What Is Franklin's Argument in "Remarks Concerning the Savages of North America"? What Examples Does He Provide to Prove This Argument?

Topics: Native Americans in the United States, Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson Pages: 2 (652 words) Published: September 9, 2012
“Remarks concerning the savages of North America " is a part of Early American Literature that highlights Franklin's criticism of the Native Americans being referred to as savages. This essay is based on Franklin’s experiences with the social and cultural nature of the Native Americans. Franklins description of native life are described in such a way as to emphasize some of the failings of his own western society. This essay was written in 1784. In this remarkable essay Franklin makes observations on how the society of Native Americans differs from that of white English America. The main point that Franklin was aiming for is that Native Americans are anything but savages. Franklin wanted to convince people that just because a culture is different than our own does not mean they are savages and unclean. He even goes as far in his arguments to say that in some respects, the native American culture and people are more polite than the British.

Throughout the entire document it gives example after example of ways the Indians respect the white peoples values and cultures and in return and in return the Americans believe the Indians values are barbaric. Benjamin Franklin was explaining the differences between the Indians and the Americans and asking, why should the Native Americans be called savages just because their lifestyle is different than others. One of the first examples given was, in 1744 at the Treaty of Lancaster the Six Nations thought it would be a good idea to make a proposal asking the Indians to send some of their young men to college in Virginia so they could teach them the lifestyle that the Americans know and practice. Ben Franklin wanted to represent the Native American people as smart and educated, just not in the same way the British were used to. The Indians had no police or anyone to govern their tribes and nobody to punish them. Ben Franklin made quite a few observations in this essay. The first one he spoke of was a...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Essay about Remarks Concerning the Savages of North America

    ...Remarks Concerning the Savages of North America In the “Remarks Concerning the Savages of North America” Benjamin Franklin writes about the Native American people and their way of life. In Benjamin Franklin’s essay he shows that the Native American people are far from savages. He explains how they are indeed civilized people. He says “perhaps, if we examine the manners of different nations with the impartiality, we should find no people so rude, as not to have some remains of rudeness.” The reason the Native Americans were called “savages” was because their rules of common civility, religion, laws and culture were different from the American culture and being that we were just socializing we did not understand their way of life. Franklin wanted people to know that the Native Americans were far from “savages” he in fact went on to express how they were and still are regular human beings. He explained how the Indian men were the backbone of their culture. The young Indian men were the warriors and hunters, the older Indians were counselors. He said “for all their government was a counsel of the sages; there was no force, there was no prisons, no officers to compel obedience, or inflict...

    Read More
    822 Words 2 Pages
  • Remarks Concerning the Savages of North America Essay

    ...Remarks concerning the Savages of North America Benjamin Franklin''s argument was explaining the difference in lifestyles of the Indians and the Americans. Why should they be called savages just because their lifestyle is different than ours. The Indians have no police or anyone to rule the disobedience of their community nor anyone to punish them. The Indian men are the backbone of their culture they are hunters and warriors and the women are there solely to take care of the children and nourish the lands why did the Six Nations believe that there was room for improvement in their community, they wanted to instill some of their values to the Indians. In 1744 at the Treaty of Lancaster the Six Nations thought it would be a good idea to make an proposal to the Indians in asking them to send some of their young men to a college in Virginia so they could teach them the lifestyle that they knew. Meanwhile the Indians have their own set of rules they did not respond immediately for it is their culture not to respond until the next day or they would seem rude. But they did not think that it would be a wise decision to send their men to Virginia because the white mans values were a lot different than there''s .They had some past experiences with the white man that the oppositions were not strong. The Indians felt the white man had no moral values when it came to either living...

    Read More
    513 Words 2 Pages
  • Elements of the Argument: "What Is Poverty?" Essay

    ...Elements of the Argument: "What is Poverty?" Steve Ross Expository Writing Dr. Nancy Nester Final 10/25/96 What do you consider poverty to be? Do you have a definitive explanation of it or do you consider it an abstract circumstance? In the article "What is Poverty?", Jo Goodwin Parker gives her ideas on what poverty is. First given as a speech, this article is written as an attack on human emotion. Her use of connotative language creates many harsh images of her experiences in a life of poverty. By using these images, Parker is capable of causing the reader to feel many emotions and forces the reader to question his or her own stereotypes of the poor. With the use of connotative language and the ability to arouse emotion, Parker successfully compels the reader to examine his or her thoughts and beliefs on who the poor are. Parker's use of connotative language causes the reader to feel many emotions. Of these emotions, a prominent one is guilt. Parker is capable of making the reader feel guilty for the possessions that he or she has. For example, she uses the phrase "You say in your clean clothes coming from your clean house, ..."(Parker 237). This causes the reader to feel guilty for having the opportunity to be clean when we all know that she doesn't have the same. She calls hot water a "luxury"(Parker 237). To those living in...

    Read More
    1102 Words 3 Pages
  • What Are the Arguments for and Against Intervention? Essay

    ...intervention, but may include losses of individual freedoms and unintended consequences.  This question will examine numerous areas in which the Government intervenes in and evaluate whether it does so in a positive or negative way. A conclusion will then be made to decide whether government intervention is an advantage or a disadvantage as a whole. ADVANTAGE 1 (INTERVENING IN BUSINESS):  One of the major areas in which the government intervenes is in business, for example by creating a minimum wage for all workers.  This means that no matter the job and responsibilities, a worker must be paid at least a certain wage for the labour they provide to a company.  This can be considered to be an advantage of government intervention as it determines that anything lower than the minimum wage is not enough for a person to live on  This is an also an advantage as the minimum wage also forbids workers from selling their labour at a lower rate, meaning that people cannot out-price the competition in terms of employability. ADVANTAGE 2 (INTERVENING IN BANKING):  One of the major areas in which the government intervenes is in banking, for example helping economic downturn lessen or stop completely through the use of bailouts.  This means that many old standing businesses will remain thanks to tax incentives, with...

    Read More
    716 Words 3 Pages
  • What Is an Argument Essay

    ...I learned what the meaning of an argument was along with the term valid and sound argument. Many people might have their own opinion on what an argument is but in Humanities an argument is a list of reasons that fit together in a particular way to support some conclusion. In everyday situations, when two people have an argument, it means they disagree about something, but in this case argument means dispute. An argument is mostly used in politics. When it comes to what a valid argument is and what a sound argument is confusion begin to arise because they both are similar in a way. A valid argument is an argument whose conclusion follows its premise. When it comes to a valid argument it can have true or false premises and conclusions. A sound argument is a little simpler to detect then a valid argument because it is a valid argument with true premises. So, if all the premises are true it is a sound argument. A great example of a sound argument is: (A.) All birds can fly. (B.) A penguin is a bird. (C.) A penguin can fly. This is a valid argument, because a penguin clearly cannot fly. The premise all birds can fly is false. Another...

    Read More
    283 Words 1 Pages
  • What Makes a Good Argument? Essay

    ...What Makes a Good Argument? What makes a good argument? Is it one where we repeatedly push our ideas and beliefs without background information to support it? One ran by one-track minds that aren’t willing to look at the issue with new eyes? No it most certainly is not. A good argument is one derived from emotional connection and reason, Pathos and Logos make an argument engaging and factual. Pathos is a writer’s tool for appealing to a reader via an emotional connection. Empathizing with a person can often get them to see things your way. Especially if they know that you have been in the same position that they are now. Logos appeals to a reader through traditional forms of facts and “reason”. You can’t argue against hard facts very easily, now can you? A trending and controversial topic currently is about names. Names can sometimes become a source of a dispute. Often people argue about what name something should have. How do we decide what our kids’ surnames will be? How do we name a period of time in history? What should we call our school’s mascot or our car in the driveway? In our text book, “America Now”, we have a few essays written regarding the different issues with how names should be bestowed. One essay that I found particularly persuasive was the agreeing side of a debate from the writing “Brain, Child”....

    Read More
    1068 Words 3 Pages
  • WHAT THE H2!? Essay

    ...WHAT THE H2!? 09-10-13 This is journal entry #20 10:30 AM 8/10/2050: The riots are still raging in the streets and gas prices are $200 a gallon. It has been 15 days since we have been told that there is no more fossil fuels. Our civilization is at the tipping point; like I said there is violent riots in the streets the lights are not turning on and neither is the water. My mom tells me it’s like this because when she was a kid everyone abandoned the idea of “clean energy” because they were told that scientists figured out how to clean up the pollution. No one thought of when we were going to run out fossil fuel and now we have. We need a new source of power, a clean and unlimited reserve of energy, hydrogen. Hydrogen is a clean and unlimited resource. Hydrogen is a completely clean resource, when used in cars it’s only emission is water vapor and heat. Hydrogen is virtually unlimited when hydrogen runs out our universe will have ended ( most likely one hundred trillion years) 100,000,000,000,000 years from now. Hydrogen is extremely efficient, it is 3 times more efficient than gasoline. You can get 480 miles a tank with the Toyota FCHV. From coral you can make it all the way to San Diego, CA and go another 156 mi on one tank. Some argue that hydrogen is very flammable and can explode. Those that argue this are 100% correct but it is not any more flammable than the gasoline in your car right now....

    Read More
    342 Words 1 Pages
  • Arguments Essay

    ...Chiang Kai Shek who dominate the southern China and Taiwan. But the booklet 'On Protacted War' essay Mao Tse Tung changed his mind on the flow of communism. Clear determination to resist the Japanese invasion of Malaya then 1941. In 1940 he was accepted into the Communist Party of China Communist Party of the branches abroad. He also joined Force 136, an armed force established by the British spy against the Japanese in Malaya. When the age of 18. Chin Peng led MPAJA or Malayan People Anti Japanese Army, a guerrilla force against the Japanese. British Army (Force Special Air Services and MI6) that deployed in the jungles of Perak, has a variety of weapons, financing, training and a variety of other equipment to equip Force 136 and MPAJA. MPAJA Army attacked the Japanese army to the banks of the Silver River near Pasir Salak in 1942. After World War II, some of the radical faiths MPAJA acted out in the forest to kill punish them of collaborating with the Japanese and British stooge and also kill local leaders such as the Chieftain and the village priest as a tactic to strengthen their dominance. In addition, the radical faction in MPAJA also tried to seize administration especially in the south of Malaya. Radical action in this MPAJA have angered the Malays who came to oppose the communist party under leaders such as Chief Red Sling Salleh. As a result of the reaction of the Malays, the Communist Party failed to...

    Read More
    950 Words 3 Pages

Popular Essays

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free