Which Is Better, True Belief and Knowledge?

Better Essays
In Meno, Socrates and Meno have a discussion on virtue and they encounter a problem. If virtue is teachable, it must be knowledge. However, since there are no teachers and students of virtue, virtue must not be taught. So they think that virtue is not knowledge. And then they start the discussion on what is true belief and knowledge. In this essay, I would evaluate Socrates’s explanation on why knowledge is better than mere true belief and the reasons that I agree with Socrates’s proposition.
Socrates’s explanation To begin with, Socrates first questions whether true belief is something no less useful than knowledge. Socrates notes that true belief and knowledge guide to the true action. He illustrates the idea by an example. To clarify Socrates’s example, I will apply his example on our campus. Suppose I need to guide a friend to Chong Yuet Ming Physics Building. I have no idea where it locate and I haven’t been to there. Now, I can visit the building if someone with the knowledge of the path guides me there or I have the knowledge of the path. But a true belief, which may be the intuition, perception, will also be equally effective in reaching the destination. If my belief is that the destination is northwest of the main building, and I convince my friend to the destination. From an outside observer, he cannot distinguish whether I have the knowledge of the path or I just luckily arrive there according to my true belief. Socrates states that “correct opinion (true belief) is no less useful than knowledge” because no matter which proposition, either true belief or knowledge, someone’s action still can be guided correctly. Although I do not agree this statement, I will discuss it in later paragraph.
So, what makes the different between true belief and knowledge? Socrates thinks that the difference between them is the justification, which is the reasoning or the rationale for your belief. The person with knowledge has the ability to account of the why behind the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    “Is Justified True Belief Knowledge?” (The Gettier Problem) Background Epistemology: A theory of _____________ What do we mean when we claim to know something? What kinds of conditions must be satisfied in order for a claim to become knowledge? Note: we are interested in __________________ knowledge here (S knows that p), not knowledge of how to do things (e.g., knowing how to ride a bike) The tripartite theory of knowledge – knowledge as justified true belief (JTB) The truth condition We…

    • 602 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Knowledge vs. True Belief The discussion of true belief and knowledge in the Meno develops in the analogy of the traveling men; one who knows the correct path to Larissa and the other who has a true belief of the correct path to Larissa (Meno 97a-c). Socrates tells Meno that if both men led to the same result, then true belief is no more useful than knowledge and both beneficial (Meno 97c). This comparison changes in book five of the Republic when Socrates says an ideal state must have a philosopher-king…

    • 662 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Knowledge and Belief

    • 1703 Words
    • 7 Pages

    between belief and knowledge in the given dialogue. Then explain what the importance of this distinction is. In Gorgias, Plato uses a conversation between two men to lay the groundwork for knowledge and belief, suggesting that everything is subjective when it comes to these words, and their definitions are open for much interpretation past their most simplest of meanings. Gorgias is meant as a guideline in which we can decide whether or not an object, idea, or event is belief or knowledge. So you…

    • 1703 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Traditional analysis of knowledge says to know that P. the following requirements must be satisfied: (1) You believe that P, (2) You have justification for P and (3) that P is true. This definition of knowledge was thought to have satisfied many philosophers for centuries after Plato, this was until philosopher Edmund Gettier wrote ‘Is justified true belief knowledge?’. In this short paper he argues that justification and truth is necessary for knowledge but not sufficient thus concluding that we…

    • 1087 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Justified True Belief

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The justified true belief theory of knowledge is an idea that if you have evidence to justify your belief then your justification makes that belief true. Your evidence holds true because of your previous experiences or your five senses thus making your idea true when you can rule out other alternative evidence. This theory is broken down into three necessary conditions: truth, belief and justification. Truth is the condition where it accurately represents the world; belief is when you believe something…

    • 438 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Plato's Beliefs on Knowledge HZT4U1 October 10, 2013 Plato was a Greek philosopher who lived 428-348BC and was a student of Socrates's. Plato had many ideas that lead to greater discovery in several branches of philosophy, however, this essay will focus on his theories involving knowledge. Plato believed that real knowledge was understanding, that knowledge and perception are the same and that knowledge requires explaination. Plato defined knowledge as, "justified true belief," which states…

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    PHI 332 Course Paper What is wrong the claim that knowledge is true judgment (or belief)? What is knowledge? What is truth? How can we really know for sure if one judgment holds more truth than another? My theory of knowledge is information passed on from one person to the next. Before I am able to answer the above questions I have asked, the question of this idea that is true knowledge must be defined first. Knowledge can be any new piece of information that I come across daily…

    • 2413 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Knowledge versus Belief Introduction The traditional or classic definition of knowledge was proposed by Plato in his dialogue Theaetetus−that “knowledge is justified true belief”. This view is formulated by a study of justified beliefs that constitute knowledge, this study is called Epistemology. Epistemology as a branch of philosophy deals with certain questions that are conducive to know what knowledge is. These questions can be proposed in the following way: What are the necessary and sufficient…

    • 1713 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Problems of Justified True Belief What is knowledge, and is anyone in a position to give an account of it? Certainly people do have knowledge, given the vast amounts that fill up our libraries; or what people refer to as common knowledge- what a person believes and understands based on their experiences; or what a professional learns through the ongoing practices within their field. These are personal accounts of types of knowledge that people may be in a position to put forth; however,…

    • 662 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Justified True Belief thesis was generally accepted: (i) S is true (ii) S believes that P, and (iii) S is justified in believing that P (Hauptli, 2003). This tripartite account as Justified True Belief has always been perceived as necessary conditions for knowledge. A belief which is true without justification appears to only be a belief which is true when it has been discovered by sheer accident. The necessitation that knowledge has to be believed is self explanatory, as without belief, its justification…

    • 129 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays