top-rated free essay

Who’s watching the Watchdog?

By johndoe2014 Apr 20, 2014 866 Words

Who’s watching the Watchdog?

Who’s watching the Watchdog?

What ethical issue is at the heart of the article?
The ethical issue at the heart of the article is the Common Rules. The Common Rules govern the ethical practice for researchers using participants. Sometimes the guidelines are unclear and not entirely effective in protecting patients in research studies. “Current trends in research and it’s regulation continue to erode the requirement of consent, while the level of acceptable risk has been elevated to the extent some have described the minimum risk as being upwardly mobile” (Alvino, p. 903). This problem has emerged in the last decade because of a paradigm shift in research toward an access model of therapy. This ethical shift has reduced patient privacy and rights (Alvino, 2003). Research projects have grown increasingly large, outpacing the Institutional Review Board’s (IRB) ability to effectively monitor these studies (Christensen, Johnson, & Turner, 2011). Why is this issue important to the conduct of research?

This issue is critically important to the conduct of research. If stringent regulations and effective oversights are not established then, research participants are placed at risk of physical or mental harm. Research is the foundation for discovery of medicine, technology, and the various other aspects that expand knowledge and growth. Mankind must constantly conduct research experiments to implode the boundaries for the empowerment of a better quality of life. What problems might arise if this issue were not addressed by a researcher? If this issue were not addressed by a researcher, then considerable health risks to participants could increasingly occur. In the case of Jesse Gelsinger, researchers did not disqualify him, protocol was not followed, and ethical guidelines blurred (Alvino, 2003). If research trials continue to erode clinical rules then it could have an impact on the public’s faith on the entirety of the research process and future studies would be compromised. Ultimately, this could result in society’s increasing unwillingness to fund and support research projects that could advance human health. How is this issue relevant to researchers in your discipline? This issue is relevant to researchers in my discipline because my discipline regularly incorporates research participants. My plan is to become a college professor, consult, and research business practices. College courses are constantly evolving, and textbooks updated to include current research or historical data. Students cannot be prepared for future careers based on outdated data, for example; a doctor treating a patient for a disease by bloodletting. Another analogy to consider is teaching math to students and stopping at basic algebra because no one challenged the boundaries of math. How do researchers in your discipline address this issue?

Researchers in my discipline address this issue by maintaining discipline-specific ethical standards that help contribute to increased safety and patient privacy. Researchers in multiple disciplines have lobbied for changes to the current regulations. For instance, Emanuel and Menikoff (2011) indicated that IRB resources should be focused on studies that contain the highest degree of risk. IRB is one of the hurdles of a doctoral student. Ethics is the foundation for teaching and research professionals. Ethical behavior is constantly at the forefront of a teacher (Valentine & Kidwell, 2008). Teachers must set an example for students to follow. What are your thoughts on how this ethical issue might affect your conduct as a researcher? As a researcher, recognizing this issue exists directly affects me. The knowledge that a current gap in the system exists shifts the ethical obligations from the government to me. While in many instances, one can rely on the government to provide an effective regulatory framework, in this instance, it is my responsibility to improve participant’s safety and privacy. The scholar, practitioner, and leadership journey will not be of value without ethics. The investment in time and money will be for naught unless scrutiny continues to expand and encapsulate the existing gap. This case study enriched my perspective on ethics and my responsibilities as a researcher. The moral obligations in ethical research encompass a vast array of rules, guidelines, and perceived obligations. Participant’s expectations must be maintained to the best of my ability. The integrity of research data and expansion of knowledge relies on the ethical behavior in which it was extracted.

Alvino, L. A. (2003). Who's watching the watchdogs? Responding to the erosion of research ethics by enforcing promises. Columbia Law Review, 103(4), 893. Bernabe, R. D. L. C., van Thiel, G.,J.M.W., Raaijmakers, J. A. M., & van Delden, J.,J.M. (2012). The risk-benefit task of research ethics committees: An evaluation of current approaches and the need to incorporate decision studies methods. BMC Medical Ethics, 13, 6. doi: Christensen, L. B., Johnson, R. B., & Turner, L. A. (2011). Research methods, design, and analysis (11 ed.). Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon. Dagaz, M., & Harger, B. (2011). Race, gender, and research: Implications for teaching from depictions of professors in popular film, 1985-2005. Teaching Sociology, 39(3), 274-289. Retrieved from Emanuel, E. J., & Menikoff, J. (2011). Reforming the regulations governing research with

human subjects. New England Journal of Medicine, 365(12), 1145-1150. Valentine, S., & Kidwell, R. E. (2008). Business students' ethical evaluations of faculty misconduct. Quality Assurance in Education, 16(3), 287-300. doi:

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Who's to Blame?

    ...Over the last twenty years, obesity has become an epidemic issue. Children are starting to become obese at a much younger age. Children that are obese are having serious health issues. Do you think Companies of fast food industries are to blame? The fast food industries are implementing more sodium and fat into their food to make the taste bette...

    Read More
  • Who's Irish

    ...¡§Who¡¦s Irish?¡¨ This story ¡§Who¡¦s Irish?¡¨ was written in 1999 by Gish Jen who is a second generation of Chinese American. As a daughter of Chinese immigrants, she deeply perceived the culture difference. ¡§Who¡¦s Irish?¡¨ is also based on her identity. Told by an immigrant Chinese grandmother, this story is full of thoug...

    Read More
  • People Watching

    ...Have you even been able to just sit down and watch people? Watching people is one of the craziest things to do in life. There are so many different types of people in the world. You can't predict what you are going to see or hear. I went to the Boise Town Square Mall and was given the opportunity to sit down and observe the lives of others aroun...

    Read More
  • Who's Write and Who's Wrong

    ...In “School is Bad for Children”, John Holt states Children are smarter, more respectable and independent than they will ever be in their lives, before stepping through the door of the school building. Holt’s essay is a very direct view of the educational system. Though some of his statements may be true, about the hindering of children thr...

    Read More
  • Electronic Watchdog

    ...CIRCUIT IDEAS ELECTRONIC WATCHDOG TAPAN KUMAR MAHARANA I VED DWI S.C. H ere’s an electronic watchdog for your house that sounds to inform you that somebody is at the gate. The circuit comprises a transmitter unit and a receiver unit, which are mounted face to face on the opposite Fig. 4: Mounting arrangement for transmitter ...

    Read More
  • Watchdog Journalism

    ...Watchdog Journalism: Investigative Reporting in Southeast Asia Watchdog Journalism, is a training video produced by the Philippine Center for Investigative Journalism (PCIJ) that talks about how the Investigative Journalism helped the citizens of Southeast Asian countries to be aware on the wrongdoings of the public officials. It presented case...

    Read More
  • Watching the Watchmen

    ...Watching the Watchmen While reading Watchmen with the purpose of textual analysis, there are many different things to consider. Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons took many original approaches to the typical super hero story when formulating this novel. Watchmen is a story about a group of outlawed super heroes in New York City. The story lines an...

    Read More
  • Bird Watching

    ...Birdwatching or birding means going outside to enjoy watching birds. It is a popular hobby. Someone who does this is called a birdwatcher or birder. These two words mean the same thing, but people who spend a lot of their time watching birds, taking their hobby seriously, are more likely to call themselves “birders”, while “birdwatchers”...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.