Preview

Voluntary Argumentative Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
438 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Voluntary Argumentative Analysis
Green rejects voluntary slave contracts in a free society founded on the idea that a totally free society should enable all of its citizens to be able to work freely. This also includes the right to enter into labor contracts, without giving up their rights to health and life. He argues that in a free society, each individual must be able to contribute positively to society in some other way outside of their labor. He also claims that a society should be able to prevent an even outlaw voluntary slavery contracts because even if it is voluntary, the slave is put into a position that denies the ability to work as a healthy and contributing member of society and in to a situation of servitude.
In contrast, libertarians and neoclassical liberals like Nozick may defend a person’s right to enter into a voluntary slave contract with another based on the idea of complete freedom for someone to do whatever they wish with themselves and their property. Those groups see labor as a simple business transaction between two people. This is where a worker can sell his time,
…show more content…
You cannot rid yourself of free will and even if you currently volunteer yourself into slavery, your future self could change your mind and want out. At this point you are no longer a volunteer but forced to be held. Thus, the term volunteer slave is contradictory at best and in no way can be used in a legal contract. However, it is incumbent on the civil society to set the stage for this idea to be unheard of. Societies or governments should set up healthcare, provide educational opportunities, and pass laws that encourage safe and fair working conditions that eliminate the need to give or sell one’s self into bondage. If someone was to feel the need to sell themselves into slavery then society and the government around it has failed as a whole and will eventually

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Indentured servitude and slavery existed in the ‘New World’ primarily for economic and population growth. In the book, Going to the Source, Slavery was defined as “hereditary” and “a lifetime status” and the slave must serve for life, however, on the other hand indentured servitude was “contractual” and “voluntary” although the servant is forced to serve for a fixed amount of years. Indentured servitude and slavery are strikingly parallel to each other from the fact that both parties participate in physically demanding labor and endure severe punishments induced by their master, nevertheless, the contractual agreement to each party is quite different, plus the primary skin color of the of party heavily impacts the treatment and escape punishments…

    • 269 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The topic sentence is clear in this paragraph but is missing information. I expected to be reading about Vancity’s launch of Fair and Fast and that is what is included; detailed information was given to expand on what is Fair and Fast and how it operates. I do think that topic sentence should have included talking about low-income needs in order for me to anticipate the information included in the paragraph where Jerry Buckland is quoted and his experiences and expertise is quoted to support the need for small short-term bank loans that available to more people. I would have it read: In June 2014, Vancity launched Fair and Fast, offering sums between $100 and $1,500, addressing a need to serve low-income Canadians. By including the key points…

    • 142 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Not only will Proposition 55 give funding to schools, but it will also protect Children’s health Care. At this point of time, California has free healthcare for families who live in poverty, and the passing of proposition 55 will help keep this free healthcare active. Many families need this because they do not have enough money to be able to go to the doctors for even one trip. The online article, “CA Can't Go Back…”, by Protecting California expresses how, “This prop gives $2 billion a year to low-income families in which can not afford to have non-free healthcare. This way, low income families are able to have health care, and children are able to be healthy.” (Protecting California) If this were not not pass, that $2 billion will not…

    • 517 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The method of skeptical inquiry or way by which Pyrrhonian skeptics bring themselves to withhold assent to every non evident proposition is known as the modes of suspension of judgment. There are five such modes that Sextus provides and they are based on: Discrepancy, regress ad infinitum, relativity, hypothesis and circular reasoning. (Empiricus, 165–169) The modes are designed to assist Pyrrhonian skeptics in in continuing their inquiry by guarding themselves from the disquieting state of dogmatism. For the sake of argument, suppose there is a dogmatist who believes that P. In order to avoid the snares of dogmatism, the Pyrrhonian skeptic would resort to withhold assent about P. According to the mode deriving from discrepancy, due to an undecidable…

    • 388 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After the colonies started to thrive with the new crop exports, there was a very high demand for field workers to cultivate those crops. There were two ways that the colonists met this demand: the use of indentured servants and the use of black slaves. Indentured servants were, by definition, “persons who agreed to serve a master for a set number of years in exchange for the cost of transport to America.” Our textbook also goes on to add that “indentured servitude was the dominant for of labor in the Chesapeake colonies before slavery.” The use of slaves started after 1700 when the supply of indentured servants began to diminish. A slave, also by definition, is “(especially in the past) a person who is the legal property of another and is forced to obey them.”…

    • 717 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Zoos, aquariums and circuses have had a lot of controversy over their uses of animals in captivity. After SeaWorld announced they will not have any killer whales in their facility people reacted with a cheer and some with sadness. The documentary released in 2013 on CNN “Blackfish” has made people's decision to stop going to and not agree with the animals in captivity all the more easier. According to Lisa Lange, senior vice president of People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals has said “Change is already happening around the world.” For example, she mentioned Mexico, Spain and the U.S. have banned things to do with the exploitation of animals, such as animal circuses, bull fighting and the bullhook for training elephants. For other…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Jodie and Mary, sisters from the island Gonzo, were conjoined at birth. Their spine was fused together and they shared the same heart and one set of lungs. Jodie was the stronger sister, as she was providing blood for Mary. Jodie and Mary’s parents, fervent Catholics, were determined to let the sisters stay conjoined. They fully believed that the girls are in the hands of God. Realizing the dire situation, the legal courts stepped in and fought for the girls to receive surgery. If the twins received surgery, Jodie would most likely survive, while Mary would almost definitely die. To continue, if the girls did not receive surgery to separate their limbs, they would both have a serious chance of fatality. The sisters would have around 3-6 months to live (Jones, 2001). Ultimately, there are two different ethical arguments. The argument for Jodie and Mary to receive the surgery to separate their limbs and the argument for the girls to be left alone and at the will of God.…

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    ¨The employer tacks on $25 per day to the debt to cover those expenses.¨( End Slavery ) The prison bus is like the ship that the slaves were taken on. People get kidnaped and sold or rape everyday.¨While working and unable to leave, this worker needs a shelter, food and water.¨Trafficked men, women and children are typically taken to brothels, escort services, massage parlors, strip clubs or hotels and are prostituted on the streets or forced to participate in pornography.¨”( End Slavery ) Forced labor is the type of enslavement used across the world to produce many products in our global supply chains.Domestic servitude can also be a form of bonded labor. This form of slavery happens when migrant workers reach a destination country, and they incur a debt for their travel and/or a recruitment fee. The fishing, textile, construction, mineral and agriculture industries are particularly laced with forced laborers. The private economy – businesses and individuals seeking to create a profit – exploits 90% of the world’s forced laborers, They just want to gain profit that motivates the force behind the institution of slavery. The consequences of live-in help can create unique vulnerabilities for victims. Domestic workplaces are connected to off-duty living quarters and often not shared with other workers. Such an environment…

    • 997 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although the prevailing definition of freedom at the beginning of the 20th century was narrow, because of the rise of progressivism, the definition broadened, as demonstrated by John Mitchell in “The Workingman's Conception of Industrial Liberty.” Published in 1910, a time characterized by dramatic economic growth, brought on by increased productivity, a rapid rise in population, and the growing consumer marketplace, this document reflected the feelings of many in the working-class.…

    • 571 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Technological innovation—at least in consumer culture—often pairs with entertainment platforms. Smartphones, tablets, and even watches have been creating a tech reliant culture. While creative mediums have expressed caution for technology, the present day has embraced constant evolution. The main reason for the adoption of technology has been the maintenance of human control. Once human control is taken away, questions of ethics arise. Robotics has slowly evolved into the battlefield with machines like drones and UAVs leading the way. While intimidating, the inclusion of robots in warfare seems to be a natural evolution. With human oversight, advancements in robotics serve to bring a new dimension of defense. In We Should Not Ban ‘Killer Robots,’ and Here’s Why by Evan Ackerman and “War Machines: Recruiting Robots for Combat” by John Markoff, the authors discuss the evolution of robotics in warfare. Among the arguments, both talk of their implementation going forward.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Indentured servants were usually men between the ages of seventeen and twenty-five and made an agreement with wealthy colonists to work for a certain amount of years to obtain land, money, or something that they needed. However, unfair colonists told the indentured servants that they had to work for a longer amount of time than it said in their agreement because of necessities they used while they were laboring for the colonist. Then years later they said the same thing over again to them to trap them in a continuous loop of labor to where indentured servants were almost considered slaves. Slavery wasn’t something you had a choice to be apart of. It was labor that you were made to do your entire life obtaining nothing in return. Slavery was forever and it didn’t stop just with you. If you were a slave and had children then your children would automatically be slaves too.…

    • 456 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    If you abolitionists want to free the workers so badly, then say goodbye to the clothes on your backs, the food on your plates, and the tobacco in your noses.…

    • 598 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The reading for this week addresses Locke’s understanding of the relationship between the poor and the capable citizens in society. He stated explicitly in his second treatise on government, the importance of work and labor in order to assess a person’s worth. Locke believes that man is not meant to be idle and that the purpose of existence is to live in the image of God and work towards a life of moral bounds and labor upon the earth making it more beneficial to all those who enjoy its benefits. During the century that Locke is writing, about 50-70% of the population is extremely poor. There seemed to be no freedoms unless the institution of waged labor came into question. Waged labor during this time was not much better than being a slave and in many ways is just an extension of slavery.…

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Analogical argument for animal minds is weaker, since the strength of the argument is a function of the degree of similarity between the reference class and the target class. Humans are probably more similar to one another than they are to members of another species. While some researchers working with great apes have expressed concern about the argument from analogy (Povinelli et al. 2000; Povinelli 2000), it has been pointed out that those concerns do not accurately target analogical arguments for the existence of animal minds (Allen 2002). Furthermore, recent uses of analogical argument to defend animal consciousness have been based on careful investigation into the causal powers of the reference property (Varner 2012).…

    • 222 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Argumentative Essay Zoos

    • 428 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Zoos are beneficial in many ways. They have many ways of protecting animals. For example, people can help endangered animals from possible extinction. They can also help animals from losing their habitat. Furthermore, people can help animals with their injuries. Also, people can get an emotional bond with animals.…

    • 428 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays