Preview

Todd Willingham: Trial by Fire

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1074 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Todd Willingham: Trial by Fire
Trial by Character
On December 23rd of 1991, a horrible tragedy occurred. A small house in Corsicana, Texas caught fire and three young children perished inside while the father, Todd Willingham who was asleep when the fire began, made it out alive. Willingham was convicted for murder by arson and later executed in February of 2004. Those are the facts but the question remains, did Texas execute an innocent man? I believe so. In this essay I will state my reasons for believing Todd Willingham was innocent at the time of his execution and give the reasons the opposition found him to be guilty. Todd Willingham was executed on the grounds that he committed arson. However, many aspects of the arson report have since been proved wrong such as the pour patterns found on the floor in the children’s room, hallway, and doorways indicating an ignition fluid. Modern science proves that the presence of pour patterns on the floor, in this case around the posts of the children’s bed, are not necessarily indicators of arson. Pour patterns have also been seen in fully developed accidental fires caused by radiant heating, melted plastics, or when the fire goes through flashover: the rapid spreading of fire through the air due to intense heat. (Beyler Report 1) It is likely that melting plastic, not lighter fluid sprayed by Willingham created the pour patterns created around the bottom of the bed. Without conducting a controlled experiment using a fire created with accelerant and a fire created without accelerant to show the difference in pour patterns, fire investigators could not be sure that an ignition fluid was actually used. Another misconception in the Willingham case is the temperature at which the fire burned being much significantly higher than normal, the fire being much more intense. This misconception contradicts many issues in modern fire science. It is true that accelerants can increase the temperature of a fire but those temperatures are also attainable in

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Module 8 lab

    • 395 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The fire started at the base of the heater, the victim was laying in that spot during the fire and the fire started at the burned puddle.…

    • 395 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Two law students, Charles Kremer and Elias Kanter attempted to help the stranded victims.“Kanter and the other students dragged two short ladders to the roof of the law school” they made an extension, by connecting the two shorter ladders together and “Kremer got down on to the roof of the burning building and tried to get the girls… and send them up the ladder” to safety.[4] By using this technique, these students managed to save 150 workers away from the fire. By the end of the fire, one hundred and forty-eight workers died, though one hundred and forty-one of them were instantly killed from: “leaps from the windows and down elevator shafts, or by being smothered. Seven died in the…

    • 873 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Innocent Man

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The non-fiction book The Innocent Man by John Grisham is about Ron Williamson and Dennis Fritz who were wrongly conivcted for the murder of Debbie Carter in Ada, Oklahoma in 1986. Grisham argues that Bill Peterson, the prosecuting attorney and his team, did a bad job. Peterson created a website to respond to Grisham’s book defending his position about the event. Most of Peterson’s writings are an attempt to convince us that he had made no mistake on the case. Although Grishm’s point of view is convincing and innocents were harmed, justice was done by getting the right man in the end.…

    • 798 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A lot of heat and controversy surrounds capital punishment in today’s society. The death penalty was built into the Texas justice system in 1835 and has retained most of its strength compared to the rest of the states. The famous motto “Don’t Mess with Texas” stands true when concerning the death penalty; In Kenneth William’s article, “Texas: Tough on Murderers or on Fairness?.” Williams states, “No one promotes this message [Don’t Mess with Texas] more than Texas prosecutors with their use of the death penalty. While the nation as a whole has become somewhat ambivalent about capital punishment, Texas prosecutors continue to seek death sentences on a regular basis, and the state carries out more executions than any other.” With this bold statement about capital punishment in Texas, Scott Vollum, Dennis R Longmire and Jacqueline Buffington-Vollum in their article, “Confidence in the Death Penalty and Support for its Use: Exploring the Value –Expressive Dimension of Death Penalty Attitudes”, found that “Surprisingly, in spite of the overwhelming support for the death penalty, 64% of respondents supported a moratorium and 48% indicated little or no confidence in the death penalty system.” Morgan Renyolds argues in her article, “The Death Penalty: Fair and Effective in Texas” that “All murders are not the same event. Executions are saved for the worst and serve obvious utilitarian ends.” She states that the death penalty is only used in the most severe cases and is necessary to deter crime. With Texas seemingly at odds with the rest of the nation concerning the issue of the death penalty, I will discuss the effects of the death penalty in Texas and explore if it has produced positive results in diminishing crime.…

    • 1322 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    One major purpose of the death penalty is to punish people for their horrible crimes. However, the death penalty has put many innocent people on death row. Since 1973, 156 people have been exonerated (released from death row/evidence shows they aren’t guilty). The average time between getting the death sentence and exoneration is about 11 years. This is already terrible, forcing innocent people to believe that their life is nearly over, because of a crime that they didn’t commit, but it gets worse. It is very likely that people living in the United States have been wrongly executed. Multiple cases have evidence that proves that the “criminal” is actually innocent. In 1991, the house of Cameron Todd Willingham was destroyed by a fire, killing the three children who were sleeping inside. Willingham escaped and his wife was shopping at the time. Prosecutors stated that Willingham had purposefully set the house on fire to cover up the abuse of his children. He was executed by lethal injection in 2004. However, there is a proof that shows that the fire was not caused by Willingham. Unfortunately, nothing can be done now because these people have already been executed, but it does teach us one thing: If the death penalty cannot be used to punish the real offender and risks the lives of innocent people in the process, it can’t be used by our…

    • 1868 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When the spark accidently landed on a piece of straw, things then escalated very rapidly. The fire by now had gotten way out of hand due to Thomas’ poor handling with the small fire, which had then engulfed into a huge fire. The sire that started on Pudding Lane and burned down one house in a matter of minutes lasted four continuous days. Within this time the fire spread very quickly. Eventually it destroyed St. Paul’s Cathedral, 87 churches, countless businesses, thirteen thousand homes and claiming six lives including leaving seventy thousand people without a place to live. The homes that were on Thames Street were full of flammable materials like tallows for candles, lamp oils, sprits and coal. Within seconds all of these were hot enough and began to melt which caused a huge explosion, which only made matters worse than they already were to begin with. Eventually the wind direction changed and burnt half of itself out only before reaching the Tower of London, where six hundred tons of gunpowder was stored. Nerves, anger and sadness with many other emotions became the root of many agreements. The main topic of arguments lead to the discussion of what was going to happen…

    • 1426 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “The most persuasive argument offered by abolitionists is the dark shadow that looms largest in the minds of people who have conflicting thoughts about the existence of capital punishment: the execution of an innocent person” (Marquis, 2004, p. 127). The argument of innocence has long plagued capital punishment. To reject the idea that innocent people are sentenced for crimes they did not commit would be ignorant. In fact, history has shown that innocent people have been sentenced for crimes they did not commit and later freed due to evidence proving their innocence. In the films Death by Fire and Deadline, innocence fuels the question should America have capital punishment today?…

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The movie screening of “Incendiary: The Willingham Case” shed new light on several topics that I feel like I have overlooked in the past. This screening presented a film about a man named Cameron Todd Willingham who was thought to be wrongly convicted for the murder of his three children. Willingham was charged with arson and then later executed without any further investigation on the large amounts of evidence that suggested his innocence. This case is significant in that it helped fuel the anti-death penalty movement and emphasized how flawed our legal system truly is.…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I watched the PBS Frontline documentary "Death By Fire," directed and produced by Jessie Deeter and co-produced and written by Mike Wiser and Michael Kirk. Todd Willingham, the father of three little girls, was ultimately charged, tried, and convicted of murdering his daughters by means of arson. The date of the fire was December 23, 1991, and he was finally executed by lethal injection on Feb 17, 2004. The circumstances surrounding this case were and still are controversial to this day. Opponents on both sides continue to voice their opinions on whether or not the state of Texas executed a man for a crime that they could not prove was a crime. As a father of two daughters myself,…

    • 1294 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Persuasive Speech Outline

    • 749 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Briefly introduce the man in an Illinois prison and explain that he was released only days before his impending death because DNA evidence (not available when he was convicted), clearly established his innocence.…

    • 749 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Innocent people are too often sentenced to death. Since 1973, over 130 people have been released from death rows in states that support the death penalty because of innocence. Nationally, at least one person is exonerated for every 10 that are executed. In 1983, Carlos DeLuna was convicted for a stabbing in a Texas Convenience store, supposedly killed the store clerk Wanda Lopez. After his execution in 1989, new evidence uncovered by reporters Maurice Possley and Steve Mills cast doubt on DeLuna’s guilt and points to another man with similar…

    • 1492 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Perhaps the fire was an act of God. Many Londoners of the day were certain that it was. It not only was a rescue from unfavorable living conditions, but many believed it was just a matter of time until God’s judgment on London was to come. Firstly, London was struck in 1665 with a horrendous bout of bubonic plague. It is estimated according to Tinniswood that 20,000 people of every 100,000 died because of the great plague. That is to say that one out of every five Londoners died (9).…

    • 1471 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Amber Young's evaluations on the issue of capital punishment reaches out to everyone and leave a trembling thought in ones mind. The thought or picture left is the number of helpless innocent victims that were brutally killed by Ted Bundy. This picture alone lets one feel no pity or remorse for Ted bundy. This essay clearly refutes the opposed arguments and brings in evidence to support…

    • 1167 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Wood Char Analysis

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Wood char depths are one of many fire indicators that fire investigators utilize for determining the area of origin and cause of a fire. It was formally believed that the deeper the char the longer the fire had burned but this has since been proven to be false. Rapid fire spread is common place due to the synthetic materials used in modern furnishings found in most homes. Most firefighters can expect to encounter flashover or post-flashover conditions at the time of extinguishment because of modern furniture as compared to furnishings from forty years ago, which were natural materials such as wood, cotton, and wool. The depth of char is still a useful tool for investigators to utilize and document as it can be used to show fire patterns, although…

    • 828 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The death penalty has been imposed on innocent people in the past. Researchers James Liebman and Jeffry Fagan examined death penalty cases in a time period of twenty-two years and found that most of the cases were not conducted correctly, and that many of the defendants were innocent. Of the “eighty-two percent of defendants with death sentences that were overturned by state appellate courts. . .7% were found to be innocent of the capital crime…

    • 664 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays