Why Is Institutional Racism so Important to Our Understanding of Racial Inequalities in Britain Today?

Topics: Racism, Discrimination, Institutional racism Pages: 13 (4288 words) Published: October 16, 2006
Why is institutional racism so important to our understanding of racial inequalities in Britain today?

The Commission for Racial Equality has stated that institutional racism involves a process by which a range of public and private bodies systemically discriminate against people of ethnic minorities. Sivanandan, the director at the Institute of Race Relations defines institutional racism as "that which, covertly or overtly, resides in the policies, procedures, operations and culture of public or private institutions - reinforcing individual prejudices and being reinforced by them in turn."

It can be defined as established law, practices and customs which in practice systemically reflect and produce racial inequalities within society. It has been noted that discrimination can occur irrespective of the intent of the individuals or the institution simply due to the fact it becomes rooted in widely shared values, attitudes and beliefs. Therefore cases of institutional discrimination are difficult to police without the fact that being acknowledged that racist outcomes are occurring without the actors knowledge. It becomes an invisible process, which inevitably may be unintentional but puts up barriers and selection/ promotion processes which result in the disadvantage of members of minority ethnic groups. There is indeed a sustained attempt to see unwitting prejudice, thoughtlessness and deployment of racist stereotypes as located in the norms and values through which many ethnic minorities become disadvantaged in many spheres of life. Institutional racism can be both direct and indirect, cases brought under the Race Relations Act 1976 provides good examples of both forms of discrimination on racial grounds, but often arising out of unintentional thoughtlessness, stereotyping or ignorance. Stereotyping has been acknowledged as critical to the way in which racism become institutionalised in everyday practices and procedures (Phillips, 1998, vol 14 p146). The disparate elements of racism and bigotry in institutional racism in an integrated manner, leads one to find it is often functionally integrated, but should not be used to label the individuals as ‘racist' but to be acknowledged as being a problem for the organisation as a whole. Law (2004) believes that stereotypes and biases underlying institutional racism are forms of cultural and historical constructs; these have been formed during colonial history and become rooted in beliefs and attitudes of everyday society. Therefore throughout the generations energies and attitudes can come to encompass unconscious forms of racial discrimination. Since the 1960s the notions of institutional racism has been developed, is has now been acknowledged that it does not necessarily mean that racism is declared, but yet that that it may be present in the consciousness of people who may have been seen more as agents than actors. Carmichael and Hamilton have been key thinkers on the forms of institutional racism; they state that it maybe overt and individual or covert and institutional. Overt may be in an explicit form, whereas covert racism does not need to appear to be intentional, but becomes implanting in everyday functioning of an organisation (Wieviorka, 1995).

Scarman (1981) drew attention to the problem of police racism but also in doing so he defined institutional racism as ‘over racist policy consciously pursued by an institution' (cited in Lea, 2000 p.220). Scarman also responded to the suggestion that ‘Britain is an institutionally racist society' (Lea 2000) by stating he rejected the notions that Britain is a society is knowingly being institutionally racist. But he agreed with the suggestion that practices may be adopted by public bodies and private individual which are unwittingly discriminatory against ethnic minorities (para 2.22).

For Macpherson there are three categories of racism which link to issues of racial inequality, firstly, racism of overtly...

Bibliography: Anthias, F and Yuval- Davis, N (1992) Racialised Boundaries. London: Routledge
Anthias, F (1999) Institutional racism, power and accountability
Braham, P et al (1992) Racism and Anti racism: Inequalities, opportunities and policies. London: Sage Publications Ltd
Commission for Racial Equality (1978) Looking for Work: black and white school leavers in Lewisham
Commission for Racial Equality (1984) Race and Housing in Liverpool- A Research Report. London: CRE
Davis, A (1981) Women, Rand Class
Gilroy, P (1987) Problems in Anti Racist Strategy. London: Runneymede Trust
Gilroy, P (1987) There Ain 't No Black in the Union Jack: the cultural politics of race and nation
Gilroy, R. (1994) Women and owner occupation in Britain. In R. Gilroy and R. Woods (eds) Housing Women. London: Routledge.
Ginsberg, N (1979) Class, Capital and Social Policy
Ginsberg, N (1992) ‘Racism and Housing: Concepts and Reality ' in Brahman, P (eds) Racism and Anti Racism. London: Sage Publications Ltd
Gordon, P (1983) White Law: racism in the police, courts and prisons
Hall, S et al (1978) Policing the Crisis: mugging, the state and law and order. London: Macmillan
Henderson, J and Karn, V (1987) Race, class and state housing
Holmes, C. (2003) Housing Equality and Choice. London: IPPR.
Hubbuck, J and Carter, S (1980) Half a chance? A Report on Job Discrimination Against Young Blacks in Nottingham. Commission for Racial Equality
Jenkins, R (1986) Racism and Recruitment: managers, organisations and equal opportunity in the labour market
Karn, V et al (1985) Home Ownership in the Inner City. Aldershot: Gower Press
Law et al (2004) Institutional racism in higher education
Luthera, M (1988) ‘Race, community, housing and the state ' in Bhat, A et al (eds) Britain 's black population: A new perspective. Aldershot: Gower Press
Mason, D (2003) Explaining ethnic differences
Malpass, P. and Murie, A. (1999) Housing Policy and Practice. London: MacMillan.
Marsh, A
Miles, R and Brown, M (1989) Racism. London: Routeledge
Phillips, D (1998) Black Minority Ethnic Concentration, Segregation and Dispersal in Britain
Phillips, D (1986) What Price Equality? Report on the allocation of GLC housing in Tower Hamlets. London: Greater London Council
Phillips, D (1987) ‘The rhetoric of anti- racism in Jackson, P (ed) Race and Racism: essays in social geography
Ratcliffe (2004) Race, ethnicity and difference
Rex, J and Moore, R (1967) Race, Community and Conflict
Ravetz, A. (2001) Council Housing and Culture. Routledge
Runnymede Trust Statistics and Race Group (1982) Britain 's Black Population
Sarre et al (1989) Minority Ethnic Housing: Explanations and Policies. Avebury: Aldershot
Scarman, L (1982) The Scarman Report: the Brixton disorders
Smith, D (1977) Racial Disadvantage in Britain. Pelican.
Smith, S (1989) The Politics of ‘race ' and residence. Cambridge. Policy Press
Townsend and Sillen (1982) Inequalities in Health
Wieviorka, M (1995) The Arena of Racism. London: Sage Publications
Brown, K (Brugel, I (1989) ‘Sex and race in the labour market ', Feminist Review, 32, p49-69
Ginsburg, N (1989) ‘Institutional racism and local authority housing '
Ginsburg, N (1989) ‘The Housing Act, 1988 and its policy context ' Critical Social Policy, (25) p56-81
Ginsburg, N (1989) ‘Racial harassment policy and practice: the denial of citizenship '
Grant, C (1988) ‘Raising the stakes ', Roof, November- December, p30-3
Gregg, A (1987) ‘Tenants tackle racial harassment '
Lea, J (2000) The Macpherson Report and the Question of Institutional Racism. The Howard Journal, vol 39, 3, p219-233
Lowe, S
Ouseley, H (1988) ‘Equal opportunities lost: the case of education '. Race and Class, 24 (4) p 84-91
Quarless, R (1985) ‘Race and housing in Liverpool '
Sivanandan, A (1976) ‘Race, class and the state: the black experience in Britain ', Race and Class, 17 (4) p347-68
Williams, F (1987) ‘Racism and the discipline of social policy: a critique of welfare theory '
Williams, J (1985) ‘Redefining institutional racism '. Ethnic and Racial Studies, 8 (3) p 323-48
Williams, J and Carter, B (1985) ‘Institutional racism ': new orthodoxy, old ideas
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • institutional racism Essay
  • Institutional Racism Essay
  • Essay about Racial Inequality
  • Racism Today Essay
  • Understanding Racism Today Essay
  • Why Is Childhood so Important Essay
  • Discrimination: Institutional Racism Essay
  • Essay about Why Is Ethics Important Today?

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free