top-rated free essay

The Planners vs the City Planner

By Onlymatang Feb 05, 2013 332 Words
The city planners
* Magaret Atwood - Canadian poet
* Purpose: question the planners about the fake perfection * Criticism of the system
* Emotion tone: emotionless, calm (beginning), materialistic, depressing, fear, sorrow, monotonous, disillusion, sarcastic, mocking, anger * Theme: man vs nature
* images about human hand in nature. – even nature is controlled by humans * society is blinded by this perfect order.
* Nature will assert its dominance over man again
* Lots of irony
* Free verse
* A lot of enjambments
* Colons are used to emphasize
* Man’s manipulation of nature
* Political dominance
* Lost of culture
* Discuss the human take-over of nature
* Criticism of abuse of power – ambiguity of the identity of the city planners * The image is more
* emotion: humourous
* talks about serioud issues without creepy feeling
* lack of identity
* beganning – precision
* second part – the illusion, avoidance(of reality) etc is highlighted * the size of stanza reduce as we go along - deterioration * language: simple diction
* colon – lists out the sanities
* end no punctuation – shows the frantic pace of the planners * lots of metaphor
* personification – nature is dominated (discourage grass) * Imagery – thought provoking, inventive
* Hose – violent
* Snow storm - confusion
The planner
* Boey Kim Cheng:
* From Singapore- migrated to Australia
* Purpose: question the government/politician about the fake perfection * Criticism
* Emotion: fear, anger, neutral, tired, materialistic, tired, surrender, monotenous * Theme: man vs nature
* images about human hand in nature. – even nature is controlled by humans * society is blinded by this perfect order.
* Nature cant do anything, the planners are unstoppable
* No rhyme scheme
* Man’s manipulation of nature
* Political dominance
* Lost of culture
* Discuss the human take-over of nature
* Free verse
* Criticism of abuse of power – ambiguity of the identity of the planners * emotion: serious
* Make you feel uneasy
* Man’s dominance over nature
* Conformity
* Themes
Themes
Science and technology VS. Culture, art and history
* Wealth, power and capitalism
* Artificial perfection - soulessness
* Disillusionment
* Emotion vs intellect
* Beganning – precision
* Alouse of nature come later
* Second part – relentlessness is highlighted
* Language: simple diction
* Personification – nature is dominated (‘skies surrender’) * Visual imagery – extended dental metaphor

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • The City Planners and the Planners

    ...Done By: http://www.livetvee4u.blogspot.com/ Below is some additional information on the two poems written by Margaret Atwood and Kim Boey Cheng respectively, found on the internet: “The City Planners” by Margaret Atwood and “The Planners” by Boey Kim Cheng Many poets lament humanity’s soulless march toward technology and i...

    Read More
  • The City Planner

    ...and, as a result, sidestep all hysteria that they cannot comprehend. This imagery is incredibly intriguing and provokes much thoughts and speculation about the real nature of these residents. By using this imagery, Atwood has left space for the imagination of the reader to unwind itself. She explores the effect of greed and neglect of the reside...

    Read More
  • The City Planners

    ...The City Planners, Margaret Atwood In this poem, the poet attacks the sterile uniformity of residential suburbs. Notice that she never mentions people. ‘What offends us is the sanities’ Sanity is defined as being reasonable and of sound mind; she is referring to ‘pedantic houses’, sanitary trees’ and things that she consid...

    Read More
  • The City Planners' and 'the Planners

    ...In ‘The City Planners’ by Margaret Atwood and ‘The Planners’ by Boey Kim Cheng, both poet uses the structure of the poem and language techniques to form the difference between the place itself and its identity. The uniformity between these two poems is the feelings of the poet expresses for this place. In ‘The City planners’ Atwood...

    Read More
  • The Planners

    ...The Planners : By Boey Kim Cheng They plan. They build. All spaces are gridded, filled with permutations of possibilities. The buildings are in alignment with the roads which meet at desired points linked by bridges all hang in the grace of mathematics. They build and will not stop. Even the sea draws back and the skies surrender....

    Read More
  • The Planners

    ...The Planners By Boey Kim Cheng The poem ‘The Planners’ by Boey Kim Cheng, is remarkably very similar to the previous poem, ‘The City Planners’ in terms of the general theme and idea of the poem; perfection, uniformity, control over nature, and “Planners” who control and create everything. However it should be noted that there is a...

    Read More
  • difference between the planners and the city planners

    ...Both poems use the word Planners in their titles and both deal with cities as their topic, focussing on the structures and organization of urban spaces. Kim Cheng uses the third person ‘they’ to create a sense of distance - of us and them, whereas Atwood uses the inclusive ‘we’, to suggest that this experience of cities is one that we...

    Read More
  • Compare City Planner and Planner

    ...w w w e tr .X m eP e ap UNIVERSITY OF CAMBRIDGE INTERNATIONAL EXAMINATIONS International General Certificate of Secondary Education .c rs om *2925136620* CHEMISTRY Paper 3 (Extended) 0620/33 May/June 2012 1 hour 15 minutes Candidates answer on the Question Paper. No Additional Materials are required. READ THESE INSTRUCTIONS FIRS...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.