A Response to Olson’s Animalism

Better Essays
A Response to Olson’s Animalism
1. Introduction
There is a human organism located exactly where you are located. Eric Olson argues that you are identical to that organism. This view is known as animalism. His “thinking animal” argument takes the following form: (1) There is a human animal where you are located; (2) If there’s a human animal where you are located, it is thinking; (3) The only thing thinking where you are located is you; and (4) So, you are a human animal. One argument, which exhibits parallel reasoning and boasts premises motivated in the exact same way, may be employed to resist Olson’s argument. In this paper I will show that this argument, which I will now call the Guanilo-Style argument, is structurally identical to Olson’s argument, but which yields a conclusion that is implausible. This will render Olson’s argument unsound, as any objections raised to the Guanilo-Style argument must also be raised to Olson’s argument. Before I present the Guanilo-Style argument, I will show why many philosophers reject animalism. Olson grants that there may be reason to reject animalism. Leibniz’s Law can help to show that you are not identical to the animal that Olson proposes you are. Disregarding scientific limitations, the argument runs as follows: (1) You have the property of being able to survive getting a new body; (2) That animal lacks the property of being able to survive getting a new body; (3) If that animal is identical to you, then that animal has every property that you have; (4) So, that animal is not identical to you. This conclusion has obvious implications on Olson’s Thinking Animal Argument, namely that you are not a human animal. However, Olson nevertheless attempts to defend animalism with his Thinking Animal Argument.

2. Defending The Thinking Animal Argument Olson defends the argument that concludes that you are a human animal. Premise (1) of his argument, that there is a human animal located exactly where you

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Animalism

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Animalism an·i·mal·ism (n-m-lzm) n. 1. Enjoyment of vigorous health and physical drives. 2. Indifference to all but the physical appetites. 3. The doctrine that humans are merely animals with no spiritual nature. ani·mal·ist n. ani·mal·istic (-lstk) adj. The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition copyright ©2000 by Houghton Mifflin Company. Updated in 2009. Published by Houghton Mifflin Company. All rights reserved. animalism [ˈænɪməˌlɪzəm] n 1. satisfaction…

    • 675 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Animalism in Mcteague

    • 1499 Words
    • 6 Pages

    McTeague, or Animalism - Unpublished The last decade of the twentieth century in America saw a rise in programs for human's "self betterment." A popular form of betterment is that of the inner animal. Interest in Native American animal mysticism, vision quests, and totem animals have increased dramatically in the past few years. No forms of media have been spared; Calvin Klein's supermodels come on during sitcom commercials to tell viewers they need to be a beast, or to get in touch with their…

    • 1499 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    2) Reverby and Olson’s ideas of the centrality of caring to nursing differed significantly. Throughout Reverby’s text it is implied that nursing is seen as an obligation than a choice. She states, “embedded in the seemingly natural or ordained character of women, it became an important manifestation of women’s expression of love of others, and thus integral to the female sense of self”, (Reverby, 2004, p. 199). Furthermore “nursing relied on the language of duty… [and] built on the obligation…

    • 265 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Animalism Animal Farm

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages

    effects of those intended. It will set an environment where citizens will not be able to thrive due to corruption and dishonesty. Stevenson’s words directly relate to Animal Farm by George Orwell, in which characters live under a system called “Animalism”. This was organized with similar ideas of equal rights,…

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Seven Commandments of Animalism | |Commandments |Violation of the commandments. Provide the quotation and page |Who violated it? |The other animals' reactions. | | | |number. | | | |1. |Whatever goes upon two legs |The Commandment stated that humans are the enemy of all the |Napoleon |When the hens…

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The metaphor of the character turning into a bird resembles the idea of the true self flying away from the body. Because of their sinful actions, the characters are thrown into a perpetual torment of motion. They go from mortals or gods with human abilities and special powers to the restrictions of an animal. They are given animalistic features and lose every sense of their humanity. Ovid leaves them with a special mark to defines their lifestyle and remind them of their mistakes. He also leaves…

    • 119 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “The Many Colors of Hinduism”, Carl Olson first introduced the practitioners of ancient vedic religion. From the division of two antithetical groups (Adityas and Danavas). Both groups aimed for creation, they represent death and life, being and nonbeing, therefore, they all symbolize the immortal life. Due to the division, the myth of Indra and Vrtra is told. Indra is the king of gods who killed Vrtra (a dragon who kept water of the world) by thunderbolt. Olson also introduces the term “Rta”…

    • 325 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Janett Olson was polishing her white, ceramic dinner platter, nearing the act of flipping off the dining room lanterns, when the telephone rang. She lifted the receiver to her ear and heard the blunt voice of Walton Manes establishing himself. “My nephew, Arkin, had a baseball tournament this weekend and came to visit, but is nearing his stay. I heard that you were driving to his hometown of Heathens tomorrow. Would you be so charming, and take him back home,” he stated with an amicable tone. “It…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Animal Farm: Animalism Vs. Marxism Characters, items, and events found in George Orwells book, Animal Farm, can be compared to similar characters, items, and events found in Marxism and the 1917 Russian Revolution. This comparison will be shown by using the symbolism that is in the book with similarities found in the Russian Revolution. Old Major was a prized-boar that belonged to Farmer Jones. The fact that Old Major is himself a boar was to signify that radical change and revolution are…

    • 1645 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Acute responses are like instantaneous responses. The first day you begin a workout routine you might feel pretty winded and sore afterwards, but overtime you can go further and do more without soreness or feeling fatigued quickly because you have adapted to the routine. Some of the acute responses that I had felt were elevated heart rate, blood pressure, and stroke volume. The stroke volume is the amount of blood that is pumped from the ventricle every time your heart beats. Another response…

    • 214 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays