Preview

Thesis For The Skating Party

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
905 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Thesis For The Skating Party
The Breaking of Ice at the Skating Party
The night of the skating party hold events that is romantic, symbolic and tragic.
Two versions of the story told by two people present at the skating party share insight into the versions they believe to be true, except one story teller has a few secrets that has laid guilt on his mind for over thirty years. Merna Summers' The Skating Party holds a lesson in love and life; Nathan and Winnie Singleton's stories are different, Winnie believes Nathan tragically lost his ‘wife to be' in a skating accident, when in reality Nathan loses a love, no one else but him knows of. Nathan's thoughts on the mood of the night, and his indirect statement referring to his tragic episode will reveal why the narrator
…show more content…
Winnie and everyone else share the feeling of, how ironic and sad; we all know Nathan wanted to save his love Eunice. "It troubled me that he had [not] had some way of knowing . I would have expected love to be able to call out to love" (Summers pg.191)
In Winnie's eyes, Nathan saves the wrong girl and regrets his poor judgment for the rest of his life that by him making that mistake, there is the irony; he loses his love by grabbing the wrong hands from the freezing lake. Uncle Nathan shows indirectly and directly that he is in love with Delia not Eunice; "I [Nathan] suppose I liked Eunice at first because she looked so much like Delia" (Summers pg. 196)
Nathan was also telling the story of stone man hill to his niece, stone man hill was the symbol of his confusion between Eunice and Delia. "I wanted both… I thought when pa told me to get those rocks picked, that that was what I had to do. I think now I should have spoken up. I know for years I felt guilty whenever I remembered that I had done just what was expected of me." (Summers

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The theme of "The Skating Party" is you cannot choose who you love. Uncle Nathan proves this theme when he says, "'You cannot love where you choose'" (Summers, 104). Uncle Nathan is going to marry Eunice, but he chooses to be 'in love' with her. With Deliah, he cannot control the fact that he loves her, and that his heart is loyal to her. When Uncle Nathan faces the choice to save either Deliah or Eunice, despite the fact that he is Eunice's fiance, he decides to save Deliah. Uncle Nathan does not believe that you can't choose who you love when he says "'If you can fall in love in twenty minutes, then you can fall out of love just as fast'" (Summers, 109). Uncle Nathan is becomes affected by his feelings for Deliah, and the decisions he makes…

    • 146 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    One day when Gemma was heading to her college Astronomy class. She’d ran into the boy that was in her dream. The one with the green eyes. She’d been so shocked she ran back to her car. As she turned the key to unlock the car door, emotions flooded her. All the emotions she hadn’t had but should’ve. She fell to the pavement. Then…

    • 218 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Plot Summary: Gene’s jealousy blinds him into believing pushing his best friend Finny off a tree is just what he deserves. Once the fog of envy disappears Gene instantly feels regretful. At first Finny tries to deny the fact that Gene his best friend just pushed him off the limb, but he can‘t run from the truth forever. But just when it seems Gene and Finny can carry on with their friendship tragedy strikes again with a final blow and Finny is gone…for good.…

    • 635 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The reader can tell that the narrator changes throughout his adventures by his shifting disposition come conclusion of the story. At the beginning of the story, the narrator illuminates the glory days of his teenage years, filling the reader's head with images of "torn-up leather jackets" and "lemon-flavored gin" (115). However, after the narrator is faced with turmoil, he realizes that he may be in over his head in his quest of being a teenage bad boy. Throughout the night, the narrator experiences a multitude of misadventures that prove to be too much for him. During the story's…

    • 658 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Finch has some interesting views on people and believed that people should not hold anger in but fight it out. Agnes, Dr. Finch’s wife, is angry at him for having three other mistresses. But Dr. Finch thins it’s funny when she’s mad and calls others to see her hysteria, and she soon sees the problem being funny as well. Then Augusten talks about his own sexual encounters with his 33 year old boyfriend while he is only 13. Along with this craziness Dr. Finch fakes a suicide attempt for Augusten to get him out of school, he spends two weeks at a mental ward before being released and school free. Another crazy event is when Natalie, another daughter of Dr. Finch, and Augusten decide to knock out the ceiling and they do punch a hole in the roof an end up putting at window on it as a skylight. The window doesn’t fit and the next day snow comes straight through.…

    • 560 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Oliver, who recently lost a father whom he never particularly admired, just wants to forget about his problems and uses Hadley as a distraction for the 18 hour flight that they are enduring together. Hadley has an epiphany and races to the only place she could imagine him being at. When she arrives, she thinks that Oliver didn’t even want to continue speaking, even though that flight is the best thing that has ever happened to Hadley. Little does she know that Oliver was going through a rough patch in life; while she’s upset about her father remarrying, he’s losing his father permanently. She lives in distraught and then Oliver follows her back to her father’s reception ceremony and tells Hadley how he really feels. In the end, Hadley and Oliver live happily ever after, Hadley realizes how happy her father is and forgives him for…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A person must learn to make decisions wisely because they will have to live with the consequences for the rest of their life. Uncle Nathan of Merna Summer’s “The Skating Party” is unable to decide between a life he wants to live and life that he presented to live. He feels obligated to live by others standards. He has spent 30 years of his life suppressing his emotions and the incident of his youth, he wishes he spoke up for what he truly wanted. Moreover, once Uncle Nathan’s niece, Maida discovers his past about the party and the stone man, her curiosity compels Uncle Nathan to ponder his past. The stone man symbolizes Uncle Nathan’s past decisions and current remorse.…

    • 337 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Charlotte was reprieved from the sake of saying something when Mrs. Parker chimed in, “Lady Denham, this is a fine thing! A young man like Sir Edward will be found very well by Miss Lambe I have no doubt.” Her ladyship cried, “Oh yes, my dear a very fine thing. A marriage to a west Indy family that will bring money. Sir Edward must spend an outing or an evening with our visitors so Miss Lambe can see the respectable man that is the Denham heir.”…

    • 514 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Lady Windermere is not ready to make the choice - she still hopes her husband's affection will be returned to her. When she cannot choose, Darlington takes his leave bitterly, saying he will be leaving England the next day forever.…

    • 3757 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    However, Gene begins to feel a bit envious of Finny, and sees his way of thinking as the truth. This then lead to an inner conflict in Gene, in which he begins to compare himself with Finny in a "Win-Lose" way of thinking. As his thinking of "competition" continues, Gene begins to see certain "flaws" within himself that leads to his insecurity, though these "missing traits" are not really flaws. He does tend to "hold himself back" several times by repeatedly telling himself how lucky he is to have Finny as a best friend, but this excuse soon shatters because he remains selfish. This selfishness of him reveals itself in chapter three, where Finny practically saves Gene from falling, but Gene tries to protect his beliefs of "Finny being the enemy" by telling himself that it was Finny's fault for getting him into the mess in the first place. At the same time, Gene's admiration for Finny's personality prevents him from refusing to go out with Finny; it is in this state that Gene is actually a confused young man, who does not know the true value of friendship, and cannot correct the jealousy that he feels for Finny. The jealousy continues to grow, and soon enough Gene jounces the limb in chapter five, resulting in Finny's fall. As I have said before, Gene is then forced to review what he has done to Finny and take a good look at himself; his mind, feeling extremely guilty for his actions,…

    • 1827 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Most children possess a certain innocence that adults sometimes criticize, and yet wish they still had. Life can be perfect in the created world of a naïve child until one day a major event or revelation occurs and ushers in a bitter reality, a lesson in life. Oblivious and unwilling to accept the truth when it is spoken by an adult, children often have to experience life lessons first hand in order to learn from them, even when they are painful. Both “The Stolen Party,” and “Helen and Eighty-Sixth Street,” demonstrate how two young, innocent girls, who seem to have life figured out, learn just how distressing the real world can be.…

    • 1222 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    However, as the story progresses, there is a final realization that “[the narrator] may never understand why some of us are cheated in life. I only know…that I am not the one who was.” (Fein, 59-60) This realization is quite a turning point in the story, and as it occurs in the last sentence of the story, it signifies that to substantiate one’s statement, in this case, the narrator’s statement of “Cheated in Life”, requires being in the role of the person, and as the frustration from the narrator’s recollection of the childhood memories builds, there is still an underlying sense of ignorance from the narrator’s displeasure due to the mother's’ illness. But when the narrator re-examines the apparent displeasure the narrator had whilst being a child, the realization of the emotions and disposition that a motherly figure possesses coincides with the recollection of childhood memories, and this sparks the truly rational conscious understanding of the ignorance the narrator had with her childhood…

    • 383 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Skating Party

    • 655 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The short story "The Skating Party" by Merna Summers is about a love triangle conveying the theme that it is essential for individuals to make rational decisions because they will have to endure the consequences for the rest of their lives. Having been raised on a farm in Willow Bunch, Nathan Singleton aspired to become a farmer with a devoted wife. Contrary to his goal, he left his home and relocated to the city to become a teacher. Then, he ultimately returned to Willow Bunch to focus on his farming career. "In some ways it seemed as if he had never really left Willow Bunch... I found it hard to imagine him as I knew he must be in his classroom: wearing a suit, chalk dust on his sleeve, putting seat work on the blackboard. He didn't even talk like a teacher." (Summers 187-188) The significance of character revelation in this quote highlights Nathan's personality traits that are reminiscent of a stereotypical farmer. This justifies why Maida found it difficult to visualize Nathan possessing personality traits pertaining to a stereotypical teacher. With further inference, it can be concluded that his specific traits didn't effectively complement his teaching career. This incompatibility influenced him to return to Willow Bunch, where his childhood aspiration almost came to fruition when he became engaged with Eunice Lathem. Though unfortunately, he receded to teaching in the city once again after her demise. Nathan's indecisive demeanour regarding his career is symbolized by engraving a tattoo on your body. The consequence was the absence of occupational stability in his life, a reminder which is symbolized by the fact that a tattoo is permanently etched onto your skin. Secondly, the theme of "The Skating Party" is reinforced through Delia's decision to skate with Nathan at the skating party. Due to the lengthy duration of time they spent together, Eunice became infuriated because she detected intimacy. Delia then agreed to skate with…

    • 655 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Alcohol Health

    • 3179 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Richard and Sophie were troubled by the alcohol addiction of Richard, the husband. Their marriage was at stake and their three children were suffering due to this. Richard was sent to an alcohol rehab to get rid of his addiction. This, according to the couple was a significant life event.…

    • 3179 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Deception in King Lear

    • 1497 Words
    • 6 Pages

    has no love for him and it does not exist. The same goes for her sister, Regan,…

    • 1497 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics