Theseus' Ship

Good Essays
The Ancient Identity Crises

The transitivity of identity is a question often contemplated by philosophers through philosophical puzzles of change. A popular version of the puzzle includes a man named Theseus and his ship. A ship in which has undergone a gradual change where all of the lumber was replaced by the new cargo of lumber it carried. The question then remains, is this still the original ship of Theseus? Philosopher John Locke attempts to answer this question by stating that identity is a subjective matter rather than objective. He begins by separating the idea of a substance, organism, and a person and the different criteria used to determine each type of identity. Naturally we would agree with Locke that a ship is a not a living thing capable of thought and assume that it can only be talked about in reference to matter. However, Locke proposes that a substance like the Ship of Theseus can be talked about with reference to a conscious subject’s beliefs towards it. This is based off the fact that a concept of the ship’s identity could not exist without human consciousness. Locke also provides a further suggestion that two things should not be questioned as whether or not they’re simply the same. The reason for this being that criteria differs among concepts so we must be careful in specifying “the same what” when making comparisons. Therefore, Locke concludes that the idea belonging with the ship is the identity of the ship itself. In other words, identity is a relative aspect rather than absolute, one that heavily depends on context.

Identity can be defined as the distinct characteristics by which something is recognized. In other words, identity is an idea created by and for people and does not exist without them. This directly links with Locke’s idea of relative identity, as the perception of an idea is a relative concept depending on what, where, when, and whom you are asking. We must also keep in mind that just because things are

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Ship of Theseus

    • 2028 Words
    • 9 Pages

    of the ship of Theseus. Change and identity becomes complex and the definition of objects change. An object is a thing that exists in time and space and has many properties or aspects such as size and colour. As these properties change, so do the object and the object’s identity, so therefore objects are always changing with time. The story of the ship of Theseus has had philosophers puzzled for centuries. The classical story is told by Plutarch (46-120 AD), ‘The ship wherein Theseus and the…

    • 2028 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Story Of Theseus Ship

    • 300 Words
    • 2 Pages

    longer be the same. This puzzle is often represented by the story of Theseus Ship, in which a hero’s ship is preserved throughout many years by replacing dilapidated parts until finally not a single original part remains, however a young engineer takes it upon himself to collect the parts of the old ship and restore it to working condition. This then poses a new challenge, what is Theseus’s ship, the original model, or the ship made of replacement parts. In the same way, when a human’s personality…

    • 300 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Jireh Batulan Endurantism, Perdurantism, and the Ship of Theseus ABSTRACT: Endurantism and perdurantism are theories that describe how objects can persist through time. These theories will be used in an effort to solve a puzzle that has been dated all the way back to the first century: the Ship of Theseus. It will be determined that the two theories fail in solving the Ship of Theseus puzzle. According to Brian Garrett of Australian National University, metaphysics is concerned with…

    • 1961 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Reid and Theseus Ship Thomas Reid was an advocate of common sense realism, derived from the ideology of Aristotelianism. He strongly objected John Locke 's theory of personal identity when pertaining to the idea of the ship of Theseus. Thomas Reid believed that there was a lack of sensus communis in Locke 's attempt at deducing what defines something as itself. I agree with Thomas Reid. In my opinion, something did change from the beginning to the end of the reconstruction to Theseus ship. With no…

    • 958 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Theseus

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Theseus GOT A B+ (89%) In Greek mythology, Theseus can truly be thought of as the greatest Athenian hero. He was the son of Aegeus, king of Athens, and Aethra, princess of Troezen, and daughter of Pittheus, king of Troezen. Before Theseus was born his father Aegeus left Aethra in Troezen of Argolis and returned to Athens before he was born. But before he left king Aegeus put his sword and his pair of sandals under a large rock and said to Aethra that when Theseus was old enough to lift…

    • 734 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Theseus

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Aethra. When Aethra had fled away on their wedding night to be with another man, Aegeus decided to go back to Athens. Theseus was then a mix of both fathers, one who was mortal and one who was immortal. Before Aegeus left he buried his sandals and sword and told Aethra to tell Theseus when he was older and stronger to move the rock. He was raised in his mothers homeland. When Theseus was old enough he moved the rock and discovered what was left under it. Aethra told him the truth about his fathers…

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Theseus and the Minotaur

    • 782 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Theseus and the Minotaur Long, long ago, there was a king named Minos. This king lived on a remarkable island called Crete. King Minos had every single thing any king could ever want. Sometimes, King Minos would send his navy to the tiny village of Athens, which was across the sea. The king of Athens didn’t have a clue what to do. He was so desperate. He thought if he had some time, he too would build a strong navy, and send King Minos packing the next time he attacked. Then the king of Athens…

    • 782 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Theseus and Hippolyta

    • 647 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Claudia Radu 26.03.2012 The Significance of Hippolyta and Theseus Hippolyta and Theseus are two of the main characters of the play “A Midsummer Night’s Dream” by Shakespeare, where the two are engaged to each other. Even though they are both fairly absent during the play and only appear in each other’s presence, they bring great significance during the play. Hippolyta, queen of the amazons, represents power and authority. Theseus is the heroic duke of Athens who “wooed” Hippolyta with his sword…

    • 647 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Perseus and Theseus

    • 274 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The two heroes I am talking about are Perseus and Theseus. Perseus comes from the story Perseus and the quest for Medusa head. Theseus comes from the story the adventures of Theseus .Characteristics of an ideal hero are bravery and strength. Perseus and Theseus showed those things. Perseus showed bravery because he wanted to prove to the king that he could kill medusa. He realized that maybe he couldn`t kill her until a man and woman came and gave him a pouch, sword, and winged boots. When he…

    • 274 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Theseus the WIse

    • 691 Words
    • 2 Pages

    mythology: Hercules, Perseus, and Theseus. All of these heroes have many of the qualities that make up a good hero. However, Theseus is the quintessential hero because, unlike the others, he makes wise decisions, treats others fairly, and is extremely courageous. Theseus’ ability to make wise decisions during critical times proves that he is the quintessential hero. In one of his adventures, Theseus sets out to kill King Minos’ minotaur in the Labyrinth. Theseus “came upon him (the minotaur) asleep…

    • 691 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays