Sad is the man who is asked for a story and can't come up with one.
His five-year-old son waits in his lap.
Not the same story, Baba. A new one.
The man rubs his chin, scratches his ear.
In a room full of books in a world of stories, he can recall not one, and soon, he thinks, the boy will give up on his father.
Already the man lives far ahead, he sees the day this boy will go. Don't go!
Hear the alligator story! The angel story once more!
You love the spider story. You laugh at the spider.
Let me tell it!
But the boy is packing his shirts, he is looking for his keys. Are you a god, the man screams, that I sit mute before you?
Am I a god that I should never disappoint?
But the boy is here. Please, Baba, a story?
It is an emotional rather than logical equation, an earthly rather than heavenly one, which posits that a boy's supplications and a father's love add up to silence.
Li-Young Lee
The first stanza is rather sad, with the ‘sad man’ being the father who cannot come up with a new story. The second stanza turns to be very happy and loving. The ‘five year old boy’ asks his ‘Baba’ to tell him “not the same story” but a “new one.”
The third stanza sets the change for the fourth stanza which is anxious, desperate and pleading. The father who is felling almost abandoned is begging his son not to go, to “Let me tell it!” ‘it’ being the story. By the last stanza the narrator is again in third person (the father) and he is feeling emotional “It is and emotional rather than logical equation” This show the fathers love for his son. He says that his son “posits” (to put forward or ask) in a “supplications” manner (humbly) which makes the “father’s love add up to silence.” This means the he is lost for words. He is so overwhelmed by his love for his son that he is speechless thus leaving his “love [to] add up to silence”
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Considering Shen Congwen’s short story “The Inn”, it is worth saying that the title itself has much in common with romantic dimensions. However, at the beginning of “The Inn” one cannot help but become aware that fin de siècle images as well as emotions appeared to prevail over the other constituents of the story’s setting; the focus here lies in arguing that the inn appears to be placed at the foot of a range of hills close to the town frontiers. Each day, the exhausted people, being involved in walking “a distance of eighty or a hundred miles” (Congwen 107), would approach the house and seek for the bed. Subsequently, they would fall asleep similar to the logs on a straw, with their bodies deprived…
- 696 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The second stanza is only two lines, "My father told us this, one night,/and then continued eating dinner." This stanza breaks up the chronology of the poem, pushing the previous stanza into the past, and making it disjointed, almost like another poem in itself. The result of the father continuing eating after he tells the story shows how dead he is inside, the recalling of the story no longer affecting him in the same way it does the reader and his own family. It is implied that he is the only one able to eat after telling the story. This short stanza foreshadows the father's personality change.…
- 346 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In the beginning of the poem, the son refers to the father as “Baba” which shows the affectionate and innocent side of the boy when he is little. The boy is pleading with his dad to tell him a story, yet the roles are reversed later when the father is begging for the son to allow him to tell a story to him. This ironic switch of roles shows the complex relationship as the father is not in the position of authority that he should be in to begin with. The father is supposed to be the leader and role model for the son, and the father is worried about things changing in the future. He sees the point where the son is a grown man and is no longer in need of his father for everything. When the son becomes a man, he will no longer have the same innocent and affectionate characteristics he has now, and he will rely on his father in a different way. However, again the father is failing the son in his present need for a story therefore setting the precedent that the father will not fulfill the needs of the son and that he is not reliable because he cannot live in the moment. Relationships in themselves are complex as they grow and change overtime, but the father is unable to enjoy the different stages of his relationship with his son because he is constantly worried about the…
- 831 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The second stanza syntactical structure illustrates complexity of childhood experiences between a child and their parents. The placement of ‘father’s” before the “Big Books” suggests that the father owned the big books because their is a possessive apostrophe. The physical placement of words shows the interdependent nature of the books in relation to the father within the phrase of the stanza. This shows that the existence of the book and the pages depends on the father. The sequence described in the first line however is not in sequential order, thus not having order can symbolize Li -Young Lee’s state of mind is disorganized without his father. Furthermore there is no punctuation in the passage, and their is no transition between the first…
- 359 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The relationship between father and son seems to be one of tension and distance as conveyed to the readers at first. For instance, the narrator "looks down" at his father digging, as shown in the second stanza, which can either be interpreted in two ways. One way is that the narrator is situated above his father who is in the fields digging, or another way in which the narrator looks down upon his father and sees no value in his occupation. As shown, the narrator's position is above his father because he has an education, which is reinforced from the start: the narrator is a writer, and most likely received more education than his father who is a potato farmer. The mood reinforces the distant relationship between the father and the son. The mood of the poem at first is solemn and grave. This is exemplified in the onomatopoeia; "a clean, rasping sound" In…
- 616 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Li-Young Lee’s poem “A Story” shows the complicated relationship between the father and the son by utilizing the literary devices of point of view and structure. Italicized lines distinguish the diction of who is talking to draw on point of view to indicate the complex relationship. Through changing perspective, Lee employs emotional interests to emphasize the conflicting perspectives that exist between father and son. Lee also adds depth to the shared “love” between the two characters to illuminate the theme of innocence and changing relationships over the course of time.…
- 740 Words
- 3 Pages
Better Essays -
Time has the tendency to impact everyone and everything. In the poem “A Story” Li-Young Lee reveals the intimate yet short lived relationship of the father and the son through the use of dialogue, conflict and point of view to hint at the inevitably of children branching out and possibly surpassing their parents. Emphasized through the differing perspectives of the father and son Lee highlights the innocence of young children and parents and their changing relationship over time.…
- 410 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The first verse of the third stanza - ‘His Polish friends -’ again shows a sense of ownership and belonging by the use of possessive pro noun. It also states a cultural reference and shows how the son feels as if he doesn’t belong. ‘Talking, they reminisced…’ this line reflects how this group of men hold a shared past and highlights the sense of ‘brotherhood’. All of this ‘Did not dull the softness of his blue eyes’, which again signifies the love and admiration the son possesses for his father. Mild and subtle expression is used to symbolise his character through the depiction of his son. Even when…
- 736 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
A man thinking about one specific event in his life and the regret he has always felt about that night, is the poem Apology to My Father. Back when the male, whos point of view the poems from, was a teenage boy, his father had just come back from war deathly wounded. They are sitting by the fireplace listening to a storm, almost falling asleep, the father tells the son to go to bed and as hes leaving the room, the son goes to kiss his father on the forehead, but hesitates. This hurts his father and the son leans down, but only giving a half-hearted kiss. In the morning his father is dead and that is the regret that will follow the son for the rest of his life. On the Birth of a Son however, is about a father fearing fatherhood and if the child will get along with him, be nice and whether he will be good at fatherhood or a failure, but then he sees his son and…
- 846 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In this story, Clay Boy experience lots of conflicts and one of them is when Clay Boy goes fine his father his father in the black church. When he enters the church everybody stares at him. When he starts walking he notices that he doesn’t know anybody in the church until, the pastier sees him and Clay Boy remembers him. When the people stared singing the song he knew the song and he wanted to sing but all he did was look at the kid next to him. When they were done singing they people made a play talking about how Jesus was born and after that Santa clause was giving people oranges and when he got to clay boy he was thinking about his dad that he said that to never take charity from people.…
- 555 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The sixth and final stanza involves the poet realising her very rebellious actions. The little child whimpers upon her father’s arm “for…
- 424 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
The structure of the poem “A Story” is very significant to its meaning. This free- verse poem has neither regular meter nor rhyme scheme. However, the dialogue of the thoughts of the man and of his son is italicized. For example, “Not the same story, Baba. A new one.”(4) This is what the dad imagines his son is saying. The child is tired of the same old stories and expects his daddy to come up with a story on the spot. On the other hand, the father is having thought of the future when his son is “looking for his…
- 488 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
What is Entitlement? Townsend defines entitlement as, “The belief that I am exempt from responsibility and I am owed special treatment. It consists of four main components: 1) I am special 2)…
- 745 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
There is this boy and he is separated from his father and his father is in the demon land. The boy lives in the middle kingdom with his mother and grandmother. the boy's father so he lives in the demon world. the boy always wanted to know about his father but his mother was too busy to answer any of his questions. They own a little farm to grow vegetables, his mother did not like talking about the golden mountain the boy thinks that might be a bad place he says. the boy finally runs into his father, the first time he ever meet his uncle. Classmates was the term which one government official might use for another official. The boy stared at at a man who walked up and father said it is really impolite to stare. Uncle bright star said what are…
- 509 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The anger that the father feels due to his unfortunate circumstances is prevalent throughout the poem and it leads to a strain on the relationship with the speaker as a child. The troubled economy resulted in the father losing his job; the speaker tells us that it was after this occurred that he…
- 1242 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays