Preview

The Zero Tolerance Policy In Schools

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1909 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Zero Tolerance Policy In Schools
The zero tolerance policy has been getting more and more heat from media and parents alike within the last couple of years. For children being sent home because of their hairstyles, or because they simply don’t have any hair at all, such as the little girl who shaved her head in support of her best friend going through chemotherapy. Although these things are understandable within the stance of following rules and the student code of conduct, is it really that important enough to deny a child their education even for just pulling them out of one class? Two stories in 2013 came out about two seperate occasions where schools pinpointed two girls because their hair did not follow their “no Afros, dreadlocks or distracting hair” rule. Both girls …show more content…
Although most cases of zero tolerance policy are not to do with student code of conduct such as hairstyle, most are almost just outrageous. This policy started it’s roots in the 1980s and 90s, when the fears concerning violence in schools and classrooms led to a dramatic increase in the zero tolerance policy (Skiba, 2014). It wasn’t long until, according to Skiba, First Lady Nancy Reagan appeared with the Secretary of the Navy to highlight the new "no-nonsense" approach to drug enforcement on 40 sailors for drug usage on a submarine in the Norfolk, Virginia, shipyard. “When disruption and disorder threaten our schools and communities, it becomes increasingly easy to accept the notion that greater authority and force are necessary in order to keep schools secure,” (Skiba, 2014). We have created, according to Kajs, "a one-size-fits-all solution", for something that should never be one-size-fits-all in the first …show more content…
School-wide prevention efforts have to be in order for this policy to work at all. With teachers having different opinions on discipline and varying degrees of class punishment, the school would need everyone of their staff on board with this change. Although it may not be hard to convince, implementing the process and training is what will probably be longest and hardest to make all terms agreeable. Another process that might help is planning documents that highlight the value of developing caring, productive citizens (Kajs, 2006). “Consequently, instead of focusing primarily on the development of zero tolerance policies, school districts should consider key factors that allow school administrators to exercise their judgment of the situations in their own hands,” according to Kajs report. Conflict resolution, improved classroom management and parental involvement and support, only hit the tip of the iceberg of change school’s efforts for the zero tolerance policy. School administration also need to assess the seriousness of threats of violence and provide support to students who may be at-risk for violence and disruption through such interventions as mentoring, anger management screening, and teaching prosocial skills (Skiba, 2014). Supporting these children is what

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    In School Suspension (I.S.S.) or equivalent / Parent Conference ● The school promotes a zero tolerance policy for crime, substance abuse, and victimization. Disciplinary policies include statements regarding anti­harassment, anti­bullying, and anti­violence policies and due process rights in accordance with state and federal laws Disciplinary policies include procedures regarding student interviews by law enforcement and Department of Children and Families. ● ● 1. 2. 3.…

    • 10347 Words
    • 52 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Us Vs Muskegee Case Study

    • 285 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The impact of United States of America v. Muscogee Public School District has had a profound effect on education. Naturally, school boards are expected to adopt policies to support the academic achievement of every student. With the rise of gang-affiliated activity, mass school shootings and terrorist-related incidents across the country, many school boards adopted strategically planned dress code regulations to manage student behavior, promote conformity, and secure a safe, distraction-free educational learning environment. Standardized dress code initiatives were designed to assimilate a level socio-economic environment and foster a positive climate/culture in which students would feel more comfortable to engage academically. However, regulations…

    • 285 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Zero Tolerance Case Study

    • 1984 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The philosophy of zero tolerance was to deter students from suspension worthy activity or dangerous activity by incorporating police officers into the schools and programs that would suspend, expel and arrest you if you began to stray down the wrong path. This was a reaction to Columbine because they wanted to take preventative measures, not reactive measures. It is stated in the movie that they were scared if they didn’t address the issues in a serious way in the first place, even if the student had no prior record, then something more detrimental could happen. The change within schools to zero tolerance policies that could not only result in school related punishments but actual arrests as we see in this film led to the more placements in the juvenile justice system. Ultimately, zero tolerance rested on the notion that kids are mini adults and thought that a deterrence program would keep them from behaving like…

    • 1984 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The documentary begins with a history of the zero tolerance policy. In the 1990's, most schools established guidelines in institutions in order to keep the campuses safe from weapons and drugs. However, schools would soon find themselves deciding which items are considered weapons and what is considered drugs. In today's society, even knives at lunch and ibuprofen are considered hazardous to the safety of our schools. Even kindergartners are being expelled and suspended for playing cops and robbers, using their fingers as guns, or drawing "dangerous" pictures of a man with a gun. Let me address the thought in many minds while watching this film. What 5 year old child is going to cause danger or harm to a school? That's just the issue, it seems our society cares more about safety due to illogical fears, rather than our children's education. That in itself is causing our education system to fail rapidly and increasingly. The documentary also informs us of other incidents occurring in the schools. A 3rd grade student was suspended for a kiss on the cheek, a 5th grader was expelled for bringing ibuprofen to school. Many argue that this kind of action taken by authority is a threat to the basic rights. Forcing students to go through metal detectors, and permitting drug searches without consent is not only robbing…

    • 1259 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    dear robert scott

    • 560 Words
    • 3 Pages

    On the discipline note I feel that discipline is not harsh enough. At Seguin High School in Seguin Texas the students will be punished by a referral how ever after so many times it means nothing they just say “so I don’t care fine I will go to A school I don’t care it doesn’t affect me” I have heard this with my own ears and I strongly feel that some other discipline should be brought in for example physical labor cleaning as in cleaning various…

    • 560 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    Skiba, R., et al. 2006. “Are zero tolerance policies effective in the schools? An evidentiary review and recommendations”. American Psychological Association Zero Tolerance Task Force.…

    • 1775 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Better Essays

    Zero Tolerance

    • 1226 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The zero tolerance policy was created to prevent weapons from being bro9ught to school, but how far is too far? In a junior or senior high setting the policy is more understood and justified, however, in an elementary setting one may argue that the policy is a little harsh. How does one classify what a weapon is? While it is easy to discuss typical weapons, for example guns or knife, it may not be so easy to distinguish between others like pepper spray or homemade bombs. This paper will discuss the authors’ opinion on zero tolerance in the elementary setting and create a plan of action for a scenario.…

    • 1226 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    First of all, Schools should be less harsh when it comes to disciplining students. Schools are punishing students for the most absurd reasons. For example, a New York girl was hauled out of class in handcuffs. Why? Because apparently she wrote on her desk with a erasable marker. In Houston, Texas an eighth grader was suspended for wearing rosary beads in memory of her late grandmother and the school insisted that the beads interpreted as gang involvement. The rules are too harsh and it seems like a child can't go to school without offending someone there. To me, this is completely ridiculous, students need to have a good learning environment in order for them to learn. With rules and policies like this, students might be too busy worrying about breaking rules to focus on whats really important and the whole reason why they're at school, their education.…

    • 670 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Rather than promoting a safe environment of learning, and opportunity, schools have made it almost impossible to tell the difference between a school yard and a jail yard. Due to “zero tolerance” policies, police presents, and relying on suspensions and expulsions for minor infractions, students are missing out of their education. There once was time when disciplinary issues could be resolved by school administrators, but now students are either suspended or expelled on the spot. Students who have never been suspended or expelled are at less of a risk for incarceration than those that have been. There are approximately 3.3 million suspensions and over 100,000 expulsions each year. Zero tolerance policies were first adopted in the mid 1990s, since then the rates have been on a constant climb. Even though, the rates of school violence has been declining, suspension and expulsion rates are still rising. Zero tolerance policies have especially affected elementary and middle school children. “Seven of every thousand pre-schoolers are expelled from preschool programs, over three times the rate of expulsions in grades K-12” according to SentencingProject.org. This is not just bad for the students that get expelled but for everyone. Turning schools into “secure environments”, with school police, and staff that looks down on every mistake you…

    • 1091 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    A zero-tolerance policy was vastly adopted following the 1999 Columbine shooting. It was created in order to make schools safer by giving harsh punishments no matter the circumstances of the issue nor the child. By using this policy, minor mistakes made by students are criminalized and can give them a criminal…

    • 430 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    First Amendment In Schools

    • 1339 Words
    • 6 Pages

    When looking at Tinker, the Court ushered in a criterion where school administrations have the right to control student’s First Amendment rights for free speech, when the speech has the potential to cause a disruption or interference towards class learning and events (393 U.S. 503). Under Frasier, an exception was introduced that would allow school administrations to control student speech if the content was deemed to be obscene and vulgar thus being offensive to the student body and staff. Ultimately, the exception is allowed without there being an explicit disruption from the speech content (478 U.S. 675). The decision in Kuhlmeier, the Supreme Court’s decision officiated a new standard that would allow regulation of student speech if the administration viewed the content as representing the school (484 U.S. 260). Lastly, in Morse, the Supreme Court held that student speech could be restricted if the content has the effect of endorsing illegal drug use (551 U.S. 393). Thus, there are at least four standards that the Supreme Court may use when considering student speech when dealing with public school, however, the same rules do not always apply to college…

    • 1339 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Zero Tolerance Policy

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Zero Tolerance Policy ensures the safety of children, teachers and administration by creating punishments like detention or suspension for students that may have a weapon, such as a gun or knife, on school grounds; using drugs or alcohol on school grounds; as well as threatening other students or school staff with physical violence. The zero tolerance policy is now a policy most schools strictly follow. The zero tolerance policy is harsh on children. Administrations are now shadowing in on children and disproportionally. There are metal detectors, doubled the number of school safeties officers, and the involvement of the New York Police Department in the schools within the middle and high schools in the communities of majority black and brown children. Many school districts now have zero tolerance policies that greatly limit discretion in individual cases, involve law enforcement personnel, and mandate removing students from school. These policies generally require out of school suspension or expulsion on the first offence for a variety of behaviors initially instituted for possession of a weapon or illegal drugs, but now frequently also including smoking tobacco or fighting in…

    • 787 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Zero tolerance policy

    • 1381 Words
    • 6 Pages

    We have heard of the Columbine shooting, where in the spring of 1999 in Littleton, Colorado over a dozen people where killed and many others were wounded at the hands of two students. Or even more recently, we heard about the Virginia Tech massacre where a single student killed thirty-two people and wounded over twenty more. University of Texas, California State University, San Diego State University, the list of school violence is long and heart-breaking. Students and teachers have lost their lives by the dozens to gunmen that carried a grudge for some reason or another. These are extreme cases, for sure, and there is without a doubt a need for discipline in schools every where. However, zero-tolerance policies are not the answer to school discipline unless they can be reformed to have fewer gray areas and kept from being too strict, be less disruptive to the education process and allow teachers to keep their voices, and figure out how to correct claims of racial discrimination, regardless of claims that they are effective.…

    • 1381 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    There’s people who support the idea, in the middle, and those who are against it. David L. Stader in his article, “Zero Tolerance as Public Policy: The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly”, partially leans on the side of keeping the zero tolerance policy. Stader tells us that drugs, physical assaults, and weapons are generally minor or not huge problems with less than 2% of schools ranking them as serious problems. Stader follows up with more statistics such as from 1993-1999, students in grades 9-12 had a percentage of 12 of carrying a weapon. The percentage then falls down to 7% down the road. Stader agrees that zero tolerance sends a powerful message to the school community that violent behavior will not be tolerated. Schools need strong, effective policies to protect our students and to help them feel…

    • 396 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dehumanization in Schools

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In my experience, discipline in high schools has always been over the top. From what I heard, it has gotten so much worse since I left. Now the students need not only uniforms (just a strict dress code really) but also I.D. tags that they have to wear around their necks like cattle. They are herded from one class to the next with teachers and rent-a-cops waiting down every hallway to prod along the stragglers. Even when I was there, a student needed a good reason to be anywhere, and even with hall passes they were hassled by monitors on patrol. In the morning when they first get there (at the ungodly hour of six A.M.) they are subjected to metal detectors, random searches, and the occasional patrol of drug-sniffing dogs. There is absolutely no trust in the system, because after all, they’re just children and are not ready or able to make their own decisions, barring the fact that once they leave High School they will be completely responsible for everything in college.…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays