Tlo vs. New Jersey: When Is the Constitution Invalid?

TLO vs. New Jersey: When Is The Constitution Invalid?

In the case of New Jersey vs. TLO, I rule in favor of the petitioner, the state of New Jersey. In this case, I found no reason in the claims made by TLO and her defense. They claimed that the search conducted by school officials was unconstitutional. These officials were searching her purse for cigarettes, which she was caught smoking in the bathroom. During the search for the cigarettes they found the cigarettes, rolling papers used for making joints, a list of names with quantities of money owed to TLO, and finally a bag of marijuana. TLO says that she cannot be tried for any of these offenses, because she was violated of her rights promised in amendment 4, unlawful search and seizure. Yet, the incriminating items were found at the same time as the cigarettes, and given reasonable cause for suspicion, the school does have the legal right to search its students, and finally, the school officials had the right to search her purse because there was a reasonable doubt of her claiming to innocence being true.

TLO's 4th amendment rights were however, in fact not violated due to the reasonable cause and suspicion of her smoking, so the search was truly reasonable. And there is the fact that the teacher caught her smoking. Obviously it is the teacher's responsibility to take the student to the principal for suspension or other means of punishment. When TLO was asked whether or not she had been smoking, she said no.

The school officials then had a reasonable doubt, and they now had by all legal means the right to search TLO for evidence that she had been smoking. The search of her purse, if she had been innocent, would have proved her innocent, or guilty if she actually was guilty. The search was conducted privately, and was by no means humiliating to TLO.

Finally the officials did search TLO's purse for any kind of evidence, to prove her innocent, or guilty. They, in the process of the...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • New Jersey vs. Tlo Essay
  • New Jersey vs. T.L.O Essay
  • Essay on New Jersey V. Tlo
  • New Jersey Essay
  • New York vs. New Jersey Essay
  • The Fourth Amendment: New Jersey vs. T.L.O. Essay
  • U.S. Constitution vs. Iriquois Constitution Essay
  • Hate Crimes in New Jersey Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free