Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

A feminist study on the Separation Scene in Milton's Paradise Lost

Powerful Essays
1250 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
A feminist study on the Separation Scene in Milton's Paradise Lost
Separation Scene of Milton’s Paradise Lost, Book IX: A Feminist Study.

One of the grappling themes of this poem is the theme of Free Will. This concept came up during the 17th century when people started becoming aware of their surroundings. The Parliament was questioning the monarch, Charles I about his expenses, policies and methods of ruling. In fact, he was the first ever ruler to be executed. And Milton, being an effective intellectual participant, found himself right in the centre of these revolutionary changes. There was a genuine attempt to understand the Bible and its teachings. In Milton’s Paradise Lost, the idea of Fall of humankind seems to be meeting with that of Free Will, time and again. Eve’s assertion to work separately is in fact an assertion of this very free will. She believes that working separately will only lead to speeding up of their job of gardening. But this personal awareness is labelled by critics as an act of violation for it contradicts Adam’s wishes. One only asks why Adam’s wishes are so important. Why is Eve’s decision not given the same credibility as that given to Adam’s? Eve was Adam’s “help meet” (help mate).This is a fundamental problem. Does Eve exist only to help Adam? Is Milton trying to say that the phallus is primary? If Eve indeed was created only to help Adam, is not her position being compared to that of animals?

It is assumed that Adam and Eve are already ‘fallen’ in the Separation Scene because the inferior position that Eve holds in the hierarchy i.e. God – Adam – Eve, has already been subverted. A renowned critic, Fredson Bowers says that Adam’s respect for Eve’s liberty, though imitating God’s for his own, is the first step in the fall.
“Adam repudiates his duty and breaks the hierarchical chain of being. He allows Eve as a free agent to seek temptation because he cannot bring himself to enforce authority on her undisturbed passion and beauty...in his role as a protector, Adam had no right to relieve himself from his responsibility to Eve by making her a free agent.” (Fredson Bowers)
Eve’s inferiority, not only in the intellectual realm but in general, is not something that can be ignored. Her classification as a human is overshadowed by her sub classification as a woman. She is the Subject whereas Adam is the Head. She was after all created from Adam’s ribs, on his request to God. She was his to control, not vice versa. And this is exactly what critics like Arnold Stein and C. S. Lewis say when talking about the Separation Scene. They find Eve’s argument as an “aggressive assertion of her independence”. They consider Eve’s pride as a major sin in the larger scheme of events. Some other critics, following the same line of idea say that Adam was the stronger of the two. In allowing Eve to go, he became the weaker. They say that Eve should not have been given the liberty of independent thought and reason. But I have a significant problem with this concept. To term Eve as the inferior and Adam as superior is a sexist formulation of ideas.

The position of Eve reflects the position of women in the 17th century English society. They were not educated and thus intellectually inferior to men. Similar is the situation of Milton’s Eve. She is the ‘embodiment of passion’ whereas Adam is the ‘embodiment of reason’. She has to turn to Adam in order to gain intellectual guidance. In fact, Eve’s knowledge of the enemy, i.e. Satan is through her interaction with Adam whereas he received a warning directly from divine machinery. Milton is seemingly suggesting that a wife is incomplete and insufficient to stand without her husband’s support and that she takes ‘bad decisions’ when she tries to imply her own mind alone.

Now, let us look at some references of Eve’s subordination from the text of Paradise Lost. For this, I will only stick to Book IX but that in no way means that there are no other references. In fact, throughout his poem, Milton has left many such references to pick on. In the Separation Scene, Adam says to Eve, “...for nothing lovelier can be found/ In woman, than to study household good” (232-233). Milton, making Adam his mouthpiece, is categorising the woman’s work as domestic care while theologically deifying the man’s work.
Adam repeatedly emphasises upon Eve’s inferiority while arguing in this particular scene. First, he calls her “Daughter of God and man” (291) which literally means that she was created by god and created out of man. Then, he addresses her as “O woman” (343) further reiterating his supremacy and in turn, her subjection. Adam incessantly argues that Eve must listen to him and not vouch for her independence. After the fall, Adam says that it is all a result of Eve’s “strange desire of wand’ring” (1135-1136).
In line 383, Eve says, “...A foe so proud will first the weaker seek”. Eve herself calls herself the ‘weaker’ of the two. It appears as if by making the woman speak such a thing, Milton is trying to justify his anti feminist stance as the natural way to behave. Before the actual separation happens, Milton brings in a lot of Pagan ideas into the text. Again, one asks as to what these Pagan ideas are doing in an epic which is clearly Christian. He did formulate a feminist Eve who believed in making her own decisions but ended up condemning this very quality in her. He associates her with the much castigated Pagan ideologies. He talks of the two nymphs who are mortals which might be an allusion of what is to happen. By talking about Delia, Pales and Pomona, all Milton does is emphasise on Eve’s sexual vulnerability which she is unaware of.

Stella Revard, in her essay, “Eve and the Doctrine of Responsibility in Paradise Lost”, makes an interesting point when she says that if separation was indeed the event that led to the fall, why do we not consider the separation when Raphael visited the couple on Earth? Eve left Adam and Raphael to talk about all things ‘studious’ and went to tend to her flowers. Revard argues that Satan could have been lurking in the shadows at that point instead of the following day. But the fact that critics place responsibility of the Fall on the separation of the next day indicates towards this need to blame Eve in some way or the other. The essential problem lies in the usage of terms such as ‘allow’ and ‘permission’. Adam had no authority over Eve whatsoever. Rather, words such as ‘plea’ and ‘request’ should be used.

Critics, when asked why the separation is so important, often counter question if Satan would have been able to tempt Eve had Adam been there with her. I personally think this question has no right answer. It is speculative. But even if we were to believe that the separation is the original cause of the Fall, charging Eve with the onus of it all is unfair. Adam was equally responsible and not because he ‘allowed’ Eve to leave but because he failed to express his thoughts and fears properly; not because he failed as the Patriarch but because he failed as an orator.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In order to proof and give example for his view, Erich Fromm gives a very convenient reference, about the birth of human history. According to the Bible, with the act of disobedience to God’s authority, Adam and Eve were forced to leave the Garden of Eden and become a fully human. Fromm states a good example of how disobedience is necessary for independence and growth. By breaking the order, Adam and Eve give a start to the human history and become independent individuals.…

    • 503 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Paradise Lost vs Genesis

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the book of Genesis 3:1-6, the passage teaches the story of how Satan tempts Eve into causing the act that leads to the “fall of mankind”. Of this biblical account, is where John Milton gained inspiration for the idea of is work, Paradise Lost. Milton’s storyline and broad array of imagery portray the tale in a different light than that told in the Bible. While both accounts of “the fall”, are used to convey the same story and outcome, the two versions share some comparative similarities and many contrasting differences.…

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Power is the control over one’s self or another person or thing. In the poem “Adam and Eve” by Tony Hoagland a man and woman strived mentally for power over each other. Instead of having the happy and loving relationship that couples are “thought” to have, at the first sign of disagreement these two instantly worked against each other to have a personal gain of their own. In this poem the speaker, Adam, and the woman, who is assumed to be Eve, struggle for power over one another to make themselves superior to one another. They use their reactions and emotions against each other to steal and regain power.…

    • 808 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In the Bible Genesis 3:16,page 161 in our text book, God is talking to Adam and Eve after the apple tasting debacle and He says, “I will terribly sharpen your birth pangs, in pain shall you bear children. And for your man shall be your longing, and he shall rule over you.” As punishment for the sin, and clearly placing men above women in the hierarchy scale, He punishes Eve harshly. Adam gets in trouble as well but it was “ Because you listened to the voice of your wife and ate from the tree that I commanded you .You shall not eat from it.” This almost gives Adam a pass on the sin of eating the apple but gets Adam in trouble…

    • 1703 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The situation between Eve and Satan in Paradise Lost remains illustrated in today’s society. Milton stresses on the fact that we do not always have to have some higher power to advise our life decisions. Even today, society wants us to create our own independent thought and acts, it is a topic used in everyday life, while the Church still wants us to follow the light of God. Whether we decide to think YOLO or decide to think…

    • 523 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Milton starts off as presenting Adam as a protecting, reasonable and logical man with great authority. God created Adam with free will, so he has to make a choice to obey God’s orders of not eating from The Tree of Knowledge, or to follow Eve’s decision. Throughout the book, Milton drops hints about Adam’s flaws; For example, how Adam does not share the warnings that God and Raphael tell him about The Tree of Knowledge, or how Adam can only think about having sexual relations with Eve instead of working. Men are believed to have logical and reason, but Adam shows the trait passion, which women are believed to have. In Milton’s re-told story of The Fall, Adam is seen to have passion and Eve is seen to have reason and logical, which is complete opposite of belief (Lansbury 2). All of these actions characterized by Adam could be why he had the blame set on him for The Fall of man.…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    While Milton’s retelling of the biblical tale of man’s origin within Paradise Lost is true to the bible, he manages to reinvent it in a slightly different manner – a manner that brings to light new questions about the roles Adam and Eve played in the fall of human kind. Speaking more specifically, his retelling of the fall of man seems to bring up questions about how gender operates within the biblical world and how it may relate to the time Milton comes from. At face value, the portrayal of Eve suggests that she is inferior and subordinate to Adam. There seems to be a stark contrast between Adam and Eve: where Adam is strong, rational, and intelligent, Eve is naïve and narcissistic. These differences between Adam…

    • 1755 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Science, it would seem, is not sexless: he is a man, a father, and infected too” (Woolf, 1938). Feminist Virginia Woolf declares this bold statement to express how science is sexist; gender bias by which women’s interests, insight, or perspective are disvalued and ostracized. Over the decades, there has been an outburst of the feminist writing on the philosophical development in literature and history. A majority of the feminist writings harshly criticize the philosophical traditions, which include topics of epistemology, ethics, and aesthetics, and brings up the expected question of why does the history of philosophy have such an importance impact on feminist philosophers? Countless feminist philosophers have studied the philosophical development throughout the years…

    • 310 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The historical context of Milton’s is important to understand Milton’s work and his portrayal of Eve. In Milton’s time women were regarded with little respect. Women did not “hold official civil or ecclesiastical positions, attend universities, or engage in major professions” though it is apparent that that they wrote and “prophesy” (Danielson 177). Women were to keep their opinions to themselves, but in reality they would often give counsel to their husbands in the private of their home (“The Early Seventeenth Century"). Although, Paradise Lost is less focused on careerism in regards to women, there correlation between Eve and seventeenth century women still exists. Eve’s characterization is much more connected to her relationship with Adam…

    • 257 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Adam and Eve’s reaction toward their sin can be contrasted by Equality 7-2521’s reaction. Adam and Eve break their one and only rule by eating the fruit from the tree of the knowledge of good and evil. “Then the eyes of [Adam and Eve] opened, and they knew that they were naked” (ESV Bible, Genesis 3:7). They made themselves loincloths from sewing fig leaves together and hid themselves from the presence of God among the trees. They were afraid of God, and they were ashamed of themselves. Equality 7-2521 is not ashamed of what he did, nor did he fear anything. Equality7-2521 “only [wishes] to be away, away from the City and from the air that touches upon the air of the city” (76). He runs away to the Uncharted Forest…

    • 611 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are similarities between Equality 7-2521 and Adam. They were both born with a natural curiosity. The curiosity caused them to do something that was explicitly forbidden. This led Equality 7-2521 to rediscover something that was wiped from human memory for a great length of time as stated on page 52: “We, Equality 7-2521, have discovered a new power of nature. And we have discovered it alone, and we alone are to know it.” (Rand 41)He attempted to share his discovery but was rejected and scorned. Adam’s curiosity led him to eat the “forbidden” fruit from the tree from the center of the Garden of Eden. This action caused his banishment from the Garden of Eden. What they both committed was considered by the governing authority to be sins. Equality 7-2521 was forced to run away because he dared to have an independent mind. Adam was forced out of Eden because he did not obey God. Also……

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Perriman, A.C. “What Eve Did, What Women Shouldn’t Do: The Meaning of Auqentew in 1 Timothy 2:12.” TynBul 44.1 (1993): 129-42.…

    • 4887 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Adam and Eve takes place in an apartment describing a scene between a couple presumably named Adam and Eve. Adam and Eve have come home from an intense date and are preparing to make love. The candles are lit as they crawl into bed when Eve “held her milk white hand agitatedly/over the entrance to her body and said No (14-15)”. Adam becomes infuriated at her rejecting him and begins to think about how much power a woman can hold over a man. Adam also begins to think about the animal-like behavior of men wondering if “the fossil be surgically removed/or dissolved, or redesigned/so the man can be a human being, like a woman (42-44)”.…

    • 626 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Perhaps the most well known story of the Holy Bible is that of the creation story. In this story, God creates the earth in six days and rests on the seventh, after creating light, dark, oceans, and animals of all types. When he feels that there should be creatures other than animals, he creates man, in His image. He names this man Adam, and then creates a counterpart for his new creation, Eve. Adam and Eve lived together in harmony with God and all the other animals in the Garden of Eden, a paradise where evil did not exist, and their only rule was to not eat from the tree of Knowledge. However, Adam and Eve, under the temptation of the serpent, showed greed, and wanted to be more like God, so they ate the fruit, in order to become like God. When compared in depth, the protagonist of the creation story, Adam, and the street sweeper, Equality 7-2521, of Ayn Rand’s Anthem are condemned men, whose stories are very similar, save one key difference.…

    • 1337 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The story of Adam and Eve is one of the most culturally important and known stories in the Bible regarding the origin of mankind. It’s generally followed by Judeo-Christians but is also grasped by other religious views, though many tend to overlook minor key details that may alter the whole interpretation. First, God created a man named Adam to primarily tend to the garden he planted in Eden. There were many trees in the garden that happened to contain two special types of trees. God allowed Adam to eat from any tree he wished, except from one specific tree. Then, God created a woman to accompany Adam who automatically became his wife. The woman came across a serpent she claimed to have deceived her. In actuality, the serpent simply told her a fact that is later proven correct with the help of her temptation. After Adam and the woman both consumed fruit from the forbidden tree, they realized that they were naked and tried to hide from God. God came to find that Adam and the woman ate from the forbidden tree because they suddenly were full of knowledge. God punished the serpent, Adam, and the woman for their disobedience. He then banished them not as another punishment but to help them avoid temptation again. Within the controversial context of the story lie theoretical themes that can be analyzed by existentialism and the Post-Freudian psychoanalytic theory of eros, thanatos, and the Oedipal Conflict. The story can be viewed using the Oedipal Conflict as God plays the role of both the mother and father figure while Adam and Eve play the role of the rebellious children. Along with this conflict, the characters of the story demonstrate existentialism qualities and carry out actions that they are either eros or thanatos.…

    • 2969 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays