Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Hamlet´S Commentary

Powerful Essays
1258 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Hamlet´S Commentary
UNIVERSIDAD PEDAGÓGICA NACIONAL
LITERATURE IN ENGLISH II
LAURA CAROLINA VELANDIA
2008134060
GROUP 1
COMMENTARY ABOUT HAMLET
In the following commentary, I will introduce, on the one hand, a brief comparative data from the play “Hamlet, Prince of Denmark” by William Shakespeare and film “Hamlet, the honor of revenge” by Franco Zeffirelli.. As regards to analysis of the work itself and the characters I will address various topics, such as: revenge, doubt, fate and ambition.
The tragedy of Hamlet, prince of Denmark is probably the most famous theatrical piece of Western culture and one of the most criticized literary works in history. It was written between 1599 and 1601, near the end of the Elizabethan Age into so-called “Problem tragedy”. The play takes place in Elsinore, Denmark, and tells us how Prince Hamlet carries out his revenge on his uncle Claudius who murdered King Hamlet, Prince´s father, and who holds the usurper crown and marriage to Gertrude, Hamlet´s mother. The play takes place vividly over madness (as real as feigned), and the course of deep pain to the excessive anger. Moreover, it explores secondary issues such as treason, incest, and moral conflict.
As film opens with the King Hamlet´s funeral and his wife in tears over his grave, the book begins with the talk of the kingdom guards on the ghost of Hamlet´s father. Also, we find differences over the staging of the play on its representation and intentions. However, we can say that both Shakespeare and Zeffirelli focus on Hamlet´s character as representing of a controversial psychology, virtue, intelligence and morality who also lost control of his own will to do the act which he is destined: to avenge death of his father.
The fate and change play with lives of characters, as the intrigue and treason become ruthlessly against them:

Hamlet:
O villany!–Ho! Let the door be lock’d:
Treachery! seek it out. P.158

As film progresses we see also that the gravedigger scene in it is different than the book, since in film there is no a partner to talk about the death of woman (Ophelia), while in the book suggests that she is committed suicide. The dialogues are faithful to the text but are shorter in the film, some scenes come forward to emphasize the director´s intentions, few others are skipped and replaced by moments of ambience and images, thus creating a different version, so it is evident pain, crime, insanity, death, deceit and usurpation of power.
Also in the pantomime there are differences, because during the staging of the small representation into the play itself, the drama presented as a prologue by messenger and entry of actors is masterfully combined. (P.90- min 1.05).
Finally, both film and the play ends, one with Hamlet´s death as a main story and the other with the entry of Fontinbras.

The idealistic nature of the political conception of Shakespeare is that he takes to produce in his characters the virtues of a great human being, those virtues which include the psychology of true friends, loyal and closest to the tragic hero and to cover the qualities that a king should have.

However, the Shakespeare´s heroes have an obvious decline at the end of their work because of continued disappointment and unfortunate events by which they traverse. In Hamlet, the fate inevitably overcomes his will, because he denies himself, but is tight cannot be said in another position.
On the other hand, the metaphysical intention in Shakespeare develops through his characters, relating to supernatural forces who call them to perform heroic works. In the case of Hamlet, the misfortune is cursed by him to have pointed out with that unwanted fate of having to avenge his father´s death.
Hamlet:
And still your fingers on your lips, I pray.
The time is out of joint:–O cursed spite,
That ever I was born to set it right! P.47

Thus, the providential destiny and the natural inclination of the characters to develop and be defeated by their own failings, to make that their weaknesses are insurmountable and, therefore, reflect a continuing struggle against nature, for example: lust in Gertrude, Ophelia's madness, adulation in Polonius, doubt and slowness in Hamlet and Claudius´s ambition.
Revenge: it is the moving subject of the action. In Hamlet, revenge becomes transcendental dimensions, as the ghost of his father asks to avenge his death, as it involves cleansing of his soul and the recovery of his honor. But this is not just a social human justice, but divine justice of an eternal character that acts covertly as a fate and that also is based on the moral conception of early Christianity. Thus, Hamlet becomes a minister and executor of a divine will and a transcendental law, which will lead him to doubt and slow in his approach.
Doubt: focuses exclusively on Hamlet, and comes in different ways in the work. On the one hand, Hamlet expresses doubt about the identity of the ghost of his father, which leads him to be slow in carrying out his revenge, and the other presents a question about true love and honest after seeing how her mother succumbs to lust and how Ophelia is provided to be a "carrion flesh." Again, on the one hand, denotes an obvious question about life itself and its meaning, and the other, it comprises a doubt over himself about his own reason and sanity.
Ambition: it moves to Claudio to commit assassination and fratricide, looking well, access to power. Ambition in Hamlet represents the imbalance and disorder of the play, besides of being this the start of something larger: the decline.
Fate: presents various forms, as the inclination of the characters to certain passions and the premonition of death.
Osric.
How is’t, Laertes?
Laertes.
Why, as a woodcock to my own springe, Osric;
I am justly kill’d with mine own treachery. P.157
Fate here seems forced and inscrutable. The goal is peace, but achieved through war, therefore, to restore balance to pass over the tragic ending of decay and find forgiveness, which can be accessed only by Laertes.
Laertes.
He is justly serv’d;
It is a poison temper’d by himself.–
Exchange forgiveness with me, noble Hamlet:
Mine and my father’s death come not upon thee,
Nor thine on me!
[Dies.] P.158
According to my personal interpretation Hamlet's revenge is quite clever, since it comes in two distinct acts: the first includes the play called "The Mousetrap", a little play planed by Hamlet and attended by those involved in the tragedy, it is here that Hamlet is aware of the guilt of his uncle; and the second is the confrontation organized by Laertes that determines the tragic ending of the play in which everyone, including Hamlet, die because of their own poison. However, his revenge leads to Prince to kill Polonius, Rosencrantz, Guildenstern and Laertes, acts that will lead his soul to perdition and eternal damnation. Thus, acts of contrition that is expected to see reflected in the most controversial figures could not be because of the doubt tangle and lies that surrounded them.
In conclusion, while Hamlet seems to find an ideal stoic and try to apply it, never get it completely, because his nature prevents it.

--------------------------------------------
[ 2 ]. Dianne, Bean. “Hamlet, Prince of Denmark” by Shakepeare, William. Converted to text PDF by campany@ufpel.tche.br
[ 3 ]. De Madarriaga, Salvador. “El Hamlet de Shakespeare”. Ensayo de interpretación, traducción y notas. Edición Bilingue. Ed. Suramericana. Buenos Aires. 1989.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Hamlet Essay

    • 948 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In using the conventions of the revenge tragedy genre, expectations are created for an audience who understand the conflict that looms under Claudius’s leadership unless Hamlet revenges his father’s ‘most foul and unnatural murder’. Yet Hamlet is conflicted over the moral dilemma that confronts him, expressing this through his Judeo Christian perspective of ‘O cursed spite that ever I was born to set it right’. His powerful use of soliloquy throughout the play explores the paradigm shift between Renaissance and Judeo-Christian ideas on life and life after death. ‘To be or not to be...’ asks Hamlet, reflecting the philosophical existential concerns of this context and supporting the plays longevity for these paramount concerns remain relevant to every context. Here Shakespeare has successfully mirrored the ferment and change in his society, whilst modern directors mirror theirs in ways that reflect their values and beliefs. It is for this reason that Shakespeare’s work is described as ‘not of an age, but for all time’ (Ben Johnson).…

    • 948 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Hamlet, Prince of Denmark has remained the most perplexing, as well as the most popular, of William Shakespeare’s tragedies. Whether considered as literature, philosophy, or drama, its artistic stature is universally admitted. To explain the reasons for its excellence in a few words, however, is a daunting task. Apart from the matchless artistry of its language, the play’s appeal rests in large measure on the character of Hamlet himself. Called upon to avenge his father’s murder, he is compelled to face problems of duty, morality, and ethics that have been human concerns through the ages. The play has tantalized critics with what has become known as the Hamlet mystery, that of Hamlet’s complex behavior, most notably his indecision and his reluctance to act.…

    • 1773 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hamlet Rhetorical Analysis

    • 1632 Words
    • 7 Pages

    In spite of the fact that the plot evokes the implication that it occurred between the close of 16th century and the start of the 17th century, Shakespeare’s Hamlet surpasses the constraints of time and muses upon both the primitive and contemporary man. In the late 16th century in England, people of all classes on the social echelon, with the exception of royals, were able to publicly eyewitness theatre. Audiences craved new plays to assuage their appetites. One of numerous dramatists that capitalized this abundance of opportunity was Shakespeare. Opposed to the modern time, audiences spectated the play to hear it rather than see it. The articulation of the lines and significance of how the story was recited was crucial…

    • 1632 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark by William Shakespeare is one of the most compelling and influential tragedies in English literature. The tragedy is rife with death, vengeance, and puissant soliloquies that are highly interpretable by the audience. Hamlet discovers his father’s unnatural death was a heinous plot by his uncle to steal the crown and the queen. Throughout the play, in Hamlet’s soliloquies, he reveals himself to be a righteous individual who will execute what he believes in: justice.…

    • 715 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hamlet - Textual Integrity

    • 1070 Words
    • 5 Pages

    William Shakespeare's famous tragedy 'Hamlet' follows a young prince of Denmark who after his father's death, is confronted by his fathers ghost and sets out to prove his uncles participation in killing his father and marrying his mother, "the serpent that did sting thy father now wears his crown". For over 400 years, Shakespeare's 'Hamlet' has been studied and examined countless times by scholars and students alike, all of whom have had different interpretations on the dramatic piece as a consequence of the texual integrity of the play. The plays exposure of life's fundamental and timeless questions in which are still relevant today, allows for the continual study and reinterpretation of the dramatic piece.…

    • 1070 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Hamlet Critical Lens

    • 391 Words
    • 1 Page

    In the William Shakespeare’s play, Hamlet the Prince of Denmark is plotting to kill his uncle, who is the king because he poisoned his father, the previous king. The theme of the play is revenge and the protagonist, Hamlet is characterized as being fully devoted to avenging his father, no matter the cost. After two months of mourning for his dead father, Hamlet encounters his father’s ghost, who tells him that it was his brother, King Claudius who killed him. Hamlet then promises his father that he will get revenge on Claudius however, his inability to act prolongs Claudius’s death. Hamlet must first find out if it was actually his father’s ghost and not Satan trying to trick him so he modifies a play that shows a similarity to the murder of Hamlet’s father at the hand of Claudius. Claudius leaves before the play before it ends and berates himself for the murder, “Oh, my offence is rank, it smells to heaven. It has the eldest primal curse on it, a brother’s murder.” Therefore, Claudius will pay the price for killing Hamlet’s father by losing his throne, his wife, and even his own life. Hamlet will also pay greatly for avenging his father. He will lose Ophelia, the woman he loves who drownes herself after her father, Polonius is killed by Hamlet who thought it was Claudius. He will lose his mother, Gertrude who drinks wine that was poisoned by Claudius and intended for Hamlet. Hamlet will also lose his own life after being stabbed with a poisoned sword by Larates in a fencing duel, who was seeking…

    • 391 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Any critical evaluation of the play “Hamlet” must be chiefly concerned with the character of Hamlet. Unlike Shakespeare’s other tragedies, “Hamlet” is singular in purpose and scope-it is the story of one man’s personal and moral collapse under the weight of his own (and other’s) decisions, intentions and machinations. The play is not complicated with subplots and extraneous secondary characters, but is wholly focused on the man himself. This dedication to a singular dramatic intention paradoxically makes for “Hamlet” to be, subjectively, Shakespeare most confusing play. It is problematic in its protagonists’ inscrutability, his missing motives, his contradictory actions, and his utter implacability to settle into one stable character. Almost everything he does further contradicts him as an individual in the world of the play and as a dramatic character. For this reason my critical evaluation of the play is that it is artistically self defeating due to its own subversions of character and dramatic convention, and this should render it unfulfilling and disappointing as a dramatic performance. Paradoxically, the plays confusion renders it all the more infuriatingly readable-it is both alienating and enticing, a work which defeats itself in its own realisation and at the same time is only worthwhile and meaningful in this artistic enigma-the individual components should not work, yet it does strike a powerful emotional and dramatic resonance in its completion. Many aspects of “Hamlet” as a text are easily criticised-it is certainly a work with a large amount of problems. However, in a rather subversive and mysterious manner the play is a wonderful work of literature.…

    • 1441 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Shakespeare’s play Hamlet (1601) explores Hamlet’s growing insecurities and uncertainties, which stem from his attempt to find certainty and order within his changing transitioning society. Hamlet’s strong moral code and genuine grief at the beginning of the play contrasts with his descent into madness and deceit, as the corruption of the court begin to deteriorate his integrity and eventually lead to his tragic downfall. Throughout the play Shakespeare explores universal notions of authenticity contrasted with duplicity, the struggle between action and inaction and challenging the archetypal tragedian. Through an exploration of these themes, Shakespeare attempts to use the characters in his play to reflect his view on humanity and the shifting, conflicting paradigms between Medieval and Renaissance thinking.…

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hamlet's Paranoia

    • 2158 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Hamlet once saw his mother as the epitome of virtue. This image is dashed against the rocks when he finds her married, incestuously, to his uncle less than two months following his father’s death. Having only seen his mother with his father, Hamlet perceives that he has lost her after she marries Claudius. Hamlet has, “All his life he has believed in her, we may be sure, as such a son would” (Bradley, 98). Hamlet looks down upon his mother’s second marriage as disrespect to the memory of his father. Hamlet cries out “O, most wicked speed to post with such dexterity to incestuous sheets!” (I. 2. 161-62). Now alone save for Horatio, Hamlet’s madness is left to grow unchecked.…

    • 2158 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hamlet Movie Comparison

    • 1115 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The purpose of this report is to compare and contrast two movies made about Hamlet. I will present and discuss different aspects of the version directed by Kenneth Branagh to that of Franco Zefirelli. During this paper you will be presented with my opinions in reference to determining which version of Hamlet best reflects the original text by Shakespeare. I will end this paper with my belief and explanation of which movie is true to the original play.…

    • 1115 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Shakespeare, William, Barbara A. Mowat, and Paul Werstine. The Tragedy of Hamlet, Prince of Denmark. New York: Washington Square, 2002. Print.…

    • 2083 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Shakespeare's Hamlet, written around 1600, is one of the most problematic texts in all of literature. With the exception of certain Biblical texts, no other work has produced such a continuing, lively, and contentious debate about how we are supposed to understand it. In fact, one could very easily construct a thorough and intriguing history of modern literary criticism based upon nothing other than various interpretative takes on Hamlet (a task which has already been carried out by at least one historian of ideas).…

    • 12004 Words
    • 49 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hamlet. Book vs Movies

    • 1541 Words
    • 7 Pages

    To play Hamlet well is to succeed on the stage or on the screen. It is one of the most complex of the Shakespearian roles that many actors have aspired to master or at least, bring something distinctive and fresh to the pivotal character. There is no doubt that Hamlet “brazenly solicits interpretation”, demonstrated by modern day actors including Mel Gibson, Ethan Hawke and Kenneth Branagh, in the medium of film. Throughout the 20th Century, film adaptations have finely developed both the character of Hamlet and have nurtured a performance of the play, in some very creative and exciting ways. Film directors Franco Zeffirelli, Michael Almereyda and Kenneth Branagh have brought “Hamlet” to varying levels of success on the screen while achieving this through stark differences in interpretation and through realising very different creative ideas.…

    • 1541 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Who is to Blame?

    • 1575 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Whether or not you are a fan of Shakespearean plays, it is apparent that the truth and purpose of his plays were in fact… not apparent at all. Consider Hamlet. A story filled with betrayal, madmen, and of course, death. Death is the primary theme of Hamlet; how each character is affected by death in some way or form. However, it is unclear on where death came from and who initially brought it upon Denmark. In this analysis of Hamlet, I will dissect the viewpoints of Indira Ghose, G. Wilson Knight, and Tabassum Javed towards identifying who is truly responsible for the deaths in this Shakespearean play.…

    • 1575 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Mack, Maynard. “The World of Hamlet.” Yale Review. vol. 41 (1952) p. 502-23. Rpt. in Readings on The Tragedies. Ed. Clarice Swisher. San Diego: Greenhaven Press, 1996.…

    • 2678 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics