THE VALUE OF QUALITATIVE INFORMATION IN
SME RISK MANAGEMENT
Edward I. Altmana
NYU Salomon Center, Leonard N. Stern School of Business, New York University, 44 West 4th Street, New York, NY 10012, USA
Group Credit Risk, Royal Bank of Scotland, Gustav Mahlerlaan 10, 1000EA Amsterdam, The Netherlands
Credit Management Research Centre, Leeds University Business School, Leeds, LS2 9JT, UK
Within the commercial client segment, small business lending is gradually becoming a major target for many banks. The new Basel Capital Accord has helped the financial sector to recognize small and medium sized enterprises (SMEs) as a client, distinct from the large corporate. Some argue that this client base should be treated like retail clients from a risk management point of view in order to lower capital requirements and realize efficiency and profitability gains. In this context, it is increasingly important to develop appropriate risk models for this large and potentially even larger portion of bank assets. So far, none of the few studies that have focused on developing credit risk models specifically for SMEs have included qualitative information as predictors of the company credit worthiness. For the first time, in this study we have available non-financial and ‘event’ data to supplement the limited accounting data which are often available for non-listed firms. We employ a sample consisting of over 5.8 million sets of accounts of unlisted firms of which over 66,000 failed during the period 2000-2007. We find that qualitative data relating to such variables as legal action by creditors to recover unpaid debts, company filing histories, comprehensive audit report/opinion data and firm specific characteristics make a significant contribution to increasing the default prediction power of risk models built specifically for SMEs.
JEL classification: G33, G32, M13
Key words: SME lending; Credit Risk Modeling; Bankruptcy; Small Business failure
Corresponding author. E-mail address: firstname.lastname@example.org,
Address: CMRC, Leeds University Business School, LEEDS, UK
The Basel Capital Accord and the recent financial crisis have provided renewed impetus for lenders to research and develop adequate default/failure prediction models for all of the corporate and retail sectors of their lending portfolios. The Basel II definition of financial distress, 90 days overdue on credit agreement payments, is the operational definition for major lenders. The literature on the modeling of credit risk for large, listed companies is extensive and gravitates between two approaches (1) the z-score approach of using historical accounting data to predict insolvency (e.g. Altman 1968) and (2) models which rely on securities market information (Merton, 1974). In retail lending, risk modeling can be undertaken using very large samples of high frequency consumer data and combinations of in-house portfolio data (e.g. payment history) and bureau data from the credit reference agencies to develop proprietary models.
In the past, retail lending was mainly synonymous with consumer lending. More recently, following the introduction of Basel II, an increasing number of banks have started to reclassify commercial clients from the corporate area into the retail one. Although this decision may have been originally motivated by expected capital savings (see Altman and Sabato (2005)), financial institutions have soon realized that the major benefits were on the efficiency and profitability side. Banks are also realizing that small and medium sized companies are a distinct kind of client with specific needs and peculiarities that require risk management tools and methodologies specifically developed for them (see Altman and Sabato (2007)).
Indeed, small and medium sized enterprises are the predominant type of business in all OECD economies and typically account for two thirds...
References: Altman, E.I., 1968, ‘Financial ratios, Discriminant Analysis and the Prediction of Corporate
Bankruptcy’, Journal of Finance, Vol
Altman, E.I., 1993, ‘Corporate Financial Distress and Bankruptcy’, 2nd ed. Wiley, New York.
Altman, E.I., G. Marco and F. Varetto, 1994, ‘Corporate Distress Diagnosis: Comparisons Using
Linear Discriminant Analysis and Neural Networks (The Italian Experience)’, Journal of
Altman, E.I., and P. Narayanan, 1997, ‘Business Failure Classification Models: An International
Survey’, in: Choi, F
Altman, E.I., and A. Saunders, 1998, ‘Credit Risk Measurement: Developments Over the Last 20
Years’, Journal of Banking and Finance, Vol
Altman, E.I. and G. Sabato (2005) Effects of the new Basel Capital Accord on Bank Capital Requirements
Altman, E.I. and G. Sabato (2007.) Modeling Credit Risk for SMEs: Evidence from the US Market.
Aziz, A., Emanuel D.C. and Lawson G.H., 1988, “Bankruptcy prediction – An investigation of cash flow
Barnes, P., 1982, “Methodological implications of non-normality distributed financial ratios”. Journal of
Business Finance and Accounting, Vol
Basel Committee on Banking Supervision. 2004. “International Convergence of Capital Measurement and
Beaver, W., 1967, “Financial ratios predictors of failure”. Empirical Research in Accounting: Selected
Studies 1966, Journal of Accounting Research, Supplement to Vol
Becchetti, L. and Sierra J., 2002, “Bankruptcy risk and productive efficiency in manufacturing firms”.
Journal of Banking and Finance, Vol. 27, p. 2099-2120.
Begley, J., J. Ming and S. Watts, 1996, ‘Bankruptcy Classification Errors in the 1980’s: An Empirical
Analysis of Altman’s and Ohlson’s Models’, Review of Accounting Studies, Vol
Blum, M., 1974, “Failing company discriminant analysis”. Journal of Accounting Research, Vol. 12, nr. 1,
Bunn. P., and V. Redwood, 2003 ‘Company accounts based modelling of business failures and the
implications for financial stability’, Bank of England working paper, No
Charitou, A. and Trigeorgis L., 2002, “Option-based bankruptcy prediction”. Paper presented at 6th Annual
Real Options Confernce, Paphos, Cyprus, 4-6 July 2002, p
Deakin, E., 1972, “A discriminant analysis of predictors of business failure”. Journal of Accounting
Eisenbeis, R., 1977, ‘Pitfalls in the Application of Discriminant Analysis in Business’, Journal of Finance.
Fantazzini, D. and S. Figini (2008), ‘Random Survival Forest Models for SME Credit Risk
Measurement’, Methodology and Computing in Applied Probability, forthcoming.
Gentry, J.A., Newbold P. and Whitford D.T., 1985, “Classifying bankrupt firms with funds flow
Gombola, M., Haskins M., Ketz J. and Williams D., 1987, “Cash flow in bankruptcy prediction”. Financial
Management, Winter 1987, p
Grunet, J., Norden L and Weber M, (2004), ‘The Role of Non-Financial Factors in Internal Credit
Ratings’,Journal of Banking and Finance, Vol 29 No 2.
Headd, B. 2003, “Redefining Business Success: Distinguishing Between Closure and Failure,” Small
Business Economics, v
Hillegeist, S.A., E.K. Keating, D.P. Cram, and K.G. Lundstedt, 2004, ‘Assessing the Probability of
Bankruptcy’, Review of Accounting Studies, Vol
Karels, G.V. and Prakash A.J. 1987. “Multivariate normality and forecasting of business bankruptcy”.
Keasey, K. and Watson R. 1987, “Non-financial symptoms and the prediction of small company failure: a
test of Argenti’s hypotheses”, Journal of Business Finance and Accounting, Vol
Litterman, R. and T. Iben, 1991, ‘Corporate Bond Valuation and the Term Structure of Credit
Spreads’, Journal-of-Portfolio-Management Vol
Lo, Andrew W., 1985, “Logit versus discriminant analysis”. Journal of Econometrics, Vol. 31, p. 151178.
Lussier, R.N., 1995, “A non-financial business success versus failure prediction model for young firms”.
Merton, R.C., 1974. ‘On the Pricing of Corporate Debt: The Risk Structure of Interest Rates’, Journal
of Finance, Vol
Micha, B., 1984, “Analysis of business failures in France”. Journal of Banking and Finance, Vol. 8, p. 281291.
Mossman, Ch.E., Bell G.G., Swartz L.M., and Turtle H., 1998, “An empirical comparison of bankruptcy
Ohlson, J.A., 1980, ‘Financial Ratios and the Probabilistic Prediction of Bankruptcy’ Journal of
Accounting Research, Vol
Ooghe, H., Joos P. and De Bourdeaudhuij C., 1995, “Financial distress models in Belgium: The results of a
decade of empirical research”
Peel, M.J., Peel, D.A., and Pope, P.F. 1986, Predicting Corporate Failure – Some Results for the UK
Corporate Sector, Omega International Journal of Management Science,14(1)
Peel, M.J and Wilson N. 1989, “Some Evidence on Discriminating between Failing and Distressed
Acquired Firms in the UK Corporate Sector”, Managerial and Decision Economics, Vol
Shanker M. C; and Astrachan, J.H , 2004, ‘Myths and Realities: Family Businesses’ Contribution to
the US Economy: A Framework for Asessing Family Business Statistics’, Family Business
Review Vol 19, Issue 2 p107-123
Shumway, T., 2001, ‘Forecasting Bankruptcy More Accurately: A Simple Hazard Model’, Journal of
Business, Vol. 74, pp. 101 - 124
Taffler, R.J., 1982, “Forecasting company failure in the UK using discriminant analysis and financial ratio
Taffler, R.J., 1984 ‘Empirical Models for the Monitoring of UK Corporations’, Journal of Banking
and Finance, Vol
Please join StudyMode to read the full document