Preview

women and the war

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
386 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
women and the war
Historians still have diverse opinions about women and the war; historians such as Arthur Marwick support the reward theory, which states that women were rewarded with the vote after their vital impact on the war effort. Evidence promoting this point like the “Women’s Land Army” shows that the government wanted to honour the women taking up jobs even though these were just woman farmers. For women the war sparked a social revolution.
On the other hand historians such as Paula Bartley and Martin Pugh oppose the reward theory seeming as the vote was a strange reward as most war work was done by young women in early 20s but they were not given the vote, only the women over thirty that didn’t do nearly as much work did. They argue suffragists not given enough credit for having shaped attitudes before WWI.
Before the war only a third of women were employed and the majority of them worked in domestic service. Women were only allowed to work in occupations deemed “fit for women” such as nurses teachers and secretaries. Women and men lived in “separate spheres” and men were considered as more important members of society. However there were many women campaigning against inequality. The Suffragists, led by Millicent Fawcett negotiated and gave speeches, whilst their opposites the Suffragettes used violence to get their way. To control this militant band of women the Government put into place the Cat and Mouse Act.
When war broke out in 1914, thousands of women were sacked from their jobs. They wanted work and they wanted to help the war effort. Suffragettes promised to stop all militant action because they realised the war was more important. However the trade unions opposed the idea of working with women so they went on strike. This led to Christabel Pankhurst organising the “Right To Work” march in July 1915. After, the Government did a deal with the trade unions known as the Treasury Agreements. The unions agreed to accept female labour in place on men during the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Bussiness Not Pleasure

    • 628 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “No one will ever know if the suffragettes or suffragists had the better tactics for winning the vote. For by August 1914 Britain was at war . . . . Millions women became a key part of the war effort making shells, bombs, guns and uniforms. In January 1918, women were rewarded when the wartime government passed the Representation of the people Act giving a vote to all women over 30 years of age.”…

    • 628 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Before the Women’s Suffrage movement began, women faced hardships that would later motivate them to take a stand for women’s rights. Women were, at that time, being abused and mistreated by men and society, in order to gain what was necessary to survive during this time in American history. The industrial revolution had just swept the nation by surprise. The industrial revolution changed the process of production from hand tools and man labor, to power driven machinery. (Dublin). This change from hand labor to power machinery affected the women greatly. The women continued to do the same jobs as before the industrial era, but now all work was done on machines to increase both output and production rates on products. This new way of manufacturing…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Before WW1 women had very little policital power and were considered inferior to men. Men didn't see the need for women to have a voice, and that their opinion was not needed. However, when the war began men were sent to war, leaving job spaces to be filled. This was when the women were called upon to fill these spaces. This was an oppurtunity for women to prove their rights for politicial power. Source A1 supports this because it states 'by the end of the war in November 1918, women proved that they were just as important to th war effort as men'. This shows that women were successful in doing so and had been given more political power. This source was taken from a website focused at GCSE students which means alot of research must have been put into the text, making it reliable.…

    • 965 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Great War had significant and enduring influence on the lives of all British women. The huge scale of the war resulted in the enormous participation of almost six million men and subsequently an extensive demand for female labour in the manufacturing and services industries. The war resulted in massive social upheaval particularly on the lives women who attained greater freedom despite tighter Government controls. Women's lives were upturned as they were thrust into the labour, social and economic spotlight, something never previously seen in British history. In particular the allies' defeat of Germany relied heavily on the input of women. Women were used extensively in Propaganda schemes run by the Government as a means to encourage men to join the army. Although the end of the war saw most women return to their traditional roles, the contribution of the female population on such an enormous scale would never be forgotten, women had proven their responsibility and capability to function within the 'male' workforce. These trends saw the beginning of the feminist revolutionary movement that sought to bring about justice and equality for all women.…

    • 1337 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women first petitioned Parliament for equality in 1649- but were told that it was unnecessary as their husbands represented them in political affairs. 250 years later many people in Britain (women as well as men) still agreed with the Parliamentary response to the petitioners for women’s rights in 1649. However, the women’s suffrage moment in Britain took hold of the country in the 1860’s. Women (over the age of 30) finally won the vote in 1918- although historians are still debating over what was the main cause of women gaining the vote: the militant suffragettes, the more peaceful suffragists or World War One.…

    • 998 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Document A shows a woman as a woodcut worker. Before the war, women were stuck in the house, having no input in how their life was run; during the war, they were running society and maintaining the economy. Women also began to libel for their freedom after the war; “What then must my situation be, when my sex, my youth and inexperience all conspire to make me tremble at the task which I have undertaken? But the friendly encouragement, which I behold in almost every countenance, enables me to overcome difficulties, that would otherwise be insurmountable.” (Document J). Furthermore, Molly Wallace is saying that when the men where away, the women were able to run society, so they should be included…

    • 550 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ww1 Unit 1 Research Paper

    • 1048 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Source 6, an essay by B. Harrison written in 1993, illustrates the idea of many people that it helped to back up the Anti’s physical strength idea; “the idea that men and women had separate roles because women are, on average, physically weaker than men”. To me this is irrelevant; this idea had been popular in previous years when opponents of suffrage had claimed that women were not worthy of the vote as they could not fight for their country. Yet how on earth can this be argued when the women did so much to ensure the victory of the war? It is evident that even though women were not on the frontlines, without their efforts from home the war could simply have not been won! In this sense they did fight for their country as they put themselves out further than they usually would have to, to protect King and country and to defend what they fought was right. Source 6 conflicts this by arguing that women did not go through “the horrors of the frontline” and that most women stayed at home whilst the men went to war. Whilst this is true, I still do not think that it omits their substantial efforts at home, and this is backed up by my previous point that physical strength was no longer enough to keep the women from having the vote. Somebody had to stay at home and run the country- old politicians were not blamed for staying at home and working in an administration role because they could not fight so why should women be? The final point of Source 6 is that the First World War “pushed all peace time agenda down the line”. Whilst this is arguably valid, once the war was won these issues would inevitably arise once again, and in my opinion it helped to bring them even closer to the forefront, as it allowed women to be seen in a different light, and also helped the suffragettes get out of what was turning into somewhat of a reoccurring rut. I think that the…

    • 1048 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    But, there were no laws enacted which specifically target protection of women in the workforce. In fact, labor was cheap and management exploitive. Laborers were being forced to work long hours without additional compensation. This time saw significant strides in women's rights. Women were striving for suffrage and equal recognition under the law. It was accomplished through petitions, going through the courts, rallies, public debates, and picketing. Although effective, working conditions for women were not equivalent to those of men. It was not until the creation of labor unions and the eventual inclusion of women into these unions that there is advancement in the working conditions for…

    • 1687 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Suffragettes Dbq

    • 1087 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The First World War could have been seen as the most important factor in achieving female enfranchisement in 1918 due to it acting as a catalyst which sped up the changing attitudes towards women. As it gave women the opportunity to prove that they really were as worthy of having the vote as men. Foremost amongst these was the fall of Asquith as PM. However, the issue would certainly not have been in the forefront of the Government’s mind without the publicity-seeking campaigning of the Suffragettes, immediately prior to the War. It is difficult, however, to consider this to have been the most important factor, due to the very negative image of Suffragettes that prevailed, and the fact that many WSPU members had defected to the NUWSS. The work of the Suffragists together with the changing laws, led to the increasing politicisation of women. So therefore it can be concluded that the militant suffragette campaign cannot be seen as the most significant factor in helping women gain the…

    • 1087 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Therefore the support and political alliances formed by the suffragists is of great significance in aiding women gain the vote. Martin Pugh argues that democratic tactics adopted by the NUWSS helped them to gain support from many politicians, however as many were “lukewarm” they were not prepared prioritise the issue. Therefore the evidence proves that women did not receive the vote solely for their participation in World…

    • 569 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In fact, the contributions that had been made by these women (amongst others), allowed women under the Wartimes Election Act in 1917, to be given the right to vote. Specifically, women who were the sister, wife, mother or daughter of a soldier, were given the right to cast a vote.13 Although, this right was only given to those women who met the requirements, it was not far after, that all female British citizens (in 1918) were given the right to vote.14 This achievement was a stepping stone for other various organizations, to take initiative and grant women the justice and the rights they had been fighting for. It is remarkable to see how women were able to slowly bring about a progressive change in a society that was catered for men. Aside from establishing themselves on a political scale, the wave of independent women also helped those women who were, for example, unwed mothers. Prior to organizations being set up, unwed mothers were not provided financial, physical and mental support.…

    • 2107 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    So in 1903 two women Emmeline Pankhurst (Born 1858 in Manchester) and her daughter Christabel Pankhurst (Born 1880 in Manchester) got fed up with the slow and inadequate protesting of Mrs Fawcett. They believed that violence gave results, they wanted the right to vote and they wanted it now. So they decided to create the "Women's Social and Political Group" (WSPU), soon thousands of other women flocked to this promising, new group and this now massive group of women caused absolute mayhem throughout the country. These were women who were now 100% inpatient and frustrated, after 35 years they still hadn't gotten any closer to…

    • 843 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Millicent Fawcett, a leading feminist and president of the National Union of Women's Suffrage Societies from 1897 to 1918 said in 1918: 'The war revolutionised the industrial position of women - it found them serfs and left them free.' The war did offer women increased opportunities in the paid labour market. Between 1914 and 1918, an estimated two million women replaced men in employment, resulting in an increase in the proportion of women in total employment from 24 per cent in July 1914 to 37 per cent by November 1918. However, their pay was much less than men’s and they were treated poorly in many areas of work. The greatest restriction placed on women was that, due to the dilution agreements with the trade unions, when the men returned after the war they would automatically get their jobs back and so the women who had taken them were forced…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Women were finally able to receive credit for the work they did around and during the time of the Vietnamese War. Unlike the men, these women were purely volunteers. The reason these women volunteered were for a number of reasons, listed but not limited to: to serve their country, to help the men injured in battle, to receive real life training/experience to help further their medical career, to get a head start in their military careers, to prove themselves to others or sometimes just to do something different from their day to day lives. While these women had received various amounts of training or real life experience (some having little to none while some had 15 plus years), they…

    • 427 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Many believe it was of great help to the cause, since it highlighted the strategic and economic value of women. It is a fact that war did matter when it comes to women getting the vote. There were little men left to push the economy and out of necessity the government chose to employ women and realised they were doing a job just as that of men. Plus since Florence Nightingale got involved in the medical aspect of war, it had been greatly improved. Nursing was now a proper profession and females became respected personnel. As ASP Taylor said “War smoothed the way for democracy-meaning women’s war effort had ensured their enfranchisement. It was not possible for the government done through the war. The Women’s movement had helped the government greatly when it came to campaigning and there was a feeling that change was at the horizon, as a popular suffrage poster hinted. In 1918 the Bill was finally passed but not all women got the vote. Middle class females aged 30 or above could vote, which means democracy was still some way down the road. But it is true war helped pave the way to…

    • 1678 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays

Related Topics