Birthright Citizenship Should Be Abolished Essay Example

Good Essays
Birthright Citizenship Aff:

We stand in affirmation of the topic Resolved: Birthright citizenship should be abolished in the United States. We define abolish according to the Black’s Law Dictionary as to annul, eliminate, or destroy, especially an ongoing practice or thing and “should” from the Merriam Webster dictionary as a word used to express obligation.

The criteria for this round will be net benefits and if we prove that abolishing birthright citizenship provides even a minute benefit or keeping it is minutely harmful an affirmative ballot is warranted.

Contention 1) Education for the children of illegal immigrants constitutes the single largest cost to taxpayers.

According to

At an annual price tag of $52 billion, state and local governments absorb nearly all of the costs of education for these children.

Undoubtedly one of the strongest arguments for ending birthright citizenship centers on the costs that American taxpayers incur as a result of illegal immigration. While the Supreme Court has ruled that even illegal immigrants and their children must receive education if they are of proper age, United States law clearly states that illegal immigrants are not eligible for benefits such as Medicare or Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF for short).

Once one member of the family is a citizen, this is no longer the case. As such, once illegal immigrant families have children, they are eligible as those children are American citizens. This is unfair because illegal immigrants receive the same benefits as their legal counterparts do; yet they are not paying an equivalent amount into the system.

Contention 2) Birthright citizenship encourages illegal immigration.

Subpoint A) The status quo creates an incentive for illegal immigration where the reward for illegally entering the country can be an American child. According to the

The benefits attached to having an American child extend beyond those associated with social

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    bettering the lives of their descendants. Today, people come to America with the same mindset of creating a better life for their offspring. Birthright citizenship should not be abolished because it is a part of the Constitution, immigrants should be able to create a better life for their offspring and a population increase of native-born noncitizens should be prevented. The United States Constitution must be upheld. The 14th Amendment reassures the people that every person born in the United States…

    • 373 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Birthright Citizenship Should Be Modified An immigrant can live in Ethiopia and not become an Ethiopian; he can live in Nairobi and not become a Kenyan; he can live in Saudi Arabia and not become a Saudi, but anyone from any part in the world can live in America and become an American. US citizenship is automatically granted to those who are born within the united states no matter their legal status. birthright citizenship encourages women to enter the country illegally to give birth. birthright…

    • 660 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    to give infants membership in the polity? Heather Horn tells us that, “ it’s a natural question to ask, now that Donald Trump’s proposal to scarp what he calls ‘birthright citizenship’.” According to Horn, there are two common types of birthright citizenships and both are involved in the US policy. The two types of birthright citizenship include jus soli and jus sanguinis. Jus soli is known as “right of soil” or being born within the boarders of a the US. Whereas jus sanguinis is known as “right…

    • 1036 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Birthright citizenship The birthright citizens also know as 14th amendment was ratified on July 9, 186, it granted citizenship to “all person born or naturalized” in the United States. In recent news the topic of birthright citizenship has been a big debate in the GOP candidate race for president. Many candidates have made it know that they are against against birthright citizenship, someone of them our top GOP leader Donald Trump, and Ben Carson. Other candidates Like Marco Rubio and Carly Fiorina…

    • 329 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Birthright Citizenship 091509

    • 16188 Words
    • 23 Pages

    IMMIG�TION POLICY CENTER PERSPECTIVES MADE IN AMERICA MYTHS & FACTS ABOUT BIRTHRIGHT CITIZENSHIP By James Ho, Margaret Stock, Eric Ward & Elizabeth Wydra SEPTEMBER 2009 Photo from �ickr.com. By Brian Wilson Photography. MADE IN AMERICA: MYTHS & FACTS ABOUT BIRTHRIGHT CITIZENSHIP BY JAMES HO, MARGARET STOCK, ERIC WARD & ELIZABETH WYDRA SEPTEMBER 2009 ABOUT PERSPECTIVES ON IMMIGRATION The Immigration Policy Center’s Perspectives are thoughtful narratives written…

    • 16188 Words
    • 23 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    others want that the constitutional amendment to change and guarantee birthright citizenship. The public shows little support on deporting all illegal immigrants, but surveys show that in the past years that they show greater support on building a barrier along the border. The public also shows on surveys that they support to change the constitution to ban birthright citizenship. My opinion on banning birthright citizenship…

    • 311 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    idea was it to give infants membership in the polity? Heather Horn tells us that, “ it’s a natural question to ask, now that Donald Trump’s proposal to scarp what he calls ‘birthright citizenship’.” There are two common types of birthright citizenships and both are involved in the US policy. The two types of birthright citizenship include jus soli and jus sanguinis. Jus soli is also known as “right of soil” or being born within the boarders of a the US. Whereas jus sanguinis is known as “right of blood”…

    • 165 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although Germany has long been characterised as the prototypical birthright citizenship country, it should be first mentioned that during the first half of the nineteenth century many of the independent German states actually had a tradition of principle of residence rather than an emphasis on birthright. Birthright citizenship was first introduced by Bavaria in 1818 and then finally implemented by the German Nationality Law of 1913 (Fessler,…

    • 68 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    few nations give out citizenship to any kids that are born on their land and United States is one of the countries that provides citizenship to people that are born on their land. Although people from various countries come to United States of America to give birth to their babies and apply for the citizenship through that, I argue that the U.S government should not provide citizenship…

    • 884 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Birthright citizenship 1.) A. Research the term "birth tourism" and how birth tourism impacts (or may impact) our system and resources. B. Which areas in the U.S. are seeing the most birth tourism? a. Birth tourism, mainly Chinese women, travel to give birth in the U.S so that their children will be U.S citizens, also called Anchor babies. After getting the citizenship for the baby, most parents return to their home country. Their plan being to send their children to college in America, once old…

    • 901 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays