Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

The Semantics of Symmetry in the Art of the Renaissance

Powerful Essays
1614 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Semantics of Symmetry in the Art of the Renaissance
Throughout this course the ideas of religion, shapes, mathematics, symmetry and perspective have been examined within numerous works of the Italian Renaissance and reflected upon during passionate discussions over the semester. In Heninger’s article The Semantics of Symmetry in the Art of the Renaissance he discusses many of these same ideals. The integration of these concepts within Renaissance art was a deliberate message to the viewer. Proto-renaissance works are an appropriate example of this; displaying a lack of naturalism these images focus more on the ideals than the representation of the human form. Later Renaissance works, although more naturalistic, still embody the awareness of an inner meaning but was also a ‘[…] transition period between those who sought to lead a life of the spirit [from those who sought to] lead a life of the senses, and its art reflects both attitudes’ (Heninger 306).
Most works created during the proto-renaissance, from about the thirteenth century to the early fifteenth century, stressed symbolism and an internal message more than naturalism and perspective. This is the ‘substance’ in which Heninger references in his statement ‘at the same time that Pater made art the end-all and be-all of life, he emptied it of substance’ (286). Walter Pater’s view of art is that it ‘[…] should induce an immediate,

intense emotion without the necessity of cerebral analysis. Intellectual effort, in fact, not only clutters but undermines the art event,’ when in fact intellectual effort is what the proto-renaissance was about entirely (Heninger 285). This notion is apparent in works like Berlinghieri’s Saint Francis Altarpiece in that the depiction of Saint Francis is almost two-dimensional giving him a flat appearance. Berlinghieri’s placement of Saint Francis in the middle of a gold background that lacks any perspective or depth makes him look as though he is floating in the space. The absence of naturalism is not due to the artist’s lack of talent but the piece was created to invoke thought about Saint Francis’ life. The stigmata illustrated on Saint Francis and the halo around his head was meant to demonstrate to the viewer that Saint Francis held a predominant role in that religious era. Henninger narrates that ‘indeed, works of art are our best means of achieving the much-desired divino furore’ (289). Divino fuore translated to divine frenzy meaning a state a contemplation in which a person enters communication with God that brings an intellectual pleasure. The back panel of Duccio’s Maesta, Noli me Tangere, depicts Mary Magdalene reaching out to touch Christ following his resurrection. Noli me tangere, meaning don’t touch me, as Christ tells Mary Magdalene that he is no longer of this world. Christ’s clothing gives a golden sheen portraying his other worldliness. The Maesta also shows the living and

the dead as portrayed with one living tree, bearing fruit, and one dead tree to correspond with the death and resurrection. ‘From perceiving the artifact’s external appearance, we move to an increasing awareness of its inner form, and eventually to participation in its idea;’ both the Saint Francis Altarpiece and Noli me Tangere are visually appealing but the imagery integrated within is meant to continually remind the viewer’s soul of divinity (Heninger 290). As time progressed art moved from the proto-renaissance into the period of the Renaissance imagery of the divine was illustrated more so through mathematics, shapes and perspective rather than symbolism. Brunelleschi’s Church of Santo Spirito is architecturally designed to resemble a Latin cross with a symmetrical transept. The dimensions of the side chapels and the chancel are equal-sized squares and two of those squares are equal to the length of the nave. ‘Since the godhead behind this cosmogony is good, his creation will image a comparable goodness, a comparable perfection, insured by the exercise of symmetry’ (Heninger 301). In addition there are 40 niches around the perimeter of the entire building perhaps representing the significance of the number 40 throughout the Bible. There are numerous references in the Bible of 40 days or 40 years denoting significant occurrences, punishments or denoted periods such as it rained for 40 days and 40 nights and there are 40 days

between Ash Wednesday and Easter Sunday. Masaccio’s Trinity was ‘[…] the first painting to obtrude the new laws of perspective’ (Heninger 286). This new law that Masaccio followed was Brunelleschi’s one-point system of perspective. The vanishing point is created at the center of the bottom step, which is at eye-level for most when viewing this piece at the Church of Santa Maria Novella. Having a low vanishing point causes the viewer to look upwards to the architecture and the Trinity, of God the Father, the Holy Spirit in dove form, and a crucified Christ. Heninger states that in his opinion ‘[…] linear perspective was introduced and codified in strict mathematical laws in order to allow the painter to demonstrate that underneath the transient phenomena of nature there is the mathematical underpinning of proportion and harmony and divine beauty’ (306). Using the archway Masaccio separates the worldly figures in the foreground from the figures of the infinite world in the middle ground. This piece also uses the symbolism of the skeleton and the inscription above it stating, “I was once what you are, and what I am you will also be” invoking divino furore.
Towards the end of the fifteenth century mathematics and numbers were incorporated more frequently as a way to convey the unity of earthliness and divinity. ‘[…] The mathematics of cosmos is revealed in several schemes […] such as the

cycle of the four seasons, or the alternation of day and night in the diurnal unit of [two intervals of 12 hours] […]’ (Heninger 308). This is apparent in Leonardo DiVinci’s Vitruvian Man, which connects the finite world and the infinite world using the visual of a man in two positions within both a square – the finite and a circle – the infinite symbolizing man’s ability to connect with both worlds. The center of the circle is at the navel and the center of the square is at the groin. The circle is a symbol of the infinite the ‘[…] never-ending perfection of God’ and ‘the geometrical figure representing 4 […] the square [a symbol of earthliness] deriving from the four elements, the four bodily humours [and] the four seasons […]’ (Heninger 312). Numerous geometrical measurements are evident such as the length of a man’s arm span is equal to his height and a man’s height is equal to 24 palms and a foot is equal to the width of four palms. The Last Supper, another famous DiVinci work, also exemplifies the symbolism of numbers in Renaissance art. DiVinci groups the 12 disciples in four groups of three, there are also three windows behind Christ and four tapestries on each wall. The number 3 is indicative of the Trinity; the Father, Son and Holy Spirit. Christ’s head at the center of the painting is the vanishing point of the linier single point perspective in this work; this vanishing point is created from the tapestries and

the coffered ceiling, all converging at Christ’s head drawing your eye to him. ‘At its origin, linier perspective in painting was designed to obtrude the mathematical organization of God’s Creation […]’ (Heninger 306).
Raphael’s Disputation over the Sacrament (or Disputa) exhibits two planes of being – earthly and heavenly. An arch or semicircular shape is repetitive throughout this piece in the arrangement of human figures, the cloud platform on which the heavenly figures are seated, the gold arches behind both God and Christ, and the lunette which the painting is in. The semicircle is once again a reference to continuous, uniform perfection of God. Single point perspective converges at the monstrance putting emphasis on the Eucharist, which according to the doctrine of Transubstantiation is literally the body of Christ. Above the Eucharist is the dove of the Holy Spirit, above that Christ sits on the Heavenly plane, and overlooking Christ is God the Father representing the direct line humanity has to God through the Eucharist. Raphael’s use of perspective uniting at the host ‘[…] simply brings the point of recession closer to the viewer’s space rather than farther away at a hypothetical

distance [which causes the viewer to] realize the unlikelihood of infinity being located in our space […]’ (Carman 9). The discussants gathered on the earthly plane are from contrasting periods in history, which also causes the viewer to be ‘[…] complicated by being contingent upon God’s infinity’ (Carman 9).
Heninger’s article The Semantics of Symmetry in the Art of the Renaissance bridges the gaps between Renaissance art, mathematics, shape, religion, perspective and symmetry allowing the viewer a better understanding of the implied meanings within the artworks of this period. ‘A work of art is such a palpable image of the ideal essences, reminding the soul that both it and the celestial forms have a common origin in heaven and thereby drawing the soul back towards contemplation of the divine;’ is a quote from Heninger that sums up the principal ideas of this paper. The Renaissance era was an important time for the evolution art, allowing for the marriage of intellectual thought and emotional conviction within works of art. The tradition of seeing mathematics, numbers, symmetry and proportions bring a harmony to the collective works of the Renaissance leaving the viewer to contemplate the state of ‘[…] ”divine frenzy,” […] that [took] the artist out of his own limited self for the extraordinary view of divinity’ (Heninger 300).

--------------------------------------------
[ 1 ]. Transubstantiation: (esp. in the Roman Catholic Church) The conversion of the substance of the Eucharistic elements into the body and blood of Christ at consecration, only the appearances of bread and wine still remaining.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    At the start of the 14th century a time period in human history started that lasted until the mid-seventieth century known as the Renaissance. A rebirth occurred that made this era captivating to study. This rebirth of intellect was in the form of a renewed interest in the classical form of thinking. This renewed way of thinking shifted the prime importance of culture away from divine and supernatural matters, to humankind now being the main importance. With this new culture based on classism, artworks started to become more common and wanted as the artists began to gain recognition. The scholars saw a new found interest in the studding of ancient Greek and Latin classics. The art work that was being produced showed increase detail in not only…

    • 1184 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Michelangelo lived during the High Renaissance period and was one of the puissant, influential, and transcendent artists of all time. He was not only a sculptor, but also an unfathomed painter, a poet and an architect. This paper intends to analyze Michelangelo’s Sybille de Cummes (1512) fresco in the Sistine Chapel in terms of the following art historical philosophical themes/concepts:…

    • 1310 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Disegno and Colore

    • 3110 Words
    • 13 Pages

    * Hall, M. Color and Meaning: practice and theory in Renaissance painting. Campbridge University Press, New York, 1992.…

    • 3110 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Art History Paper #1

    • 1085 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The purpose of this assignment is to compare and contrast Giuliano Bugiardini’s Madonna and Child with St. John the Baptist, and the Master of Frankfurt’s Holy Kinship. Both are examples of Renaissance paintings, however, Bugiardini’s piece is an example of southern Renaissance, where the Master of Frankfurt’s is one of northern Renaissance.…

    • 1085 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout history, art has been used to depict events, traditions, and beliefs. The usage of such principles of art is prevalent during the Gothic age, transitioning to the Renaissance period. Artist across Europe were influenced by the distinct styles of the two time periods, and it is apparent in many sculptures and paintings by famous artists such as Giotto and Michelangelo. The two consecutive art eras, are based around religion and the church; many of the paintings and sculptures that are staple pieces of the Gothic age and Renaissance period are either architecture, paintings, or sculptures used for religious purposes.…

    • 505 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    One of the most influential artistic styles in western culture is the Classical Style. This term describes the art and architecture produced in Ancient Greece between the late sixth and early fourth centuries B.C.E. The harmonious order that governs almost all the aspects of Ancient Greek Civilization, including politics and philosophy, was the basis of this rich artistic period which has always had a strong influence on Western culture. Nevertheless, there have been some periods in history where the Classical influences were more prevalent. This influence could not be more evident than in the Renaissance, which refers to the rebirth of the Classical Style. The Renaissance which spread through Europe started in Italy around 1300 C.E. and lasted though the seventeenth century. In this period, the artisans did not just copy the Greek’s but also revived their principles of harmony, order, proportion, and realism. In this paper, I’m going to exam one sculpture and one building from each of these two periods to identify the similarities and differences between them.…

    • 1341 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The high renaissance is thought of to be the climax of art and emergence of artistic geniuses. The technicality of art dramatically evolves since the middle ages as well as heroic composition and artistic imagination. As Humanism and individualism arise in the renaissance artist take on a different perspective and some of the greatest thinkers and philosophers will emerge. Raphael’s ‘School of Athens’ is the ultimate embodiment of the renaissance because it captures the most eloquent pictorial articulation. Everything from Raphael’s architecture style to his creative use of figures scream renaissance.…

    • 652 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    After the Bubonic Plague, the people of Italy started questioning the church, and in doing that, they started the Renaissance. People of the Renaissance had many brilliant ideas and values which greatly affected the artwork of the time. In today’s society most people who are asked to name a great artist of all time reply with names such as Leonardo Da Vinci, Raphael or Michelangelo. These people created their genius masterpieces during a time of growth and change in Europe known as the Renaissance. One thinks that the Renaissance came about when it did for many reasons such as changes in the church, and that affected people’s world views. Realism, humanism, and secularism are outcomes of these changes. The realism of the time focused in the some pieces of art helped in the making of a brilliant piece by Leonardo Da Vinci called The Mona Lisa and Michelangelo’s David, an amazing statue which was based on the ancient Greek and Roman sculpture, otherwise known as the classics. Next, a secular piece of art was a painting entitled Peasant Wedding by Flemish painter, Pieter Bruegel. And lastly, the value of humanism is pictured in the painting School of Athens by Raphael.…

    • 921 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Fillipo Brunelleschi was a renowned Italian artist, sculptor, engineer and architect of the Italian Renaissance. During the early stages of his architectural career, Brunelleschi made a rediscovery of the concepts and principles of one point linear perspective, which he used intensively and extensively for the ornamentation of his architectural ventures. Before Brunelleschi, others had understood the importance of perspective, but up until then, no one had succeeded in devising a mathematical formula for one point perspective. His discovery, use, and demonstration of one point linear perspective proved to be a major turning point in Renaissance art and architecture, and unbeknown to Brunelleschi, his achievements were to have a great impact on the Renaissance, and those who followed him. Perspective is defined as the method of representing threedimensional objects in recession on a two-dimensional surface in order to give the same impression of a relative position, size, or distance as the actual objects do when viewed from a particular point.1 Brunelleschi understood the importance of this concept, and desired to demonstrate how indispensable it could be. This essay will discuss the influences that played an instrumental part in Brunelleschi's achievements, additionally it will discuss how Brunelleschi first demonstrated his formula of linear perspective.…

    • 2172 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    In this artwork attributed to Luca della Robbia made in 1460-70, Virgin and Child with lilies depicts Mary as the mother of God, instead of the queen in heaven, and emphasized the maternal side of Virgin and the human nature side of Christ. As one of the most popular devotional subject, it conveys the purity and virgin statues of Mary through symbolic pattern such as lilies and a suggestion of Virgin Mary’s perpetual virginity through the annunciation angels, which Virgin Mary born Christ the child without sin, to present the holy spirit of Virgin Mary and, therefore, evoke devotions to Virgin Mary. In addition, when comparing to Giotto’s Ognissanti Madonna in the Ognissanti Church in Florence, this relief shows us a shift towards naturalism in its depicting of Virgin and child, as well as presenting of space and colors, which fits into Vasari’s description of an naturalism art development trend. Finally, due to the size of the artwork, I suggest this piece of work was for domestic use, instead of for public devotion in churches. I also suggest it might was made to hang exteriorly on the wall near a garden due to its durable characteristic of terracotta and the subject depicted as Virgin and Child in nature.…

    • 2343 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Statue of Khafre

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In the extensive subject of art history, there are pieces of art that echo the period it was created in, the history of land and its people, and still stand to this day as a age-old reminder of the significance and value of a once era. Though early art, before the Common Era, has a large number of quantities that do in fact represent the ‘pieces’ there are a certain few portions of art that, in its whole, exemplify these standards.…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Italian Renaissance was a reawakening of literature and art, as well as many of the ideas of previous cultures (“The Impact,” 2016). Although they were not the only ideas to be revived, Greco-Roman Classical beliefs were perhaps the most prominent. The revivification of ideas such as humanism and Platonism and their effects on art make the influence of the Greco-Roman Classical period blatantly obvious in the philosophy of the Renaissance period.…

    • 509 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Jacob Burckhardt, writing of the civilizing influence of the Renaissance, says, “In the Middle Ages . . . [m]and was conscious of himself only as a member of a race, people, party, family, or corporation. . . . In Italy, man became a spiritual individual, and recognized himself as such”(Burckhardt 81). In an age when there are so many influences dragging us back towards a loss of individuality and personhood (mass consumerism, the “war on terror,” among others), we need art to humanize us again and make us attentive to the image of God in…

    • 1964 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    New sects i.e the Calvinists thought that churches and church services should be simple and plain affairs. However the Council argued that a God of greatness should be worshiped with the kinds of ceremonies, rituals, and churches with these great qualities. This affirmation of the beauty and grandeur of expressions of faith discovered its path into Baroque art. Images are very straight forward, dramatic, plain but the art also attempts to draw the viewer to participate in the scenario. The art has a sense of physical, psychological and emotional intensity. In the art there is sensational contrasts between light and dark but also the light and the shadows. Whereas in the Renaissance art it clearly has defined figures with each isolated from…

    • 152 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In the early 16th century, when proportion, symmetry and regularity of parts of Renaissance architecture are the emphasis and strong points of structures in the eyes of society, a new kind of artistic style showed up…

    • 1864 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays

Related Topics