top-rated free essay

Vernonia School District V. Acton

By brycenwojta May 06, 2013 1137 Words
Brycen Wojta
Ms. Sheehan
Gov. 12, Hr. 4
Dec. 17, 2012

Vernonia School District v. Acton (1995)

Case Identification
The Vernonia School District v. Acton case took place in 1995 at the Rehnquist Court at Vernonia High School in Oregon(1). This case was decided on Monday, June 26, 1995 (2).
In a town named Vernonia, Oregon, the local public schools faced a major problem regarding the drug use of students while participating in high school athletics (3). The Vernonia School Board were disturbed that drug use increases the risk of sports-related injury (4), so they approved an anti-drug policy, the Student Athlete Drug Policy, which requires random drug testing of the school’s student athletes (5). However, this became a conflict with the parents of a child named James Acton. The parents refused to sign a consent form to allow their kid to take the drug test because they felt it went against the 4th Amendment’s prohibition against “unreasonable” searches (6). The case was dismissed in the Federal District Court and was appealed to the Court of Appeals for the 9th District (7). This court favored the Acton families’ complaint, but random drug testing in public schools was ruled allowable in 1988 in Indiana, Illinois and Wisconsin (8). The case went on appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court to conclude conflicting court decisions (9).

Constitutional Question
Does random drug testing of high school athletes violate the reasonable search and seizure clause of the Fourth Amendment (10)?

Petitioner’s Argument
An example of a search subject to the demands of the 4th amendment is a state-compelled collection and testing of urine, including the requirements of the Student Athlete Drug Policy, which was determined by the Skinner v. Railway Labor Executives’ Association 1989 (11). By the case New Jersey v. T.L.O. 1985, the State’s power, in public schools, is tutelary and custodial over students. This allows a higher degree of supervision and control that other free adults are not able to do (12). Rules enforced upon the conduct of schoolchildren would be dismissed if undertaken by an adult (13). Fourth Amendment rights are different in public schools than any other place in America because students are required to take many physical examinations and to be vaccinated against various diseases (14). Having students perform these procedures, it creates less privacy for students than the general population (15). When student athletes sign up to participate in a sport-related activity, it’s expected that there will be less privacy because they must change amongst each other in a locker room and shower with no separation of any kind (16). Also, these student athletes put themselves in a situation where they are regulated more than any other students. These student athletes are required to have a preseason physical examination, insurance coverage with a signed insurance waiver, maintain a minimum grade point average, and agree to the rules of conduct for the particular sport/coach (17). Another point is the collection of urine is a process that is nearly identical to what people face when they enter a public bathroom. The males produce samples fully clothed, facing the urinal, and only observed from behind. The females produce samples in a closed stall with a female monitor outside the stall listening for tampering (18). The results of the drug tests are disclosed to selective school personnel who need to know in order for the student athletes to be protected from the effects of drug use (19). *

*
Respondent’s Argument
The Fourth Amendment applies to searches, including urinalysis according to New Jersey v. T.L.O. (20). Public school students don’t lose their constitutional rights at the schoolhouse gate which was determined by Tinker v. Des Moines Independent Public School District 1969 (21). Students are protected in school because of the Fourth Amendment and school officials must respect the Amendment (22). The school district’s procedures are much more invasive than the procedures in Skinner and Von Raab because the district makes it so the students have to produce urine on demand and under observation (23). While in comparison to Von Raab, people got a five days advance notice of the time and place for collecting the urine sample (24). Once the urine sample is collected, the privacy is still being invaded. In some cases, the most significant privacy interests might be contained in the urine (25). This can include various private medical facts about someone that isn’t related to the main point of the urinalysis. For example, one could find out if the person is an epileptic, pregnant, or diabetic (26). This is information that the school district has no right to know and is information that has no purpose in preventing drug-related injuries (27). Court’s Decision

In favor of the Vernonia School District, the court voted 6-3 on June 26, 1995 (28). Also, it was ruled that the Drug Testing Policy is constitutional under the Fourth and Fourteenth Amendments (29). This was decided because state-compelled collection and testing of urine constitutes a search under the Fourth Amendment (30). *

*
The privacy interests in the process of collecting urine samples under the District’s Policy is not violated because the conditions in which the urine is collected is nearly identical to the normal procedures of a public restroom (31). Also, the tests look for standard drugs and not medical conditions and are released to a select group of people (32). Children that have been committed to the temporary custody of the State as a schoolmaster are the subjects of the District’s Policy. This means the State may have more control and supervision than they would over free adults (33). The policy upholds substantive due process of the Fourteenth Amendment because the drug testing is fair (34). The procedural due process of the Fourteenth Amendment is also upheld because the process for collecting the urine sample is fair (35). Neither the law, nor procedure, deprives any person of life, liberty, or property. The Skinner v. Railway case of 1989 helped the justices make a decision because the case also dealt with drug testing (36) Justice Ginsburg concurred, stating that the District could constitutionally demand drug tests on any student who’s required to attend school (37). Justice O’Connor, Stevens, and Sauter dissented, stating that the student athletes give no reason to suspect of drug use (38). Impact of Decision

Federal government officials praised the Court’s decision as supportive of their war against illegal drug use. The ruling was thought as a victory for the kids By Lee Brown, Clinton’s advisor on drug policy (39). A leader of the American Civil Liberties Union criticized the Court for failing to protect the students in schools (40). The case was used as a precedent in the case Board of Education v. Earls of 2002 (41). *

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Vernonia School District V. Acton

    ...On June 26, 1995, the Supreme Court decided on the case Vernonia School District v. Acton as to whether or not random drug testing of high school athletes violated the reasonable search and seizure clause of the Fourth Amendment. During the 1980's and 1990's there was a large increase in drug use. The courts decision was a strong interpretation ...

    Read More
  • Minersville School District V. Gobitis

    ...At times in schools, there could be disagreements and disputes between the decisions of government and the rights of individuals. Students attend school in order to become well-educated young adults. The schoolteacher’s main objective is to make sure that students are receiving the maximum amount of learning to prepare them for future endeavor...

    Read More
  • Safford Unified School District #1 V. Redding

    ...Safford Unified School District #1 v. Redding Facts In Safford Arizona school on October 8th, officials strip-searched a 13-year-old girl after they received information from another student that the girl possessed "prescription strength" 400 mg ibuprofen and 200mg naproxen. While attending math, assistant principle Kerry Wilson entered t...

    Read More
  • Bethel School District vs. Fraser

    ...Bethel School District vs. Fraser This case involved a public high school student, Matthew Fraser who gave a speech nominating another student for a student elective office. The speech was given at an assembly during school as a part of a school-sponsored educational program in self-government. While giving the speech, Fraser referred to his ...

    Read More
  • McGrath v. Shenendehowa Central School District

    ... McGrath v. Shenendehowa Central School District (2010) The case of McGrath v. Shenendehowa Central School District began on May 3rd, 2005 when Theresa McGrath, a senior at Bethlehem High School, suffered a horrific knee injury playing a regular season, varsity lacrosse game at their opponent’s field in the Town of Clifton Park. From The...

    Read More
  • Timothy W. V. Rochester School District

    ...Timothy W. V. Rochester School District Abstract The provision of resources to handicapped children is subject to a wide variety of federal and state laws and statutes. However, due the varied and spectacular range of disabilities and combination of disabilities it is often difficult to easily decide who should receive benefits and who shoul...

    Read More
  • District of Columbia v. Heller

    ...American Government November 29, 2014 District of Colombia v. Heller The District of Columbia had a law banning all handguns. Dick Heller challenged this law in 2008, on the grounds of the Second Amendment. This was the first time that the Supreme Court had regarded what it meant for an individual’s right to possess weapons for private uses,...

    Read More
  • The Oakland School District

    ...THE OAKLAND SCHOOL DISTRICT BUSINESS PURCHASING 104-170 MARCH 6, 2012 OVERVIEW In reviewing an analysis of his school district’s paper buying habits, supply manager Gene Smith uncovered some interesting statistics regarding the Oakland School District’s supply ordering habits. Through the growth of the school district, purchase o...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.