Marquis’ Anti-Abortion Argument * Marquis suggests that the parties to the abortion debate find themselves at a stand-off. Pro-lifers want to focus on the fact that fetuses are human beings (at least potentially) whereas pro-choicers want to focus on the fact that fetuses are not persons (even though they may be so potentially). * Marquis suggests that to make progress in the abortion debate‚ what we need is a new strategy. His preferred strategy is an argument he calls the “future life
Premium Abortion Fetus Abortion debate
If‚ as Marquis argues‚ it is wrong to kill a potential person because doing so deprives it of a future like ours‚ is it wrong to practice contraception and deprive a potential person of a future like ours? There are various views regarding abortion and whether it should be accepted. Applying the Doctrine of Sanctity of life is a conservative view against abortion. An observation made by Don Marquis believes that abortion is wrong because it deprives a being of a future like ours and it is morally
Premium Abortion Pregnancy
The Day of the Dead‚ October 31 to November 2‚ is a holiday celebrated to remember those who have passed away. Day of the Dead celebrations are generally celebrated in states from Mexico. The holiday is celebrated by making beautifully decorated altars that often contain food‚ drinks‚ flowers‚ and toys (Villalba). The holiday “recognizes death as a natural part of the human experience” (National Geographic). Death is something everyone has to deal with at a point in their lives. It is often found
Premium Life Poetry As Time Goes By
Marquis gives a definition of abortion as being “an action intended to bring about the death of a fetus for the sake of the woman who carries it.” Marquis says that both sides of the argument can agree that everyone has a right to life. His question then becomes what it is that makes a person be identified as a person. He gives
Premium Abortion Pregnancy Abortion debate
has a right to life‚ then abortion is impermissible”‚ even though it can be challenged. I believe that Don Marquis has presented a strong argument in favor of the view that abortion is immoral. In fact‚ Marquis’ states in his premise one that “any being that can be deprived of a future like ours has a right to life”‚ the second premise is that “the human fetus has a future like ours”. Thus‚ Marquis’ conclusion is “the human fetus has
Premium Abortion Pregnancy Fetus
Don Marquis’ "Why Abortion is Immoral" In his essay "Why Abortion is Immoral‚" Don Marquis argues against the morality of abortion on the premise that the value of a fetus’ future is so great that it is immoral to take that potential future away from it. Essentially‚ he contends‚ abortion is tantamount to murder: killing an individual is prima facie wrong because the loss of the goods of one’s future is the worst loss a human can suffer. He calls this potential future a "future-like-ours‚"
Premium Abortion Abortion debate Pregnancy
The Dilemma of Marquis’ Future Like Ours Argument when applied to Euthanasia In his essay "Why abortion is immoral"‚ Don Marquis defends the anti-abortionist view. He bases his defense on the moral impermissibility of killing in general through what he calls the deprivation thesis (DT)‚ which is that killing is wrong if the subject of the killing has a future like ours because killing the subject deprives it of its future. Marquis’ argument‚ known as the future like ours (FLO) argument against
Premium Ethics Morality Euthanasia
In “Why abortion is immoral‚” by Don Marquis‚ Marquis sets out an argument that abortion is “seriously immoral that it is in the same moral category as killing an innocent adult human being.” Marquis first wants us to understand why killing a person is wrong. He presents us with an argument that the loss of one’s life is one of the greatest losses one can suffer. Because this prevents a person from having a valuable human future‚ a future like ours. What makes killing any adult human being wrong
Premium Abortion Pregnancy Fetus
PHI 180: Introduction to Ethics Reading & Study Questions for Unit 2: Ethical Theories 1 Explain Marquis’s presentation of the "typical" anti-abortion argument. 1. Fetuses are living and human. 2. Humans have the right to live. 3. Fetuses have a right to life. 4. Women have a right to control their bodies. 5. The right to life is morally more important than the right to control one’s body. 6. Abortion places the right to control one’s body over the right to life. Abortion
Premium Ethics Morality Human
Judith Jarvis Thompson and Don Marquis both have markedly different views on the topic of abortion. Thompson generally argues that there are cases where abortion may be morally permissible‚ due to the rights of the mother‚ while Marquis argues that abortion is almost always morally wrong‚ except under extraordinary circumstances‚ because the fetus has a future life. In this paper‚ I will evaluate the arguments of both parties‚ as well as identify what premises‚ if any‚ they both agree on. In addition
Premium Abortion Pregnancy Abortion debate