Preview

Was Christopher Colombus a Hero or Villian

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
790 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Was Christopher Colombus a Hero or Villian
October 15, 2012 Was Christopher Columbus a Hero or a Villain to America? Yes, Columbus discovered America, but do you know how many deaths and how much destruction it cost? Columbus went to explore the ocean and he found a new continent, North America. He was actually looking for India and its gold but found a different place. Exploration of North America brought so many bad things to people. All of those things happened because of Columbus. It makes one want to say that Columbus is a villain.
First thing that makes Columbus a "bad guy" is lying. Columbus lied to the queen about the explored island. He said that there's a lot of gold and spices, and people there would share anything with anyone. Columbus also lied that he reached Asia, which was his destination spot. He said all those things to make the queen believe that he's a good man and to save himself from the death. Five hundred years before Columbus was even born, the Vikings settled land in northern North America. They were the true discoverers of the New World. Christopher Columbus merely takes credit while the Vikings are remembered as drunken savages. Not only did he not discover the New World, but his calculations were based on other's works. What kind of "hero" can't find his way to where he wants to go and then receives the credit for a complete and utter accident! This doesn't only make him a liar but it also makes him selfish. But yet we Americans still nationally celebrate his “accomplishments” that were all just faux.
Another interesting fact about Columbus being a villain is that he deculturalized people. When he arrived, he started to control all of the land. He wanted to shape the Americas into a European society, and he did not want to consider the current ways of the Native American practices into his new society. In fact, he would kill-or have his men-kill the Natives if he felt that they were being too unruly. For example how Columbus was on a mission to convert everyone to

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Taking into consideration the moral standards of the 1490’s Europe, Christopher Columbus is clearly guilty of the crimes against him. The crimes are as follows: he and his men were responsible for the deaths of many of the indigenous people referred to by Columbus as “Indians,” and accused of causing ecological devastation through the importing of plant and animal life not native to the Western Hemisphere. Columbus physically interacted with the Native Americans by using force to get what he wanted, and carried out massacres and strange cruelties to the defenseless men, women, and children of the Indian tribes. Columbus also started what is called the “Great Disease Migration” by bringing dangerous diseases into a world venerable to these diseases.…

    • 656 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Columbus is known for discovering America, but he did not because it was already inhabited by other settlers. For instance, “The American Heritage Dictionary defines ‘discover’ as ‘To be the first to find, learn of, or observe’”. (Source 4). It is not possible to discover a place which tens of millions already know about. Columbus also got credit for proving that the world was not flat, and was actually round. This is also incorrect because during that time educated Europeans did not believe the earth was flat, but “the few who did believe so, the ones routinely cited by modern historians to support the medieval flat earth idea, were the exceptions rather than the rule, ridiculed by their peers.” (Source 4). Lastly, Columbus was said to have spread Christianity. The Natives of the Caribbean were demolished within two generations by the Spanish discoverer. None of the generations were “converted to the Catholic faith, which was supposedly a prime motive of those voyages.” (Source 4). As you can see, Columbus clearly does not deserve the credit for doing nothing.…

    • 668 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Due to Christopher Columbus’s self-motivated actions, he should be considered a tyrant by America. When Columbus landed on America, he enslaved many Native Americans and forced them to do as he asked. He also stole most of their gold and pushed them away from their lands when he brought 17 ships and 1500 people to take over. These actions exposed his corrupt motives. Although Columbus discovered America for Spain, he treated the Native Americans with disrespect, proving that he does not deserve his own…

    • 85 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Christopher Columbus (1451 - 1506) is claimed to be discoverer of America in 1492. Many people in today’s society believe this lie, for in fact Columbus did not discover America. Columbus has been classified a villain for various reasons, one of those reasons being that he is receiving all the credit for something that he did not do. The only thing that Columbus did was open up the passageway to America for the Europeans, who really discovered America.…

    • 274 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Christopher Columbus is not what people actually perceive him as.Christopher Columbus is not the great man that we celebrate 1 monday out of the month of October,he has done countless horrible things to Native Americans.Christopher Columbus did not discover America,He enslave Native Americans,and he did not prove the earth was round.Christopher Columbus was not even his real name,his name is Christoforo Columbo and he was born…

    • 68 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    First of all, Christopher Columbus was credited and rewarded for being the first person to ascertain America. Columbus was recognized as the discoverer of America, even though he didn’t discover America. Is this fair, should Christopher Columbus be remembered for a happening that he didn’t complete? Christopher Columbus arrived to America when he was on his voyage exploring the unknown seas. However, for him to go on his trip he had Queen Isabella fund him. It took Christopher Columbus seven years to convince Queen Isabella into funding his journey. Columbus went on a journey and when he got to America the Vikings and Native Americans had already been there, before him. Since the Vikings and Native Americans…

    • 573 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I must admit, at the onset, that I have a pretty negative thoughts about Columbus. My teenage idealization of the man who "discovered" America was crushed when I read the text book and hearing class discussions. From the book, I learned how Columbus enslaved and murdered thousands of Arawaks and other Native American people. The New World he had once portrayed as a paradise had swiftly spun into something much darker. Columbus's actions were unjustifiable immoral, to say the very least, inhumane. However, he honestly believed that he was doing a good thing by "converting" the Arawaks. Based on the cruel historical events and the fact that he didn’t really discover America. Why should he be celebrated?…

    • 396 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    first thing that made Columbus a bad guy, was the lie that he told everyone. Columbus…

    • 216 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    When I was younger I was taught in school that Christopher Columbus was a brave and determined man who set sail in 1492 in search of a water route to Asia, resulting in him being the first man to discover the Americas. Since then I’ve come to realize that is he anything but that. Higher education schooling has taught me that he in fact did not discover the Americas, and instead was a ruthless ethnocentric man who’s greed led to slavery, torture, and mass decline of Native Americans. Which leads me to my opinion that we should not continue to glorify Christopher Columbus and celebrate his “achievements” with a day dedicated to him.…

    • 525 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I wasn’t a big fan of the film 1492. The portrayal of Christopher Columbus in this film was very inaccurate as far as what he brought to the so-called "New World". The film displayed Columbus as the first person to locate America and to cross the Atlantic Ocean but as history shows others had accomplished this years before he did. In the film he could be looked at as both the villain and as a hero. He was obviously looked at as a hero to some because he is the one who was supposedly responsible of discovering America. Even though Christopher Columbus is thought to have discovered the New World, a lot of people considered him to be a villain because of the way he treated the indigenous people he met. He enslaved natives and demanded…

    • 353 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Columbus had taken credit for things that he didn’t accomplish. He wasn’t the first to discover America since there were already people living there and others had known about this land. Also, there was a myth being taught at schools that had said Columbus was the one to prove the earth was round. Many educated Europeans had already believed in the world not being flat during the time of Columbus. However, those who didn’t agree with this statement mocked the ones who did. Lastly, Columbus was not the first non-American to discover the new world. “There is, indeed, considerable evidence that people from all around the world, including Europe, had visited the Americas for trade, fishing, refuge, and even settlement.” (Source: Why We Should Abolish Columbus Day by G Rebecca Dobbs) Therefore, Columbus had not truly succeeded in the things we know about him and did more negative things than positive.…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    Christopher Columbus found a new world and jumpstarted an age of exploration like no other. After he found the Americas there was massive colonization, giant trade increases and more resources such as gold and silver were being surfaced. Europeans learned new agricultural techniques from the indigenous people, the Europeans also acquired a large number of new crops to farm such as potatoes, tomatoes, corn and cocoa. With all of the pros that the age of exploration brought to Europeans it is hard for one to imagine that Christopher Columbus could be a villain. Could there possibly be evil behind some of the wonderful discoveries of Christopher Columbus? The problem is exactly what you just read, people only know the good things Christopher Columbus brought to the world and they ignore the terrible things he did. Christopher Columbus was a villain because his discovery of the Americas eventually leads to the destruction of Native American culture, he was not the first European explorer to land in America, and he did now accomplish his mission to find India…

    • 2037 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Should a man whose actions created a wave of genocide and killed thousands of innocent natives be considered a hero? Christopher Columbus found the Americas, but today he takes credit for discovering a new world. Native Americans had been living in civilizations across North and South America long before Columbus had "discovered" it. This journey has now ruined many of those cultivations as well as the citizens. With his expedition, he exposed countries to new disease and violence. His greed led him to deprive America of its natives and its resources. Thirdly, he also introduced Native Americans to slavery. These horrible monstrosities should be added to Columbus's reputation, which shows him to be a villain in American history. Christopher Columbus had evil intentions from the start of his voyage when he promised to repay Ferdinand, Spanish monarch and founder of Columbus's travels, with gold, spice, and other resources. When he first arrived in what he thought was Asia, he quickly gathered the natives and introduced them to slavery. What he did was wrong and he shouldn’t be celebrated.…

    • 562 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Columbus a hero or a villain?, This question has plagued historians thru out the ages and its based on this question that Zinn and Schweikart answer in different ways. Howard Zinn in the first chapter of his book “A People's History of the United States” talks a bout…

    • 1576 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Columbus day is a national holiday in America celebrating the man that “discovered’ America. The problem is that he did nothing good for America. He brought slaves and disease to America, or what he thought was Asia. Columbus was an Italian, when Italy didn’t want to pay for his voyages he went to Spain's king and queen to ask them for the money, they agreed on the condition that he paid them back. When Columbus got to what he thought was Asia, but in reality was the caribbean islands, he captured slaves and sent them back to spain. This didn’t make him as much money as he hoped because most of the slaved died on the ships returning from the caribbean. When he went back he had the help of hundreds of slaves to help him find gold. When the…

    • 412 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays