Preview

To What Extent Have American History Textbooks Accurately Portrayed American History? Essay Example

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
430 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
To What Extent Have American History Textbooks Accurately Portrayed American History? Essay Example
To what extent have American History Textbooks accurately portrayed American History? James W. Loewen wrote this tell-all to expose the real meaning of American History; “diffusion of ideas is perhaps the most important cause of cultural development”pg.39. Loewen realized that not one but all twelve of the top high school US History textbooks failed at making history somewhat captivating to their readers. These books eliminate any ambiguities and problems that arose during the creation of the American society. By not throwing light upon social stratification, American History textbooks allowed high school students to wonder out into a society that came into view as “the rich getting richer and the poor getting poorer”. Loewen first started off by talking about Helen Keller and Woodrow Wilson, and the process to “heroification” which was quite corrupt. He stated that American History textbooks painted the picture of Keller and Wilson as “perfect creatures without conflicts or human interest” for their course of action to mold them into “heroes”. Loewen felt that Wilson and Keller, and whoever else was glorified, in textbooks led students to misinterpret who they really were.
High school history books cantered over the settling of the Americas before Columbus and his sailors arrived. The textbooks portrayed Columbus as a scholar but failed to unmask his major part in slavery and genocide. “A European disease that wiped out the natives” was known as a myth to the people of Plymouth and in the Caribbean. Loewen stated that if the Native Americans had not made the sacrifices for the Europeans then the US would have been poor but textbooks neglect stating that fact. White Americans always ruled Black Americans; racial uneasiness was always around after 1526 when the Spaniards brought the first African slaves to the Pee Dee River. The relationships established between the Blacks and Whites encouraged the formation of the Republican political party and ended the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The Betrayal of History by Alexander Stille was an interesting historical perspective about the evolution of textbooks used to teach our children about United States history. Prior to reading this article, I was unaware of the deliberate omissions and lies the publishers used to frame their narrative of our historical events. For example, publishers Holt and Rinehart want to create a multicultural hero for the Hispanic populations of Texas and California so they made up the story that a Spanish explorer Bartolomeo Gomez discovered the Hudson River. When, in fact, Gomez was Portuguese not Spanish and there was no evidence to support that he discovered the river.…

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    As the first chapter in this long analytical book, chapter one serves as the foundation for the rest of the novel, with a basic premise that “history textbooks make fool out of the students.” It shows how portrayal of historical figures and events in the best light for the reputation of United States leads to biased and distorted historical education.…

    • 1732 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A People's History of the United States is a book written by Howard Zinn, whose purpose is not to introduce someone to American History. He assumes his readers already know the basics. Of course, many people do not. It is not a history of the United States but it is a series of contentious corrections to the history traditionally taught in American classrooms.…

    • 2482 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    While I sit in my US History college course, the only thing I am indebted about is the academically stimulating Professor, who sanctions quality analytical dialogue. If I was required to sit through this class, accepting the fabrications and omissions of the materials, I would have opted for a great amount of “sick days”, along with a lower grade. Upon analysis of the obligatory text, however, I am incessantly reminded of why I so abhorred the subject of history since age ten. I guess I’m just not the type of intellectual, whom likes to be fed a load of bullshit, and then told to swallow it holding a coerced smile, while dutifully citing it as a deliciously satisfying meal of facts. The American history academia is overflowing with emblematic propaganda, heaving with histrionic melodrama, in which teaches pupils to think as simple-minded, white-centric citizens. Here, you will read a comprehensive elucidation on precisely why this is so apparent.…

    • 2636 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Later in the essay Loewen begins to discuss how high school history textbooks leave out many important parts of history, which could change the way the class system is seen. The authors of these American history books are bringing to light labor history, not showing that multinational companies are shipping their factories overseas limiting the work in the United States. James Loewen examined twelve history books to compare what was written and of those twelve six had no trace of social class or structure mentioned anywhere including the index.…

    • 990 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When it comes to America’s history, I believe there is much to be said that often is left out. Much of this I can reference back to a class that I was fortunate enough to take at Rutgers as a junior, Politics and Culture. The class had a very interesting aspect, which concerned historical memory. Historical memory can be defined as state sponsored collective memory. In order to understand this concept it is important to first understand the concept of collective memory. Collective memory is the emotional quality that is given to past events. It is not so much history based on fact, but instead how a certain society remembers their history. Essentially historical memory is a collection of narratives about the past that state-sponsored elites turn into non-negotiable facts, such as the way Loewe critiques the textbooks provided to students. These students then in turn take what the professor teaches and the textbook preaches at face value as absolute fact, essentially eradicating the possibility for negotiation and debate.…

    • 528 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    James Loewen uses his piece Lies my Teacher Told Me to reveal the flaws in America’s mainstream textbooks. Loewen points out the fact that textbooks try to “indoctrinate blind patriotism” (Loewen 6) and “keep students in the dark about the nature of history” (Loewen 8). Almost every American textbook sells history using the “soft seduction” approach, as explained in Robert Greene’s book, The Art of Seduction. Textbooks try to seduce Americans into being proud of their country by making American historical figures look like heroes, like in the case of Helen Keller, Woodrow Wilson, and Christopher Columbus. “Heroification” (Loewen 11) has a negative effect on American textbooks because it gives students a false impression of their country’s history.…

    • 823 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In Ward Churchill’s “History Not Taught is History Forgot: Columbus’s Legacy of Genocide”, depictions of the European’s genocide and greed are numerous. Christopher Columbus nearly caused the extinction of the native Taino’s people. He used slavery as the premiere method of extinction. Upon his arrival, the Taino’s population ranked eight million. When he departed, that number had dwindled to 100, 000. His successors carried on his policies, and the natives were further decimated to a mere 22, 000 in the year 1514. By the year 1542 they were reduced to 200 individuals, rendering them virtually extinct. The consequences of Columbus’ policies indirectly led to an absolute extermination of an entire culture.…

    • 197 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    James Loewen wrote the book "Lies My Teacher Told ME" to help the students of the United States become aware of their true history. This book attempts to show how and why American history has been taught the way it has without regard for the truth. Mr. Loewen had compared twelve different history textbooks they are: The Great Republic, The American Way, Land of Promise, Rise of the American Nation, Challenge of Freedom, American Adventures, Discovering American History, The American Tradition, Life and Liberty, The United States – A History of the Republic, Triumph of the American Nation and The American Pageant. Loewen has argued his cases for Heroification, Euorcentrism and the first settlers, and Racism in our history. He has done this knowing fully that most people do not want to know the harsh realities of our nations past. The United States has tried to maintain a positive image throughout history. Unfortunately, it has many skeletons in its closet that need to come out to heal this great nation on many levels. If the public at large new the real role of racism in our nations infancy and how men tried to pursue their way of thinking as opposed to what is good for the country they would be ashamed at what the United States has stood for in the past.…

    • 1442 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In 1492, Christopher Columbus, discovered America. More than 500 years later Columbus Day is a national holiday. Statues are up, even in Pueblo, and thanks are given for what he has done for us. We learn about him in grade school and we are told of his brave adventures. However twenty years later in my first history class another picture is being painted of Columbus; not from my History book, but from my teacher. I thought it was interesting to be learning these conflicting views of him and researched the facts. Apparently a lot of people feel the same way…Christopher Columbus was a villain. Nearly 500 years ago Christopher Columbus…

    • 1777 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    My Teacher Told Me

    • 1179 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Throughout our educational lives, we have been told countless stories of how this nation came to be. Countless hours in a classroom for 12 years, just to be told half of the story, sometimes a bunch of lies or overly edited facts. In “Lies My Teacher Told Me” Loewen utilizes many different sources such as journals, images, newspaper clippings and oral accounts of events that took place through out history. With these sources Loewen proves that text books give false information or omit things all together to keep from offending people of a certain culture race or religion. Loewen also proves that the text books alter the events to create a more likeable story thus saving the characters already glorified reputation. The way he does this is by…

    • 1179 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    distort history to the point that much of what the books contain is essentially untruthful. He has…

    • 582 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There has been a notable change in the American History from the last 400 years until now. At the beginning the American History the subjects that the historians interpreted were politics, diplomacy and war. The only people who could do the interpreting were only white male Americans. The contemporary American historians wrote nearly about everything that affected everybody. This times were very different from what they are now, when you read history, you are reading the historian's point of view or encounter with the world. The historians were fully dedicated to this, they spend hours, days, years of…

    • 850 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Texas in 2015, children's history textbooks were written to whitewash history and underplaying slavery to make it sound like a side issue and not everything it actually was. It also teaches children that god is the root of everything, despite these lessons being taught in a public school. This type of education is taking away real history from children and not allowing them to get an actual understanding of how awful american has been. Allowing american kids to think that american won everything is untrue and unrealistic. In Canada, a textbook taught children that the European settlers who first arrived were given the land by the native canadians and the natives were happy to move; which couldn’t be farther from the truth. (The Guardian). While most people will agree that rewriting history has negative impacts, some historians argue that it’s not always intentional and happens more than previously thought. Due to personal bias, sometimes historians do research purely to answer their hypothesis. Once they reach that answer, they are done researching; when in reality, there is more to learn. While this may seem like a slight difference, over time it can actually impact the retelling of…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Ap Euro

    • 691 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “Ex Post Facto,” by Stanley Schmidt, describes how people view history and historic societies’ beliefs. In this modern world, most people look down on past events that would now be considered unacceptable. He uses Christopher Columbus as an example throughout the text, and explains how his methods of conquering new land would be seen as cruel and evil in this present day. Kidnapping, murdering, and destroying most of the Native American homes is not easily forgiven in this day and age.…

    • 691 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays