Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

English Studies 178 SEMESTER ESSAY

Better Essays
1507 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
English Studies 178 SEMESTER ESSAY
This essay will highlight how violence is demonstrated throughout Pumla Dineo Gqola’s “In the Clarity of a Third Class Compartment” by analyzing the reactions of the specific characters in the story’s reaction to the hooligans’ rude comments and actions that take place in a enclosed train carriage. Specifically looking at how violence can be seen as more than in just a physical way but also in the use of language and by a person’s image. Resulting with the thought that the overall representation of violence is the lack of authority’s rules taking place in this era in South Africa.

Pumla Dineo Gqola’s short story “In the Clarity of a Third Class Compartment” takes place in South Africa in 1996, just after the Apartheid era. The story incudes an odd combination of citizens riding a train who get disrupted by many different ranges of violence. Using examples of how different passengers on the train reacted to a certain situation to provide the different ways violence is represented throughout the story.

When the word violence is brought to discussion there are certain stereotypes and directly associated words to describe violence. Majority of people associate violence with physical and brutal inflicted harm onto people or objects but when not just focusing on the obvious physical aspects of violence there are much more deeper meanings to the word. The Oxford Dictionary explains that violence is not just an behavior involving physical force intended to damage someone but can also be classified as a strength of emotions or an unpleasant destructive natural force. There is a great deal of violence displayed in “In the Clarity of a third class compartment”. Violence is represented in this short story through image, language, and actions. Each classification has a different effect to the situation but each of them signifies the same idea.

One of the ways which violence is represented in “In the Clarity of a Third Class Compartment” is through image. Appearance is a very powerful way of representing an image of one self to the world as to how one would like to be characterized. Unfortunately judgment follows this idea, which is why when a group of rowdy young men climb aboard a still third class train compartment they were classified as hooligans from first glance. They are described by “having an appearance that is accompanied by the image of those responsible for train violence” (Gqola 79). One of the young men carries a scar on his cheek, lips that are similar to an alcoholic’s and blood-shot eyes to match. Strolling onto the train with their reputation and their baggy pants a presence is immediately presented as the atmosphere on the train changes. Resulting just from their image the citizens on the train have made assumptions that these men are capable of violence. Highlighting the idea that violence can be represented through image and attitude not only by out lashing actions. Violent people and places where violent things take place set a scene for intimidation just as how the passengers on the train observed the boisterous men without directly staring. The passengers are intimidated by their violent image. Trying so hard to keep up their violent hooligan image the young men start disturbing the peace on the train by outbursts of inappropriate threatening comments.

Used as an verbal expression violence can also be represented in language. By using harmful words, shouting at a person or any way of using verbal sounds in a demeaning and intimidating way. In “in the Clarity of a Third Class Compartment” the young men shamelessly and openly discuss vulgar violent acts of raping women saying “You jus’ take what you want… from where you want.. even if you have to deal with the husband of father before..” Laughing while the other passengers sit in shock of the men chatting about “grabbing the cherrie.” Rape is a violent crime committed by criminals and these men are conversing and joking about this act. They are discussing this violently with their degrading languages directed at “getting two for the price of one” referring to if there is more than one female to rape at a time. One of the passengers hears this conversation commenting that her lover would never speak any of the languages that the men used to spew hatred on women.” The point that is made when the passenger says this is that these men speak in a different type of aggressive way that is not usually tolerated within her personal life.

The young men then continue in their violent expressions by harassing and insulting a school girl on the train calling her names such as “girlie.” Taunting her they persistently asking her questions. “ What’s the matter, girl, you too good for us?” Verbally harassing her causing much irritation from all this unwelcome attention. There is violence in the voice of these men as they feel they are in charge of the situation, holding power of this girl and making everyone on the train well aware of this by the comments they are making. Majority of the passengers turn a blind eye to the verbal assaults as they feel it is not quite their place to step in although everyone can feel the discomfort formed by their obnoxious comments.

Although none of the passengers budded in standing up for the girl after their remarks once the violence moves into a action the bystanders view the situation as more serious. Everyone is familiar with the term “actions speak louder than words” this quote makes it understandable that physical expressions of hatred makes a much greater impact regarding violence than verbal expressions. Violence applied through actions is a powerful way to express behavior involving physical force. This can be explained through the series of events happening in the train. After the men used a form of violence through language upon the girl there was a discomfort on the train passengers kept to themselves. Only when one of the men physically touched the school girl inflicting physical threats of violence on the girl is when the passengers where quick to jump in to defend the girl. One can easily ignore the voice of someone taunting you but when the threats become physical they become more difficult to ignore. Leaning into and breathing on the girls face was taken further when one of the hooligans reached to touch the girl’s bum. With every violent action there is a great chance of a violent reaction. After the men grabbed the girl she immediately shoved the guy back in a instinct of self defense. The actions of the hooligans not only sparked reaction from the girl but witnesses also lashed out in violent actions. One of the passengers exclaimed that these boys need to be taught a lesson, and that they need a good klap. Others radically mentioned that they should be thrown out the window, like they deserve.

It is made clear that violence can be demonstrated through actions which sometimes even leads to an endless chain of violent action and reaction. The hooligans taunted one girl in reaction the girl and some bystanders acted back in a violent drastic way, wishing death upon the young men. After a few incentives were given to why these men deserved to experience violence themselves the narrator notes that “Nobody really wants to start beating up anybody and get involved in something ugly.” This directly links violence to something negative, something ugly.
Only after violence is desired to punish the bullies is when they realize it may be time to keep quite, as they no longer are in a dominating stance in the situation.
Violence is represented in a physically threatening manner with a destructive value in the ways it is described in this section. From the guys wanting to grab the school girl resulting in the passengers wishing to throw them out the window ultimately ending in a brawl of everyone on the train physically abusing everyone. The offenders do get away without any punishment as the statement is made that “hooligans usually get away with anything on the train” this represents how there is a lack of authority during this time period in South Africa. Authority could make a big impact on the violence tolerated in public areas such as the train.

The definition of violence is summed together as a behavior with intended unpleasant intentions of harm placed on something else. The hooligans on the train in “In the Clarity of a Third Class Compartment” represent this definition of violence in multiple ways. Violence represented through the actions they perform, the language they use and through the image they portray. Being labeled as the “offender” in the story, they initiate violence only to receive their own serving of violence in return. In the end all the violence is looked past due to violence ultimately representing an absence of authority to stop situations like this one from occurring.

Bibliography

Gqola, Pumla. In the Clarity of a Third Class Compartment. South Africa: Pinetown Printers, 2008

Bibliography: Gqola, Pumla. In the Clarity of a Third Class Compartment. South Africa: Pinetown Printers, 2008

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Third, the thesis is demonstrated through firefighter Anthony Smiljanic’s perspective. Anthony is apart of the Los Angeles Fire Department, and during all the rioting, he sees first hand, the things people say, and the way people feel. For instance, it is on Day 3 of the riot when he says, “There’s nothing to do but stare at new red, blue, or black graffiti that says, ‘F**k the Police,’ and ‘F**k the National Guard,’ and ‘Kill Whitey,’ and try not to take it personal (156) . . . I’ve never seen anything like it” (156). Smilijanic understands both sides of the riot, and tries to be completely unbiased and unprejudiced whilst doing his job - unlike the police who arguably started this whole riot. Smilijanic witnesses his superior Gutierrez when…

    • 338 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Plot Summary Stephen Kumalo, a priest in the small South African village of Ndotsheni receives a letter stating that he must travel to Johannesbur, New York City of South Africa. Upon arriving to Johannesburg, Kumalo is overwhelmed but is helped by a fellow priest named Msimangu. Kumalo finds his sister Gertrude living the life of a prostitute and attempts to sway her from her ways. While various events occur that teach the listener and Kumalo about the racial cleavages plaguing the country, Kumalo discovers that his son who he came to Johannesburg to find has accidentally murdered a prominent black South African rights advocate, Arthur Jarvis. Kumalo befriends his son’s pregnant girlfriend and takes her under his wing as a sort of adopted child. Absalom is eventually ruled guilty of murder by the South African courts and is sentenced to hang. Grief stricken, Kumalo returns to his village to find it in a state of disrepair. While in Johannesburg we were introduced to Arthur Jarvis’ father, James Jarvis who comes into an uneasy relationship/friendship with Kumalo at this point. Arthur Jarvis’ son, who is learning Zulu and is eager to learn about the Black South African culture, introduces many helpful reforms to the…

    • 1030 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nt1310 Unit 2 Part 2

    • 983 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The uniform presence of a policeman within the White Rose shopping centre (DD208, 2013, Chapter 1) gives the perception of safety and security for the public, which mother Khadiji described gave parents, ‘a sense of reassurance … by offering an extra safety net’, delivering social welfare and crime control. However, the surveillance video also shows how younger groups often feel targeted as troublesome by the presence of an authoritative figure, purely because of the way they’re characters are judged on how they are dressed; one young girl even commented on how unwelcomed this made her feel (DD208, 2013, Chapter 1). Therefore,…

    • 983 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Tensions rise between different cultures, always have and always will. That being said, violence is bound to occur, it’s just a matter of how and when. During the late 20th century of France, conflict was a reoccurring theme, with the involvement of wars, rioting, and social controversy. These conflicts are shown within the movies “Cache” and “The Battle of Algiers.” In this paper, I will discuss the violence partaken in each film.…

    • 1409 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Violence is never a single victim crime. Violence can have long lasting effects across more people than intended, and have effects more everlasting than can be believed by the person committing the violence. Truman Capote in his book “In Cold Blood” manages to convey the darker meaning of the actions of the characters in this novel. Capote manages to show the everlasting effects and what has been lost from the violence committed. Through his use of figurative language Capote depicted the harsh realism and the true effects of the violence.…

    • 696 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Chapter 1- Every Trip Is a Quest (Except When It’s Not) • The Quest (adventure) contains: o The Quester- a person who goes on a journey o A destination o A reason to go there o Challenges and trials along the way • Questers are usually younger characters that are still attempting to discover what they are looking for. • The usual reason for a quest is self-knowledge. •…

    • 2196 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Glasgow 5th March 1971

    • 1369 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Edwin Morgan’s vivid visual poem “Glasgow 5 March 1971” deals with the themes of violence, crime, apathy and responsibility.This poem is all about street violence and how people don’t get involved. “Glasgow 5 March 1971” is a very dramatic visual poem about a “young man and his girl” who get pushed through a window by some thieves and are not helped by the passing drivers. The poet is commenting on the individualism of modern society and telling us not to stand by and watch others suffer and that we need to stop the violence in our society. It is about how society accepts violence without objecting, whilst pretending to object. In this poem, Morgan freezes a dramatic moment in time in a vivid manner. This essay will show how the poet uses an attention-grabbing opening, effective word choice and imagery to capture a moment in time which changes everything. It will then go on to show how realistic violence, everyday characters and an underlying message help to present the poet’s ideas and to add excitement and emotion to the incident he describes.…

    • 1369 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    It is easy to infer that there are inevitable differences in culture between a European woman in her seventies and a fifteen-year-old African girl living in apartheid-ruled South Africa. In the introduction of the book, editor and expert in the field of South African studies Shula Marks articulates that the cultural differences between Lily and Dr. Palmer make for a difficult understanding of correspondence…

    • 2079 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    english essay

    • 414 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The author Tina Fanning in the newspaper article “cars no longer sustainable”, which was written in July 2007, contents the effect of car usage on global warming and the effect on the future of our children that proves the high level of harmfulness that global warming causes. The audience in this article is aiming at car users and state governors.…

    • 414 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Based on the 1989 novel by Bryce Courtenay, the dramatic motion picture ‘The Power of One’ narrates the life of English boy P.K and his numerous struggles to overcome the racism in the Apartheid era. As the film takes us through P.K’s brutal losses and his gains, we are able to clearly see the continuous injustice against the native South Africans and the aspects of P.K’s personality that evidently help him reject the racism apartheid system; the courage, love and friendship that are needed to fight injustice.…

    • 767 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gandhi (Movie)

    • 924 Words
    • 4 Pages

    During the next scene viewers are taken back to 1893 in South Africa where a young lawyer by the name of Mohandas Gandhi is thrown off a train for refusing to move to the third class car even though his ticket placed him in first class. Because of this event, Gandhi sees through to start a non-violent protesting organization for the civil rights of Indians.…

    • 924 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When he describes himself as being “young and ill-educated”, and bitterly hating his job it helps me understand his story better. He uses a lot of figurative language he talks in great comparison to the oppression and the oppressor a lot. It’s good to know that his stories are credible because he gives first hand encounters on the events. This essay is written in firsthand experience in the beginning of the text he states that he is an officer of the Imperial police working in India. The author’s main job at the time that he is narrating the story is to respond to a report of the death of a local man who was killed by an elephant. He stated that he found the man “lying on his belly with his arms crucified and head sharply twisted to the side.” so he had to have been there to give such a descripted tale. The death of the elephant is the most significant part of this essay given by the author. Throughout this whole essay the author weaves his thesis about the effects of imperialism not only for the oppressed but for the oppressor. He says the “every white man’s life in the East was one long struggle not to be laughed at,” the story basically captures a universal experience of going against one’s own humanity at the cost of a part of…

    • 512 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gandhi Movie

    • 1133 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The first part of the film examines Gandhi's long struggle to force the South African government to end discrimination against Asians. In the early scenes, the young lawyer Mohandas K Gandhi seems naive, apparently surprised to discover that he and other non-whites are treated as second class citizens, something which seems to him at odds with his perception of the British Empire as a source of enlightenment in the world. The struggle that follows sees Gandhi and his fellow dissenters develop formidable notions of civil disobedience and non-violent resistance against a regime that seems more than happy to resort to brutality or incarceration to maintain the social order.…

    • 1133 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    George Owell Imperialism

    • 1070 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Owell begins the story with the discontent the police officer has with his job and India…

    • 1070 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Freedom Writers Adversity

    • 508 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “Freedom Writers” highlights the challenges one must experience in order to change their values. These challenges are evident through a montage of archive news footage in the establishing scene which emphasises on the dangers, violence and destruction caused from riots. This sets a tense atmosphere for the audience giving insight to the historical…

    • 508 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays