Preview

The Value Of Teaching History Through Fiction Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
956 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Value Of Teaching History Through Fiction Analysis
The writer of the Point article, "The Value of Teaching History Through Fiction" had the main idea that historic fiction could make readers relate more to the story and might have them want to learn more about the subject. For instance, in the Point article it states that, "...fiction can make history matter—make it irresistible—to young readers” This tells us that fiction could make historic events seem interesting to readers and make them want to know more about it. Another detail that supports the Point article's main idea is when the text states, "The goal of good fiction should be to move people. It should move them to laugh, to cry, to care, to think... History too should move people—or else how will they learn from it?" This supports …show more content…
For example in the text it says that, "for the older reader, of course, Bruno’s innocence comes to stand for the willful refusal of all adult Germans to see what was going on under their noses in the first half of the 1940s.” For younger readers, she argues, the story’s slow release of details “becomes an education in real time of the horrors of ‘Out-With,’ known to the grown-ups as Auschwitz" This shows us that the story could be taken as adults ignoring the events taking place around them or as a slow release of events in real time in Auschwitz. What Hughes says helps support the claim made in the Point essay by showing how historic fiction could benefit people in real life. All in all, Kathryn Hughes' view of The Boy in the Striped Pajamas is that it can mean different things for adults and for …show more content…
For instance, in the essay it says, "Young Bruno mishears “Auschwitz” as “Out-With” and “the Führer” as “the Fury.” As Cesarani points out, “any normal German nine-year-old would have been able to pronounce Führer and Auschwitz correctly.” This shows us that it is impossible for Bruno to mispronounce these words for his German background. It also says in the text that the some of the puns and language Bruno uses wouldn't make sense as his main language is German. This helps support the author's claim by having the wordplay mislead some readers to not know what out-with and the fury really stand for. In conclusion, the wordplay Bruno uses in the book is inappropriate and it helps in the writer's argument.

The word conundrum means a type of question or statement that's confusing. I this from the Point article where it says, "...the great conundrum of the Holocaust is that it was perpetrated by human beings, not monsters. Few movies have rendered this puzzle so powerfully.” The way the word conundrum was used made it seem like it was a question and the second sentence used the word puzzle to describe how the Holocaust was done by humans also helped by making the word conundrum seem as a puzzle or something confusing. As you can see, I think the word conundrum means a question or statement that's

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Secondly, the guileless tone of the book soon turned out to be extremely annoying and played to why the book was as unconvincing as I found it to be. In all honesty, I could not believe that a nine-year-old boy from a German family has never heard about the Jews, or wasn’t even the slightest bit aware of what was thought of them. Even if his parents tried to guard him from the war, which was definitely shown by Bruno's parents, he needed to at least understand the situation a little more for this book to be the least bit believable. Bruno's complete ignorance of the Führer and the fact that Germany is at war is hard to…

    • 119 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    When thinking of stories the book expresses “Information travels under what seems like idle chatter. Stories are vessels. So build a Trojan horse. A narrative story that people want to tell (Jared from Subway) which carries your idea along for the ride.” People like to think in terms of narratives, rather than in terms of information. They are more concerned with the whole entire story rather than the content. Good stories have the ability to transmit information to others. Stories are also easier to remember; therefore, are more memorable than focusing on dry information or facts. When telling a story it gives people the ability to talk about ideas and products more easily and…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Miss

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In “The boy in striped pyjamas” Boyne juxtaposes the character Pavel and lieutenant kotler in chapter 7. The writer does this to demonstrate the vast differences between the way a soldier and a prisoner were treated in 1942. The reader knows from the context of the novel that Jewish prisoners were treated practically brutally by German officers.…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Both the historical pieces by Jane Yolen who wrote The Devil's Arithmetic and John Boyne who created The Boy in the Striped Pajamas use the power of relationships between characters to transfer the message about the Holocaust and the barbaric nature of the events. The connection between the characters is shown on page 159 in Yolen's book when the protagonist states, “ Run for your life Rivka. Run for your future. Run. Run. Run. And remember.” The author made the relationship between the characters so strong that it showed how hard it was to be in the camps and the sacrifices you had to make for loved ones. It proves that some people in the situation during the time of the tragedy were cruel but others were really good at heart and caught in a bad situation. The novel The Boy in the Striped Pajamas used the same technique as Jane Yolen, the message the reader gets through friendships. It was conveyed on page 44 when the young child Bruno states, “ Father returned to his office which was out of bounds at all times and no exceptions.” This little boy is so young and it is hard for him to comprehend why people are on the other side of the fence held hostage and why his dad is always working. Through his eyes it doesn't make sense, which is what many people think of the Holocaust, but when you're a little…

    • 1362 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Boyne uses narrative voice and a variety of other literary devices to convey the main ideas of prejudice and discrimination, power of friendship and innocence in his novel “The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas (BITSP)”. Boyne’s novel portrays the story of a young German boy in Nazi Germany who befriends a Jewish child residing in the Auschwitz Concentration Camp. The author explores prejudice and discrimination, power of friendship and ideas of innocence in his novel. Boyne uses third person limited narrative, dramatic irony, juxtaposition, setting and symbolism to convey these ideas in his novel. Boyne’s novel uses these techniques to create these ideas, giving us an insight into the experiences of the Jewish people during Nazi Germany.…

    • 1250 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the movie, “The boy in the stripped pajamas,” 8 year old Bruno has a great deal of loss of sovereignty. Set in the times of World War II, and the son of the commandant o a concentration camp, he knew little about what was really going on. Understanding that he was only 8 years of age, it was obvious to why his father kept such things from him. Oblivious to it all. Until one day, he and his family moved from their old home into more of a secluded area, not knowing less than a few feet away were…

    • 650 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “We identify with those stories, we want to get lost in them, forget the world for a few minutes, or hours, or days.” People tend to read fiction books more because they are able to go into their own world for the time they are reading the books. The world would rather have fiction books, non-fiction isn't something that you could read all the time it would get boring. The readers need to know that without fiction many books they've read won't be readable anymore because there's so many of them. As technology evolves we will have to adapt our fiction-making powers, and discover new ways of making our own lives worth sharing and documenting. Fiction will allow you to make your own life and to write about it without having to put everything that's the truth. Readers will be more interested if you put fictional pieces in the book and not have all nonfiction truthful thing in the whole book. Therefore without fiction in our books it will be a hard time trying to enjoy reading in…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the movie Bruno is talking to one of the Jew slaves after he gets hurt and the Jew helps him. The jew tells him he was once a doctor and Bruno thought it was strange that he gave that up to peel potatoes for his family. This shows his pure, child-like innocence. Throughout most of the movie, Bruno remains ignorant of his surroundings throughout most of the movie and thinks that the concentration camp behind his house is just a farm where the people were funny looking pajamas. he soon learns at the end of the movie that the propaganda shows he watched with his Nazi father were a scam once he entered the…

    • 790 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Literature helps people experience things they would otherwise never be able to experience. Liam O 'Flaherty’s “The Sniper” is a great example of this. When O’Flaherty is explaining the scene where the sniper is on the room lighting a cigarette and a bullet whizzes past his head is a great scene that helps explain what it would be like to be in that position (O’Flaherty page 474). Most people have never been in a war, even fewer in a sniper fire fight, and therefore most people will never know what it is like for those few that have been in that position. But by reading this story, people can almost visualize what it must have been like. The adrenaline pumping through their veins and the terror as a bullet almost hits you seems like an almost impossible thing to understand if you weren’t actually there, but O’Flaherty uses literature to help explain what it was like. Literature can also help explain what it was like to live in a totally different environment. In “Warring Memories” by Kandi Tayebi, she does just that by show us what her husbands like was like in the Middle East. She explains how he would watch CNN and comment on how men should take their rings off or their bodies will be looted and mutilated once they are dead (Tayebi page 510). This again is a life completely different then life in America and by reading about it, it helps spread awareness of what other people’s lives are like. History is another reason to study literature. Many pieces of literature do a great job of explaining history without boring the reader with nothing but facts like a history textbook. “Like a Winding Sheet” by Anne Petry does a very good job of doing just that. It isn’t nearly as boring as reading a civil rights textbook but does a great job of showing how hard life could be for an African- American in the 1960’s. She showed how you could have to work extremely long hours of manual labor without breaks just to…

    • 1002 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In paragraph seven, the text says, "By manipulating the historical realities of the Holocaust for the sake of a good story, Boyne runs the risk of giving readers a distorted view of the Holocaust." This was an example of what the writer was arguing about and what they think about the book, The Boy in the Striped Pajamas. The writer believes that the book manipulated some historic events in the Holocaust for the sake of a good story. To support their argument farther more, the writer quoted David Cesarani on the topic of how Bruno would pronounce some words, it says, "Young Bruno mishears “Auschwitz” as “Out-With” and “the Führer” as “the Fury.” As Cesarani points out, “any normal German nine-year-old would have been able to pronounce Führer and Auschwitz correctly.” This shows us that the author had changed the pronouncing of the words Auschwitz and the Fuhrer to out-with and the fury, this is impossible because Bruno is born in Germany and he should then also be able to speak German fluently. The writer also had some well supported points, one of them was a quote from Cesarani that says, "Guards patrolled the fences and prisoners did not have the freedom to move about at will. Boyne’s literary device hides the ugly truth of the concentration camps: constant roll calls, slave labor,…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    A Girl Is Shunned

    • 1285 Words
    • 6 Pages

    There are pieces of writing in history that have helped many people, and there are pieces of writing that do not help anyone. It is good writing that makes an impact on a lot of people, or maybe even a few people. Good writing is based on its ability to relate to the world and society, and its ability to connect to the reader. Being able to relate to the acts of society makes a story good because it helps people understand how the world and everything around them works. They can portray the good…

    • 1285 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Themes like intolerance, the discrimination against Jewish people, and the will and strengths that these people had to survive. Most of this discrimination against the Jewish people came from the Nazi soldiers, but not all Nazi soldiers were ‘evil’, some were just doing what they were told with fear of being turned against if they didn’t. Some other texts of this genre explore whether or not everyday Germans had a full understanding of what was going on and weather or not they did anything about it. These issues can be seen in ‘The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas’. We see a lot of hatred towards the Jewish people through characters like Lt. Kotler and Adolf Hitler, and we also see a lot of evidence of the German people being unaware of what was going on. For example, Bruno asks Shmuel if he played “Football for example. Or exploration”. This identifies Bruno’s lack of knowledge of what went on in the concentration…

    • 776 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The same can be said about literature. Students tend to want to learn about things that are relevant or even remotely related to their lives or the lives of their parents and grandparents. This is the reason we have seen an increased popularity of slightly more modern history courses like History 3369: The World in the Twentieth Century. Take the Vietnam War for example, it is one of the longer wars that America has participated in, spanning right around twenty years. So, it is likely that most people born anytime from the 1930-40s to present-day, served or knows someone who served in that horrendous war. Because of this close relation, students are more interested in learning about these events and the stories of those who experienced it. In some cases, this is history they can touch and interact with it by speaking to those who lived it. The Things They Carried by Tim O’Brien is one of the best books about the Vietnam War. It focuses on the lives of soldiers of infantry division before, during and after serving in the war. Tim’s reason, which he shared in a 2014 interview, for writing the book is a shining example of how History and English are so closely linked. He said, “histories only go so far, and novels – fiction in general – are a way of trying to breathe some life and faces into the abstractions of dates and, you know, historical events.” (Port City Daily,…

    • 1094 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Boy in the Striped Pyjamas is a novel by John Boyne. This novel is set during World War 2 and explores themes such as prejudice, racism, war, innocence and friendship. What sets it apart from other novels is that it uses a third person limited point of view, and mostly depicts events as they are seen by a young and naïve boy. This was one of the main narrative conventions that engaged me in this novel.…

    • 904 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A person has also the right to be wrong. But a textbook has no right to be wrong; or to evade the truth, falsity history, or insult and malign a whole race of people. That is what the textbook do” (Henry, 1970) It is different to write a general book and a history book. A general book can be fiction, but a history book must tell the truth. The question is, can history book really tell the truth? The answer is no. It is no such thing as an unbiased book. Every communication expresses the views of individuals making them. In the case of books, those views are fixed in aspic for all who dip at any time in the future into that particular confection. (Klein, 2002) Every one has a unique viewpoint which he subconsciously brings to bear on all incoming sensory material; totally objectivity is just not possible for anyone. History book are inherently biased because of the personal influence and interpretation of historians. Historians put their own biases in every aspect of collecting data and presenting it. All of the material would be part fact, part inference, part judgment, and part…

    • 1427 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays