What Is Franklin's Argument in "Remarks Concerning the Savages of North America"? What Examples Does He Provide to Prove This Argument?

Topics: Native Americans in the United States, Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, American Revolution / Pages: 3 (652 words) / Published: Sep 10th, 2012
Continue Reading
“Remarks concerning the savages of North America " is a part of Early
American Literature that highlights Franklin's criticism of the Native Americans being referred to as savages. This essay is based on Franklin’s experiences with the social and cultural nature of the Native Americans. Franklins description of native life are described in such a way as to emphasize some of the failings of his own western society. This essay was written in 1784. In this remarkable essay Franklin makes observations on how the society of Native
Americans differs from that of white English America. The main point that
Franklin was aiming for is that Native Americans are anything but savages.
Franklin wanted to convince people that just because a culture is different than our own does not mean they are savages and unclean. He even goes as far in his arguments to say that in some respects, the native American culture and people are more polite than the British. Throughout the entire document it gives example after example of ways the
Indians respect the white peoples values and cultures and in return and in return the Americans believe the Indians values are barbaric. Benjamin Franklin was explaining the differences between the Indians and the Americans and asking, why should the Native Americans be called savages just because their lifestyle is different than others. One of the first examples given was, in 1744 at the
Treaty of Lancaster the Six Nations thought it would be a good idea to make a proposal asking the Indians to send some of their young men to college in
Virginia so they could teach them the lifestyle that the Americans know and practice. Ben Franklin wanted to represent the Native American people as smart and educated, just not in the same way the British were used to. The Indians had no police or anyone to govern their tribes and nobody to punish them. Ben
Franklin made quite a few observations in this essay. The first

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Remarks Concerning the Savages of North America

    Remarks Concerning the Savages of North America In the “Remarks Concerning the Savages of North America” Benjamin Franklin writes about the Native American people and their way of life. In Benjamin Franklin’s essay he shows that the Native American people are far from savages. He explains how they are indeed civilized people. He says “perhaps, if we examine the manners of different nations with the impartiality, we should find no people so rude, as not to have some remains of rudeness.” The reason….

    Read More
    822 Words 4 Pages
  • Remarks Concerning the Savages of North America

    Remarks concerning the Savages of North America Benjamin Franklin''s argument was explaining the difference in lifestyles of the Indians and the Americans. Why should they be called savages just because their lifestyle is different than ours. The Indians have no police or anyone to rule the disobedience of their community nor anyone to punish them. The Indian men are the backbone of their culture they are hunters and warriors and the women are there solely to take care of the children and nourish….

    Read More
    513 Words 3 Pages
  • What Is an Argument

    learned what the meaning of an argument was along with the term valid and sound argument. Many people might have their own opinion on what an argument is but in Humanities an argument is a list of reasons that fit together in a particular way to support some conclusion. In everyday situations, when two people have an argument, it means they disagree about something, but in this case argument means dispute. An argument is mostly used in politics. When it comes to what a valid argument is and what a sound….

    Read More
    283 Words 2 Pages
  • Savages in North America

    Remarks Concerning the Savages of North America Benjamin Franklin describes the cultural difference between the savages and English in North America. “Perhaps, if we could examine the manners of different nations with impartiality, we should find no people so rude, as to be without as to be without any rules of politeness; nor any so polite as not to have some remains of rudeness” (Franklin 219). Franklin is saying that nations who are polite usually don’t have rules to have a polite society and….

    Read More
    319 Words 2 Pages
  • What Is Dennett's Argument?

    gives an argument that belief paradigm based on the intentional system, attribution in the cases he brought up leave as a great deal of the reasoning inexplicit. By using hypothetical scenario that he used for came up where a man is swerved because he wanted to avoid a detached hubcap. For argument Dennett, he asserts that is unlikely an explicit representation of the relevant propositional attitudes occurred in the man’s consciousness. Something was situations his not belief that means he is in danger….

    Read More
    624 Words 3 Pages
  • What Is The Federalist Argument

    Federalist Argument By James Beasley I have chosen the federalist point of view to portray in this argument. I have chosen this side of the argument because, the federalist stood for the voice of the people. They wanted equally spoken opinions of all people from any social class. Another reason why I have chosen the federalist point of view is due to the fact that they wanted a stronger central government. They also disagreed with factions which went against American values. In the following I….

    Read More
    505 Words 3 Pages
  • What Is a Solid Argument?

    A solid argument consists of a claim, reasons/evidence and conclusion. “Reasons are beliefs, evidence, metaphors, analogies, and other statements offered to support or justify conclusions. When a writer has a conclusion she wants you to accept, she must present reasons to persuade you that she is right and show you why. You cannot determine the worth of a conclusion until you identify the reasons” (Browne & Keeley, 2012, p.28). Absent reasons or conclusion the argument is weak, unclear, pointless….

    Read More
    282 Words 2 Pages
  • What Are The Arguments Of Dualism

    By examining dualism, idealism, and physicalism, it becomes clear that idealism has the best arguments in its favor and has the fewest philosophical problems. George Berkley, Rene Descartes, and J.J. C. Smart were philosophers who were trying to understand the relationship between the mind and the body. George Berkeley believed there are no mind independent objects, and that everything that exist only exist through one’s perceptions. Rene Descartes thought that the mind and body had a causal relationship….

    Read More
    422 Words 2 Pages
  • to what extent is the cosmological argument a weak argument

    To what extent is the cosmological argument weak? Although the cosmological argument is a strong argument for the theory that the universe it is a weak argument for the existence of the classical theological God. Thomas Aquinas was a very important man to the cosmological argument; it was him who came up with some of the strongest theories to support the argument. He came up with his five proofs which to him proved the cosmological argument to be true. One of his proof was the ‘cause’ proof….

    Read More
    495 Words 2 Pages
  • Does the First Cause Argument Prove That God Exists?

    ‘The First Cause Argument Proves that God Exists.’ Do You Agree? The First cause, or cosmological, argument suggested by Thomas Aquinas is that everything that comes into being must have a cause. They can’t cause themselves, so they must be caused by something outside themselves. This chain can’t regress forever, so there must be a transcendent power that began the chain. That is god. Another argument, the Kalam Cosmological argument, states that everything that comes into being must….

    Read More
    797 Words 4 Pages

Popular Essays