Preview

was the united states justified in going to war with mexico

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
624 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
was the united states justified in going to war with mexico
Amy Pham6 th HourDBQMexico and the United States were two nations whose opinionsdiffered from each other. In 1846, a war broke out between the two overdisputed territories. The Mexican-American war was one of the mostcontroversial events that occurred in the 19 th century. Both nationsclaimed that the other was at fault for causing the war. The Mexicans mayhave had their reasons for thinking so; however, the Americans wereequally justified, if not more, in going to war with Mexico.One of the main conflicts that drove intentions of going to war wasa disagreement of what the true border between Mexico and Texas shouldhave been. The Mexicans thought of the Nueces River as the appropriateboundary, while the Americans insisted on the Rio Grande to be theTexas-Mexico border. Not only did Mexico have Texas, but also a territorythat extended all the way up to the Oregon territory. John On Sullivan said,oe hampering our power, limiting our greatness and checking th
Amy Pham6 th HourDBQMexico and the United States were two nations whose opinionsdiffered from each other. In 1846, a war broke out between the two overdisputed territories. The Mexican-American war was one of the mostcontroversial events that occurred in the 19 th century. Both nationsclaimed that the other was at fault for causing the war. The Mexicans mayhave had their reasons for thinking so; however, the Americans wereequally justified, if not more, in going to war with Mexico.One of the main conflicts that drove intentions of going to war wasa disagreement of what the true border between Mexico and Texas shouldhave been. The Mexicans thought of the Nueces River as the appropriateboundary, while the Americans insisted on the Rio Grande to be theTexas-Mexico border. Not only did Mexico have Texas, but also a territorythat extended all the way up to the Oregon territory. John On Sullivan said,oe hampering our power, limiting our greatness and checking th
Amy Pham6 th HourDBQMexico and the United

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    In chapter three of “Occupied America, A History of Chicanos,” Acuna explains the cause of the war between Mexico and North America. Eugene C. Barker states that the immediate cause of the war was “the overthrow of the nominal republic by Santa Anna and the substitution of centralized oligarchy” which allegedly would have centralized Mexican control (Acuna 39). Texas history is a mixture of selected fact and generalized myth. The expansion and capitalist development moved together. The two Mexican wars gave U.S. commerce, industry, mining, agriculture, and stock rising. The truth is that the Pacific Coast belonged to the commercial empire that the United States was already building in that ocean. In the Polk-Stockton Intrigue, Americans found it rather more difficult than other people to deal rationally with their wars. Many Anglo-American historians attempted to dismiss it simply as a “bad war”, which took place during the era of Manifest Destiny. Most studies on the war dwell on the causes and results of the war, and dealing with war strategy. The attitude of Mexicans toward Anglo-Americans was obviously influenced by the war and vice-versa. In the end, by late 1847 the war was almost at an end. Scott’s defeat of Santa Anna in a hard fought battle at Churubusco…

    • 1328 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mexican War Dbq Essay

    • 678 Words
    • 3 Pages

    and Texas believed that the Rio Grande was the proper border between Mexico and Texas.” (Roden 315). They believed that the Rio Grande was the proper border. “Mexico thought the Nueces River was the proper border between Texas and Mexico.” (Roden 315).This quote shows that there was some confusion on where the border was. Some of the territory was disputed.. This information shows that no one knew where real territory was or who it belonged to. Polk sent an envoy to try to buy California. This information shows that Polk wanted more land. There was disputed territory that no one had declared. This is why the U.S. was not justified in going to war with…

    • 678 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Mexican American War

    • 409 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Many attempts have been made to rationalize the war as just and right. Polk claimed that the United States had been provoked into war by Mexico, and that what motivated him to go to war was, "the strong desire to establish peace with Mexico on liberal and honorable terms . . ." Pulitzer prize winner Justin H. Smith claimed that Mexico was simply unable to understand or appreciate the goodwill and righteousness of her northern neighbor. These and other rational for the Mexican war are simply cover-ups for the truth. The Mexican-American War was a premeditated act of aggression on the part of the U.S. government, perpetrated upon a weak, defenseless people.…

    • 409 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mexican American War

    • 4451 Words
    • 18 Pages

    The Mexican American War began on April 25, 1846. The war lasted two years losing many men on both sides. The Mexican war was the third major fought by the United States. In 1810, Miguel Hidalgo y Costilla triggers the beginning of Mexico’s fight for independence from Spain. Mexico gained its independence in 1821 after a long and bloody revolution against Spain. For Mexico, the war between them and the United States was a fight to keep their institutions and national integrity intact, to protect themselves from present and future aggressions by the Americans, but more than anything else, the war was a struggle for land. In the early days of the republic, most Americans made their living by farming, so in 1803 President Thomas Jefferson purchased the Louisiana Purchase Territory because he wanted to provide “room enough for out descendants to the thousandth and ten thousandth generation.” In 1803 the United States purchased land from Napoleon west of the Mississippi, also known as the Louisiana Purchase. The Unites States nearly doubled in size, extending its borders two thirds of the way from the Atlantic Ocean to the Pacific Ocean. In 1804-1806 the Lewis and Clark expedition explores western North America. Mexico had a population of only about 2,500 living in Texas, they offered cheap land to attract Americans and build up the territory. Mexico only allowed one religion which was Catholicism and for everyone to follow the teachings of the church. The U.S government marked the route of the Santa Fe Trail so settlers in New Mexico can get goods from the U.S that they have not been able to get from Mexico. By the early 1800s many of the inhabitants of Mexico didn’t like the Spanish Rule and wanted to establish a democratic government. In 1810 there were several executions. The gachupines (those born in Spain) executed Miguel Hidalgo y Costilla who had led a large group of mestizos (the offspring of mixed marriages) who were rebels in…

    • 4451 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Mexican-American War

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The physical beginning of the Mexican-American war between the United States and Mexico began with a Mexican attack on American troops who were stationed on the southern border of Texas on April 25, 1846. The swift conclusion to the war took place as General Winfield Scott occupied the Mexican capitol city, Mexico City on September 14, 1847. Within a few months, the Treaty of Guadalupe was signed with Mexico recognizing the US annexation of Texas as well as Mexico succeeding from California and New Mexico.1 The causes of the Mexican-American war varies from historian to historian. Some blame a dictatorial Centralist government of Mexico beginning the war by continuing to claim Texas even after its establishment of an independent republic. Others argue the United States provoked war with Mexico by annexing Texas as well as stationing troops at the Mexican border. A final thought is that the greed of United States President James Polk who “forced Mexico to war in order to seize California and the Southwest”.2 The most likely cause of the Mexican-American War is a combination of the three.…

    • 1043 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Mexican-American War

    • 844 Words
    • 4 Pages

    “America’s wars have often been controversial” (Roden 317). The Mexican- American War was not an exception to this rule. Many Mexicans felt that they were cheated their land. On the other hand, the US felt it was their destiny to conquer the whole North American continent and Mexico was in the way of their greatness (Roden 317). The belief in Manifest Destiny, that the USA started the conflict, and that the US had no right to Texas are all reasons that the US was not justified in taking about half of Mexico.…

    • 844 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1846-1848 the first U.S. armed conflict fought on foreign soil happened, the Mexican-American War. The administration of the President, James Polk, believed they had a "manifest destiny" to spread across the continet, over to the Pacific Ocean. When the war was over Mexico had lost some where around one-third of it's territory, the U.S. claimed present-day places like California, Utah, Nevada, Arizona, and New Mexico.…

    • 443 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mexican War Dbq

    • 789 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The United States in 1846 was not justified in going to war with Mexico. The United States did not have proper justification to respond with violence against the Mexican government. The war with Mexico was also a product of the United States’ belief of Manifest Destiny. Polk’s over ambition to seize new territory from the Mexicans and disappointment over their refusal to sell him California also possibly played a factor in his willingness to wage war against Mexico. The United States under the leadership of President Polk clearly provoked Mexico into attacking US troops. To no extent was the Mexican War a justifiable war. All these reasons show that the US had no business starting a war with Mexico for territory that was rightfully theirs.…

    • 789 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Even though there was a peace treaty wrote up before the fighting began Mexico did not consider it much of a compromise. They would lose all of Texas, Oregon and California. From the Mexican view point it looked like that had no choice but to fight the matter out. If they did not stand up for themselves they would look like a weak country. It seemed to them that the Americans were not treating them fairly. So, they started taking action. Which ended in an all out war.…

    • 594 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    The Mexican American war had numerous argument espoused both for and against the Annexation of Texas. The reasons against the war are very well articulated and deserve attention. However,…

    • 1786 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    A second reason the Mexican War was justified was an invasion that Mexico has passed the boundary of the U.S. (Doc B) James Polk, an American Political wrote to the Senate and House of Representatives that was a war message from the President. James informed the Senate & House of Representatives to order an efficient military to take position on the Rio Grande to meet a threatened invasion of Texas by the Mexican forces. Mexican troops were preparing to cross the river. This evidence shows the U.S. was justified in going to war with Mexico because Mexico had killed and injured sixteen Americans,…

    • 584 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mexican American War

    • 310 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The Mexican American War was a conflict between the United States and Mexico. This was a battle for land where Mexico was fighting to keep what they thought was their property and the U.S. desired to retain the disputed land of Texas and obtain more of Mexico’s northern lands. There were two main causes of the Mexican War. First, the idea of “Manifest destiny” meaning the belief that America had a God-given right to occupy and civilize the whole continent. As large number of Americans migrated towards the west searching for land, the fact that most of those areas already had people living in them was ignored. Instead, an attitude and belief that democratic Americans would do a better job of running the lands than the Native Americans prevailed. President Polk shared and led the vision of Manifest Destiny, and did offer to buy the southwest land from Mexico. However, the Mexican government refused the offer, and because of this tensions continued to rise. The second major cause of the Mexican War actually started off with the Texas War of independence .During the 1830s, Mexico needed settlers in the under populated northern parts of the country and therefore allowed U.S. citizens to come and live in the Texas area as long as they took an oath of allegiance to Mexico and converted to Catholicism. Thousands of Americans accepted the invitation and migrated to the Mexican province of Texas. However, many of the new “Texans” were not satisfied with the way the Mexican government tried to run the province. So that led to the Texas Revolution began as both Mexicans and Americans living in Texas fought for independence from the Mexican government. A final victory resulted in the capture of the Mexican President who was forced to sign the Treaty of Velasco, granting Texas its…

    • 310 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Having many settlers all over the territories supported them in gaining this. For example, by 1830 there were more than 20.000 Americans lived in Texas and they were opposing Mexicans government. “These settlers did not intend to become Mexican citizens. Instead, they planned to take over Texas.” (Out of Many, 245) Thus, it leaded to the war. Although Mexican-American war gained so many pros and contras, but it was clear that the government at that time did whatever it takes to complete their Manifest Destiny. It was the president James K.Polk from Democratic Party who was an expansionist. He was optimistic to make America stretched from the east until west coast. So, he sent his secret envoy, John Slidell to offer Mexico some money in order to buy their lands but Slidell was rejected. Angry Polk sent his army to the disputed zone making his soldiers involved in skirmish with Mexican soldiers. He lied that Mexico started it first and asked congress for war; “War exist, and, notwithstanding all our efforts to avoid it, exists by the act of Mexico herself. This claim of President Polk’s was of course contrary to fact.” (Out of Many, 247) It was clear that he wanted to expand America, although by war, because the beginning of the war was confusing, no one knows what the reality happened at the border that raised the war. Even Abraham Lincoln questioned Polk’s account of the border incident. (Out…

    • 1315 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Manifest Destiny

    • 370 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Similar to the case for and against Manifest Destiny, the case for and against the war with Mexico is controversial. The Mexican-American war can be looked at many ways: such as a war for more land, more slavery, and economic expansion. Many people believed that expansion was needed because of the growing population. Polk a proponent of Manifest destiny desired to expand and therefore supported the war. War with Mexico offered the chance to acquire Texas and California. John Harmanson stated in a speech, “It is not an ‘unjust, unconstitutional, and damnable war,’ or one that could have been avoided with honor. […] By insult and defiance. Nothing but war would do her. Let her have it, then, to her heart’s content.” (5) Thus, the country is bound to go to war and therefore expand. Many people felt that expanding westward was the best possible thing to do. Many agreed with Robert Johanssen. He stated, “To extend the boundaries of the United States was to extend the area of freedom,” (5) Expanding land would give many opportunities allowing many to fulfill their dreams.…

    • 370 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Winston Churchill once said “Manifest destiny was on the march, and it was unfortunate that Mexico stood in the path.” In 1845, the Republic of Texas was annexed to the United States of America. There was one problem, though. Mexico and the United States disagreed on the border of Texas, whether it was on the Nueces River or Rio Grande River. There was a war between the two countries that lasted from 1846 to 1848. After the Mexican army lost, they surrendered Nevada, California, Utah, Arizona, Colorado, New Mexico, and Wyoming. Also, in the Oregon Treaty of 1846, under…

    • 217 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays