Preview

comparing and contrast cinderella

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1118 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
comparing and contrast cinderella
Everyone knows the story of Cinderella, the girl who finds her prince with the help of a magical fairy god-mother, transforming her previously horrible life to a fabulous depiction of every little girls dream. Generations of children around the world have heard the story Cinderella countless times, however most people are unaware of the multiple versions of this legend. The European version of Cinderella ,“Aschenputtel” written by the Grimm Brothers consists of the female protagonist being treated as a servant, yet somehow manages to leave her cruel family behind for her Prince whom she lives happily ever after with. Another version of Cinderella is the Native American tale “The Algonquin Cinderella”, where the female protagonist is also mistreated by her family, however she is fortunate enough to “find” her own prince in her village. Although both stories present similar morals, both vary in details such as characters, settings,and use of magic. Initially, although “Aschenputtel” and “The Algonquin Cinderella” both include female protagonists who lived horrible lives, the characters themselves are the most apparent difference between the two tales. Even in the very beginning of the text both female protagonist share different names, in Grimm’s version the girl is named Aschenputtel which is the German translation for “ash polish”, in other words a cleaning lady or maid (What does Aschenputtel mean, answers.yahoo). However in the Native American version the girl is named Oochigeaskw translating to “scarred women” in the Native American Language (Legendary Native American Figures, native-languages.org).
Additionally, not only do both characters have different names but they also have contrasting physical aspects. Aschenputtel is a beautiful girl whose new family forces her to cover up her beauty “[taking] away her pretty dresses, putting [her in] an old gray kirtle, and givingbher wooden shoes to wear”(183); as opposed to Oochigeaskw whose older wicked sister

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In all these versions, readers or viewers find a common thread to all. The wicked stepmother and siblings are either punished or forgiven, while the sweet, gracious, and beautiful Cinderella marries the prince, and as such escapes her miserable life. According to this tale, marriage is the ultimate goal in life especially for the woman. In Cinderella, all the maidens in town go to the ball just to marry the prince. Even Cinderella desires to go because she sees marriage to the prince as the solution to her problem. “The ideological and psychological pattern and message of either Perrault’s or the Grimms’ Cinderella do nothing more than reinforce sexist values and a Puritan ethos that serves a society which fosters competition and achievement for survival” (Breaking the Magic 195). And this applies to the other two versions in this analysis. Women are typecast as incomplete and invisible without the prince, who obviously is a wealthy archetype. There is a certain important message in Cinderella that is most profitable to marry a rich man, because it earns the woman respect and dignity.…

    • 1127 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the Cinderella story’s there mother dies because she is really sick. They all had shoes. All they story had farriers in the story’s the stepmother was jealous of her beauty and her smartness. Ashenputtle, Yeh-shen and the other Cinderella she was a maimed for her stepmother and stepsisters. The other Cinderella she got married to a prince.…

    • 190 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Virtually everyone has heard many kinds of fairy tales at some points especially in their childhood. Fairy tales are not only for entertaining, but also for passing down information. Tales and stories have been used as a valuable tool to explain natural phenomena, explored relationships, and teach morals. Tales can mirror and influence society. Different cultures have their unique version of tales to carry and pass down the needs of their particular society to the next generation. The same tale in the Europe is different from the tale told in Canada. Both Cyrus Macmillan and Charles Perrault’s “Cinderella” tales describe Cinderella as a gentle and beautiful young lady. Cinderella in both versions had a tough life at the beginning that her sister treated her very cruelly, yet she received a good marriage at the end because of her good characters. However, those two versions have difference. In Macmillan’s “Cinderella”, the author focuses on the character of protagonist. The warrior married Cinderella because she had spoken truth. In Perrault version, the prince fell in love with Cinderella because of her beautiful appearance although the story was also emphasis on her good character. Overall, both versions of Cinderella were stressed on her inside and outside beauties, which make her had a biggest reward.…

    • 992 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    To begin with Cinderella has always been that girl mistreated very poorly but has never give up. Her stepmother begins to show her true colors after her and her father got married. “She employed her in the meanest work of the house” (Perraultt). Cinderella step mother was very mean and only cared about her real daughters in the French story. But in the Chinese story Yeh-Shen real mother died. And her father married someone else and her stepmother did not like Yeh-Shen so she mistreated her and killed Yeh-Shen’s fish which was her only friend she had. “She would also scoured the dishes, tables, etc.…

    • 753 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Ashputtle and Cinderella are two fairytales that are very similar but also different. The theme of the stories are almost the same both step mothers are mean and so is the sisters for example when the stepmother called Ashputtle a sloven (dirty or untidy person) in Cinderella mean comments and actions were made to Cinderella and Ashputtle both. The sisters are rude and are in the way of Ashputtle and Cinderella getting to the ball. Cinderella is different in some ways in detail and theme like when she went in a giant pumpkin to the ball.…

    • 170 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Growing up I can remember how I felt after watching the Cinderella story. Inspired by the rags-to-riches fairy tale, I can remember hoping that maybe someday I could be like Cinderella. I never imagined the story I knew all-too-well would have been dramatically altered from its original version. Though the lesson remains the same, comparisons reveal numerous differences between Walt Disney’s Cinderella to the earlier Charles Perrault’s “Cinderella: Or the Glass Slipper”. Variations are noticed in characters, events, and outcomes of this world-famous…

    • 802 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    sample

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The conflict is another aspect of the story that makes” Cinderella” superior to “Little Red Riding…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Films that I particularly favor are thrillers. One reason Thrillers become so enjoyable for me, a sense of diversion is created making the viewers more indulge in the movie all the way to the ending. The plots are usually twisted, climatic, suspenseful and intelligence is often use far as the writing perspective to result in an ecliptic viewing of the movie. A really great thriller will usually bring a shock factor by the climax, then the movie will receive a better understanding from the beginning to end. Another genre of films I enjoy are Musicals they are fashionable and express emotions through singing. I am really into lyricism so I enjoy comparing the actual expression of the each character's individual story and the progression…

    • 649 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cinderella Summary

    • 313 Words
    • 1 Page

    Today’s media plays a massive role in the establishment of a fantasy marriage that was first embodied in the classic tale of Cinderella. Many people are persuaded into believing that these finely crafted stories occur everyday and are very much achievable. Catherine Orenstein illustrates this in her essay “Fairy Tales and a Dose of Reality”.…

    • 313 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first two factors are the same for both the stories because each story has a girl who is put down by the evil influence of her stepmother and stepsisters. The magical intervention is in both stories and is represented by nature. An item that identifies each girl from the stories is a little different though. In Aschenputtel the item is her shoe in which she has lost. In The Twelve Months the item is the apples. Finally the last factor is shown in both stories by…

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Cinderella Research Paper

    • 2634 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Throughout the years, there have been several retellings of Cinderella. Some of the retellings are based on culture, the society at that particular moment and what would grab the audience attention. One of the most common retelling of Cinderella is: The Complete Grimm’s Fairy Tale. There’s also the: Radio Plays for Children. One of the most recent retelling would have to be: A Cinderella Story. All three of the retellings leave the audience with a different interpretation of Cinderella. Never the less you will get the same moral of the story from all three.…

    • 2634 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    This assignment requires you to compare (meaning compare or contrast) two versions of the best known and most ubiquitous of all folk tales, the story of Cinderella. The two best known European versions of this tale are in your coursepack, those of Perrault and the Grimms. The coursepack also includes several other versions of the tale, selected from a wide range of cultural backgrounds. You can also locate your own version(s) of the story on the internet, in collections of folk and fairy tales found in libraries, even in picture book editions. If you do select your own version of the tale, please okay it with me to make sure it is a legitimate Cinderella story.…

    • 436 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are many versions to the famous fairy tale Cinderella. Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm’s German version of Cinderella, “Aschenputtel,” is a household story of a young girl named Cinderella who eventually marries a prince. This specific version of Cinderella gave birth to the Walt Disney version of Cinderella that most Americans know today. However the stories are very different. The Grimm brothers’ version is much darker and gory then the classic American version. Small differences like this shed a different light on Cinderella and her journey to a “happy” ending.…

    • 782 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In contrast, there is Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm and their tale of "Ashputtle". The German version, with its pagan magic, spell casting, and self mutilation is much more violent and aggressive. This style was obviously written for lower class citizens, peasants. Peasants would have a wedding celebration as opposed to a ball, and gold slippers were considered precious and invaluable to the audience, the idea of glass slippers would have been incomprehensible to them. The punishment of the stepsisters would leave a modern audience wondering, what happened to "happily ever after?" How can Cinderella possibly enjoy her happiness while carrying partial guilt for her step-sisters blindness? However, in the German culture of that era, the punishment was viewed as just and Cinderella would have her happiness without guilt.…

    • 563 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Cinderella In The Odyssey

    • 1270 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Everyone knows and loves the fairytale “Cinderella” where Cinderella starts out as a maid, wearing nothing but rags, and doing nothing but chores. She desires to go to this ball, but her nasty stepmother sends her to work right away, without allowing her to go. Fortunately for Cinderella, her fairy Godmother transforms her into a beautiful princess and lets her go to the ball, where she meets the price of her dreams. He is astonished by her beauty and in the end of the fairytale they fall in love. Everyone is fascinated by Cinderella’s story but one may not realize who is truly the reason for Cinderella’s good fortune. Without the help of her fairy godmother ensuring that everything worked out for Cinderella in the end, she never would have…

    • 1270 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays

Related Topics