
#
Questions for Further Consideration
• Have we educated ourselves about the current state of academic misconduct in our program locations? • Who has the power to handle cases of academic misconduct in the host country and are we prepared to accept their decisions?
• Should our students be held to the standards of the host country, whether they be more stringent or more lenient?
Contact Us
Opal Leeman Bartzis
Institute for Study Abroad
Butler University, Indiana
oleeman@butler.edu
Anne Hayner
Kroc Institute for International Peace Studies
University of Notre Dame, Indiana
ahayner@nd.edu
Thank you
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
FINAL EXAM ****NOTE: THIS WAS A CLASS TAKEN ON CAMPUS - MAY NOT BE USED FOR ALL ETHICS COURSES***…
- 856 Words
- 4 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Markkula Center for Applied Ethics “A Framework for Thinking Ethically” Santa Clara University. 5 November 2009. <http://www.scu.edu/ethics/practicing/decision/framework.html>.…
- 1783 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Many health care organizations are now calling for multicultural competent health care professionals. It is suggested cultural competence is as an ethical obligation and cross -cultural skills should be placed on a level of parity with other specialized skills (2009). Within each culture exists an incredible diversity of groups and subgroups (2011). Achieving a base of knowledge for each group creates a challenge.…
- 261 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Cited: Newton, L. (2004). Ethics in america source reader. (2nd ed., pp. 96-97, 101-110, 119-120). Upper Saddle River, New Jersey: Pearson Education.…
- 812 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
References: Boylan, M. (2009). Basic Ethics in Action: Basic Ethics (2nd ed.). Retrieved from The…
- 749 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
References: Boylan, M. (2009). Basic Ethics (2nd ed.). Retrieved from The University of Phoenix eBook Collection database.…
- 510 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The following paragraphs will discuss business ethics from different cultural backgrounds. The focus of the backgrounds will be from the Mexican and Chinese aspect of proper business ethics. The articles, Double Standards: Mexico Business and Business Ethics in China are the two articles I will summarize to the reader. I will discuss the primary ethical perspectives of each country covered in the articles, as well as how the articles contributed to a better understanding of global ethical perspectives. Lastly, I will describe the business ethics of each foreign country.…
- 1427 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Hunt, L. H. (2011). Ethics. Web: World Book. Retrieved August 25, 2011, from World Book…
- 2355 Words
- 10 Pages
Powerful Essays -
References: Arthur, J., & Scalet, S. (2009). Morality and Moral Controversies (8th ed.). Upper Saddle River, New Jersey: Pearson, Prentice Hall.…
- 1604 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
Thiroux, J., Krasemann, K. (2012). Ethics: Theory and Practice. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education, Inc.…
- 736 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
America has not always had the same working conditions and ethical guidelines it has today, in fact in the early 1920’s American industries painted a very different picture. There were no child labor laws so it was acceptable that twelve year olds went to work to “feed the family.” There were no safety guidelines in place, if you got your arm chopped off working for the railroad then your oldest child had to go to work to make up for your lost wages. There certainly were no ethical standards that companies and employees had to follow; women did not work outside the home so there were also no sexual harassment laws in place. American Industry in the early 1900’s was a lot like China is today; perhaps this is why so many American jobs are lost to China every day.…
- 1524 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
Lo, B., and Whitehouse, M. (2010). Resolving Ethical Dilemmas, 4th Edition: Lippincott Williams and Wilkins, p.…
- 3289 Words
- 14 Pages
Best Essays -
By Jesper Ryberg within the Journal of Ethics; March 2011. This journal article was discovered…
- 1321 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Shafer-Landau, R. (2012). The fundamentals of ethics. (2nd ed., p. G-6). New York: Oxford University Press.…
- 681 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Lafolette, Hugh. "Living On a Slippery Slope." The Journal of Ethics. 9. no. 3/4 (2005): 475-499.…
- 2342 Words
- 10 Pages
Powerful Essays