top-rated free essay

To Kill a Mockingbird Novel vs. Film

By danyboi233 May 20, 2013 784 Words
TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD-

NOVEL vs. FILM

PART 1

In the book ‘To Kill a Mockingbird” by “Harper Lee” there were many characters that the movie that was released shortly the book was published and became a best seller. After reading the book, and then watching the movie, I have made some observations on what characters were not mentioned or described in the movie and what bits and plots were not there. To start off with characters, I noticed that there were to characters that were dropped from the book and were not included in the movie remake. There was Uncle Jack and Dolphus Raymond. There are many scenes that I realize are missing in the movie remake of the book “ To Kill a Mockingbird”. For starters, I realize that you never see scouts teacher Mrs. Caroline. In chapter 2 in the novel, you are introduced to Mrs. Caroline and the Cunningham family when scout had to explain to Mrs. Caroline about Walter. Mrs. Caroline asked if Walter Cunningham wanted money for lunch because he had none and Scout was the only student that could explain how the Cunningham family doesn’t borrow or take money from any family or person.

Another part that was different is it never mentions Judge Taylor’s house being broken into in chapter 27 in the book. Not once in the movie was it mentioned to anyone that the judge’s house was broken into. “ Judge Taylor clumped to the back porch to let Ann out and found the screen door swinging open. A shadow on the corner of the house caught his eye, and that was all he saw of his visitor.”(Lee, 333) This quote is in the book and is proof that Judge Taylor, when home alone, had an intruder in his house and just left before he saw them!

The last scene that I noticed was absent in the movie but was in the book was when Atticus and Mr. Underwood caught Jem, Scout and Dill in the courthouse when Calpurnia ran in with a letter from Atticus’s sister, Aunt Alexandra. “I know where they are Atticus, Mr. Underwood spoke up. They’re right up there yonder in the coloured balcony- been there since precisely one- eighteen p.m.”(Lee, 226)

PART 2

In the movie, there were only a few things I noticed that were added and different in the movie. When Jem and Scout walk past the tree outside of the Radley house, in the movie they fin only to sculptures made out of wood, not soap like the book said and Mr. Radley filled in the hole in the tree where they found the sculptures in the book at night and they found it filled in the next morning, but in the film, Mr. Radley filled the tree in in front of Jem and Scout.

I found that the book had more reverences and revolved around the whole Mockingbird thing and on how not to treat people differently. But I found that the movie was just a story on a family who lived in a racist area in the U.S.A.

The last thing I noticed was in the movie, Tom Robinson’s arm was hurt in a farming accident and lost full movement of his arm but his arm was still there, but in the book its different. He hurt his arm in a farming accident and didn’t have it at all.

PART 3

If I were to compare and contrast the book “To Kill A Mockingbird” to the movie version, I would compare a few main things. For the biggest theme that they share, I would compare them are which version best describes the moral of the book? Story that is don’t do anything to someone who hasn’t done anything and treat people the way you want to be treated. I would by far say the book covered this topic better because the movie just felt like it was just a boring old movie about a family. Another topic I would compare them to be details and this is obvious because in almost all cases when there is a movie remake of a book, the book has more details. The last thing in common that the book and the movie can be compared to is that I have a tough time thinking and picturing details in the book and this is where the movie is better. If I were to compare differences one big difference comes to mind and that’s in the book, Scout is the main character and it focuses on her points of views on what is going on around her. In my opinion, the book was a lot better!

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Film Review: To Kill a Mockingbird (1962)

    ... To Kill a Mockingbird Film Review Joseph Webb Introduction to Film ENG225 Instructor David Preizler June 24th, 2014 To Kill a Mockingbird Film Review “Like film genres themselves, trends in media criticism are cyclical, a pattern exemplified by the history of film genre studies” (Mittell, 2000, pg. 88)...

    Read More
  • To Kill a Mockingbird: Movie vs Novel

    ...of lessons, the movie version of the novel To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee is not! Harper Lee entwines these life lessons throughout her novel; however, the movie version fails to incorporate these lessons into its plot. Thus, the movie version must be deemed incomplete, as it is most certain that there are many important lessons that Jem an...

    Read More
  • To kill a mockingbird: differences between film and novel

    ... To Kill a Mockingbird: The Differences Between The Movie and The Book "You never really understand a person until you consider things from his point of view... until you climb into his skin and walk around in it." (Harper Lee, To Kill a Mockingbird). This quote defines one of the most important messages in the book, concerning power and p...

    Read More
  • To Kill a Mockingbird - Film - Quotes

    ...To Kill a Mockingbird Intro – colouring in by child, tearing of bird drawing Atticus Finch – Good Lawyer who accepts hickory nuts for legal work from Mr. Cunningham Strong belief that all should be treated fairly Won’t let his son, Jem, have a gun Jem: “He won’t let me have a gun…” RE: “Boo” Radley rumours Tells Scout to ...

    Read More
  • In To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee

    ...In To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee, the small-mindedness of the Maycomb community hiders Maycomb people to truly understand each other. Arthur Radley, also known as Boo, is assigned with negative characteristics without validation by the Maycomb community. As the story unfolds, Scout, the narrator, starts to know more about Boo Radley, ...

    Read More
  • Critical Analysis of the Film to Kill a Mockingbird

    ...Analysis of the film To Kill A Mockingbird The film To Kill A Mockingbird holds many different criteria for which it can be judged. Some of the most striking aspects of the film concern the point of view of the narrator, and the symbolism as well. Our first-person narrator is Scout Finch, who is five when the story begins and eig...

    Read More
  • To Kill a Mockingbird - Growth of the Children in the Novel

    ...During the course of the novel, the children experience many significant events and relationships. Examine the children’s growth through the course of the novel.   The classic novel To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee explores the irrationality of adult attitudes towards race and class in the Deep South of the thirties. Throughout the cours...

    Read More
  • Powerful vs. Powerless - to Kill a Mockingbird

    ...What is power? I believe that power is having the ability to do anything you want, it allows you to shape your own reality and other. I am here today at the Power to the People 2013 youth convention to talk about the novel ‘To Kill a Mockingbird’ written by Harper Lee, and how it explores the concept of what powerful and powerless is. Power...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.