Preview

What Is Sophie's Guilt

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
846 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
What Is Sophie's Guilt
There are two recurring themes in the novel Sophie’s Choice by William Styron, which is love and guilt and they lead to the death of the protagonist. In the novel, the love Sophie has for those who mean the most to her shapes her life and the guilt she possesses leads to her own demise. The narrator of the novel is a graduate of Duke University and an aspiring writer who gets close to his roommates Zofia (Sophie) Zawistowski and Nathan Landau. As Stingo grows closer to Sophie, he learns about her dark past in the concentration camp, how she and Nathan met on one faithful day, the destructive relationship between Sophie and Nathan, and the dark guilt she has kept for many years.
In the novel, Sophie has to choose between her two children on which child goes into the concentration camp, and which child gets to be gassed immediately. But, the question is: How did she get into this predicament? The answer is Sophie’s love for her mother. One fateful night changed the course of her life and her children. “I got caught smuggling for a reason which may
…show more content…
Which one will you keep?’” (Styron, page 529). This question marks the beginning of Sophie’s guilt. Sophie deals with insurmountable guilt daily, the guilt has to deal with the decision she made at the concentration camp based on this question. When she was asked the question on which child goes to the concentration camp with her and which child is killed immediately by gassing. If she does not choose, both children are sent to the gas chamber. When Sophie says “ Don’t make me choose, … I can’t choose.” (Styron, page 529) the doctor states “Send them both over there, then,” to the aide and that is when Sophie calls out “... Take my little girl!” Sophie is filled with the guilt of sending her daughter to the gas chamber and letting her son live in the concentration camp with her. The memory of this event haunts her until she commits

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Killing Chickens

    • 1025 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Betrayal and loneliness are two of the hardest emotions to encounter in life. Nevertheless, at some point everyone will experience and be forced to deal with them. This is made even harder when they are caused by someone you love and trust. In Meredith Hall’s “Killing Chickens”, she uses various literary devices such as metaphor, simile, and imagery as she processes her husband’s affair and describes having to kill chickens. Hall’s literary nonfiction is based on the happenings of a specific day that was truly hard to handle after being deceived by ones she loved:…

    • 1025 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    To start off, Sophie was a hidden deviation and her parents did everything they could to…

    • 568 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    apush

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The book “The Sunflower” starts with Simon Wiesenthal being put into a concentration camp during the Holocaust. He lives his life as a prisoner day by day until one day he is taken with a group to clean trash at a hospital. While walking through the town to the hospital he sees a cemetery for Nazi soldiers. He noticed that each grave had a single sunflower planted on top of it. When Simon reaches the hospital he is called inside by ta nurse who brings him to a patient’s room. The room he was brought to was the one of a dying Nazi named Karl. Simon was stuck in Karl’s room listening to his story about what he has done to Jews, the people he has killed and his mother. When Karl is done telling his story, he begs Simon for forgiveness. Without answering Simon leaves. He couldn’t decide whether it was a good idea or not to forgive the Nazi. The day after, Simon is brought back to the hospital. The nurse again brings him inside and instead of going to the patient’s room she gives him Karl’s possessions. Karl had passes away the night before. One day after Simon is freed from the camp, he goes to visit Karl’s mother’s house. He thinks it will help him decide whether or not he made the right decision of not forgiving Karl. After he speaks to her, he still can’t decide whether he made the right decision. At the end of the story he asked the reader what they would have done the same thing.…

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Four Perfect Pebbles

    • 976 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The book begins with Marion Blumenthal, a young girl sleeping on her mother’s arm in a concentration camp in Bergen-Belsen, a town northwest of Berlin. Their fellow inmates are dying by the dozen. Marion vividly describes the horrors she experienced in the camp. Daily she found herself stepping over dead bodies that were just left strewn about. One of the worst torments was the daily roll call. They would stand in the below zero temperatures for hours on end with barely a layer of clothing to protect them from the frost. There was one good part of her day however; Marion and her mom would spot her father and brother Albert, and for a few short moments they got to be a family. Albert and dad always brought “surprises”. They brought what “extra” food they had saved from the previous day. Marion would bring along her secret treasure; four perfect pebbles. Marion’s pebbles gave her a sense of purpose, and belief that it would keep her family together.…

    • 976 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Taylor Gambill

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Love is a major theme in The Book Thief by Markus Zusak. Rudy’s love for Liesel causes him to stick by her side through good and bad. Liesel is compelled by her love for books and the feeling of conquering new words. Papa’s love for Liesel is very profound throughout the course of the book. Love is the driving force for many people throughout the novel.…

    • 500 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    ‘The Book Thief’ by Mark Zusak The Book Thief is a story of a young german girl named Liesel Meminger in Nazi Germany during world war 2. At age nine her brother drops dead in front of her and when Death himself comes to collect his newest soul, he becomes fascinated with Liesel. From then on death narrates the story of a girl who moves into a foster home where she develops relationships between her new Papa and Mama, her best friend Rudy, her secret friend Max, but most importantly we witness her relationship with books and words that take her on a journey though life. Using your prescribed text, examine what the composer of this text reveals about Changing Perspectives and how they convey these ideas (750 words). It is expected that you will identify and analyse at least 2 techniques /forms /features. Use the PETAL structure to help you remain analytical. Mark Zusak reveals the concept of Changing Perspectives in his book ‘The Book Thief’ through how he has personified Death as the narrator. He does this in such a way that causes the reader to reconsider their thoughts on ‘what’ death is, and to then ask themselves about ‘who’ death is. The idea of who death is, is challenged when Zusak writes, “Yes, I know it. In the darkness of my dark-beating heart, I know. He’d have loved it all right. You see? Even death has a heart.” (p262) Truncated sentences are used here to help quickly convey to the audience the new aspect of who death as a personified character is. Emotive language used by death in this quote allows the audience to see a compassionate side of death that is not normally explored in other texts. Death also states in this quote about how he has a heart which also makes the audience reconsider and change their perspectives of death…

    • 1949 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After being in the Lutz ghetto for months, Opa Samuel was taken away because the SS are rounding up everyone that was at the hospital last night. Surely they will be sent to Auschwitz, a death camp. Suddenly the word is spread that there will be a surprise search for hidden children. They decide to hide their children in the cupboard and hope they won't be found. Before they line up they slap their cheeks and bite their lips to look healthy. When the officer walks up he sends both Gertrude and Bridget to the the trucks. Aunt leah runs up and says that she won't leave them. “Casually the officer raised his pistol and shot. First the two girls and then Aunt Leah. In the head”. (49) Mia runs forward and gets shot by the officer. Daniel and his…

    • 204 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thornton heavily emphasizes the image of the Holocaust during Carlos’ stay at Amos and Sara’s refuge. Amos shares his and Sara’s experiences in Auschwitz with Carlos through his “...picture of people with no hair who looked like skeletons...either crying or laughing.” (78) The skeletons in the photograph, Amos and Sara, were liberated from the concentration camp and survived by maintaining hope in a future despite all the horrors that surrounded them. Sasha, the daughter of a friend of Amos and Sara’s, has her story told as well by Amos who explains that she “...offended a guard by asking for something to drink when she had a fever. He cut out her tongue with a bayonet and threw it in a refuse heap where a rat appeared to run off with it to his burrow.” (78) She still held onto hope despite the torture, pain, possibility of death, and eventual muteness. Sara, Amos, and Sasha were some of the few who survived the Holocaust with their hope and belief intact. They held onto their hope following the nightmare they were forced to live through and continued to maintain it throughout their lives thus giving them meaning and reason to live.…

    • 896 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Forgiving Dr. Mengele

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Eva Mozes Kor was a twin. Her and her twin were both Auschwitz survivors. The main point in this film is that forgiving someone is good for you. Eva and her twin were separated from their family right as they arrived to the camp. Not only did they have to work, but because they were twins they got sent through several tests and experiments. Eva saw bodies and didn’t let herself think that was going to be her. She refused to let herself or her sister die. She said that if she died through Dr. Mengele’s experiments, then he would win, she didn’t let him. Eva and her twin got injected with something that affected their bodies and made them very ill. After Eva’s injection, Dr. Mengele said she had about two weeks. But that didn’t stop Eva. Towards the end of the two weeks she found herself crawling on the floor searching for some water to drink, telling herself, “Im not going to die.” She didn’t. The war ended and they got saved. Eva felt as if she was more her twins mother than her sister because she was always taking care of her. Later on, Eva’s sister had a serious problem, her kidneys had not grown. They were the same size as a ten year old’s. After there was no more Eva or the doctors could do she passed away. Eva began looking for answers. What was the injection that caused her sisters kidneys to stop growing? How could someone do this to a child? The answers weren’t ever found. Eva couldn’t find any records of anything Mengele had done. She did find a German doctor that was in Auschwitz at the time. The fear of having a conversation with the doctor, the German doctor, was bad. It turned out that the doctor was very nice and respectful to Eva. He had no answers but knew that all of Mengele’s experiments were very private. She felt the need to forgive this doctor as a Jew, for all that he has done in the past. Eva was asked by a reporter if she thinks, since she forgave this doctor, she can forgive Dr.…

    • 617 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Separation of families was a strong and leading cause of unforgiveness during the Holocaust and Khmer Rouge. Mam stated that little children were taking out of homes so that the Khmer Rouge could indoctrinate them. Stein, the niece of Eliezer's mother finds Eliezer and his father at Auschwitz and is desperate to hear news of his family.…

    • 651 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Elli, her mother and all of the prisoners they meet all have to undergo numerous physical and psychological hardships when they are forced into the concentration camps. They are treated like cattle on their way to the slaughterhouse when they are taken from their houses to the ghetto, then to the synagogue, and eventually to Auschwitz, the death camp.…

    • 924 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Summer Reading Question

    • 868 Words
    • 1 Page

    2. The effect of guilt is one of the major themes of the novel. Based on…

    • 868 Words
    • 1 Page
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Onward, patience from all members is a necessity to inherit absolution. Particularly, in Albom’s novel, Chick’s daughter, Maria, finally forgives Chick’s failures, but this is only done after she is given time and space away from him. At the same time, Chick must be patient in trying to reestablish his relationship with Maria. Chick recalls how the last time he is close to Maria is when she is a teenager and he continues to reminisce, “I had fallen out of my daughter’s life...I had sunk so low I had been banished from her wedding. She [Maria] used to love me, she honestly did. She used to run at me when I came home from work… ‘Maria is ashamed of me,’ I finally mumbled” (Albom 88). Decades later, he finally renews his relationship with Maria…

    • 1367 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout history families have been negatively impacted due to political oppression. Similarly in the case of The Chrysalids families that have a member with a deformity, are often forced to either kill their loved one or move to the fringes. The religious prejudice that people have on blasphemies, changed the life of Sophie Wender; a young girl that has six toes since birth. Sophie was forced to leave Waknuk and start a new life in the fringes, after her secret was revealed. Negatively changing her entire family’s lifestyle. This incident is identical to the holocaust. Near the early 1940s many Jews went into hiding for years, trying to save themselves and their families from the wrath of the Nazi’s. This had a negative impact on their lives, similar to Sophie, as they were forced to leave their homes and start a new life from nothing. Both cases show how lives change when a family is forced to flee into hiding.…

    • 471 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lois Lowry wrote an award Winning book called "The Giver", the story is based on a dystopian world were no one is able to make their own choices and their emotions are controlled.The story is about a boy named Jonas who is chosen to be a receiver, and receives memories from the Giver. Jonas notices what's happening in the memories and how wonderful some are, but he is also shown the truth behind being released, very very cruel, the way they kill innocent people Jonas just does not like that. Jonas and The Giver decided that everyone in the community needs to know the truth. They made a plan to escape the community and leak the memories, Jonas set off on a journey. This story is about taking risks and making choices, because mostly everyone in the story makes a choice that decides their fate.…

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays