Preview

Torture Is Ever Justificable?

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
346 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Torture Is Ever Justificable?
Torture: Is It Ever Justifiable?
By: Michael Levin In this essay Michael Levin is trying to convey that torture could be good. He believes in this theory because he thinks that if someone has done harm to another person than doing harm to the criminal is only natural. Michael Levin said “I am advocating torture as an acceptable measure for preventing future evils.” What he means by this is that, by showing people that others have been through the death penalty it gives the public the thought in the back of their minds saying that, if I do harm to a person, harm will be done to me. I would have to agree and also disagree with the statements that Michael Levin made through his essay. I would have to agree partially because, if someone did harm to me or to a friend I would hope that they would suffer in some kind of way to get back at them. I know this maybe isn’t the right thing to say but I would be devastated if someone killed someone in my family or friends. Also when Michael quoted that he was advocating torture as an acceptable measure for preventing future kills I think is true. I this this is a true statement because it shows the world what will happen to you if you harm someone else. I would also have to disagree with Michael Levin because as part of my religion and what
I have been grown up with I don’t think people should be tortured. I would almost rather for a criminal to sit in jail for the rest of their life and think and regret what they have done. This would also show others the dark side of jail and how you can become mentally unstable. Overall Michael did a good job explaining, to torture only the obviously guilty, and only for the sake of saving innocents, and the line between the USA and the others will remain clear. I would mainly agree of what he had to say throughout the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    In part 3, Morris (2002, p.171) discusses why prison conditions matter and why penal reformers, including himself, have devoted their lives and travelled thousands of miles to other countries in search of answers to questions that would improve prison correction from what is corrupt or defective. Morris (2002, p.172) suggests human rights are relative to all human beings whether free or imprisoned and he considers prisons as a smaller community within the world. Thus, the infliction of unnecessary torture and pain cannot be justified and therefore must be prevented and eradicated.…

    • 2326 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The main idea of this passage is to expose the irrelevance of the ticking bomb scenario for the topic of torture. The article as a whole does not take a direct stand for or against or torture, however, it slightly attacks the areas for torture. In addition, with a vast amount of reasoning and evidence the authors cover all areas relating to the topic of torture such as morals and humanity being the most controversial questioned issues in reference to the…

    • 927 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Levin also mainly uses the persuasion method of answering the opposition but he uses more examples than Iacopino does. Levin begins his essay by stating that “it is generally assumed that torture is impermissible, a throwback to a more brutal age” he also questions the oppositions and answers to defend his opinion when he states “torturing the terrorist is unconstitutional? Probably. But millions of lives surely outweigh constitutionality”. This is effective because he shows that he is aware of the questions of the opposition but feels strong enough that torture can be justified to go against the majority of people who think torture is immoral and can never be used, he uses this to show that he has a good enough argument to go against what most people think or feel. He also states “if you caught the terrorist, could you sleep nights knowing that millions died because you couldn’t bring yourself to apply to electrodes?” he uses this example to make it personal, to show people that torture can be used in some situations. By making it personal he makes people think about the idea that torture can be used if it is…

    • 1019 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When conducting the Stanford Prison Experiment, the subjects entered knowing that it was a fictional institution, simply to be used for study. General Karpinski was in charge of an operation that was far from fiction. Karpinski was sanctioned for overseeing an operation that was reportedly committing numerous instances of “sadistic, blatant, and wanton criminal abuses” according to Hersh (2004). Such dehumanization is unacceptable in any culture, but it is especially so in the Arab world (Hersh, 2004).…

    • 705 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    James Gilligan relays an enlightening message in his article, Beyond the Prison Paradigm: From Provoking Violence to Preventing It by Creating “Anti-Prisons”, about the history and sole purpose of jails. Gilligan dates his research about jails all the way back from the first civilization known to man, Sumerian, to the jails we see and know so well today. At the beginning of time jails literally meant “house of darkness” which when compared to any of today’s jails is very similar to our maximum security facilities with solitary confinement. Jails were first used as a place to house those citizens, who chose not follow the social norms of society, and used a very violent form of punishment to teach a lesson to any of those citizens who even had thoughts of straying away from the social norms and rules of society. Prison was metaphorically seen as hell and the prison guards the demons of hell whose role was to follow through with the punishment of the prisoners. Prisoners would be tortured physically and mentally and then either released or executed depending on the severity of his or her crimes.…

    • 951 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    This type of situation has been repeated in history with one example being the War Crime Trials for the Nazi soldiers after the Holocaust. In that instance, since people’s lives were lost, these Nazi officials were given the death penalty because people believed they should receive the same type of punishment for their actions. In this hypothetical example, no deaths were lost, but there was torture and terror involved which some people argue that torture is far worse than just being given the death penalty. So is being tortured actually worse than just being given the death penalty? The importance of considering this question is that if torture is worse than the death penalty then the death penalty would be a lesser punishment and any punishment “above or below what would be acceptable for the crime committed would be immoral because it does not…

    • 1062 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    I agree that prisoners shouldn’t have all the same rights as everyone else, but I do not agree with the use of torture on prisoners who have been captured and held as suspected terrorist because they deserve the right to be treated humanely.…

    • 1840 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Tragedy In Torture

    • 1125 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Using torture to as a way to gain intelligence involves a tremendous amount of assumptions. The Torturer is assuming that they have the correct person, they are assuming as the victims level of involvement and guilt in the situation, and lastly by using torture they are assuming that there is no alternative way to extract the information.…

    • 1125 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are many questions relating to the use of torture against any person whatsoever. As such, there are different perspectives on the ethics of its usage as well. While some believe that the use of torture becomes necessary at times, others believe that whatever the circumstances are, torture can never be justified. Some very pertinent issues related to the use of torture are, “Suppose a child has been kidnapped and a person has been suspected of committing the crime. Is it justifiable to torture that person in order to try to extract information from him about the child? Now suppose the person would not react at all if he is subjected to torture but there is a chance that he would divulge information if his child of the similar age as the…

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In a contemporary society where crime takes place we expect the state authority to dispense justice in the form of punishment to maintain social solidarity. There are many forms of punishment that can be given to an offender, each with their own functions for the offender and society itself.…

    • 1349 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Levin acknowledges this when he writes, “Torturing the terrorist is unconstitutional? Probably. But millions of lives surely outweigh constitutionality” (532). Basically, Levin admits that the methods of torture may not be legal and civilized, but he still promotes its use because the lives of innocent people has more value than rules and regulations. The Constitution is only a guideline and its purpose is to serve the people, which, Levin deems, is the purpose of torture. Although I agree with Levin that millions of lives are important, I think that it is a mistake to disregard the Constitution. With this document, arise carefully written laws, a clear justice system, and order among all people. If Levin dismisses one part of the Constitution then he is essentially abandoning the American way of life, social order, community, and promoting instead chaotic anarchy, in which individual decide whether they want to follow laws or not. Following the Constitution is crucial because it aids the United States in keeping high moral standard in which other countries can follow, this means that the document sets undisputable rules that everyone must obey and regulates the government’s control. In other words, I believe that millions of lives do not outweigh constitutionality because the rules and regulations it establishes serve to protect billions of…

    • 516 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The prison camp used social alienation techniques to bring about the destruction of self-awareness among the prisoners. They treated each prisoner like animals and did not acknowledge them as human beings. The ability to cater to basic human functions as we do was taken away. This degradation broke the prisoners down and stripped them of their personal traits. This kind of treatment worked well in a group-style setting with other prisoners experiencing the same type of torture.…

    • 264 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Hanging Audience

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages

    We see that the author's purpose is to allow the readers to understand that the prisoners were not treated humanly, and allows us to see the negative attitudes the authority had towards the prisoners.…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Hanging Analysis

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages

    “it is curious, but till that moment I had never realized what it means to destroy a healthy, conscious man[,]” said the narrator. After the prisoner stepped around the puddle, the narrator noticed that he has no right to take this man’s life. The prisoner, just like any other person, deserves to live a long life. At the beginning, the narrator didn’t see the prisoner as a person, he saw him as just another part of his job. Now, the narrator sees him just as he sees any other regular person. He notices that he can still think like anyone else, he’s body still functions properly, and that he’s breathing the same air as he is. And as the narrator said, this prisoner wasn’t dying, he was as alive as everyone else.…

    • 540 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Write an essay (900-1200 words) in which you analyse and comment on the article "Why not everyone is a torturer" by Stephen Reicher and Alex Haslam.…

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays