J.L. Mackie

Topics: Free will, Philosophy of religion, God Pages: 2 (494 words) Published: April 8, 2010
J. L Mackie
Mackie’s argument
The proposed solution to be discussed and Mackie’s response to it is the claim that ‘evil is due to human free will’ and as such it cannot be attributed to God. Evil should instead be attributed to the free actions of individuals, the power of which has been endowed upon them by God. While it is acknowledged that there exists evil in the world, as a result of some human free will, it is claimed that freedom of will is a more valuable good than any resultant evil. Through God allowing such freedom, He has satisfied His ‘wholly good’ requirement. Creating men who always choose good

Mackie’s first criticism of this solution is that if God was omnipotent and he created men so that they would favour choosing good over evil, why did he not create them such that they would always choose good? The obvious response to this claim is that to constrain man’s actions in such a way is to critically undermine freedom of the will; to demand that man always choose one way whether it be in the promotion of good or evil is still to control his will and deprive him of his freedom and autonomy. Paradox of Omnipotence

Adequate solution
For Mackie, an adequate solution is one that if adopted the initial problem does not arise for you, however the solution may have raised other problems. The only discussed solution that does not hold God responsible for evil in the world is the compatibilist approach to free will. Upon formulating this solution the two major issues are on the interpretation of omnipotence and freedom. Omnipotence has been revealed to be an almost meaningless term by way of the paradoxes that it gives rise to, such as the ability or inability of an omnipotent God to make rules or animals that restrict its own powers. The interpretation discussed and ultimately the proposal that gave rise to a compatibilist approach was that proposed by Mackie and so there is little that he could criticise about this part...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Mackie and the Problem of Evil Essay
  • Essay about The Problem of Evil
  • Essay on Brown Mackie Versus Ivy Tech
  • bob mackie reaserch paper
  • Student: Typography and Brown Mackie College Essay
  • Doodle in the Scarlet Ibis Essay
  • Public Relations Essay
  • essay questions

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free