Preview

Community, Responsibility, and Guilt

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1474 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Community, Responsibility, and Guilt
Essay 1: Community, Responsibility, and Guilt The novel Chronicle of a Death Foretold by Gabriel Garcia Marquez tells the story of Santiago Nasar’s death. More importantly it tells the story of what values and honor mean to a community and to what extent one can go to maintain that standard. A central theme in the novel is how a society can pressurize its people to act and behave in a certain way. They feel bound by a standard that if not kept, then it will bring shame to their family. In the novel, after her husband returns Angela Vicario to her family on their wedding night, she admits that it is Nasar that had taken her virginity. Her brothers, Pablo and Pedro, viscously murder Nasar to regain their sister’s and family’s honor. In this society a man or woman without honor is an outcast to the community and to the culture. Almost everyone in the community knew what was going to happen but no one did anything about it. Everyone in the community had excuses to why they did nothing to help. Excuses stating that they didn’t believe it would really happen or that they just didn’t know what to do. Each person seemed to just hope that someone else would do it; someone else would stop them, and didn’t want to take responsibility. The novel reflects how a community can victimize individuals within its society causing detrimental affects to both the general public and the specific individuals involved. The novel looks into the Latin American culture and how its cultural norms and the importance of honor effects the entire community. The principles that obligates the Vicario family and the community conducts the murder of a most likely innocent Santiago Nasar and burdens Pedro and Pablo with the duty to defend the family honor. In this culture, honor of a woman’s purity does not only belong to the female individually but the honor belongs to the family as well. To not be pure can bring shame on the family name in the eyes of the entire community. So much so that

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Killing His Wife

    • 630 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In the introduction of this chapter, we learn that on November 28th, 1595 Gaspar de Peralta, a judge for the Royal Audiencia of Charcas, answered a call from his next-door neighbor’s house. Once he entered the house, he found a domestic horror scene. Having entered the bedroom, Peralta found his chief scribe and the secretary of the audiencia (Fernando de Medina) standing over the bloody bodies of his wife and her lover, Beatriz Gonzalez. Fernando de Medina (the Husband) immediately confessed to murdering his wife and her love. He proceeded to tell the judge of his wife’s long- term affair with Beatriz Gonzalez. Fernando de Medina believed that it was his right to defend his honor. One of the first documents was a statement from Medina, saying that in no point in time in the twenty-seven years or so of marriage had he given his wife a reason to be unfaithful. In the document he explained that over the twenty-seven years he had moved from place to place and he always provided his wife with everything she’d ever needed. She provided him with two children and they all were all well taken care of. The last and final move though was she meets her “new suitor” in the garden. He goes on to say that Gonzalez and his wife would use any opportunity and location to be together. They used his (the husband) home, or the lovers, she would either wear her own clothes or try to hide their relationship and wear men’s clothing. In this passage the husband feels he has to defend his honor because he found out that all of his servants were aware of this affair.…

    • 630 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gender identities and roles are a crucial part on a women’s life in 17th century in Spain and what will be later become America. When looking the histories on these century, women transgression toward society norms shaped by Spain influence of a “ideal” women behavior should be like. Two fitting examples of how women transgress in society at the time is Catalina de Erauso and Sor Juana Ines de la Cruz. These two women had to change many aspects in their life to accomplish an internal freedom, which at the time society didn’t approve as appropriate for an ordinary woman. Some of the crucial aspects affected by this choice are gender and how they are predive at the time, transgression towards social rules, identity and how it had to be changed to be accepted and personal freedom…

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Vicario Brothers Quotes

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In Gabriel Garcia Marquez’s novel Chronicle of a Death Foretold, Marquez details the murder of Santiago Nasar at the hands of the Vicario Brothers and the Society’s role in his death. Marquez uses a journalistic and magically realistic style in recounting the events that transpired in the town, using these styles to focus heavily on the societal ideals in the Colombian town. The heavy focus on Catholicism, and the honor that is associated with religion, is the Vicario Brother’s main reason for their murder of Santiago. The townspeople view the Vicario Brother’s as honorable men whose machismo and masculinity justify the killing of Santiago. However,…

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In their society the idea and concept of honor is the most important to a family. It affects how a person lives. The result of the Vicario family not having their honor was the reason Santiago was killed. Honor is so important that sometimes people will do anything to regain it and in this case murder someone. The Vicario the best way to reclaim their family's honor was to murder Santiago. Angela's family finding out about her secret not only destroyed her relationship with her family, but was cause for Santiago death. Angela could of easily told her mother who her perpetrator was and stopped the murder from happening. Not only did she keep the secret of her virginity, but lie about who took and even stated it later on in the story. She even realized that keeping that secret was a mistake, while her mother was beating her and was crying, because she felt bad for Bayardo, who went through a long process so they could get married. In their society the concept of honor and what surrounds it is a very hard thing to live up to, and the hardship that surround a woman are very hard to…

    • 424 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Though the story is subjective, it also questions the mind of the reader in terms of critical thought. Diaz highlights how an person is reduced to just social class and race and by doing so asking a question relating to the authority or accuracy of the decrease of social beings. Though the story is subjective, it also questions the mind of the reader in terms of critical thought. The story fails on the moral side as it gives inferences on physical emotions and sexual relations. An curious reader should consider the ways a person manipulates their appearances within all the contexts that the writer discusses. A reader should also review own beliefs on expectations, stereotypes, biases and social and racial divisions in the determination of…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Patria, one of the brave Mirabal sisters, goes through the most drastic life-changing battle. Patria struggles to overcome the tragedy of having a miscarriage and is overwhelmed with emptiness. Patria’s strong insecurities reveal themselves as she buries herself in sorrow and sadness struggling to come to terms with her loss. Patria still continues on but hides to protect herself. Although she loses her identity, she hides it from her community: “…a model Catholic wife and mother. I fooled them all! Yes, for a long time after losing my faith, I went on, making believe” (Alvarez 55). Still known in her community as a good Catholic wife and mother, Patria hides her loss of identity to others and projects toward society an image condoning her oppressive struggles, but inside she was “an empty house.” She goes on living the life expected of her, as she resumes her duties and puts on a good face over her broken heart. Patria represents the fears and insecurities we all portray when faced with challenges. She foreshadowed the rest of the people of the Dominican…

    • 1294 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Killing / Fiesta, 1980

    • 1575 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Today, family is one of the most sacred values we share in the individualist society we live in. Every family is different and has different rules and values; but in most of them, fathers are supposed to be leaders of the family, and role models for their children. They are also considerate like the one who transmits the traditions of their ancestors in order to carry them on. “Fiesta, 1980” is a short story written by Junot Dìaz taken from his short story collection, Drown, (1996). “Killings” is also a short story taken from, Finding a Girl in America (1980), written by Andre Dubus. Both of these stories are dealing with the family’s subject and provide us different perspectives of it. In Dìaz’s story we can see the relationship among a foreigner family, while in Andre Dubus’s story we see an American average family. In both stories, fathers play an important role; they figure prominently and have a considerable impact on their family but on the story also. The father in Dubus’s story is more family oriented that the one in Dìaz’; moreover the family is more closely–knit in Dubus’s story than in Dìaz’s story. The difference between the behaviors of the two fathers can be explained by their cultural backgrounds, which are not the same. These stories also provide us another perspective of the father’s role in the family, through their strength and their weakness without compromise.…

    • 1575 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cartagena

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In the seventeenth-century Cartagena, defending one’s personal and household honor led to public acts of violence and even homicide. Offenses against a man’s honor basically provoked anger and desire for an apology, but individuals and public authorities manipulated violations of the honor code. Self-protection on bureaucratic hierarchies was one of the most effective ways to manipulate justice in colonial Spanish America, even when men would use their horrifying acts as torture. The honor men had was taken very seriously against women because “It proves Maria Manuel who was a woman living in Cartagena in the early 1600s, suffered horrible physical abuse due to her master’s sexual jealousy.” Pg. 55 The defense of a male honor came from elite status and privilege in a combination with sexual jealousy, motivated Maria Manuel’s master to abuse her. The ordeals were taken into place because her tortures justified their violence with rhetoric of honor, and that proved the sexual dominance over women. A few years later, a nuncio for the Cartagena Holy Office named Juan Ramos Perez, bought Maria Manuel. Perez eventually abused Maria, and even though a baby was created between them two, she was not happy because of the physical abuse Maria Manuel experienced. After the relations with Perez, Maria found a young Spaniard named Juan De Soto who had made a promise to marry her in front of witnesses so she could no longer live with her master’s sins. Unfortunately, for Maria, Soto fled after hearing rumors that Perez was enraged. This issue caused Maria Manuel to fall back into Perez power. Perez punished Maria by hiding her in several homes in Cartagena, and afterwards sent her to live with a family, which Maria Manuel’s sexual relation with the familiar caused her to get pregnant which then prompted a horrific response from her master. Maria was then imprisoned so she can be hidden…

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Honor In La Constancia

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Husbands were more concerned about what everyone else thought so they needed to be constantly on guard to exhibit conduct benefiting their sex, as well as vigilant that no one maliciously tarnished their reputations (224). The story of “La Constancia” vividly illustrates the relationship between honor-status and honor-virtue. When Jose Maria believed that his wife’s virtue had been taken, he was dishonored not because his he believed that Constancia actually committed adultery, but because Jose believed what he had been told about his wife’s…

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During the eighteenth century, one of the utmost aspects to have in life for the Spanish in colonial New Mexico for men was honor, this was the very center of their moral system.(pg.177) Having honor was those who colonized New Mexico and conquered the Indians forcing them to submit.(pg.177) In order for one to achieve getting that respect it meant that they had to prove it to everyone and they had to see it with their own eyes, basically needing their approval. Not only did they fight for honor, but they also had to fight to maintain it depending on “brute force”.(pg.177) This essay will explore Ramon A. Gutierrez’s discussion on manhood and honor on two different levels, one of status and one of virtue.(pg.177)…

    • 385 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Guilt and Punishment

    • 307 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Creon’s actions and judgment in the play Antigone were questionable, but I don’t think he deserved the punishment he received at the conclusion of the play. My philosophy of life probably influenced my decision because I believe that everyone deserves a second chance. Creon was arrogant and did not listen to anyone’s advice, including Tiresias, a prophet who has never told him a lie. However, in the end he realized what had happened and accepted his fate.…

    • 307 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    American Lit

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Esperanza is not a significant supporter of the gender positions that continue to keep women in her neighborhood demoralized. The men on Mango Street abuse not only their wives but also their daughters and imprison them in the home. Many times just being a woman can cause reason for such abuse. This is a fact that can be observed in the beatings which unfortunately Sally continuously gets, and also in the rape of Esperanza. Esperanza presents us with an analysis of the way men and women relate to each other and refuse to abide by the demands applied to her sex by marriage or perhaps acting in a womanly way. For our character, disobeying gender position and staying independent is considered an act of rebellion as well as a source of power.…

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Death Foretold Duality

    • 1301 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In Chronicle of a Death Foretold, Gabriel Garcia Marquez contrasts the vocal piety of the characters with the immorality of their actions in the small Colombian town of Sucre in 1951. Marquez uses metaphors and biblical allusions comparing Santiago Nasar to Jesus in order to illustrate the moral hypocrisy conflicting with the apparent self-righteousness of the Vicario twins and Angela Vicario.…

    • 1301 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In this society, sexual double standards arise as it is traditional for women to wait until marriage before giving up their virginity, yet men are expected to be experienced with the matter. It can be stated that with a guilty conviction, less empathy is shed toward Santiago Nasar, as he should be aware of the societal pressure for women to wait until marriage before getting deflowered. However, Santiago was also fulfilling his societal pressures as a male member. Essentially, although Santiago Nasar is guilty for deflowering Angela Vicario, his conviction is not one of shame as he was simply acting as society has taught him. Additionally, even though the immorality of murder may not be able to be completely pardoned, the Vicario brothers’ well meaning and honor behind the murder can be understood when in context with the society in which the novel takes place. Perhaps it is not Santiago who is responsible for deflowering Angela, or the Vicario brothers for his murder, but the structure of the society that is worthy of the…

    • 1262 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    As you can see, Chronicle of a Death Foretold by Gabriel Garcia Marquez is one of the most important Latin American novels to ever be written. The story depicts the life of what was once an ordinary town in Colombia forever changed by a murder which was inspired by a death of Marquez’s friend. He also displays the dominance men have over women and how the town expects both genders to behave. It is these reasons why I acknowledge why the book is not only of the most important books in Latin American literature, but one of the best ever…

    • 1751 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays