Preview

Women: Does Stereotype Threat Affect Their Ability?

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
680 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Women: Does Stereotype Threat Affect Their Ability?
Women: Does Stereotype Threat Affect Their Ability?
Today, we live in a world where people of many races, genders, cultures, and backgrounds face typical generalizations made by everyday people called stereotypes. These stereotypes may also change the way people behave simply because the stereotype has a negative effect on their ability to perform a particular task. When people have fear of conforming to a particular stereotype that results in inadequate performance, they face what is known as stereotype threat. One common stereotype is of women performing worse than men on math tests. Now, is this because they have less capability in math or simply because the stereotype is stressed too much? An article of an experiment done by Steven Spencer, Claude Steele, and Diane Quinn called “Stereotype Threat and Women’s Math Performance” in 1998 answers this question by conducting three related studies to see how stereotype threat effected women’s math performance. Study one was done to verify the stereotype that states women underperform on difficult math test than men, but perform equally as men on easy math test. The researchers used 28 men and 28 women that had already completed at least one semester of calculus with a grade of a “B” or higher. After obtaining the results, the researchers concluded that this stereotype was true with the participants in the research. Women did perform worse than men on the difficult test but they did just the same as men on the easier math test. However, the researchers question was what caused women to underperform on difficult test? They believed that women experienced stereotype threat, which affected their ability on score well on difficult test. Therefore, the researchers conducted another study to see how stereotype threat affected women on their test results. The study was similar to study one, containing 30 women and 24 men that were selected with the same criteria at the University of Michigan. This time however,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    To experience stereotype threat, one needs to accept that the stereotype about oneself is true. False…

    • 519 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the threat condition participants were instructed they would be taking a math test that had been shown to produce gender differences; in the no threat conditions, participants were also told they were taking a math test but that the test had been shown not to produce gender differences. This explicit stereotype threat manipulation has been shown to produce performance effects in previous research (e. g. , Brown & Pinel, (2003), Jamieson & Harkins, (2007)). No specific mention was made as to whether men outperformed women or vice versa, only that gender differences did or did not exist on the task. Participants were expected to infer that women would perform more poorly than men based on the societal stereotype that men are superior to women in mathematical ability. Each participant responded to a questionnaire upon completion of the math test. 2 questions allowed us to evaluate the effectiveness of the stereotype threat manipulation: “To what extent are there gender differences in performance on this task?” (1 = No Gender Differences, 11 = Gender Differences) and “Who do you believe performs better on this task?” (1 = Males Perform Better, 6 = Males and Females Perform The Same, 11 = Females Perform Better). Participants were also asked to rate how difficult the test was, how interesting the task was, how anxious they felt about their performance, and how much effort they put into the task, all on…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Studies have shown that stimulating positive stereotypes leads to improved skills and boosted academic performance. One particular study found stereotypes can boost or hurt performance based on the stereotype activated. The study focused on triggering different stereotypes in Asian American women and seeing how the different stereotypes affected performance. Stereotypical qualities of Asian American include strong quantitative attributes and poor verbal skills. When the women’s Asian identity was asserted, the women scored higher on a math test (Shih 117). Ultimately, not all stereotypes affect education negatively. Positive stereotypes enhance academic performance simply based upon the stereotypical group a student becomes involved in. Throughout Kory Williamson’s nine years of teaching high school students, Williamson has seen students belonging to positive educational stereotypes have boosted academic performance. Students feel pushed by the clique to achieve more academically. The clique members are expected to place an emphasis on education. As a result, clique members have boosted academic performance (Williamson). On one hand, positive stereotypes clearly lead to improved skills and advanced academic performance. But on the other hand, negative stereotypes impact a student’s education and test scores. The effects of negative stereotypes cannot be overlooked. Many students…

    • 1066 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Best Essays

    Given the rapidly changing demographics of today’s classrooms combined with the high-stakes testing environment created by the passage of No Child Left Behind, it is important to understand potential explanations for the persistence of achievement gaps. Explanations for the achievement gap have included high populations of English Language Learners (ELLs), socioeconomic issues, lack of resources at the school, teacher, and student levels, and even inherent differences in the intellectual abilities of stereotyped and non-stereotyped groups. A theory developed by Steele and Aronson, called stereotype threat, provided a radical view into how knowledge of stereotypes affects performance (McKown & Strambler, 2009). Stereotype threat is the experience of anxiety or concern in a situation where a person has the potential to confirm a negative stereotype about their social group. The purpose of this research was to determine how and when children begin to develop knowledge of stereotypes and how stereotype threat affects academic performance.…

    • 1653 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    | | | | |Describe the effects of stereotyping. | | | | |Compare stereotyping with prejudice. | | | |Reading |Read Ch. 2 of Racial and Ethnic Groups. |N/A |0 | |Reading |Read this week’s Electronic Reserve Readings. |N/A |0 | |Participation |Participate in class discussion. |Due 7 Sunday |10 | |Discussion Questions |Respond to weekly discussion questions. |Due Day 2 & 4 |10 | |Nongraded Activities and|Watch the video “Myths and Stereotypes” in this week’s Electronic Reserve Readings. |N/A |0 | |Preparation | | | | |Myths and…

    • 2054 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Self-fulfilling prophecy applies to stereotypes, as well. In fact, it may very well be the reason that stereotypes will continue to exist. Concerning gender, one stereotype is that females are worse at mathematics than men. The stereotype may not make sense, but after being told this enough times, it can influence the actions of both genders. Girls may tend to not work as hard in the subject because it may seem like they can never match a male’s ability. Johns, Schmader, and Martens created an experiment to study how knowledge of stereotype’s power over people impacted performance on tests. They take the gender stereotype about math and determined that Women scored lower when they thought gender was being studied. W they explained before the test that stereotypes about gender could create imaginary stress, women actually scored on par with men. The control group showed that when the test wasn’t referred to as a math test, the two groups also scored the same.…

    • 1013 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What most people don’t know is that when someone is open to the element of a negative stereotype about which they belong, they perform worse on the task related to that negative stereotype. This effect creates a problem when women try to enter the STEM fields because of the belief that men are better at math than women and that men make better engineers and scientists. When someone is told that he or she is not good at a certain skill he or she begins to believe it and eventually start to perform inadequately. Shelly Correll, a sociology professor, created a study where she told the subjects (women) that men scored higher in the first test (even though they all scored about the same) and the subject scored lower in the second test.…

    • 710 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The closest achievement gap to white students in 2014 is the Asian American students, 75% graduation rate and 69.4% respectively (UIC, 2014). This gap does little to disprove the “model minority” myth that is used to invalidate the hardships minorities face. The “model minority” myth is the stereotype that Asian Americans have succeeded in the American dream because of their achievements (Golash-Boza, 2014). However, this stereotype is self-sustaining to a certain extent in education because students, especially minorities experience stereotype threat. Stereotype threat is the fear that one will do something to confirm a negative stereotype of their race (Heine, 2011). For example, reminding an African-American student of the ‘Blacks are unintelligent’ stereotype will show a statistically significant decrease in test scores than if they were not reminded of the stereotype (Heine, 2011). Stereotype threats can also positively affect student performance because they fear in disproving the positive stereotype. For example, reminding Asian Americans that they are supposed to be ‘good at math’ or ‘highly intelligent’ can create motivation that will increase their test scores and in turn their educational…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Stereotyping has lasting negative impact. Past studies have shown that people perform poorly in situations where they feel they are being stereotyped.” Performing a task or assignment in a toxic environment can cause an individual to lose confidence and be very unfocused. Overall, stereotypes are harmful, and not just towards the people they are directed at.…

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Summary: In Chapter 7, Steele discovered that people felt anxious under stereotype threat, but most people did not acknowledge it or they did not aware it. For example, after crossing a narrow, wobbly bridge, men tended to interpret their their feelings of anxiety as an intense attraction for interviewer. Black students who were told to finish a task which measure their intelligence would experience blood pressure rising dramatically, while they did not consciously aware of it. Steele later also indicated that the anxiety caused by identity threat would directly lead to an impaired performance in working memory, which was the memory that needed for retaining information for immediate use. He gave the case study of a group of women who expected…

    • 482 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In today's world, many people has different stereotype about somebody. There are positive and negative, but both of them are harmful to people. People always stereotype about other people who they don't fully know them. In Archbishop Riordan High School, most of the students think Chinese students are very good at math. In fact, some of the Chinese students are very bad at math. This maybe harmful to those Chinese students who did badly at math, because it makes them think they are different to a normal Chinese student. It shows not only negative stereotype will be harmful to people but also positive stereotype will cause harmful to people.…

    • 711 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The issue is called stereotype threat, and it is the explained by Massey and Owens to be a process where a stereotype in society causes an effect in individuals involved in the stereotype. The specific stereotype discussed and the one that I believe is the most relevant in college today is the stereotype that blacks don’t perform well academically. The stereotype is often in much harsher terms, but the gist is that they aren’t as academically successful as say white students. The threat takes effect when black students are aware of the stereotype. The effect of the threat can manifest itself either internally or externally. A stereotype threat is internalized if a student believes in the stereotype in some way. This internalization is a threat to their academic success, because it is a threat to their self-esteem. To clarify if a student thinks they won’t be successful in school because of the stereotype, then they might (subconsciously most likely) “disidentify” from their own academics. This is liken to the argument “my grades don’t define me.” By students not putting in all of their effort they have an out of sorts so it doesn’t tarnish their self-esteem. If a student externalizes the threat, then it’s a very different process. The student doesn’t actually believe the stereotype, but…

    • 1549 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Perceptions of the tests were evaluated as measures of knowledge and intelligence using a modification of the check for stereotype threat inductions by Steele and Aronson. Steele and Aronson’s single-item measure began with an open-ended statement followed by three possible response options, and participants responded by choosing one of the options from the following: "The purpose of this experiment was to: (a) provide a genuine test of my abilities in order to examine personal factors involved in verbal ability; (b) provide a challenging test to examine factors involved in solving verbal problems; (c) present you with unfamiliar verbal problems to measure verbal learning" (Steele & Aronson, 1995).…

    • 107 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    There’s is a stereotype (pg309) I have been experiencing for most of my life- “ Asians are good at math.” Whenever I do good on a test for math, people would already have an expectation that I would do good on the math test, so, they common things like “ Oh, of course she did good, she’s asian, she’s suppose to be good.” This kind of prejudice from people makes me feel pressured, because I feel like people are expecting me to do good, I start to put myself that way (conformity). Sometimes even myself would fall into this stereotype, one time there was someone who got over one hundred percent on the math test, immediately I thought it was this asian guy in my class. This false assumption is the ultimate attribution error (314) because I was making attributions consistent with my prejudice. The stereotype do make me feel frustrated because I work really hard to score good on the test, but people would think I know it from birth because I’m asian. And whenever I do bad on a test, people would would common things like “ are you really asian? you’re supposed to be good at math.”…

    • 347 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Kaiser and Miller’s study indicates if women were forewarned about prejudice, they were evaluated more negatively and distanced themselves from the traditional stereotype than women who were told after their essay was written. This shows that women are very susceptible to prejudice. However, the researchers only induced prejudice before/after and had them write about their future, but did not give them a chance to defend themselves. It would be interesting to extend the research by seeing how women would defend…

    • 423 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays