Preview

Billie

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1955 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Billie
Why did the United States under-estimate the difficulties in bringing order and development to Afghanistan and Iraq?

At the start of the twenty-first century, the United States engaged in two military interventions, the invasion of Afghanistan in 2001 and the invasion of Iraq in 2003. What were supposed to be short, sharp wars dragged the US into the long and failed missions of reconstructing the Afghan and Iraqi states. Today, 97% of Afghanistan’s licit GDP is derived from foreign aid and efforts to guarantee stability are still being undermined by the Taliban-led insurgency. In fragile, conflict-driven Iraq, the population constantly struggles with ongoing water shortages, electricity scarcity and a broken economy. Given the immense costs of the two invasions, it is paramount to ask how it all could go so wrong. Focusing on the period of the Bush administration, this essay seeks to answer why the US under-estimated the difficulties in bringing order and development to Afghanistan and Iraq.

Dr Toby Dodge has identified several faulty assumptions that underpin military intervention, which explain why the US failed to bring order and development to Afghanistan and Iraq. One of these assumptions is that military force can achieve political ends, something which it did not do in Afghanistan. Henry A. Crumpton, a former CIA officer who was largely involved in ousting the Taliban, confessed that winning the war in Afghanistan required the US to “get in at a local level and respond to people’s needs so that enemy forces cannot come in and take advantage.” In ignoring this fundamental aspect of counterinsurgency, efforts succeeded only in keeping urgent problems at bay while hoping that the situation in Afghanistan would improve on its own. This brings us to a second faulty assumption underpinning military intervention: the overestimation of the stability, competence and popularity of the intervener’s local allies.

What a fragile state on the verge of collapse



Bibliography: Barfield, Thomas (2010), Afghanistan: A Cultural and Political History Princeton University Press, Princeton, United States Carlstrom, Gregg, (June 2011) “’Economic depression’ looms in Afghanistan” Al Jazeera, retrieved from http://www.aljazeera.com/news/asia/2011/06/20116812933228775.html Dodge, Toby, (March, 2013) “Military intervention: Afghanistan and Iraq” Dodge, Toby, (2010), “The Ideological Roots of Failure: The Application of Kinetic Neo-Liberalism to Iraq.” International Affairs 86(6), pp Blackwell Publishing Ltd, Oxford, United Kingdom Holmes, Stephen, (2007), “The Matador’s Cape: America’s Reckless Response to Terror” Cambridge University Press, United Kingdom Oweiss, Ibrahim M., (2007) “Why did the United States fail in its War on Iraq?” Rid, Thomas, (2010), “Understanding Counterinsurgency: Doctrines, operations and challenges” Taylor and Francis, United Kingdom Rohde, D. and Sanger, D. E. (2007). “How a ‘Good War’ in Afghanistan Went Bad.” New York Times, 12 August 2007, retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/12/world/asia/12afghan.html [ 1 ]. Carlstrom, Gregg, (June 2011) “’Economic depression’ looms in Afghanistan”, Al Jazeera. Retrieved from http://www.aljazeera.com/news/asia/2011/06/20116812933228775.html [ 2 ] [ 4 ]. Dodge, Toby, (March, 2013) “Military intervention: Afghanistan and Iraq” Lecture conducted from the London School of Economics and Political Science [ 6 ]. Rohde, D. and Sanger, D. E. (2007). “How a ‘Good War’ in Afghanistan Went Bad.” New York Times, 12 August 2007, retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2007/08/12/world/asia/12afghan.html, p [ 9 ]. Barfield, Thomas, Afghanistan: A Cultural and Political History, 2010, Princeton University Press, Princeton, United States, p. 304 [ 10 ] [ 23 ]. Rid, Thomas, (2010), “Understanding Counterinsurgency: Doctrines, operations and challenges”, Taylor and Francis, United Kingdom, p. 199 [ 24 ] [ 25 ]. Dodge, p. 1276 [ 26 ] [ 27 ]. Ibid, p. 1280 [ 28 ] [ 29 ]. Ibid, p. 1282 [ 30 ] [ 31 ]. Ibid, p. 1283 [ 32 ] [ 33 ]. Dodge, p. 1284 [ 34 ]

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Rex Murphy’s essay, “What We Are Fighting For,” strives to outline the reasons behind the Canadian governments’ continued deployment of troops to Afghanistan. Murphy reviews the initial reasoning for deploying troops overseas, then continues on to explain that simply disbanding the Taliban government is insufficient. He indicates that the UN led mission is also implementing peacekeeping measures, and Canadian troops, as Peacekeepers remained. Murphy outlines the ambitious peacekeeping goals and provides insight into civil liberties those of us from democratic nations, often take for granted. The author then delves into the intricacies and obstacles faced in attempting to install a democratic government in a country still under threat of Taliban…

    • 223 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    POL300 Assignment 2

    • 1138 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Global Issues (1992-07-19). Anatomy of a Victory: CIA’s Covert Afghan War — Global Issues. Globalissues.org. Retrieved 2014-04-14.…

    • 1138 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In his essay” What are we fighting for,” Rex Murphy discusses what he sees as the most compulsory reasons Canadian troops are in Afghanistan, to support some form of democracy that can resist malevolent influences and provide for its citizens, basic civil opportunities. Murphy begins his discussion with recapping the events leading up to our involvement in the Afghanistan operations, primarily 911, and supporting our ally, the United States in removing a government that supported such atrocities. The Afghanistan mission, which was UN approved, was intent on, most importantly, removing the Taliban and providing stability for its citizens through better government. However, Murphy discusses how without support a new government is not sustainable…

    • 289 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Looming Tower

    • 4335 Words
    • 18 Pages

    References: Bergen. P., (2010). The Longest War: The Enduring Conflict Between America and Al-Qaeda. New York: Simon and Schuster…

    • 4335 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    9/11 Summary

    • 2006 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The attack on the United States on September 11, 2001 (better known as 9/11) by Osama Bin Laden rammed a wedge into the relationship between the United States and the Islamic world. In result the U.S. invaded Afghanistan and the invaded Iraq. Professor Irogbe’s article on the occupation of Afghanistan and Iraq argues that the U.S. actions are igniting rather than reducing global terrorism and if U.S. were to withdraw troops from these countries it would promise for global peace and security. The article covers the cost of human and financial resources of the war, abuses committed by invaders including the application of extraordinary rendition, the indefinite detention of prisoners…

    • 2006 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Afghanistan is a war torn country located in central Asia. There are currently approximately 319, 000 internally displaced people in Afghanistan. (Encyclopedia of the Nations, 2012) The poverty is extreme, there are frequent natural disasters that tear down cities and villages, (Refugees International, 2001) and the people are in continual danger of violence. This violence includes constant suicide bombings, ambushes, abductions and rocket attacks. In 2009 there were at least 12 of these incidences every day. (Kazem-Stojanovic, 2011) They are living in fear of their lives 24/7. Due to a severe drought in 2011, there is a lack of food and therefore thousands are suffering from starvation. (Refugees International, 2001) There is also the current issue of the coalition forces deciding to take their troops out at the end of 2014. (Amiri, 2012) Citizens fear that once they are gone the Taliban will regain full control again.…

    • 1269 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Within this trajectory, the Soviet invasion of, and subsequent war with Afghanistan (1979-1989) stands out in particular as a lasting legacy of the Cold War. Globally, its outcome continues to plague international society in the current struggle between the Western liberal democratic order and Islamic extremism.…

    • 1849 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The war in Afghanistan started after the September 11th, 2001 attacks in the United States while President Bush was in office. President Obama was inaugurated as president on January 20th, 2009 and he picked up in the middle of a long war in Iraq and Afghanistan. After taking office, General Stanley McChrystal was selected to command NATO operations in Afghanistan. McChrystal submits a detailed report, to then Defense Secretary Robert Gates, calling for a surge of 30,000 – 40,000 troops in Afghanistan. The general’s assessment reflects the “Polis Model” in that he writes “success demands a comprehensive counterinsurgency (COIN) campaign” and further writes “failure to gain the initiative”, “risks an outcome where defeating the insurgency is no longer possible”. This assessment gives the portrayal that increasing the troop count in Afghanistan is the only feasible option and that any other method would result in failure. To make matters worse, McChrystal’s 66 page assessment…

    • 658 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Annotated Bibliography

    • 277 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Lane, S. “Withdrawal from Afghanistan to start within months” The World Today, April 17, 2012…

    • 277 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    911 Term Paper

    • 1717 Words
    • 7 Pages

    President George declared a war on terror shortly after the attacks on the world trade center and the Pentagon. The U.S. gave the Taliban and the Afghan government an ultimatum to turn over Osama Bin Laden and they refused. The US and NATO invaded and the Taliban government was toppled in eight weeks with the help of the Northern Alliance. The U.S. continued to punish and pursue Al Qaeda into the mountains and surround them. Our military was within weeks of crushing Al Qaeda when the Bush Administration shifted focus to Iraq. This created a vacuum that led to an Al Qaeda resurgence. The U.S. loosing focus on Afghanistan angered our Pakistani ally. A decade later we our no closer to winning the war in Afghanistan than we were in the beginning. Even with Bin Laden dead American casualties have sky rocketed from 270 in 2008 to 3,371 last year. We are now left in a quagmire in Afghanistan because we failed to complete the job in Afghanistan, while fighting an unneeded expensive war in Iraq. (Hirsch)…

    • 1717 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    |Afghanistan and the role of the U.S. |Since the fall of the Taliban, drug |explore the complex interaction between the|…

    • 358 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    AFTER 11 years spent waging war on terror in Afghanistan and Iraq, almost $1.5 trillion in direct costs and hundreds of thousands of lives lost, the Western public feels it has learned a hard lesson. It is more convinced than ever that even the best-intentioned foreign intervention is bound to bog its armies down in endless warsfighting invisible enemies to help ungrateful locals.…

    • 2231 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Following the September 11 terror attacks, the U.S. sent thousands of troops to Afghanistan to pursue the al Qaeda terrorists who plotted the terror attacks. Almost 10 years ago, the U.S. sent troops to the Central Asian country in order to protect the U.S. after Osama Bin Laden declared war on the United States. Within a year of entering into the country, the U.S. shifted its focus from Afghanistan to Iraq, which led to the resurgence of the Taliban. Currently, the U.S., under the Obama administration, has developed a new strategic plan in which troops are “to disrupt, dismantle and defeat al Qaeda in Pakistan and Afghanistan, and to prevent their return to either country in the…

    • 1147 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Doldrum Analysis

    • 795 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The present state of U.S. Civil Military relations reflects sporadic frustration and disharmony. The tantrum mainly could be due to its sapping into prolonged conflict with broad objective yielding very less tangible results. The nature of the war on which U.S. presently is with its grand alliance entail the highest degree of passion .As Churchill was eager to wait prolong ‘to empty the pond with a cup’. The political intent and military requirement is difficult to match and criticizing each other, which has wedged the cleavage into civil-military relations. The sudden deputation of Gen David Paetraus to Afghanistan portrays…

    • 795 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The calculating of America leaders in Afghan war becomes dilemma when they have not attained the political outcomes. In an ideal world, we can expect that national leaders will behave in a "rational" way. This means that before they make decisions, they will calculate, discuss each one carefully and carefully, and then rank them in order of priority from high to low. Most importantly, leaders will choose the way and means that they think are most effective, with low costs to achieve the goals. In other words, leaders will spend time developing a strategic orientation before implementing policies. And when the strategic direction has been announced, we expect that leaders will ensure the right policy is outlined in the strategic direction.…

    • 1012 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays