top-rated free essay

Which Medium of Instruction Is Better

By Mittukutty Dec 17, 2012 942 Words
Why English should not be the medium of instruction in India

In India, one erectile dysfunction for which a miraculousAyurvedic or Unanni cure is not peddled in Technicolor over all media is of hackles. For the good reason that they are always up. That is a required genetic trait for our television anchors and they compensate for nature's oversight in this regard for the rest of the population. So a new outrage cannot make hackles rise, it can make only make them bristlle. Say anything against English, and they not only bristle but also positively come shooting off the snarling mass of the enraged, like quills from a porcupine.

I have no desire to turn into a man-eater, as many leopards in India have, after being maimed by porcupine quills. I hasten to clarify that this column is not against English. I am all for English and for Indians learning it across the board. But I am decidedly against English increasingly being preferred as the medium of instruction in schools.

In January, Swaminathan Anklesaria Aiyar cited, in a column in the Times of India, research findings from those who study cognition to argue against teaching English in Class 1. The easiest language to learn for all human infants is the language they hear spoken at home, the mother tongue. When children who do not hear even a smattering of English at home are taught English in their first year of schooling, their entire learning process is impaired. If they learn to read their mother tongue first, and then learn English, they learn both languages much better. This is just about teaching English. It can be imagined that teaching maths or science or history through English would be even more disastrous. Kids end up learning by rote, not understanding a thing. They pass their exams all right, but end up unemployable graduates, their native capacity to learn damaged for ever, and their creative faculties crippled. This is a tremendous loss, both at the individual level and at the level of society.

Indians are firmly convinced that the only way to learn English properly is to learn everything else through English. This is contrary to logic and empirical evidence both in India and around the world. Children in every country today learn English, but they learn it as a foreign language, and learn it well, in all countries where English is not the native tongue.

Consider countries like Korea, Japan, Germany, Sweden, Russia, Brazil and China. They have economies that are better than most. Their schools teach English, but employ their own mother tongues as the medium of instruction. Korea's population is smaller than Tamil Nadu's. Japan's,smaller than Bihar's. The Scandinavian countries are comparable, in population size, to Mayur Vihar, Thane, White Field or some other suburb in India. Their languages remain vibrant, they create new knowledge and literature in their own languages and produce Nobel prize winners and world-beating companies. Of course, they also learn English, the de facto world language. Except in colonised India, nowhere do people believe that unless they abandon their mother tongue and embrace English as the sole language of instruction, their future is doomed.

Today, many Indian languages are slowly dying. The best and brightest among them learn only English. The poetry they write will be in English. Their creativity will not nourish the roots of their mother culture. Great Indian languages whose proto-sounds have resonated with sense and sensibility for thousands of years will languish and die. Sounds implausible? Welsh is almost dead. Irish writhes in its death throes. The print order for a book of poetry in Hindi, nominally the mother tongue of over 450 million people, is 500. But for Hindi films, Hindi poetry would probably be dead by now.

Premium advertising in the print media goes to English publications. When people have money to spend, they defect from their mother tongue to English. Everyone wants to earn more money, they will want to imitate the habits of the elite, who wear Fab India ethnic and converse only in English. The current fetish with English Medium destroys learning and creativity, produces unemployable graduates and sets Indian languages on an inexorable course of destruction. What is the alternative? Teach kids in their own mother tongues. Produce world class textbooks, translate them, by all means, from English, for all levels, and revamp the teaching of English as a second language.

With a proliferation of television channels in all languages and the coming spread of wireless broadband, use of multimedia to expand the scope of teaching English to cover speaking is not difficult at all. (Disclosure: I studied in Malayalam all through school and how I speak English is an endless source of amusement for my two Delhi-brought up, deracinated children).

English itself will be the biggest beneficiary from Indians deciding to teach their young in their mother tongue while also teaching them English separately and thoroughly.

Can Indian languages lend themselves to specialised registers required for academic rigor in varied disciplines? But of course. In Europe, the language of science used to be Latin, till science and society got democratised. Many Latin terms continue to be used in science. Indian languages can continue with Latin and English for technical terms instead of going for long-winded artificial coinages. If Korean and Swedish can deal with microelectronics and Abba, there is no reason why Indian languages cannot.

Indians need to be multilingual, and they can be. Learn English, we must, but in a manner that does not kill off Indian languages, children's ability to comprehend or even English itself. Stop bristling, please.  

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Which is Better?

    ... “Don’t Fight. Switch”: Analysis of Nokia Lumia 1020 v Samsung and Apple phones Commercial Everyday newer and better technology is introduced to the world; new computers, phones, cars, and etc. So, for us to keep up with the newest technologies released every day, companies put out commercials and advertisement for us, the consumers, to...

    Read More
  • English as a Medium of Instruction

    ...own. Hence researchers, who have tested children who are taught in their mother tongue and those whose medium of learning is a language that is alien to them, have found the first group to have a better understanding of what is taught to them and better verbal skills. In fact, when they move on to learn a second or even a third language a...

    Read More
  • English a Medium of Instruction

    ...English a Medium of Instruction A question we are still grappling with in Pakistan after 60 years is, what should be the language of instruction in our schools? In Dhaka Quid-e-azam said “let me make it very clear to you that the state language of Pakistan is going to be Urdu and no other language. Anyone who tries to mislead you is re...

    Read More
  • English as Medium of Instruction

    ...ENGLISH AS MEDIUM OF INSTRUCTION IN THE NEW GLOBAL Asst.Prof.Chincholkar.B.B Dept.Of English. Rajarshi Shahu College, Parbhani Abstract The English language is continuing to establish itself as a global lingua franca in a period of unprecedented globalisation. In the last decade educational systems worldwide have shown interest in the adoption...

    Read More
  • Which One Is Better?...

    ...MOHAMMED MIJANUR RAHAMAN MOON CYBER ZONE, STEDIUM ROAD, FENI-3900 +8801815 066588 ~ Objective To work in a position that utilizes my ability and challenges my quality and efficiency. This offers development opportunity for building my career as a computer engineer as well as Hardware and network. Now looking to con...

    Read More
  • Which Is Better Poetry and Prose?

    ...form of literature than poetry. Prose must still contain a certain amount of veraciousness and technique in order to be created. However poetry requires these things in order to be successful and whilst it is some people’s view that prose is layered with different meanings and is read to be analysed, poetry is simple, often encapsulating intri...

    Read More
  • Instruction

    ...IPPR Instructions Use these assigned topics to complete your IPPR Lesson Plans: IPPR #1 Lesson Plan: Place value, integers, and computation (Module/Week 3) – Create a place mat and teach a lesson that will assist students with understanding place value and computation using integers (not decimals). IPPR #2 Lesson Plan: Problem Solving (...

    Read More
  • Which Is Better Free Trade or Protectionism

    ...Which is better the Free Trade Policy or the Protectionist? Amanda Birchum Mid-Continent University Bus 2423 Introduction to Microeconomics Michael Roberson Insert Paper Title Here For centuries there has been an ongoing debate. Which trade policy is better, is it the Free Trade Policy or the Protectionist policy? To answer this ques...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.