Preview

Why Was Confederation A Good Idea

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
663 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Why Was Confederation A Good Idea
Confederation happened in 1867 which made Canada what it is today. Confederation was good idea because the result of political,economic,social and military conditions in place at the time.

During the time that Confederation was going on, The Fenians were a huge threat towards Canada. Fenians were a bunch of Immigrants from ireland living in the US, they were a threat to Canada because they wanted Britain to leave Ireland.Attacking Canada would push Britain towards leaving Ireland. Confederation would help this because it would loosen their ties with Great Britain making less likely to attack them. Looking back on it now The Fenians didn't have the right equipment or army to actually do any damage but,the people living in British North America hadn't known that and still thought of it as a huge threat.

Another reason as to why Confederation was a good idea was because of cheaper trading within the country. After Britain stopped the Corn laws and the United States made their trading taxes cost more, British North America was in trouble. The United States and Great Britain were British North America’s biggest trading partners, the different colonies did not trade between each other because if the pricey taxes. By Making British North America one country it would make the trading
…show more content…
Pro Confederation was luck enough to have Sir John A Macdonald as a leader. Macdonald at the moment was the only person who was a lawyer. This was a big deal because being lawyer would give him the proper idea of what Confederation would do for Canada. He was a huge help with making the people in British North America to choose the best option, Confederation. Confederation would also make Canada a democratic country making it easier for the citizens to get their voices heard, where you didn't need all the education that Sir John A Macdonald

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    With intentions of creating a united nation, colonial leaders developed the Articles of Confederation. Although the Articles of Confederation helped lead the United States to the creation of the Constitution, it did not provide for an effective government from 1781 to 1787, do to its lack of power to control commerce and impose taxes, the failure to amalgamate its people as a country, and its inability to enforce laws.…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many people tend to think that the reign of the Articles of Confederation were a complete waste of almost ten years and to some extent, they are right. The confederation style of government has many weaknesses. The Articles of Confederation gave sovereign power to each of states to rule themselves that isn't always a bad thing but take into effect the states history, they couldn't agree on anything. It was hard for them to become unified while they were fighting for their independence in the American Revolution. After the states won their independence they had to set up a government, and of course they didn't want it to be anything like the British so the central government was severely lacking in power, among other things. Under the Articles of Confederation The Congress had no power to levy taxes or tariffs; that makes for a ruthless shortage of money the only way it could gain funds was ask the states for money most of those requests were ignored or only partially met. Speaking of money, the congress did have the right to print its own currency, but so did the states. "One ground of discontent in the army" was the slowness of congress to pay their…

    • 900 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Articles of Confederation were meant to give the United States a loose, weak central government, making the Articles ineffective. With the Articles of Confederation, the United States was unable to support soldiers due to the inabilities of Congress. The United States was also unable to remove British trading posts from their home soil. The weakest states, who were not influential and least populous, had power over those that were strong and heavily populated. Also, the United States did not financially thrive between the years of 1781-1789. By 1789, citizens of the United States started to become weary because of the weak central government. The United States was unable to flourish and to unite under the Articles of Confederation.…

    • 905 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    On July 1st of 1867, the passing of the British North America Act indicated that Canada had become a nation. Before Confederation, what we know as Canada today was merely a bunch of scattered British colonies. When the colonies united to form the Dominion of Canada, they were able to depend upon themselves for economic and security reasons. Because they traded goods amongst themselves without tariffs and depended on each other for protection, an initial sense of unity was formed within the new Dominion. This also led Canada to reduce its reliance on Britain and thus became more independent. Canada's main affairs may have been controlled by Britain at that time, but this event served as a prelude to Canada's growing nationhood and has spurred this young nation to take its first steps in building its own identity.…

    • 674 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    For their part England wanted to retain their interest land and saw the formation of a new country, loyal to them, as their way out. The problem for them was they had little or no presence in the area west of the great lakes except for the the coast of what is now BC. "Victoria & Westminster"…

    • 637 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Before we can rationally answer this question, we must realize the meaning of the word confederation. A confederation is a loosely headed form of government. It is the opposite of the word union. The Articles of Confederation was a weak government, but it was purposely intended to be that way. The last thing the3 government wanted was to formulate a strict government. This probably would have caused the reasons for fighting the American Revolution to resurface.…

    • 509 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Articles of Confederation was the first constitution introduced to Congress 1777 that linked the thirteen independent states together in dealing with common problems. Ratified in 1781, under the Articles of Confederation did make lasting contributions to the nation's well being. The Articles of Confederation despite it's defects, was a significant stepping stone toward the present constitution. Under the Articles of Confederation, the central government was successful in governing the United States in terms of clearly outlining general powers, regulating the western lands and keeping the thirteen colonies together in peace.…

    • 601 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Articles of Confederation caused many problems for our founding fathers. There were many important factors that were abandoned in order to run a functional nation. Some of the problems were: no federal army, no national currency, the federal government could not tax, there were no centralized courts for interstate crimes, and it was extremely difficult to pass a law and almost impossible to pass an amendment. Lucky for us our founding fathers met in Philadelphia and discussed how they can approve on the Confederation. Eventually they came up with the Constitution of Independence and the Bill of Rights. Before the Constitution was created there was a lot of arguing and compromising done. Without compromise it would be impossible to create the Constitution.…

    • 1164 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Articles of Confederation, from 1781 to 1789, provided the virgin country with an efficient form government, transferring power from a monarchy to a democratic republic. However, The Articles of Confederation failed to secure our country. It left our nation utterly defenseless and divided without the existence of a standing national army and grievances among states. The reason for such a short period between its adoption and its revision was due to the many problems that occurred.…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It's one of the, if not the fairest way to govern a country. Democracy means that they'll try to get everyone’s opinions and ideas. Each province will vote who will govern it and who shall represent them in the parliament. More provinces in the Confederation equals better laws because more voices are heard. If a province or territory leaves the Confederation, it will make things chaotic. To make things worse, the separated province or territory won't be able to get as many different opinions and ideas because it is small compared to the rest of Canada. Some provinces such as Quebec complain about being left out, but from 1957-2011, they've received an extra 120 billion dollars from equalization payments. Those extra money can be used to preserve their heritage and culture. Atlantic provinces weren’t doing so well, so the Canadian government helped them by giving them money payments. Now, Newfoundland has found oil and it gives money back to the government in return for it’s help. In Canada, citizens can form their own party and if it receives enough support, it could win the federal election. The Western provinces felt alienation because they thought the government didn't care about them. That gave rise to the reform party which eventually became the Conservative party of Canada. The Conservative party is also the governing party of Canada. As you can see, Canadian politics are fair and…

    • 672 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Articles of Confederation were a primitive version of the current Constitution of the United States. Back in the 1700's all thirteen states approved the Articles of Confederation. The Articles served as the only way to keep the states unified. Though they were weak (most people were afraid of having a strong central government) they still helped in modeling the United States Constitution and helped in stabilizing the government. Although this is true, it would be ridiculous to try to prove that the Articles of the Confederation were an effective government, because the Confederation failed to act as an effective government in about every way possible. Most people look for the following characteristics to comprise an efficient government: the power to tax and use taxes, the ability to regulate trade, and the ability to unite its sections under one power. Although there were some strong steps taken in the articles to try and make the United States a better country, The Articles of Confederation lacked most if not all of the characteristics necessary to be an effective government.…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Coming out of the war the new nation had a number of issues to attend to. While under the Articles of Confederation the government addressed these issues the best it could. Unfortunately some issues were not addressed as well as others. Although the Articles of Confederation were able to sign a treaty with England through the Treaty of Paris, ending the war, and was able to settle disputes for the settlement of western lands between the states, the Articles of Confederation failed to create an efficient way to settle the national debt, and were unable to effectively solve the problem of piracy. Thus, to a lesser extent, the government, under the Articles of Confederation, were effective in solving the problems that confronted the new nation.…

    • 983 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    When the United States won its independence from Great Britain, her leaders were quick to throw out the idea of a powerful central government. After all, the people of every prior civilization in history that chose to adopt a unitary system of government would find themselves subjected to despotism after a very short period of time. The Americans, a people whose desire for liberty motivated their fight for self-determination, were desperate to make sure that they would never follow that path. It therefore seemed that a confederation with an extremely weak central government was the only logical choice for the…

    • 1568 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Trouble with trade was another problem. Britain wanted free trade no taxes. The British North American colonies did not agree. If Britain demanded free trade and no taxes how would the colonies get their money for all the goods that they were producing? The only way to end this is confederation. If they came together as a strong central government they would no longer be controlled by Britain so they wouldn’t be forced into free trade, they could still get profit for their goods. Also the colonies could freely trade with each other because now no longer are they competition they are all part of the same nation working together.…

    • 563 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This led to the creation of the Constitution. The Articles of Confederation didn’t allow Congress to tax the people. There was no national currency, and it was incredibly chaotic. Then the Constitution was created, and a national currency emerged. A system of Checks and Balances was put into place for the three branches of Government. Congress can tax, raising money for a strong army, and other helpful things. Overall, due to the flaws of the Articles of Confederation and the problems it created, the Constitution was…

    • 793 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays