BEHAVIORTHERAPY28, 187-210, 1997
A Cost-Effectiveness Analysis of Cognitive Behavior Therapy and Fluoxetine (Prozac) in the Treatment of Depression DAVID O. ANTONUCCIO
University of Nevada School of Medicine and Reno V.A. Medical Center (116B2) MICHAEL THOMAS
University of Nevada Dept. of Accounting and CIS
WILLIAM G. DANTON
University of Nevada School of Medicine and Reno EA. Medical Center/(116B2) Depression affects at least 11 million Americans per year and costs the U.S. economy an estimated 44 billion dollars annually. Comprehensive review of the existing scientific evidence suggests that psychotherapy, particularly cognitive behavior therapy (CBT), is at least as effective as medication in the treatment of depression, even if severe (Antonuccio, Danton, & DeNelsky, 1995). These conclusions hold for both vegetative and social adjustment symptoms, especially when patient-rated measures are used and long-term follow-up is considered. In addition, several well-controlled studies with long-term follow-up (Evans et al., 1992; Shea et al., 1992; Simons, Murphy, Levine, & Wetzel, 1986) suggest that CBT may be more effective than drug treatment at preventing relapse. The relative effectiveness of psychotherapy for depression, particularly CBT, has been reinforced by meta-analyses reported in both psychiatry (Hollon, Shelton, & Loosen, 1991; Wexler & Cicchetti, 1992) and psychology journals (Dobson, 1989; Robinson, Berman, & Neimeyer, 1990; Steinbrueck, Maxwell, & Howard, 1983). In the era of managed care, it fs not enough to be effective; treatments must be cost-effective. This paper considers the outcome studies as the basis for a cost-effectiveness comparison of drugs and psychotherapy in the treatment of unipolar depression. The analysis shows that over a 2-year period, fluoxetine alone may result in 33% higher expected costs than individual CBT treatment and the combination treatment may result in 23% higher costs than CBT alone. Supplemental analysis shows that group CBT may only result in a 2% ($596) cost savings as compared to individual treatment. This paper is based in part on a paper presented at the 1996 American Association of Applied and Preventive Psychology National Conference on Prescription Privileges for Psychologists, Reno, Nevada. Address correspondence to David O. Antonuccio, VA Medical Center (116B2), 1000 Locust St., Reno, NV 89520. 187 00o5-7894/97/0187-021051.00/0 Copyright 1997by Associationfor Advancementof BehaviorTherapy All rightsof reproduction in any form reserved.
A N T O N U C C I O ET AL.
The point prevalence of unipolar depression is estimated to be between 3% and 13%, with 20% to 50% of the adult population having a prior history, and as much as 20% experiencing at least some depressive symptoms at any given time (Amenson & Lewinsohn, 1981; Kessler et al., 1994; Oliver & Simmons, 1985). Women are consistently found to have rates of depression twice as high as men. In 1990, at least I1 million Americans experienced an episode of depression, costing the U.S. economy an estimated $44 billion in increased accident rates, increased substance abuse, increased medical hospitalization, and increased somatic illnesses and outpatient medical utilization (Greenberg, Stiglin, Finkelstein, & Berndt, 1993). Antidepressant drug treatment (Morris & Beck, 1974) and cognitive behavior therapy (CBT; Antonuccio, Ward, & Tearnan, 1989) are empirically based treatments for depression that have established clinical efficacy (Antonuccio, Danton, & DeNelsky, 1995). In the era of managed care and limited resources, depression treatments must demonstrate their cost-effectiveness as well as their clinical effectiveness. The current paper addresses the relative clinical effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of drugs and CBT in the treatment of unipolar depression. The comparative outcome literature is briefly reviewed. A costeffectiveness model, previously generated from this outcome...
References: Amenson, C. S., & Lewinsohn, P. M. (1981). An investigation into the observed sex difference in prevalence of unipolar depression. Journal of Abnormal Psychology, 90, 1-13. Anderson, I. M., & Tomenson, B. M. (t995). Treatment discontinuation with selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors compared with tricyclic antidepressants: A meta-analysis. British Medical Journal, 310, 1433-1438. Antonuccio, D. O., Akins, W. T., Chatham, E M., Monagin, J. A., Tearnan, B. H., & Ziegler, B. L. (1984). An exploratory study: The psychoeducational group treatment of drugrefractory unipolar depression. Journal of Behavior Therapy and Experimental Psychiatry, 15, 309-313. Antonuccio, D. O., Danton, W. G., & DeNelsky, G. Y. (1995). Psychotherapy versus medication for depression: Challenging the conventional wisdom with data. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 26, 574-585. Antonuccio, D. O., Thomas, M., & Danton, W. G. (in press). A cost-effectiveness model: Is pharmacotherapy really less expensive than psychotherapy for depression? In S. Hayes & E. Heiby (Eds.), Prescription privileges for psychologists: A critical analysis. Reno, NV: Context Press. Antonuccio, D. O., Ward, C. H., & Tearnan, B. H. (1989). The behavioral treatment ofunipolar depression in adult outpatients. In M. Hersen, R. M. Eisler, & E M. Miller (Eds.), Progress in behavior modification (pp. 152-191). Newbury Park, CA: Sage. Beck, A. T., Hollon, S. D., Young, J. E., Bedrosian, R. C., & Budenz, D. (1985). Treatment of depression with cognitive therapy and amitriptyline. Archives of General Psychiatry, 42, 142-148. Beck, A. T., Rush, A. J., Shaw, B. E, & Emery, G. (1979). Cognitive therapy of depression. New York: Guilford. Beck, A. T., & Young, J. E. (1985). Depression. In D. H. Barlow (Ed.), Clinical handbook of psychological disorders (pp. 206-244). New York: Guilford. Blackburn, I. M., Bishop, S., Glen, A. I. M., WhaUey, L. J., & Christie, J. E. (1981). The efficacy of cognitive therapy in depression: A treatment trial using cognitive therapy and pharmacotherapy, each alone and in combination. British Journal of Psychiatry, 139, 181-189. Blackburn, I. M., Eunson, K. M., & Bishop, S. (1986). A two-year naturalistic follow-up of depressed patients treated with cognitive therapy, pharmacotherapy, and a combination of both. Journal of Affective Disorders, 10, 67-75. Bowers, W. A. (1990). Treatment of depressed in-patients: Cognitive therapy plus medication, relaxation plus medication, and medication alone. British Journal of Psychiatry, 156, 73-78. Brown, R. A., & Lewinsohn, P. M. (1984). A psychoeducational approach to the treatment of depression: Comparison of group, individual, and minimal contact procedures. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 52, 774-783. Brugha, T. S., Bebbington, E E., MacCarthy, B., Sturt, E., & Wykes, T. (1992). Antidepressants may not assist recovery in practice: A naturalistic prospective survey. Acta Psychiatric Scandanavia, 86, 5-11. Conte, H. R., Plutchik, R., Wild, K. V., & Karasu, T. B. (1986). Combined psychotherapy and pharmacotherapy for depression: A systematic analysis of the evidence. Archives of General Psychiatry, 43, 471-479. Covi, L., & Lipman, R. S. (1987). Cognitive behavioral group psychotherapy combined with imipramine in major depression. Psychopharmacology Bulletin, 23, 173-176. Dobson, K. S. (1989). A meta-analysis of the efficacy of cognitive therapy for depression. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 57, 414-419.
ANTONUCCIO ET AL.
Dunn, R. J. (1979). Cognitive modification with depression-prone psychiatric patients. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 3, 307-317. Elkin, I., Shea, T., Watkins, J. T., Imber, S. D., Sotsky, S. M., Collins, J. F., Glass, D. R., Pilkonis, E A., Leber, W. R., Docherty, J. E, Fiester, S, J., & Parloff, M. B. (1989). National Institute of Mental Health Treatment of Depression Collaborative Research Program: General effectiveness of treatments. Archives of General Psychiatry, 46, 971-982. Evans, M. D., Hollon, S. D., DeRubeis, R. J., Piasecki, J. M., Grove, W. M., Garvey, M. J., & Tuason, V. B. (1992). Differential relapse following cognitive therapy and pharmacotherapy for depression. Archives of General Psychiatry, 49, 802-808. Fava, G. A., Grandi, S., Zielezny, M., Rafanelli, C., & Canestrari, R. (1996). Four-year outcome for cognitive behavioral treatment of residual symptoms in major depression. American Journal of Psychiatry, 153, 945-947. Frank, E., Kupfer, D. J., Perel, J. M., Cornes, C., Jarrett, D. B., Mallinger, A. G., Thase, M. E., McEachran, A. B., & Grochocinski, V. J. (1990). Three-year outcomes for maintenance therapies in recurrent depression. Archives of General Psychiatry, 47, 10931099. Greenberg, R. E, Bornstein, R. E, Greenberg, M. D., & Fisher, S. (1992a). As for the kings: A reply with regard to depression subtypes and antidepressant response. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 60, 675-677. Greenberg, R. E, Bornstein, R. E, Greenberg, M. D., & Fisher, S. (1992b). A meta-analysis of antidepressant outcome under "blinder" conditions. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 60, 664-669. Greenberg, R. P., Bornstein, R. E, Zboroswski, M. J., Fisher, S., & Greenberg, M. D. (1994). A meta-analysis of fluoxetine outcome in the treatment of depression. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 182, 547-551. Greenberg, R. R, & Fisher, S. (1989), Examining antidepressant effectiveness: Findings, ambiguities, and some vexing puzzles. In S. Fisher & R, E Greenberg (Eds.), The limits of biological treatments for psychological disorders: Comparisons with psychotherapy and placebo (pp. 1-38). Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum. Greenberg, P. E., Stiglin, L. E., Finkelstein, S. N., & Berndt, E. R. (1993). The economic burden of depression in 1990. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, 54, 405-418. Hersen, M., Bellack, A. S., Himmelhoch, J. M., & Thase, M. E. (1984). Effects of social skill training, amitriptyline, and psychotherapy in unipolar depressed women. Behavior Therapy, 15, 21-40. Hollon, S. D., DeRubeis, R. J., Evans, M. D., Wiemer, M. D., Garvey, M. J., Grove, W. M., & Tuason, V. B. (1992). Cognitive therapy and pharmacotherapy for depression: Singly and in combination. Archives of General Psychiatry, 49, 774-781. Hollon, S. D., Shelton, R. C., & Loosen, E T. (1991). Cognitive therapy and pharmacotherapy for depression. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 59, 88-99. Jamison, C., & Scogin, E (1995). The outcome of cognitive bibliotherapy with depressed adults. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 63, 644-650. Kapur, S., Mieczkowski, T., & Mann, J. J. (1992). Antidepressant medication and the relative risk of suicide attempt and suicide. Journal of the American Medical Association, 268, 344l -3445. Kathol, R. G., & Henn, E A. (1982). Tricyclies: The most common agent used in potentially lethal overdoses. Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 171,250-252. Kessler, R. C., McGonagle, K. A., Zhao, S., Nelson, C. B., Hughes, M., Eshleman, S., Wittchen, H., & Kendler, K. S. (1994). Lifetime and 12-month prevalence of DSM-III-R psychiatric disorders in the United States, Archives of General Psychiatry, 51, 8-19. Kovacs, M., Rush, A. J., Beck, A. T., & Hollon, S. D. (1981). Depressed outpatients treated with cognitive therapy or pharmacotherapy: A one-year follow-up. Archives of General Psychiatry, 38, 33-39.
Kramer, R (1993). Listening to Prozac. New York: Viking. Kupfer, D. J., Frank, E., Perel, J. M., Cornes, C., Mallinger, A. G., Thase, M. E., McEachran, A. B., & Grochocinski, V. J. (1992). Five-year outcome for maintenance therapies in recurrent depression. Archives of General Psychiatry, 49, 769-773. Lenhoff, M. (t994). Potential complications of fluoxetine. VA Practitioner, H(3), 33-41. McLean, E D., & Hakstian, A. R. (1979). Clinical depression: Comparative efficacy of outpatient treatments. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 47, 818-836. McLean, R D., & Hakstian, A. R. (1990). Relative endurance of unipolar depression treatment effects: Longitudinal follow-up. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 58, 482-488. McLean, R D., & Taylor, S. (1992). Severity of unipolar depression and choice of treatment. Behavior Research and Therapy, 30, 443-451. Miller, R. C., & Berman, J. S. (1983). The efficacy of cognitive behavior therapies: A quantitative review of the research evidence. Psychological Bulletin, 94(l), 39-53. Miller, I. W., Norman, W. H., Keitner, G. I., Bishop, S. B., & Dow, M. G. (1989). Cognitivebehavioral treatment of depressed inpatients. Behavior Therapy, 20, 25-47. Morris, J. B., & Beck, A. T. (1974). The efficacy of antidepressant drugs: A review of research (1958 to 1972). Archives of General Psychiatry, 30, 66%674. Murphy, G. E., Simons, A. D., Wetzel, R. D., & Lustman, P. J. (1984). Cognitive therapy and pharmacotherapy: Singly and together in the treatment of depression. Archives of General Psychiatry, 41, 33-41. Narrow, W. E., Regier, D. A., Rae, D. S., Manderscheid, R. W., & Locke, B. Z. (1993). Use of services by persons with mental and addictive disorders: Findings from the National Institute of Mental Health Epidemiological Catchment Area Program. Archives of General Psychiatry, 50, 95-107. Nemeroff, C. B., DeVane, C. L., & Pollock, B. G. (1996). Newer antidepressants and the cytochrome P450 system. American Journal of Psychiatry, 153(3), 311-320. Oliver, J. M., & Simmons, M. E. (1985). Affective disorders and depression as measured by the diagnostic interview schedule and the Beck Depression Inventory in an unselected adult population. Journal of Clinical Psychology, 41, 469-477. Olfson, M. D., & Klerman, G. L. (1993). Trends in the prescription of antidepressants by officebased psychiatrists. American Journal of Psychiatry, 150(4), 571-577. Pastuszak, A., Schick-Boschetto, B., Zuber, C., Feldcamp, M., Pinelli, M., Sihn, S., Donnenfeld, A., McCormack, M., Leen-Mitchell, M., Woodland, C., Gardner, A., Horn, M., & Koren, G. (1993). Pregnancy outcome following first-trimester exposure to fluoxetine (Prozac). Journal of the American Medical Association, 269, 2246-2248. Paykel, E. S., Dimascio, A., Haskell, D., & Prusoff, B. A. (1975). Effects of maintenance amitriptyline and psychotherapy on symptoms of depression. Psychological Medicine, 5, 67-77. Protos, J. (1995, December). Jagged little pills: The financial side effects of Prozac can be unnerving. Smart Money, 83. Reynolds, C. E, Frank, E., Perel, J. M., Imber, S. D., Cornes, C., Morycz, R. K., Mazumdar, S., Miller, M. D., Pollock, B. G., Rifai, A. H., Stack, J. A., George, C. J., Houck, P. R., & Kupfer, D. J. (1992). Combined pharmacotherapy and psychotherapy in the acute and continuation treatment of elderly patients with recurrent major depression: A preliminary report. American Journal of Psychiatry, 149(12), 1687-1692. Robinson, 'L. A., Berman, J. S., & Neimeyer, R. A. (1990). Psychotherapy for the treatment of depression: A comprehensive review of controlled outcome research. Psychological Bulletin, 108, 30-49. Roth, D., Bielski, R., Jones, M., Parker, W., & Osborn, G. (1982). A comparison of selfcontrol therapy and combined self-control therapy and antidepressant medication in the treatment of depression. Behavior Therapy, 13, 133-144.
ANTONUCCIO ET AL.
Rush, A. J., Beck, A. T., Kovacs, M., & Hollon, S. D. (1977). Comparative efficacy of cognitive therapy and pharmacotherapy in the treatment of depressed outpatients. Cognitive Therapy and Research, 1, 17-37. Rush, J., Beck, A. T., Kovacs, M., Weissenburger, J., & Hollon, S. D. (1982). Comparison of the effects of cognitive therapy and pharmacotherapy on hopelessness and self-concept. American Journal of Psychiatry, 139(7), 862-866. Rush, A. J., Hollon, S. D., Beck, A. T., & Kovacs, M. (1978). Depression: Must psychotherapy fail for cognitive therapy to succeed? Cognitive Therapy and Research, 2, 199-206. Settle, E. C. (1992). Antidepressant side effects: Issues and options. Journal of Clinical Psychiatry Monograph, 10, 48-61. Shea, M. T., Elkin, I., Imber, S. D., Sotsky, S. M., Watkins, J. T., Collins, J. E, Pilkonis, P. A., Beckham, E., Glass, D. R., Dolan, R. T., & Parloff, M. B. (1992). Course of depressive symptoms over follow-up: Findings from the National Institute of Mental Health treatment of depression collaborative research program. Archives of General Psychiatry, 49, 782-787. Simon, G. E., VonKorff, M., & Barlow, W. (1995). Health care costs of primary patients with recognized depression. Archives of General Psychiatry, 52, 850-856. Simons, A. D., Murphy, G. E., Levine, J. L., & Wetzel, R. D. (1986). Cognitive therapy and pharmacotherapy for depression: Sustained improvement over one year. Archives of General Psychiatry, 43, 43-48. Song, E, Freemantle, N., Sheldon, T. A., House, A., Watson, P., Long, A., & Mason, J. (1993). Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors: Meta-analysis of efficacy and acceptability. British Medical Journal, 306, 683-687. Steinbrueck, S. M., Maxwell, S. E., & Howard, G. S. (1983). A meta-analysis of psychotherapy and drug therapy in the treatment of unipolar depression with adults. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 51, 856-863. Stravynski, A., Verreault, R., Gaudette, G., Langlois, R., Gagnier, & Larose, R. (1994). The treatment of depression with group behavioral-cognitive therapy and imipramine. Canadian Journal of Psychiatry, 39, 387-390. Teasdale, J. D., Fennell, M. J. V., Hibbert, G. A., & Amies, P. L. (1984). Cognitive therapy for major depressive disorder in primary care. British Journal of Psychiatry, 144,400-406. Wexler, B. E., & Cicchetti, D. V. (1992). The outpatient treatment of depression: Implications of outcome research for clinical practice. The Journal of Nervous and Mental Disease, 180, 277-286. Wexler, B.E., & Nelson, J. C. (1993). The treatment of major depressive disorders. International Journal of Mental Health, 22, 7-41, Wilson, P. H. (1982). Combined pharmacological and behavioural treatment of depression. Behaviour Research and Therapy, 20, 173-184. Yates, B. (1995). Cost-effectiveness analysis, cost-benefit analysis, and beyond. Evolving models for the scientist-manager-practitioner. Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice, 2, 385-398. Zimmerman, M., & Spitzer, R. L. (1989). Melancholia: From DSM-Ill to DSM-III-R. American Journal of Psychiatry, 146, 20-28. RECEIVED: November 1, 1996 ACCEVrED: March 12, 1997
Please join StudyMode to read the full document