Preview

Truthiness Persist Over Time

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
816 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Truthiness Persist Over Time
Truthiness Persists over Time
In the research article “The effect of nonprobative photographs on truthiness persists over time” published in Acta Psychologica, researchers Fenn, Newman, Pezdek and Garry (2013) intend to determine whether or not the nonprobative photographs have a long effect on people’s judgments about the reliability of a series of trivia. That is to say, the exact research question is “Does the effect of nonprobative photographs on truthiness persist over time?” From the research, people are able to see the way their brain acquires information and is able to determine the reliability of their brain after forty eight hours.
In recent years, people have had the ability to access enormous information easily through non-credible
…show more content…
The researchers split the experiment into two trials. Each trial has thirty six identical trivia claims with divergent conditions. In the first trial, the condition is that half of the questions will be present with the nonprobative photographs, which means they are related to the trivia claims but do not suggest the answers. In the second trial, the condition changes to all of the questions will be present with only trivia claims. In both conditions, the participants have to answer that whether the trivia claim is true or false. By designing these two conditions, the researchers will be able to compare the participants’ bias to say “true” with the trivia claims that have nonprobative photographs versus with only the trivia claims in the first trial and in the second trial. After comparing, the researchers will be able to indicate that whether or not the participants still maintain their answers of trivia claims with nonprobative photographs in the second …show more content…
From what the researchers found, people can have a broader implication on how others can take advantage of the photographs to make them change their judgments about whether the information they perceive from the non-credible sources is true or false over time. As an illustration, the pyramid sales employees of Herballife can use photographs of people’s changes of body over time when using their products to convince people to agree with their statement that their products are effective and healthy. Therefore, people should participate in their scheme to have the best result. By that method, the pyramid sales employees are able to recruit thousands of people to join them. According to the research, these people will maintain their beliefs up to forty eight hours that their body will improve as the photograph presents. By the time they realize it may not as what they have been told, it was too late because they already bought the products and be part of the scheme. Nevertheless, because of the research, people understand the power of truthiness over time. Whenever people are convinced to make a decision, they can wait at least forty eight hours to think and decide it in the most effective and beneficial

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Gary Wells’ experiment was in regards to reinforcing the witnesses’ memory. Wells had two groups of subjects that watched a low quality video of man committing a crime. After the video, the first subjects were asked to identify the man in the video from a photo lineup. With no reinforcement, the subjects were rather insecure with their selection. The second group of subjects were asked to watch the same video and identify the man from a photo lineup. With reinforcement from the conductor of the experiment,…

    • 825 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Loftus and palmer were interested in seeing how misleading questions affected eyewitness testimony, they conducted a lab experiment in which 45 students were shown films of traffic accidents, they were then asked a question about how fast the car was going, students were either given the verb hit, smashed, contacted, collided or bumped. The group with smashed estimated the highest speed whereas the group given the word contacted estimated the lowest speed, this suggests that leading questions have a significant effect on memory. Loftus et al conducted another lab experiment to assess the effect of misleading info on EWT.…

    • 241 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Psy 322 Week 1 Assignment

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages

    After taking a deeper look into the whole idea of consumer psychology there are lot of new approaches that are on the horizon that could possibly take effect. Image is a factor into today’s society whether we believe it or not. There is always the cliché that…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Research suggests that the duration of short term memory is limited to on average of up to 2 minutes. Duration is the amount of time a memory lasts before it is no longer accessible. The researchers Peterson & Peterson were testing how 24 university students could recall 3 random syllables after counting back from a generated number in multiples of 3. The finding of this research was the larger amount of time between seeing the syllables and recalls them lead to a decrease in the amount of people that could recall the original 3 syllables. The conclusion that was made from this was that as time increases a lower amount of people can recall as the time elapses. Some of the strengths of this experiment were that they found out the correct things about their aims and it supported their hypothesis, as well as meeting their aim and hypothesis a strong conclusion and strong correlation. These are advantages because they are all key things to make a successful experiment and in order to be acknowledge for hard work strong analysis and good evidence has to be used in order to get noticed, there were however some disadvantages to their experiment as there are to all these were that because they have only use 24 participants it cannot be generalised and this also makes it a unfair test and is not representative, as well as only 24 students they were all in university which is a biased sample as well as a biased age because it also means it cannot be generalised except internally for their year. As well as duration there are other things that make up key parts of the short term memory with capacity now to follow.…

    • 762 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    By presenting participants with conditions that contain words; pictures; pictures and words we should be able to identify that the pictures are the better memory…

    • 3524 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Loftus showed participants a series of pictures of a man stealing a red wallet from a woman's bag. 98% later identified the colour correctly. When then being given a wrong description of the wallet as brown, participants persisted in describing the wallet as red. This refutes Loftus and Palmer's findings as the participants actually continued to describe the wallet as red, even when told it was brown, unlike L & P's findings who found that the majority of participants did alter their recall of glass due to the false post event information.…

    • 390 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    There is much controversy surrounding the use of deception in research studies because it is an act in which researchers intentionally omit information from participants. However, there are several pros to this approach, one of them being that deception eliminates the possibility of participants altering their behavior and their responses based on the knowledge provided about the study to them. Another reason is that the study will in turn conclude to be more conscientious and reliable, thus maintaining its validity.…

    • 610 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    3. Based on psychological research, would you agree or disagree with the conclusion that eyewitness memory is generally accurate?…

    • 385 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The article “Your Perception Is Your Reality” by Tony D. Clark discusses how individuals regarding their perception may be influenced by society; however, everyone has the ability to choose their own perception that corresponds with their lifestyle. There are plenty of advertisements and commercials that are shown to a wide audience on a daily basis, and people are there to witness them and become conditioned to believe an idea that could potentially shift their perception. As individuals with beating hearts and a working brain, we chose to select certain messages that seem pertinent to us and these ideas are what help develop our perception on the world. Eventually, people develop habits that involved choosing an idea more frequently than others, which also helps create who we are as a person. Clark illustrates how our perception is our reality by giving examples of how we can observe items around us and appreciate all that we see.…

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Loftus and Palmer - Essay

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Before the Loftus and Palmer undertook their studies into the effects of leading questions on memory recollection, Carmichael (1932) researched the effect of different labels on the reproduction of identical figures. They showed two sets of participants the same images but with different labels and then asked the participants to reproduce the images from memory. They found that the different groups produced very different images depending on what label they had. This showed clearly how memory recollection was effected and distorted by literary prompting. This correlated very closely with the work of Loftus and Palmer who also used words to stimulate recollection of particular events. Therefore both demonstrate how the use of words can actually alter recalled memory.…

    • 461 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Dr. Sarah N. Dipety conducted an experiment to see whether chocolate can improve memory better than plain sugar can improve memory. To recruit participants, Dr. Dipety put the following ad in the local newspaper, “Earn $20 for participating in a one-week study on eating habits. Call Dr. Dipety at the Department of Psychology.” Forty people answered the ad and came to Dr. Dipety’s lab, where they were given 35 candies to eat during the week. Participants were told to swallow, not chew, each candy with a glass of water every three hours (i.e., five candies per day). All candies were coated with a tasteless shell that would dissolve in the stomach. Inside this shell, some candies were filled with chocolate, others with plain sugar. The first twenty participants phoned Dr. Dipety were given candies filled with chocolate; the second twenty participants were given candies filled with plain sugar. Participants did not know which candies they were receiving. After the participants finished their one-week study, they went to Dr. Dipety’s office. At that time, each person was given a memory test about items they might have seen in Dr. Dipety’s lab during the previous visit. The results of the study showed that people who swallowed the chocolate candies remembered the items in Dr. Dipety’s lab more often than the people who swallowed the plan sugar candies.…

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The aim of this experiment was for Christian Najjar, Talley Moorman, John Gressette, and Thomas McCutchen to replicate Elizabeth Loftus’ study on reconstructive memory (Experiment number 3) (Hock 120). In the original study conducted by Loftus, participants were shown a video of a white sports car driving down a road. After the video, the participants were divided into two groups and then asked a series of follow up questions. One group was given a questionnaire that contained a presupposing question such as, “How fast was the white sports car driving when it passed the red barn?” The other group was given a questionnaire with control questions such as, “How fast was the car going while traveling along the country road (Hock 120). A week later,…

    • 170 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thirty-seven of the fifty subjects conformed to the majority at least once, and fourteen of them conformed on more than half of the significant trials (“Conformity”). Overall, 35 percent of the subjects’ responses conformed to the group’s incorrect judgments. This is surprising because the control group achieved near perfect accuracy, showing that the task was not inherently difficult. In addition, when the experiment was duplicated allowing the subjects to write down their own judgments privately after hearing the incorrect responses of the group, conformity was drastically reduced (Baxter).…

    • 415 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Do You Like Pugs?

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages

    For our stats project we decided to analyze how the characteristics of the person asking the question changes the answer. To do this, we asked two randomly selected groups of people the exact question: “do you like pugs?” However, one group was asked the question by someone wearing a pug shirt, and the other group was asked by someone in plain clothes. We believed the most submissive class to the charastric bias would be the freshman, so we used them in our experiment. To ensure this Simple Random Sample was completely random, we assigned every student in the freshman class a number and then used the random number generator on our calculator. The first twenty five students selected were placed in the non-pug wearing shirt group, and the last twenty five students selected were placed in the pug wearing shirt group. We hypothesized that wearing a pug shirt would persuade people to say that they liked pugs even when they did not. Our hypothesis proved to be correct. While overall the vast majority of people said they liked pugs, the three no’s that we received only came from the group who did not see the pug shirt. 88% of the non-pug shirt group said yes, while 100% of the pug shirt said yes to the question. We asked twenty-five people in each group and did not receive a single no from the pug shirt group. This data shows that there is some persuasion that comes from what the questionnaire is wearing.…

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The aim of this experiment was to investigate the availability bias in judgments about the…

    • 2768 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays