Preview

Who Is To Blame For Romeo And Juliet Essay

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1412 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Who Is To Blame For Romeo And Juliet Essay
Romeo and Juliet written by William Shakespeare, is a play that has been studied in high schools for years. This tragedy is about two young kids who fall in love, and how all of the different characters actions intertwine and have an effect on the conclusion. At the end of the play, the Prince says “Some shall be pardoned, and some punished.” (5.3/319) It is clear in this well-known play that the adults, in fact, are to be blamed for the children’s death. In my opinion, the Nurse, Lord Capulet, and Friar Lawrence are to blame for Romeo and Juliet’s death. With these three characters actions all combined, it created an inevitable fate for Romeo and Juliet.
The Nurse, Juliet’s caretaker since she was a young girl, is partially to blame for Juliet’s
…show more content…
In the morning, Capulet decides to tell Juliet that she is to marry Paris. When the Nurse stands up for Juliet, Capulet says horrid things to her. At this point, the Nurse tells Juliet that it is best for her to marry Paris, because Romeo is banished and won’t come back for her. Right away, Juliet tells the Nurse she is leaving to confess her sins to the Friar, however, she actually goes to seek the Friar’s advice. The Nurse is guilty in this situation because she helped make the plan for Juliet to marry Romeo, and then shortly after, told Juliet to marry Paris instead. The Nurse was only trying to save Juliet from the consequences of her secret marriage. While this is true, if the Nurse hadn’t gotten involved in the first place, or if she helped Juliet escape to Mantua, Romeo and Juliet would have lived. It is evident that the Nurses actions contributed to Juliet and Romeo’s death.

Lord Capulets’ fiery, passionate temper toward his daughter impacted most of Juliet’s decisions throughout the play. Ever since the beginning of the play, Capulet felt that he had a huge responsibility for Juliet, and that he had to choose who she was going to marry. He feared that Juliet was going to marry too young, and that it would be to a boy that the Capulets’ did not approve of.
But saying o’er what I have said

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Juliet and the Nurse are very close and Juliet trusts her with a lot of information. The Nurse is the one to go talk to Romeo about Romeo and Juliet's wedding plans. Juliet trusts the Nurse to help her whenever she needs help. There is a very strong bond between the two and the Nurse does what Juliet wants because she is like a daughter to her. Lord Capulet is outraged once Juliet does not want to marry and the Nurse tries to step in. She tries to pull him away, but he soon reminds her that she is only their worker. She becomes cowardly and stops being that mother figure once reminded she has no authority over Lord Capulet. Juliet is hurt by her parents and is expecting the nurse to help her. The Nurse has to agree with Lord Capulet and tells Juliet that Romeo should mean nothing to her and she should go marry Paris. Caring deeply about Juliet, the Nurse wants to keep her safe and to do the right thing. Juliet agrees to this plan, although her real intentions are told after the Nurse leaves when Juliet says “...Go, counselor. / Thou and my bosom henceforth shall be twain” (III.v.252-3). Juliet was abandoned by the nurse and so Juliet does not trust anything the Nurse says or does. Ultimately Juliet feels betrayed and hurt that someone who cared so much about her would do something like that to her.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Nurse acts as a mother to Juliet in many ways all throughout the play, and even before the play. When Juliet is in a time of hardship, it is the Nurse she turns to as opposed to her mother. The motherly figure in a girl’s life is often dependent upon whom she feels fits the position best, and in this case, it is the Nurse, not her true mother being Lady Capulet. It is evident that Juliet feels this way about the Nurse because in the scene in which Juliet is faced with the rage of her Father forcing her to marry Paris, she clearly turns away from her Mother for guidance. Instead, she asks the Nurse to comfort her. “What say’st thou? hast thou not a word of joy? Some comfort, Nurse.” Juliet clearly says to the Nurse, asking her for comfort. Not only this, however the Nurse practically raised Juliet to be the girl that she…

    • 1023 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    She encourages Juliet to become aquatinted with Paris. When Lord Capulet became angry with Juliet for not wanting to marry, Lady Capulet won't help her. When I read this, I wasn't that surprised, because in the beginning she was not very close to her daughter. But it made me view Lady Capulet as a mean person.…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Juliet and nurse have a strong bond at the beginning of the play, due to the relationship nurse agrees to help Juliet marry Romeo as nurse feels it is what Juliet really wants. However when lady Capulet wants Juliet to marry another man, late on in the play, the nurse advices Juliet to forget about Romeo and this is where the main start of Juliet feeling failed occurs. Juliet confides in her nurse for advice about Paris’ marriage proposal, but the trust between them breaks down when nurse says ‘I think you are happy in this second match, for it excels your first’ Juliet is angry at nurse for saying this as she wants the nurse to help her continue her love for Romeo. Feeling failed by Nurses lack of help she decides to go to Friar Lawrence for help, breaking her relationship with nurse. In this situation the Nurse may not have failed Juliet, as she only did what she thought was best for her, however through Juliet’s eyes, the nurse failed her by helping her with Romeo at the start but stopping…

    • 835 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the play “Romeo and Juliet” written by William Shakespeare I blame the reason for their tragedy on Friar Laurence. In the play the Friar married Romeo and Juliet to each other and didn’t inform the Capulet's nor the Montague's. The Friar also tried to help Juliet by giving her a sleeping potion so she wouldn’t have to marry Paris. He also failed to deliver the letter to Romeo saying that Romeo didn’t die, but she was in fact sleeping. “I could not send it here it is again nor get a messenger to bring it thee so fearful were they of infection” (Shakespeare 470). Lastly the Friar had blamed the two lover's death of Romeo and Juliet when both the Capulet's and Montague's had heard of there passings.…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the story of Romeo and Juliet, the Nurse is a mother-figure to Juliet. First of all she grieves the loss of Juliet, like a mom would grieve the loss of her daughter, when Juliet drank the vial that Friar Lawrence gave her to fake her death. “O woe! O woeful, woeful, woeful day! Most lamentable day, most woeful day. That ever, ever I did get behold!” (Shakespeare 1083). In this quote the nurse is showing grief for Juliet’s death. She is doing this by saying that this is the saddest day she has ever seen. Second, she wants Juliet to be happy and doesn’t just enforce what Lord Capulet says. “Go, girl, Seek happy nights to happy days” (1008). When the nurse said this she was saying to Juliet that she should go and do whatever would…

    • 285 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Juliet's maturity

    • 487 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The betraying of the nurse and Lady Capulet strengthens her independence. When the nurse and Juliet's mother suggest she should marry Paris, she didn't take any of their advices. Juliet asks them to leave her alone. When Tybalt died, the nurse advised Juliet to forget Romeo and marry Paris, "Shame come to Romeo!" (3.2.91), "Will you speak well of him that killed your cousin?"(3.2.97). At that point Juliet knew that she lost nurse's…

    • 487 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Nurse wants Juliet to be happy, she says so at the end of Juliet’s first scene. She ensures that Romeo and Juliet get married, and tries to ensure Juliet is happy with the “wanton blood up in [her] cheeks” (II.v.71) all the time. She weeps with Juliet at the recent news of Romeo’s banishment and leaves to find Romeo “To comfort [Juliet]” (III.ii.139) even if Juliet’s comfort is temporary. In Act III Scene v, the Nurse jumps into Capulet’s ranting to try to calm him down so Juliet doesn’t have to be verbally assaulted any longer. After Capulet and Lady Capulet leave, Nurse gives Juliet some advice to follow her parent’s orders because she will never see Romeo again. She wants Juliet to move on because she thinks that a new love will make her happy. This line is to the detriment of their relationship, but she made this decision thinking of Juliet’s depressed pining for Romeo, causing her to cry for hours. Unlike the Nurse, Lady Capulet has a blasé outlook towards her daughter’s feelings. She asks Juliet’s opinion on marriage and then tells her to consider Paris. Juliet must respond to her mother’s orders so she says “I’ll look to like, if looking liking move;/But no more deep will I endart mine eye/ Than your consent gives strength to make it fly” (I.iii.98-100) to mask her feelings while appeasing Lady Capulet. Juliet says “He shall not make me a happy and joyful bride.” (III.v.118) and her mother seems to fixate on this line because she confesses that “I will not marry yet; and, when I do, I swear, /It shall be Romeo” (III.v.122-3), and Lady Capulet has no reaction whatsoever. After Capulet enters and Lady Capulet tells him Juliet’s decision, Juliet interrupts, covertly she telling her mother that she loves Romeo. Capulet flies into a rage unseen in his character before this and Lady Capulet asks Juliet if she’s crazy for her cryptic messages in front of her father nonetheless, not once thinking that her daughter…

    • 844 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The nurse's relationship with Juliet is that of a mother-daughter. Juliet's mother hardly acts as a mother figure to her at all, it is mainly the nurse who Juliet looks to for reassurance and comfort. The nurse's love for Juliet can be seen in the way she acts and the things she does. In the beginning of the play when Juliet first meets Romeo, the nurse warned Juliet that he was a Montague. The nurse was looking out for Juliet and trying to protect her because Juliet's a Capulet and the Montagues and Capulets do not get along. Another time when the nurse demonstrated her mother-like qualities was in her support of Juliet's marriage to Romeo. Juliet was so in love with Romeo, that the nurse snuck behind her parent's backs and encouraged the marriage of Romeo and Juliet. However, when things start to go bad with the marriage, the nurse suggest to Juliet that maybe she ought to reconsider and marry Paris. Juliet was offended by this, but the nurse only did it because she was looking out for Juliet and wanted her to be safe. The nurse is always there for Juliet when she needed someone to talk to or get advice from, unlike her real mother. The love that the nurse and Juliet share is one different than many others simply because the nurse took on the mother role in Juliet's…

    • 539 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Nurse is a very crucial character in The Tragedy of Romeo & Juliet. She keeps the secret of Romeo and Juliet quiet. She cared for Juliet for her whole life. She became a second mother for Juliet. In the end the nurse turn on her for the “good”. Which as we know she does it to have Juliet as safe as possible. The Nurse means good by what she says but it does not help Juliet in her situation. This makes her feel more cornered which guides her to her death…

    • 270 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    This part of the play also gives background about Lady Capulet, Juliet, the Nurse, and all of their opinions about Juliet becoming older. The nurse says a particularly lengthy speech about how much she contributed to Juliet’s life and how much she cared for Juliet. Aside from revealing her talkative nature, the nurse’s speech also discloses some information about her past daughter, who passed away during an earthquake, which lead to the nurse caring for Juliet to an even greater extent. When discussing Juliet’s childhood, the nurse also reveals her humorous personality while stating, “Yes, madam. Yet I cannot choose but laugh…” (Shakespeare 824). Even though she was describing the time Juliet fell and got injured, the nurse still managed to slip in some humor, which makes Romeo and Juliet more enjoyable. Lastly, the nurse’s speech discloses her views on Juliet getting married. The nurse makes a few obscene remarks about Juliet getting older (even though Juliet was five), which shows how the Nurse and other characters of the story have viewed Juliet to be more of an “object,” not a…

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The nurse is the Capulet’s servant, a faithful servant who tries her hardest to please Juliet and the rest the Capulet’s at the same time. The nurse is also a very important character in the play in the Capulet’s lives as she was hired for the job of breastfeeding Juliet, because she had unwanted breast milk due to the tragic loss of her little Susan; although she might just be another servant in the household, she has a far more superior responsibility. She plays an important role as Juliet’s confidant, and a crucial character that strongly influences Juliet’s thoughts and actions. The relationship between The Nurse and Juliet is even seen to be stronger than Juliet and her own mother’s relationship.…

    • 1490 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Up until this scene the Nurse, her maternal figure and confidant, the Nurse sides with the Capulets and recommends that Juliet does the same after her argument with her parents over marrying Paris. The shocked Juliet responds, (3.5. 228) "Speakest thou from your heart?" Juliet, distraught, because the Nurse does not support her wishes to be with Romeo. She finds it hard to believe that the Nurse would have her break both legal and moral laws in marrying Paris. She feels betrayed and thus ends her trust in the Nurse's confidence. Juliet’s final and desperate hope goes to Friar Lawrence in the hopes that he may help her. "If all else fail, myself have power to die" (3.5.244). That quote from Romeo and Juliet shows as dramatic irony because we know her fate and she doesn’t, so when she talks about death it foreshadows later in the…

    • 320 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The nurse went against Juliet's parents' wishes and told her it was okay to go ahead and marry Romeo. She knew Mrs. Capulet arranged for Juliet to marry Paris, but she still encouraged Juliet to marry Romeo. "Then hie you hence to Friar Lawrence' cell; there stays a husband to make you a wife" (pg. 331, lines 68/69). By saying that, she over-stepped her boundaries of being just Juliet's nurse.…

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Romeo And Juliet Symbolism

    • 1865 Words
    • 8 Pages

    She soon has to educate herself on the subject upon falling love with the handsome Romeo Montague, the son of her father’s rival. Being a young girl born into an aristocratic family she has been denied much of the freedom that Romeo benefits from. This means no adventuring out into the streets of Verona, no going out after dark, and of course no reckless behavior involving a boy, but what kind of a life would she live if she did not do just that? A longer one that is for sure, but also one full of misery. Luckily Juliet has somewhat of a guardian angel looking out for her. This guardian angel also known as the Nurse, helps her with her various challenges that come up in Juliet’s life.F In a time where the parents are not involved enough with Juliet, even at a young age, the Nurse has filled the spot. In place of Juliet's mother, the Nurse has breastfed her, raised her, and treated her as if Juliet was her own daughter. So instead of going to Lord or Lady Capulet for advice and wisdom on things Juliet would go to the Nurse. As the Nurse was also technically working for her, there were a lot of rules and regulations she needed to follow in order to keep her job, and this conflict would later affect Juliet’s judgment to tell the Nurse about the things going on in her life. Things that if the Nurse ever told her parents, Juliet would be in an enormous amount of trouble. In those times Juliet's best option was to seek advice from her dear friend and priest Friar Lawrence. The Friar is a friend to both Romeo and Juliet so he was often put into the direct middle of their situation. He was kind, wise, and always ready to help them out with a plan if the need arose. Friar Lawrence was the entire reason Juliet and Romeo were able to consummate their marriage. He says to Romeo that they are too young but his hope is to “To turn your…

    • 1865 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays