22 October, 2013
A Critic's Opinion on “Story of an Hour” Julie Moore, author of an article on Kate Chopin's, “Story of an Hour,” believes that Chopin was not a feminist, even though her story gives the reader the impression that women long for freedom, and that they are oppressed. I agree with Moore that Chopin was not a feminist, because Louis Mallard all throughout the, “Story of an Hour,” resists the urge to celebrate her husband's death even though it has given her the freedom to live for herself once again. In the story there are instances where Mrs. Mallard shows excitement and joy when she discovers that she is free once again. I do not believe that this part in the story shows that Chopin is a feminist, but rather a common feeling that both genders would get upon the point of finding out that their husband or wife has died. Julie Moore believes that marriage causes couples to despise being in union, and ultimately end up longing for freedom. Kate Chopin, according to Moore, “Can be viewed as a writer of women's rights although she does not declare herself a feminist by any stretch of the imagination” (Moore). In an article called, “Kate Chopin's “Story of an Hour” and the Roles of Women,” Julie Moore says that, “Kate was neither a feminist nor a suffragist. She was nonetheless a woman who took women extremely seriously. She never doubted women's ability to be strong.” Mrs. Mallard resists the excitement and joy approaching her due to the fact that she is free, when in the story it says, “She was beginning to recognize this thing that was approaching to possess her, and she was striving to beat it back with her will” (Chopin 39). The quotation shows why Moore believes that Chopin was not a feminist. Mrs. Mallard knew that she was free, but did not want to rejoice about it, knowing that she had freedom at the cost of her husband's life. I agree with Moore's opinion that Chopin was not a feminist, otherwise Chopin would have expressed her feminist views through her fictional character Louis Mallard, and instead of resisting the feelings of joy and excitement, Mallard would have let the feelings overtake her. Instead, the narrator says, “She knew that she would weep again when she saw the kind, tender hands folded in death” (Chopin 40). Louis Mallard's husband was a kind, and tender man, allowing readers to see that she was not oppressed, and that she longed for freedom because she had a different understanding of what freedom was. Although in, “Story of an Hour,” Louis Mallard says, “Free, free, free!” (Chopin 39), followed by the narrator saying, “Her pulse beat fast, and the coursing blood warmed and relaxed every inch of her body” (Chopin 39), I do not believe that it is enough to label Kate Chopin a feminist. The suggestion made is that unlimited choices lay ahead of Mrs. Mallard. Also, a sign of reawakening within her is made when it is expressed that her pulse beats fast and blood flows through every inch of her body. Julie Moore comments that, “she herself is coming alive again in the knowledge of possibility” (Moore), which is a feeling that any person would get after breaking free from a commitment, giving me more reason to agree with Moore that Kate Chopin was not a feminist. Chopin, according to Moore, “Saw freedom as much more a matter of spirit, soul, character of living your life within the constraints that the world makes [or] your God offers you, because all of us do live within constraints” (Moore). In the, “Story of an Hour,” it says something very interesting that caught my attention, “There would be no one to live for during those coming years; she would live for herself. There would be no powerful will bending her in that blind persistence with which men and women believe they have a right to impose a private will upon a fellow-creature” (Chopin 40). In this quotation Kate Chopin clearly shows that she is not a feminist, by making the statement that man and woman both impose rules on each other that make them live an uncomfortable life together. Moore says in her article, “Mrs. Mallard and Kate Chopin, far ahead of their time, make a statement about marriage and the relationships between men and women and the nature of marriage itself. Not that Mrs. Mallard did not love her husband but that the institution of marriage itself made women subservient and men too” (Moore). Marriage itself is what makes people desire freedom, according to Moore, because once a person says those sacred marriage vows, that is basically the last time one lives for themselves, and must start living for the other too. Julie Moore believes that Kate Chopin, author of, “Story of an Hour,” is not a feminist even though Chopin, throughout the story, tells of a woman who is experiencing the excitement and joy of newfound freedom. I agree with Moore's belief because throughout the story, Mrs. Mallard resists celebrating the fact that she has been given the opportunity to start her life over again. Although there are instances in the, “Story of an Hour,” where Mrs. Mallard shows excitement and joy after finding out that she is free, and able to live only for herself, I do not believe that these parts of the story are enough to label Chopin a feminist. I believe that both genders would get ideas and feelings, such as the kind that Louis Mallard had, after finding out that they are no longer part of a long term commitment. Moore has the belief that marriage itself makes women and men subservient, suggesting that this is the reason Chopin writes about freedom, and not because she is a feminist. I agree with Moore's belief about marriage and the effects that it has on both men and women, for after a certain period of time, imposing rules on each other make one despise unity and desire freedom. Therefore I agree with Moore's belief that Kate Chopin was neither a feminist nor a suffragist, but nonetheless a woman who took women seriously, such as in the case of Louis Mallard in, “Story of an Hour.”
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
It aided feminists in their struggle for gender equality and it was a controversial and criticized piece of literature because of it. What makes the novel so important is how Kate Chopin portrays the situations in the story. The action, conflict, and excitement are all psychological. It is amazing that Chopin could make nothing but a woman’s thoughts so meaningful. Edna’s goals, desires, and thoughts romanticize the goals of the early feminist movements. The way in which Chopin expresses significant psychological events is incredible and effective in portraying female struggle for independence and equality in the…
- 1273 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Throughout history, women have been oppressed because they did not have the same rights as men. Thus, they have suffered unfair treatment such as not being able to vote, having their voices heard in the political sphere because of their gender and so on. Therefore, feminist criticism, which focuses on the women’s perspective, gradually formed and became quickly integrated into the literary works such as Kate Chopin’s short stories, “The Story of an Hour” and “Desiree’s Baby”. Kate Chopin is an American author who advocated that women and men both should have right of equality and freedom. In her short story, “The Story of an Hour”, Kate Chopin describes a young wife who has heart disease which is why her sister and…
- 1328 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Millions of people were “focusing on the changing position of women at the turn of the century” (“Awakening” 1). The Women’s Movement was a national movement by women for women. They fought for equality – legally, politically, and socially. Kate Chopin was alive for the first and second waves of this monumental feminist movement. By the time Chopin began writing in the 1890s, the second wave of feminism had already begun. Women had made great strides. The National Organization for Women (NOW) was born in 1966. This group fought for maternity leave rights, tax deductions for child-care expenses, equal job-training opportunities for poor women, etcetera (Burkett 1). In a relatively short time period, “women gained access to jobs in every corner of the U.S. economy…divorce laws were liberalized…women’s studies programs were created in colleges and universities” (Burkett 2). Unfortunately, women were still expected to complete the traditional “housewife tasks”: cleaning, cooking, and taking care of the children (Henry 168-69). Needless to say, society’s focus was turned to the political and social progression of women. This is why Chopin was concerned with “the fixed idea of women’s roles. She and other women were beginning to set down the roots of modern feminism” (Davis…
- 1460 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Kathleen M. Streater is author of the article “Adele Ratignolle: Kate Chopin’s Feminist at Home in The Awakening” which was published in the peer reviewed journal, The Midwest Quarterly. After doing an extensive search of Streater’s background, it does not appear she has written any other articles. Although not an expert on the subject of Chopin, Streater makes a unique and convincing argument in her article. She uses expert quotes to bolster her position that “to focus solely on Edna’s radical feminism is to limit Chopin’s exploration of feminism itself” (409). This argument is unique, as the author describes, because many critics dismiss Adele all together as a feminist. Chopin’s depiction of Adele as a “mother-woman” muddies the water because to “become a wife and mother is, on some level, to capitulate one’s self to patriarchal systems” (406).…
- 821 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Elizabeth Fox-Genovese, Emory University historian and women 's studies scholar was once interviewed on a documentary about Kate Chopin, the author of The Awakening (Fox, 2007, p. 27). She described Chopin as, " a woman who took women extremely seriously. She never doubted women 's ability to be strong. She came from a long line of strong women whom she loved and respected," (E. Fox-Genovese, personal communication, June 23, 1999). Although she was influenced by the womanizing author Guy de Maupassant, Chopin 's most recognized novel, The Awakening, leaks feminism on every page (E. Fox-Genovese). Throughout The Awakening, Kate Chopin develops her heroine, Edna Pontellier, as the "ultimate feminist".…
- 1258 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Kate Chopin is an American feminist fiction writer and a woman ahead of the time. Similar to the female characters in her stories, Chopin was an independent woman. She would often smoke cigarettes or walk in the streets unaccompanied; these practices were considered unusual for a nineteenth-century woman to do. “The Story of an Hour” is one of Chopin 's feministic short stories that focus on women and their views on marriage. It was published in 1894 and shows self-assertion when the protagonist, Louise Mallard, rejoices after hearing of her husband 's death. Kate Chopin, the author of “The Story of an Hour” uses symbols to expose her point about the control of women in a male-dominated society.…
- 1334 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
The omniscient narrator of “Story of an Hour” by Kate Chopin immediately informs the reader that the main character, Mrs. Mallard, suffers from heart trouble thus revealing to her the tragic news of her husband has to be done with great care. Mrs. Mallard does not “hear the story as many women have heard the same, with a paralyzed inability to accept its significance” but instead she wails with “wild abandonment” and steals away to be alone in her room, shunning her sister and slumping into one of her armchairs in a state of shock. Alone, she then begins to realize that she is now independent and suddenly fills up with joy. Chopin uses characterization, symbols, and setting to inspire women to seek independence and hint revolting against gender conformity or against social norms that limit women's possibilities in life.…
- 534 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
“Love and passion, marriage and independence, freedom and restraint.” These are the themes that are represented and worked with throughout Kate Chopin’s works. Kate Chopin, who was born on February 8, 1851, in St. Louis, was an American acclaimed writer of short stories and novels. She was also a poet, essayist, and a memoirist. Chopin grew up around many women; intellectual women that is. Chopin said herself that she was neither a feminist nor a suffragist; she was simply a woman who took other women intensely seriously. Chopin believed women had the ability to be strong, individual, and free-spirited. She herself reached out, in hopes for freedom, and the freedom to explore and express ideas. (Fox-Genovese). Today, Chopin is best known in the literary world as author of the novel, The Awakening. The Awakening was highly controversial in its time due to the way it dealt with “the condition of the nineteenth century woman in marriage”. It is now seen and recognized as an overtly feminist text. (Le Marquand). Other of Chopin’s feminist texts include; Athenaise, A Pair of Silk Stockings, and The Story of an Hour. Although Chopin claimed that she herself was not a feminist, she would drink, smoke, and be her own woman (which were considered feminist acts of her time). “Kate’s writings provided her with the means to live how she wanted- both mentally and physically- rather than play the role society expected of her” (Deter). The heroine in The Awakening, Edna, comes to find that she is “dissatisfied with her marriage and the limited, conservative lifestyle that it allows”. Edna wanted change, change the way women were seen and thought of. “She wanted something to happen- something, anything: she did not know what” (Chopin). As the novel develops, Edna becomes a desperately independent woman, who lives disconnected from her husband and children. From there, the…
- 2058 Words
- 9 Pages
Good Essays -
The desire of freedom definitely comes with an immense price. In “The Story of an Hour,” Kate Chopin describes her main character, Louise Mallard, as a freedom seeking housewife, trapped in an unwanted marriage with her husband Brently Mallard. She soon after gets granted the gift of freedom when she finds out her husband had been in a train accident, which ironically Kate Chopin’s father died of the same tragic death. With Kate Chopin’s unique writing style, she has been a major influence in literature for decades. According to Feminist Writers, “she opened her 19th-century female readers’ eyes to a familiar world [they] had never know.” Authors S. Selina Jamil and Daniel P. Deneau both analyzed the story and gave their opinions on how the emotions of Louise affected internally and externally. With two different viewpoints on the short story, both authors provide valid points when scrutinizing the direct variation when it came to Louise’s motives. When reading “The Story of an Hour,” one is drawn into the troubling tale of Louise Ballard and how she reacts to her trying times as a thought to be widow. The ending throws the reader for a loop and is completely unexpected, but that’s Kate Chopin’s writing style. The story is unpredictable, enjoyable, and controversial, and definitely leaves the reader satisfied.…
- 1342 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Kate Chopin’s,”The Story of an Hour,” is an ironic and symbolic story as it portrays an innuendo of repression through the example married women. Chopin’s short story begins with Mrs. Mallard becoming lurid as she hears of her husband's death. Consequently, Mrs. Mallard underwent changes from depressed to an elated state of emotion. Chopin displayed Mrs. Mallards’ grievances and attitude towards freedom through her diction. Just as Mrs. Mallard perceived that she gained her freedom, news was delivered to her stating Brently Mallard was alive. Without hesitation Mrs. Mallard died not only because her freedom was gone, but because she felt guilty when she happily reflected upon her husband's death. Presumably, the cause of Mrs. Mallard's death was heart disease, thus making Chopin’s…
- 427 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In “The Story of an Hour,” by Kate Chopin, Louise Mallard is a dynamic character who went from a state of grieving to being overjoyed by her new freedom. When she first hears of her husband’s death, she is overwhelmed with misery. After reflecting on what happened, she looked outside and realized the new life ahead of her. Kate Chopin relates what she observes in simple prose, but when her emotions are described, the words are vibrant and powerful. This suggests that Louis has a deep inner-life that is not connected to the outside world of her husband or friends. This can be seen Page 652 in the line when Kate says,”…she went away to her room alone.” The fact that she cloisters herself in her room to discover her feelings is important. The world outside of her own bedroom is only minimally described, but the world inside of her mind is lively and well described by the narrator.…
- 457 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
“The Story of an Hour,” by Kate Chopin displays the internal battle of Mrs. Mallard and her struggle with independence. Due to unforeseen circumstances, Mrs. Mallard’s negative outlook on her life and marriage suddenly changed into a confident and independent glimpse of the future. What was initially a negative outlook on matrimony, quickly developed into a confident and independent demeanor. The audience is vividly exposed to Mrs. Mallards change in identity regarding her role as a woman, and her optimism. The reader experiences a rapid transformation of wife to woman through Chopin’s creative use of irony and symbolism, alongside a theme of co-dependency and feminism.…
- 1131 Words
- 5 Pages
Powerful Essays -
“It is the wife’s responsibility to provide for her husband, and to maintain a happy home; the single spot of rest which a man has upon this earth for the cultivation of his noblest sensibilities” (Doc. 26, “Woman’s Rights and Men’s Wrongs”). Women are meant to uphold a certain expectation that has been held over them for centuries. But in the nineteenth century things for women began to change. While many women fulfilled their "responsibilities", a large number of women responded to this attempt to define and limit their roles with literature and work in the feminist movement. There were many feminist writers during this time as well, such as Charlotte Perkins Gilman and Kate Chopin (who began writing at the beginning of the fight for women’s rights, but did not exactly declare herself a feminist). Most of this change came about because of the actions women took upon themselves and their desire to break out of the limits imposed on their sex, because of the specific roles women are expected to pursue. They have been unjustly held back from achieving full equality for much of the human history. Chopin was neither an activist nor an advocate for the roles of women. She was nonetheless a woman who took women extremely seriously. She never doubted women 's ability to be strong because she came from a long line of strong women whom she loved and respected; her great-grandmother, grandmother, and mother affiliation. She had a lack of interest in feminism, she had a different understanding of freedom for women. “She saw freedom as much more a matter of spirit, soul, character of living your life within the constraints that the world makes [or] your God offers you, because all of us do live within constraints. There 's no indication that for example she regretted her marriage, or regretted being a mother" (PBS). Whereas Gilman is a straightforward activist. Even though during this period of life people felt that, “the ideal woman…
- 1873 Words
- 6 Pages
Best Essays -
After I read the short story "Story of an hour" by Kate Chopin I was surprised about marriages from back in time, and how women barely had any rights. The story expresses a woman's hurt, and pain towards the supposed death of her husband. The news takes her by surprise, and she becomes more depressed with her life. Kate Chopin uses profound language to depict her pain and sorrow.…
- 496 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Altogether, Chopin's uses symbols, such as 'the open window', metaphors, like 'the elixir of life', and verbal irony, to reveal the negative influence of the social expectations of women in 18th and 19th Century. Though social 'norms' are different today, women are still seen a 'certain' way. Even today, in the 21st Century, women are often seen as subordinate to their male counterparts. The feminist movement has made major progress in correcting these view, but there are still steps that need to be made. In her time, Kate Chopin was an innovative author, giving 'The Story of an Hour' a feminist twist, to raise awareness for women and leave a lasting effect on the feminist movement for years to…
- 120 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays