Preview

Why Is Gattaca Unethical

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
451 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Why Is Gattaca Unethical
If our world ever became like the one presented in the movie, “GATTACA”, I might go insane. I don’t think I would ever be able to accept the fact that babies would be treated as science projects or the latest toy, “customized to your own desire.” A parent that has the choice to enhance their child’s features, simply, should not. Beauty is undefined. A parent should love their child, no matter what their physical appearance, and accept whatever unique beauty God gave them.
Selecting the traits of an offspring is unnatural for many reasons. God intended humans to be made through the joining of love, not in a test tube in some lab. Genetically engineered human beings have been proven, in the movie, that they are no better than the “God-children”. When Eugene raced his brother to see who could swim out farther, his brother almost drowned because of overworking his body. In this scene, and throughout the movie, Eugene wouldn’t let his heart condition hold him back from success.
…show more content…
Your child wouldn’t have to suffer from hereditary diseases, they would be accepted by society, they’d have a long life, etc. Women who were not fertile could have the procedure done if they could not conceive a child, but the process of genetic engineering has many cons as well. For example, if the technology were available, knowing the exact lifespan of a child would weigh heavily on a parent. How could the child grow up knowing when they would die because of a flaw in their parent’s DNA, something they had no control of? How could the parent live with the guilt of knowing how much time they had with their son or daughter? Sexual procreation combines the best and worst of the male and female by taking the risk of not knowing what their baby may

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Chem 8.06

    • 553 Words
    • 3 Pages

    -One possible benefit for genetic engineering is is that with gene therapy, a fetus a genetic defect could be treated and even cured before it is born.…

    • 553 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The essay “Building Baby from the Genes Up” by Ronald M. Green explains how in the future, parents might be able to design the genes of their future baby. Green supports genetic engineering of embryos, “why not improve our genome?” (549). He thinks that with the process of in vitro and preimplantation, it could eliminate disease or confer desirable features onto our future. Some medical professionals is concerned about the effect of genetic selection in parenting, Green said “The critics concerns may be less troublesome than they appear”, he thinks that parents will not love their children any less in the quest of perfection, and any kids will not be pressured to live up to perfectionist and expectation.…

    • 538 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Through his film Gattaca, Andrew Niccol shows that the ‘not-so-distant future’ of genetic engineering is not as superior as it seems. A time where children are engineered from conception is imminent. An obvious benefit of such a world is the ability to eliminate all genetic flaws from diseases to deformities. While this may seem like a utopian society Niccol suggests that the more technologically advanced man becomes, the more human spirit is lost. He also implies that man can never engineer past primal human characteristics. Using the story of Vincent Freeman, a man born genetically inferior with high ambitions to enter the elite aerospace corporation Gattaca, he illustrates his first idea with the setting and lighting then…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    However, genetic manipulation is still a slippery slope for more trivial “improvements”. The people in the film did not stop at eliminating harmful diseases but they also started altering things like muscle mass, intelligence, personality traits, hair color and this is when eugenics becomes problematic. Like the society in Gattaca, we could be at risk of becoming a superficial society obsessed with perfection. For example Eugene Marrow, the man Vincent borrows his DNA samples from in order to pose as a valid was obsessed with perfection. Marrow was genetically engineered to be a winning swimmer, his entire existence was dedicated to swimming and yet he still wasn’t good enough. Eventually, we came across someone who was as better swimmer than him and he received a silver metal. Marrow began to feel useless, he was genetically perfect and yet he was not, so he attempted to kill himself by running in front of a car. He failed, survived and as a result was paralyzed from the waist down. Marrow became even more depressed, he found some use in helping Vincent but in the end, he killed himself because even though he was genetically engineered to be the “best” but he was not and thus a failure. By meeting Vincent, an invalid who was far more qualified to do great things despite his genetical disadvantages, made Marrow realize that genetic manipulation is not what makes you the “best”. Perhaps it gives you an advantage, which why Marrow decided to give Vincent, his DNA samples but that is not was Vincent eventually became an astronaut, he became one based on his own natural merit. Eugenics is about “improving” individuals but Marrow is an example Gattaca suggests that Eugenics become problematic when we stop…

    • 2232 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the movie GATTACA, the audience is shown a new, futuristic world, in which the genetics of any offspring can be changed and altered to create a genetically perfect child, known as a "valid". In this new society, having an embryo genetically altered, and then inserted into the uterus of the mother, much like IVF, is seen as the "normal" way to conceive, and the previously normal, now atypical "faith birth" wherein intercourse is the cause of conception, is frowned upon, as it produces genetically "invalid" children. Everything, from the gender of the child, to the colour of their hair, can be manipulated, and is rationalized by stating that the child is "Still you, just the very best of you". In this type of society, only the genotype is important, and all else is regarded. Morally and ethically, society knows realistically that perfection does not exist, and it is the flaws within humans that set us apart from other species.…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Gattaca Movie Analysis

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The geneticists mentioned that he is trying to give the parents the”best possible start” and that the child will be the “best of you.” I think people are misunderstanding that the child is the best of you, but not the best human being, because we are not perfect. Imperfection is what makes human unique. This shows that the genetic traits are the potential guides or the “start” of life, but people can still change due to their living environment. Sometimes I think gaining too much control of things makes it too complicated and it is better to leave it to nature and chance, just like how the parents in the film wanted some traits to be…

    • 1211 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why Is Gattaca Unethical

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Survival of the fittest is one of the most common themes in ecology. Through natural selection, the organisms most capable of adapting to an environment will be the ones to pass on traits for their offspring to inherit. Although the natural process of passing on traits will supposedly take millions of years, geneticists have discovered that procedures such as eugenics and embryo selection will facilitate this process. However, one can reason that disposing of the rejected live human embryos, discouraging the sexual fertilization between certain groups of people, and regarding people with certain physical and mental traits as being the inferior are unethical.…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gattaca

    • 1123 Words
    • 5 Pages

    For science now enables discrimination that is far more expedient than simply skin colour. Vincent, a ``God'' child, is conceived without the help of genetic engineering and is quick to realise that his physical inadequacies, in particular a congenital heart condition, will prevent him from reaching his full potential. It…

    • 1123 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    My presentation today will be regarding the pros of eugenics and its impact on society. After studying the movie GATTACA, it is clear that eugenics plays a vital role in the storyline. Although the movie was created in 1997 and was set in the ‘not too distant future’, it is evident that what was fictional is partially becoming reality. Medical treatment is becoming more sophisticated, prevention of diseases is evident. The use of eugenics in sport leagues has been introduced. The further enhancement of eugenics is becoming rapid, and profound. Many people have a negative attitude towards eugenics after inspecting GATTACA; the cons of eugenics have been demonstrated flawlessly in the movie. But what GATTACA fails to do is cover in depth the pros of this new and advanced technology we possess.…

    • 536 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gattaca Essay

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The film Gattaca is based on the theme of a eugenic society in which science and medicine are imperative in the running of the world. Medicine in this movie has the ability to genetically engineer humans before they are born. The geneticist selects the best genes from the mother and father to create a near close to perfect child, which most of the time is born with no diseases or flaws. The appearance of the child can also be selected and sometimes geneticists take it upon themselves to make the child as close as possible to their ideological views on perfection. However, this film presents to society a major ethical dilemma involving the morals and ethics associated with…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Typically, genetic engineering is viewed as a drive for mastery which deviates from the appreciation of nature and the gift of life (Sandel 9). Sandel believes it is against our human nature to tamper with genetics because it strips us of our humility. For example, parents are supposed to nurture and love their kids but genetically modifying them takes away that relationship. Children are a precious gift and should be accepted for who they are, not for what society dictates is “perfect”. Strengthening his argument, Sandel brings our attention to two types of love: accepting and transformative. A parent who displays accepting love is “open to the unbidden” of their child and loves them for who they are (Sandel 11). They focus more on the being of their child rather than their well-being. Alternatively, transformative love seeks to change the child assuming something is wrong with them in the first place. As one can see, this type of love is similar to germline engineering, in that its focus is on well-being. The problem that Sandel discusses is how parents are unable to maintain a balance between the acceptance and need for success from their child. A parent’s need to mold their children’s lives leads to the larger problem of hyper-parenting. Oftentimes, they get caught up in setting their child up for success and perfecting them. This brings us back to the point…

    • 450 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What if when your mother saw you for the first time, she did not resemble you at all. If everyone in your family had one certain phenotype, and you came out with another. At the end of the day that's fine as long as it was done naturally. Is there an unnatural way of doing this? Indeed, this is a term we like to call designer babies. Usually during this process selected genes are added into an embryo of an unborn child outside the stomach of the mother. This is not yet legal, but the technology for it is upon us, but why would any parent want to do this? They might not fear the risks but they may have insecurities, and might know that their child will be born with an illness.…

    • 552 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The practice of eugenics is very expensive, engineering a perfect child is not something that most people can afford. It also kills human diversity because it takes away the diversity of the biological parents. When the new generation of people is created genetically, it eliminates the diversity of the previous generations.…

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As technology becomes more advanced, the idea that one day we could create a specific child and have that person grow inside of you becomes more and more likely. With the invention of a mechanical womb, a child can grow outside of the mother leading to an endless amount of possibilities both for the mothers seeking children and the overall health of the children. There are many benefits of genetically altering fetuses, as it can eradicate entire genetic abnormalities and diseases. A parent who is not prepared to raise a child with a genetic abnormality could be warned so they could start planning for the birth of their child. Gender could be revealed earlier. Progress for growth could be accurately tracked, based on their genetic codes. Characterizes that are dying out, such as children with red hair and children with freckles could make their return. These possible improvements to prenatal and postnatal children could make the world a safer place.…

    • 286 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In the past thirty years, humans are witnessing a huge revolution in the genetic engineering industry. Having identified most of the Human Genome, gene sequencing has become programmed and extremely fast, and laboratory techniques in molecular biology allow for in-vitro fertilization and transfer of genetic material. Gene therapy and repair based on stem cells research allows for replacement of a defected allele in the DNA, and even a whole damaged tissue in the patient. In general, it is accurate to say that genetic engineering is a controversial topic about which people tend to have strong opinions. The genetic engineering issues that mainly catch the attention of the moral community involve the pre-birth improvement of human fetuses. The ability to screen for detectable diseases is already available in the laboratories. Fertility clinics are also currently able to satisfy the need of a couple for conceiving a male or female child, following the parents’ request, but this is routine compared to the potential of genetic engineering, whose avant-garde aim is the selection of specific traits such as hair color, height and even intelligence. It is this selection that is the most fascinating upshot of advances in genetic engineering, but also the most difficult genetic issue facing the moral society.…

    • 1595 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays