Preview

Why Is Gattaca Unethical

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
697 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Why Is Gattaca Unethical
Survival of the fittest is one of the most common themes in ecology. Through natural selection, the organisms most capable of adapting to an environment will be the ones to pass on traits for their offspring to inherit. Although the natural process of passing on traits will supposedly take millions of years, geneticists have discovered that procedures such as eugenics and embryo selection will facilitate this process. However, one can reason that disposing of the rejected live human embryos, discouraging the sexual fertilization between certain groups of people, and regarding people with certain physical and mental traits as being the inferior are unethical.
Primarily, one can argue that simply “flushing the other embryos down the drain” is the waste of potential human life. Discarding unwanted embryos is the direct result from embryo selection: when a woman’s eggs
…show more content…
This is best portrayed in the 1997 film Gattaca, where a futuristic dystopian society displays extreme segregation between the genetically-engineered “valids” and the unwanted “invalids,” those born of natural birth. Even after several years of exercise and studying, Vincent, who was born of natural birth, could not change the fact that he was an invalid and resorts to literally changing his identity in order to be accepted into Gattaca. Today’s society is beginning to resemble Gattaca in the sense that the physically and intellectually competent are sometimes looked upon as having more worth or value than one who is not. Although a disabled man might not be able to contribute to a society as much as Albert Einstein did, it does not change the fact that he is still a human being who is just as capable of being appreciated and loved by others. Therefore, labelling a person with disabilities as being “retarded” or “mental” and treating them as an inferior is being dangerously

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Embryos are essentially microscopic human beings. Regardless of what good they may provide to the field of medicine, the ethical controversies surrounding embryonic stem cell research are profound. Stem cells, the cells used by the human body to replenish damaged tissue, are found in both embryonic and adult form. At the adult level, stem cells can be extracted from bone marrow, but the real ethical debate arises when embryonic stem cells are introduced. “Pluripotent” embryonic stem cells are among the only type that can form any of over 200 cell types, making it the most useful and versatile. These cells are isolated from the inner cell mass of the embryo when extracted, and subsequently terminates the embryo itself, which is technically manslaughter. However, it must also be noted that embryonic stem cell research can provide effective treatments and even cures for those in need of organ transplants and other irremediable predicaments. Therefore, it is safe to say, from a utilitarian perspective, that the essential “death” of one embryo can save the lives of many, and with Jeremy Bentham’s phrase “the greatest good for the greatest number”; I believe that embryonic stem cell research is ethical.…

    • 1044 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is an age-old question. The pro-life versus pro-choice debate has been argued for many years now. The stem cell debate is a similar concept, but the biggest difference is in most states a fetus can be aborted until they are 20 weeks old (editors, shape.com)! Whereas, embryonic stem cells come from embryos 3-5 days old. A common misconception with embryonic stem cells is that the child is getting taken away from their mother. This is because embryonic stem cells come from leftover vitro fertilizations so the cells would have gone to waste but instead are gone to help other people. These fertilization centers often have extra frozen cells. Many consider not using these cells is a waste (cirm). An important aspect to note is the difference between a fetus and an embryo. An embryo is an organism from the moment of fertilization to the 8 week mark. Whereas a fetus is from 8 weeks to the moment of birth (O’brien).According to Theresa Ellefson, mother and biology teacher, “ although I think that the pros of embryonic stem cell research outweigh the cons, I am not the mother of the embryo, and if I was it might alter my opinion.” This is a common opinion with mothers because they know how many benefits can come from the cells but they also do not want to volunteer their eggs. Although embryonic stem cells are not directly taken away from mothers, they are still sensitive with giving up their…

    • 2096 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why Is Gattaca Unethical

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages

    If our world ever became like the one presented in the movie, “GATTACA”, I might go insane. I don’t think I would ever be able to accept the fact that babies would be treated as science projects or the latest toy, “customized to your own desire.” A parent that has the choice to enhance their child’s features, simply, should not. Beauty is undefined. A parent should love their child, no matter what their physical appearance, and accept whatever unique beauty God gave them.…

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Embryonic stem cells can potentially cause tumors due to the rapid growth when injected into adults. Another big issue with the research of the embryonic stem cells is that in the far future, this could lead to the knowledge on human cloning. Seeing as embryonic stem cells come from the embryos, adult stem cells biggest advantage is that the body’s own stem cells can be used, effectively removing the problems of immune rejection or abnormalities. Many people who are religious would argue that harvesting the embryo is against belief. This is a main controversy because these people believe that the four-five day old embryo has a soul and is evidently murdered when harvested. They believe that the research on these cells violates the sanctuary of life. Their argument is that the embryo in the situation is a potential human being and see the fertilized egg as starting a…

    • 558 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    embryo research is right or wrong and if it’s beneficial or just a waste of time. There are some…

    • 698 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The process of cloning has remained one of the most controversial topics as debates continue about the pros and cons of Cloning. Cloning which is the process of duplicating DNA or living stem cells can be dated back to over 200 years ago. The two most common types of cloning are Therapeutic Cloning and Reproductive Cloning. Therapeutic cloning is a process that specifies the use of cloning stem cells for the treatment of an illness or disability (Ham, 2007). Reproductive Cloning involves inserting a cell into a host but uses donated embryos to harvest stem cells that can be converted into almost any type of cell needed (Ham, 2007). Many arguments are being posed by scientists, pro-life representatives, medical researchers and religious followers about why the practice of cloning should be allowed or banned with all parties making strong points on either side. Today there is a great amount of experimenting and cloning tests being conducted on animals. The United States government has suppressed support for human cloning practices (Bush, 2002). This report will elaborate on the different views from the pro and con side of cloning and provide a realistic synthesis and a conclusive resolution for the practices surrounding the cloning process.…

    • 1304 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    For those who believe that the embryo has the moral status of a person from the moment of conception, research or any other activity that would destroy it is wrong. For those who believe the human embryo deserves some measure of respect, but disagree that the respect due should equal that given to a fully formed human, it could be considered immoral not to use embryos that would otherwise be destroyed to develop potential cures for disease affecting millions of people. An additional concern related to public policy is whether federal funds should be used for research that some Americans find unethical ( Kathi E. Hanna, M.S., Ph.D., Science and Health Policy…

    • 1330 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Abortion Revision Notes

    • 876 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Natural Law asks what our design or purpose is as humans. One of the primary precepts is to protect and preserve the innocent. This alone leads to a secondary precept 'Do not abort.'…

    • 876 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    1301355 CCRS Ethics

    • 1931 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The Roman Catholic Church published its views regarding the use of embryos for stem-cell research, stating "it is immoral to produce human embryos intended for exploitation as disposable biological material” (Catechism, 2275). It is unsurprising that the Church holds this view as it also opposes all direct abortions, deeming them immoral and unethical, as every human life is thought to be deserving of value and…

    • 1931 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Philosophy Essay Is the human embryo a ‘Potential Person’ or a ‘Person with Potential’? For centuries, reproduction was considered to be the work of nature. People had no control over it because they did not have enough information about the process of reproduction to be able to moderate the number of children they had. The mentality of reproduction letting “nature” decide has changed because of advances in reproductive techniques. Nowadays human life can begin, not just in a woman’s womb, but also in a petri dish. Ova can be extracted from a woman through surgery and fertilized with semen and the resulting embryo can develop for some time in the laboratory. This process is called in vitro fertilization and embryo transfer (IVF/ET) This process has been developed so that couples with infertility problems can have children together anyway instead of adopting. The ethical problem is that, when this process is carried out surplus embryos are created and frozen just in case the couple would want to have children again in the future; this is done to avoid a second surgery on the woman. If, within a period of time, the embryos are not used, they are either destroyed or else donated for experimentation. This experimentation has resulted in experts being able to identify embryos which have genetic diseases and so when these are identified just before implantation back into the womb, only the healthy embryos are introduced. These advancements in biological technology have put the moral status of the human embryo into question. Is it wrong to experiment on or destroy unused fertilized ova? It is believed that the key question to understanding the moral status of the human embryo is: Where does human life begin? Any biologist will tell you that human life begins at fertilization, and that is scientific fact. So the real question is: Is the human embryo a potential person or a person with potential? There are 2 main issues surrounding this argument. The first focuses on…

    • 1383 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are reasons why it is unethical such as it goes against the constitution. The 14th amendment states that “all men are created equal with certain unalienable rights. Life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness” meaning no one should be deprived of their life. A lot of people believe there is no person at the point of conception but, there is. At that point there is a makeup of a unique genetic code which each and every one of us have. When you abort a fetus you are depriving it of life it will not have the liberty or the happiness as stated in the constitution and the fetus is unable to defend itself.…

    • 696 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Stem Cell Research

    • 973 Words
    • 4 Pages

    It is argued that the good that can come from such research outweighs the moral risk that human life will be devalued in the process. A great deal of human suffering stands to be alleviated if the research is successful. There is no ethical objection to research on embryos that would otherwise be discarded. Not one extra embryo would die as a result of the procedure, but many children and adults may live as a result of successful research. It is also said that opponents should look at what they are really fighting against and at the moment it appears to be revolutionary medical cures that will improve the lifestyles of thousands of people. They claim that those who disapprove of this are not open minded enough to consider the potential benefits that the type of research could bring, however the most interesting claims I’ve heard is that scientists have covered a campaign of misinformation. The diabetics and those who suffer Alzheimer or Parkinson’s disease have been promised hopes of cure that are actually non-existent. The advocates of destructive experimentation on embryos do so on utilitarian grounds alone. They conjure up the appealing picture of a world free of some of the diseases that afflict us when in fact; they cannot create it at all.…

    • 973 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Eugenics has been defined as “The science of improving a human population by controlled breeding to increase the occurrence of desirable heritable characteristics.” In other words, eugenics is a process used to rid certain societies of individuals that could potentially be considered weak, or undesirable. Eugenics is an unpopular yet extremely important, and very serious subject. The idea of whether or not Eugenics is considered good or unacceptable is controversial. I believe the latter. Throughout history, eugenics has been used in a negative way to terminate certain beings because of race, religion, and mental or physical handicaps.…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Human embryos have a moral status from the moment of fertilisation that should be respected so any research using human embryos is wrong.…

    • 418 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are three kinds of stem cells that are classified according to how versatile they are in their development. Totipotent stem cells are the most versatile type, these can divide into cells that will generate all the cells that will make up the embryo; these totipotent cells are about three days old. Pluripotent stem cells give rise to all tissue types but cannot develop into the entire organism; these are pluripotent on the fourth day. Unipotent stem cells are the adult precursor cells that may be in specialized tissue but can also develop into other cells, these cells can come from a person at any age not essentially from adults. Stem cell research is an individualized approach in medical science to essentially help people who suffer from diabetes, Parkinson’s disease, and Alzheimer’s. The new cell growth from the stem cells give these types of people hope that one day they will be able to walk without having to take medication to control the pain or joint agitation from the Parkinson’s disease, or possibly like Christopher Reeves who injured his neck from an accident and just wants to ability to walk and move his limbs once again.…

    • 1004 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays